Bhikkan & ORS v. National Highway Authority Of India & ORS

1 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 2.6.2017 Bhikkan and others .. Petitioners v.

National Highway Authority of India and others .. Respondents



   




   

  !"!#$% &'

()**    *+!#$% & ) $ ,$-  .*!#$$!/0   ( *$! ( )!0 1(!' ') $ ,$-#'*!$ $0*
#*. & $ (!$# * $*("*)** #"&2*$$ ( * !*+("0&#,3456'

( # (& 7'

"*$*+ * !*+("0("$")$10(& )( *0( +*%& '()** *("(*!*+(& )* #( 1'*%*!1!$&* -8$-9 '( $&2*** &# ,93:#&( !* $*" +$!*&")!&$ ) $+  '(*& *;/ $!< +*+%*

'$*$ (# -=,,6:7
6
*%*!78>4 $& !'

( )** (! '$ %*  $)$10(*& #"(* $*&* (1+*% (& )( *0 & *$(&!*  (!$ "*  '( $+  '(*
*;/

2 $!< +*+ &6)7( $)$*
? -49:5 -=,5@ +*$*+($ (%* '$*$ (#$&*$$ ,:,--=,5"! )!&$1'

(& #*"(*&(*$$**  ( '

*$ $+  '(*& # $$$,,9-=,5)$10 1! () 
*
*%*!))! ,=488 '-=,,@*($  (%* '$*$ (# (1'$ $&* $*&* (%1+*%'

&!&!* ' $$) **+(  ** !*$1. 1$*1$1 & '*!!*( )$*+))!1'

 1!() 
+*( $+  (*
*;/ $!< +*+ &6)7

$& !'

) $ ,$-$  $*) ('

*$'&!) **  '(*+!$& !'

()*#"'*$(( ))** &1$*) '*  '( $)$10 *%** &( '(*
* +*$*+($ ( &6)7 (!%)( '*A&$1!

" B()*&*)!!*$$ "10(*
*/ $!< +*+ &6)7#$*)1!( '&((1'* ' !* $*(1 A$$    (  * *!!0 *$  !$C "  %*$

$$$->3-=,-* (+*+( &6)7& 1  ($!0  $*$    (  &*& &#  *  )) * )*%) ) $ 8$: & *$( )**  &!* '

(+ ' !* $** && $&"*(($&** '(*
*/ $!< +*+ &6)7 ?(*!& *$*+(&!*  '()** * (!*+(  '(1 %C&*$$&** #() $ (!!12*$ '

!!

"(&$*&* $$ ,,9-=,5*$10( 1!) 
*
*%*!

3 ))! ,=488 '-=,,6*($ ( %  *   '  $*  $  (7#    (  '

!!

"*+ ''&C B ( ( "$  '  !*  $ *   !*     ( !$  1  $  ''&*%  !0  

) &$*+)$*+ ($ '(*+(


$*/ D!< +*+%* $*$ (# *-98-==9
&!$$& ( !$ 1 )$'

') &$*+# () ** "

!$1& %$10() %**  (*+( <*
)* $)&0 *  $  &2*** #  (1*!**   $ !   &#  -=,8  6&   *  '

&  ,,-=,:7#"(*&(&(1 $))!*&1!

&2***   $  (  * !  *+("0  &# ,34510%* ' *'*&* ;

$*$$ () %**  '(& '-=,8 ?*(  (  '

*$  $*'*&*   $ &!*'*&* *( $ '(*+(
#( &*%*!))!$*) 'E (  "*  )**   *  && $*+!0  $*) $  '  *  ( !!

"*+  6*7()**  0))!0 (
) ( *0C& C $&2*** 
!!& "*(* )* $ '  ('

(+ ''

*$ 1'*F 6**7(*$
)( *0"*!!* *& $&!!'

(& $;)!0' ( * !

*+("0( *0 '$* 6***7  ( 
)  ( *0  (!!  (' $ *()**  &!* '

('

*$ 1'*#)&*!!0*%*" '($&**  '(*
$( 1!) 
#&*$1 %F 6*%7'()** '

$*!$ #!'

).*+))! 0"$ (*''&(!!

4 1)$"*(*)* $ ''

 (' ( $ ''*!*+ '())!*&* F 6%7( * !*+("0( *0 '$** $*&$ $) *( )01!*  ())! 0"$#**C1*+'*A$ $) *&& 67*0* !*G$1."(*&( (!!1$*1$1 & **+'*!*0 (  !**+*   *  ( / !$     $  !

< +*+ &6)7E

($'!1$ *  '('

*$ $)$ 10(*
("*)** *$*) '&& $*+!0 (Rajesh Bindal) Judge (Sneh Prashar) Judge 2.6.2017   √ ?(().*+; C).*+H;

?(() 1!H;