High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3486/2007dismissed

(O&M) Ajmer Singh v. Paramjit Singh And ORS.

2018-09-11Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

"#$$%&'&()$*#$+,$-../ . 0+$-&(12 **$33"(# 4$-'5'

"-"+0&#&(12#2$-'

$'*(6$(#'

" # $%&'( )* +,"( ,+-'

-$'$(#) -7'2"82"(/$(&-69%"#$:&#2 -5'2"(#;"-$$-/69%"#$/ -#2$"**$33"(# - "(&'2;5+"-&(13"/69%"#$/ --$'*(6$(#'. <<<<< ,+-'.) **$33"(#= 6$$(6"(# ./ :2 -$+"&($6 5('5%%$''53 &( 6$$(6&(1#2$%3"&+#2$*3"&(#&-'*$%&&%*$--+"(%$:&#2"3#$-("#&9$ *-"8$--$%9$-865,3$#2$$"-($'#+($8"3(1:&#2&(#$-$'# 1-"(#$6,8#2$#-&"35-#"(6+6&&$6,8#2$>:$-**$33"#$5-#,8 %(&(&(1&##(38-$#5-(#2$$"-($'#+($8"3(1:&#2&(#$-$'#/2"' "**-"%2$6#2&'5-##2-512#2$&('#"(# $153"-$%(6**$"3

$'*(6$(#=*3"&(#&&('#&#5#$6#2$'5&#-'*$%&&%*$--+"(%$ #2$"1-$$+$(##'$336"#$6 ?.??&(-$'*$%#3"(6+$"'5-&(1. 7"("3' .. +"-3"' "1-$$6 # ,$ '36 - " ##"3 '"3$ %('&6$-"#&( / /@

A="1"&('##2$"33$1$6-$%$&*#$"-($'#+($8 /

A= 2$6"#$-$B$%5#&("(6-$1&'#-"#&(#2$'"3$6$$6"'*$-#2$"1-$$+$(# :"'&B$6"'

.??

'*$-#2$"9$-+$(#'/*3"&(#&:$(###2$&%$ 5, $1&'#-"-/;2"+"((,5##2$6$$(6"(#'6&6(##5-(5*#$-

:"&#&(1/#2$*3"&(#&1#+"-7$62&'*-$'$(%$,8':$"-&(1"("&6"9&# >"#$-(/&##-"('*&-$6#2"#6$$(6"(#.&(%335'&(:&#26$$(6"(#/ 9&6$'"3$6$$66"#$6. .??/#-"('$--$63"(6+$"'5-&(17"("3'.

+"-3"'5##2$'5&#3"(6 2$ "-$+$(#&($6 '5&# :"' %(#$'#$6 ,8 6$(8&(1 #2$ $B$%5#&(#2$"1-$$+$(##'$33/+5%23$''+"&(#"&(",&3&#8"(63%5' '#"(6&#:"'%(#$(6$6#2"#/&("%#/6$$(6"(#.2"6#"7$("3"(-+ #2$*3"&(#&#'$(62&''(",-"6#2-512"1$(# "(0&#&(12"3&"'&33""

3"&(#& 2"6 *"&6 "'5+ /

A=&('#$"6 "1-$$6 "+5(# /@

A=$$(6"(#.$B$%5#$6"("1-$$+$(#&("95- "-"+0&# &(12/:2&'#2$'(*3"&(#&/( .??"'"'$%5-&#8--$*"8+$(# ,5#(#:&#2"(&(#$(#&(#'$33#2$3"(62$"1$(#%++&##$6-"56:&#2 #2$6$$(6"(#'2$+"##$-:"'-$$--$6##2$*3&%$"(653#&+"#$38/" %+*-+&'$:"'$$%#$6:2&%2:"'-$65%$6&(#:-&#&(1( @.??

$$(6"(#&3$6"'$*"-"#$:-&##$('#"#$+$(#"(6-"&'$6 #2$6$$(%$,("&6$*5-%2"'$--"9"35",3$'"3$%('&6$-"#&( (#2$,"'&'#2$$9&6$(%$,-512#(-$%-6/#2$#-&"35-# 6&6(#1-"(##2$6&'%-$#&("-8-$3&$,5#-6$-$66$$(6"(#.#-$#5-( #2$$"-($'#+($8/

