Sarbjit Singh v. Addl Chief Secretary Cum Financial Commissioner Appeals Punjab



    
     
   
 

 !"#$% & & 

 '($)#*+ +$% & & 

,'!-.+(,+%/0 &&&&&(+(+$%!

"! 1 ##+(+$%'2
0+),*!('!3*14+%'%*+'2
$44+ +$%!55'2 1%.'- &&&& 5$%#%(
6  7 86&,

, 

  












 

!
"



#
"





, 

   :&   %






& 

'  

() *+ (*,-
./ 
 ,0

1"
 2+3' 
 %

 %
''



(( ,, (*,4
./ 
 (0 
%

''
"


!
,3(*,4
 

,- (*,+
./ 
 20

%

1"

''
."0
 

!6!
 ,$$

(*,+

  %
"""
7 


"

 

"7
1 
%


'


 




' 


8""
  9"
:'

1


 

9


"
7

'

 "

0
;' 
6



"
;' 
'"%
<




8""
 
9"
:'

1



(, (*,$



;' 
""



8""
  




'

7
;' 
7

9

 3"'
7
'


""


 "
'


" "

=
  

 '

""
,$
"
7

<7
""%
*4
" '


%





77

" 
 




9


7  
 


"

6


 "
"

7

 


$*
%





%
& "



7



 ;' 
<>

<
"'

%
"'


7
 



;' 

6




 $
7
"  


$*
%




 ?


7
"
 ; %


7""

6
'



'
 
""
''

'


 $

 '

;' 
;
""

"





'





%
 

 $


 '
' 

  "






 
7 
'

;' 


8""



() *+ (*,-



 "
@



"
 

%
7%

"


"


"

''



"
7


 
%

"
''
6

""
 

"
''
 

'






"

 
'

'

' 

 (( ,, (*,4 ""

 "
@


 "



%

"
''
%
7% 
"
7





 
!6!
 ,$2

(*,+
 !6!

 ,$$  (*,+   " 1"
''
""



7


 


7
 
<7


'

 '
"
1"
''
'


 

' 


,- (*,+
9 

 




%
7%

"


 ;
 "




'"%
 


'

'



'

7 
'
' 

  "


 

 "
 

;' 
<

 '


7


 

& "








<7



%
"'




 
'
;' 


8""

 



/ 
7#

;' 
<

 '


%
"'
 




#


%

""
 
""3!"
 

 

' 

 



   

%



 ;' 


8"" ;
 "


 $

'"% 

 '
'
%
 "



<
 "


7
 '

"



<
 '




 $


'
' 
  "

 
7
''
%


""


 


'

;' 
<

 '

"
""
 "




   
'

""



 ''



""

 


  $


'
' 

7
 "%


;' 

 8""
<
 '


'
'
%

""
7
 "%

"
%

""
 %

!"
 %




'
"


  

   

         




""

 
"

'
 
'
'"
%


 
%




%

""

'
7
"%

"
%

""

!"
 

7""

<
 '




'




'


 '


;
 "



7
 "%


7 
 "


7
 
6
'




'












'
 

 
%
& "
<7

 $
 "
& "

 ?

"

; %


7""

;
 "








 



;' 

%
"'




7""

<7



'
"

!

 

"

#$


%  & ''(  "  ''


) '

') %
"'


"


 "

9

 '!;' 0
0'%#7 *' < 15!'=
"


  

  
 



 
                  
  

   "



#$

 !"#$ #  %&         

'   ( 

$     ))  

  
      * 9 

 '

%
 "



 7 
%





=





7
#
% 
"
""


"
%

""

7""

 !"
 
9 
""


 

#
  
7

 



=

"

"
"7 

'


;' 




""
 



7
7
 "


7
#
%

""  "


 


"
"7
""


'
 %
 

'
  "





;' 


 


"

'
 
'
'"
%
9 "7
"


 *   +,

 ""%
" "



 

""


 
 

#

 7

 



%

""

 


 
'


%
9


#!



  +  +-. '/  ))(
7"
"
7 
'
& 

"

+,    

  

       )           

    

   

)    

  

    

       

  ))

  


)





  )

>

9
'
7
7
#
%

<A "







 



 +  +-.

   '  

=
+!

- 

" +-. ')

 (


7"
"
7

'
&  
"


)  
    ))
 "
      )
    )    

      -  



     

             
    
    )   
)      ))
 9



""

 

#
  
7

'



9 


 
%




%

""
7


"
% 
""

!"





'

 

'

 %
'

& & 

 <, 

 =
 
  B
#3
 C3 B
 "
 C3