A=/&$/#2$65,3$#2$"+5(##2$$"-($'# +($8"3(1:&#2&(#$-$'#CD*$-"((5+'(#&%$6",9$/#2$>:$- **$33"#$5-#+6&&$6#2$0561+$(#"(66$%-$$"(6%(&($6#2$6$%-$$ #$"-($'#+($8/

A="3(1:&#2&(#$-$'#C?D*$-"((5+ - 7'2"8 2"(/ 3$"-($6 $(&- 5('$3 "''&'#$6 ,8 -5'2"(#;"-$$-/69%"#$/-$*-$'$(#&(1#2$"**$33"(#'5,+&##$6#2"# ,#2#2$5-#',$3:",6&%"#$6&(1-"(#&(1#2$-$3&$/-/#2$"+5(##"7$( -+#2$*3"&(#&:"'"%#5"338-$#5-($6#:"'(#*''&,3$#2"#"*$-'(/

:22"6*"&6"3+'#+"0-*"-##2$"+5(#5#/ /@

A="(6(38 "'5+/@

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

A=2$ #-&"35-#6$%-$$6#2$'5&#"'*$-#2$#$-+'"(6%(6&#&('#2$"1-$$+$(#/ ,5##2$*3"&(#&6&6(#"''"&3#2$&(6&(1',8&3&(1"("**$"3,$-$#2$ >:$-**$33"#$5-#"(6$9$((%-'',0$%#&('2"9$,$$(&3$6&(#2&' 5-#"1"&('##2$+6&&%"#&(#2$0561+$(#"(66$%-$$-$(6$-$6,8#2$ **$33"#$5-#"(6/#25'/5-1$6#2&'5-#-6&'+&''"3#2$"**$"3 2"9$2$"-6#2$3$"-($6%5('$3-#2$*"-#&$'/"**-"&'$6#2$ *"*$-,7/-$%-6'#2$%5-#',$3:"(6"+#2$9&$:#2"##2$-$&'( -%$"(6+$-&#&(#2$'5,+&''&(' -2"(/-/6$$(6"(#+&'$-",38 "&3$6#*-9$#2$6&'%2"-1$A-$#5-("+5(#/

A=#2$-#2"(#2$ "+5(#-$$--$6#&(#2$"1-$$+$(#6&-$%#"(6%1$(#$9&6$(%$2"' ,$$(*3"%$6(-$%-6$&#2$-#2$"1$(#(-#2$*"''*-#-#2$"&-#&%7$#' #2$'(-:2+2$2"6"33$1$638#"7$(3"($B"+&($6-'$$(#2$3&12# #2$6"8&(6$*$(6$(#:&#($''2"',$$($B"+&($6#,$3&$#2$%(#$(#'

#2$"1-$$+$(#%(#"&(&(1$3$+$(#-$5(6$"-($'#+($8#2#2$ %5-#',$3:/,8(#&%&(1#2$"%##2"#(*5-*'$:536,$'$-9$6&( 1-"(#&(16&'%-$#&("-8-$3&$/%(&($6#2$-$3&$##2$"3#$-("#&9$-$3&$"(6 #2"##:&#2&(#$-$'#C?D*$-"((5+ '"(5*'2##2$"-$+$(#&($6,'$-9"#&('/6(#&(6 "(8&33$1"3&#8-*$-9$-'&#8&(#2$&+*51($60561+$(#"(66$%-$$>:$- **$33"#$5-#2$"-15+$(# -2"(&'(#'5'#"&(",3$"(6&'2$-$,8 -$0$%#$61-5(6-&(#$-$-$(%$&'+"6$5#/+5%23$''"(8'5,'#"(#&"3 E5$'#&(3": $'53#"(#38/#2$"**$"3&'6&'+&''$6 /01 . ,+-'

023 )*45( -3/3267 82

928

-3/3 /1# 928