← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/23640/2012allowed

State Of Punjab And ORS v. Satish Kumar And Arn

2015-11-19Mr. Justice Darshan Singh14 pages

 

     

    

 



  



  

   !



 " #$ %"

&'()$ *+,-.) #*.

# #.

 #.

#  

  

         

 ! ///// ! "  #  $% & '

( 

  ($% #*.

# #.

 #.

#0* ! "

  

 &&)

&&*+   ,



( ( -   .

  !/  &0!&   1       23  +  

 & ,     &/45 ,

  !67*8 9:; 

    --<

-   ((     (       1      1  

 

4-<     2 -

(  ( <  ((   1-(

  2 -



  1

- (   

   1

 (



 1=    >

>? (

 =      

!!

     -  

  -  1    

 (( 

4-<  (1   - 

1

    

1     "

#

 !

 1   

  !!6671 &6!66)   1 @ ,  -1-< 

1!/6 1

<4 - 1

-A4 !6!667&66!667 !!&!667&6!&!667 !*/!66/@0)!66/ !!&!66/&6!&!66/ !7!66)&67!66) !/!66)&6/!66) 7 "!!  2 -

  && !66B (     -

(   

(          C

<          

  !  

4               <  

 1

 

   1

( 

  

? (- 

 !!     2 " (

   (

 ? (1 

11 !7

!) +   ,

 1

 =  1  <

<  

   (   

  1-(  -  

  

 

1

    1  ( 1     

        1    -   1 (       (  -< / "   ?

 -  ?  ( -  

 (  > (  -  

? 4@5  1          ((  !!   1  -(  -<  - 

 !  ((   1-(- 

   

"= 

-?   '!7,-    -    =   -       < (  

      -

            -   (        ((-

 ! 

 ,- -<D      -  -  -    

  &/45 ) " 3    +     (  1   -

 ( E



 -

  &/45  1

 &70 1 (  !&  1  

                  

1   (    

      

4-<

 

  4

       F    (

 3  +       +  

' 1 .

,,23  4 5G!66)H/ ++7!6-  +    &/45     1     

1    (    

 1     -<  4



  &/4F                    (1     -< - 1 &/4F

      (  

    (       9  :   &GH"3   + 

    1   1  (   -    -    -  

       

1     &/45#( 4

-   (

- 

 -

   2 -< 





  "3  + (       -     && !66B -  

< -(    



 &4 1&0&00@- !!  -

      1  (  (    (      

-< "- -  .

!/&0!&-  1 (  

   - * "    - - 

 !-       

    

      "



      3  +     &06!66*" - 1 !/&00!-  -  (



 

!  

 (    &70 1-- 4=   &/4F - &/4 5 (   -<   

 

  

 ((

 &/45 -

- 13  +    B  

 (

 ,(    

1          

1  (        

      <         1 ( 

    

-  D

1D   &G H F   F

   +  "3 14  -4 $ 6

 $7)8 

) 6

0,9(

0:14  

4 I!6B7G&H,3# GJ5H&!/"F

  -

      +  ' 6   ,!!2  , ;

6 '

# <!!  4 5,#!6*B+/7B , - (   

      "-?

 1 F

G H,(    

1

  1 +     <

    4 ,  <=  4 5G!6B0H&++/@*A,# !6BB  +  !!B&  -    F

    

    1       +      

,  $44 

4 ,,431, 640, 6 

4 5 G&0!@H  !)  ++  !)    =   -    ,(

             8;  

(

 +   

 =  ,

1" +       (

(4      (           +     -       

 1    , + *', G&00/H/++!       

-  -



( " -  -

 

-     +  ",(   



1-  ( &G H

 

  "

 &G H

1  (   

 8 &G+H

!67&;" 

       4  1            



      

       -  -

  ?      

 ((  



-  6 "  (   1  



 (

 !

 ( -  1 

-

 

  (8 ;

   

  -  1  

   ( 

 "

 

 -- ((   

     &GH  

  ?

 ?  &/45

-  9  :    &/45    (   

 &/4F

&/4-     1 ( &/4F (- &/4  1   + "D-< D-        1D"   &/4F    (    =  (1  -<    - -< '        1,   &/4F

 -< -       A 1

 1-< -

      1I

      (   1  

   

1  -<

-       1 + 4  -

  -   &/4F    

1                 -<  

                 1   &/4

 

  

  

D D-  

1 -< -      

 1 1 &/4F "  ?       &/45 -     -   ( ( 



 

    

    -<  I   1   &/4F  ,     =         1   (     - D  D   "

  4

       -<

 1  (           -< 4

   ,      -<

       1   (  -   

  -   (



       

    -<  + 4  (    

1 -<  -  &/4F 

 

   

 

  

   &/45 

1 (1  -<  '     

           

( -   D

  &/45  "          :

!0 '     =   -   - 1      +  -  

- (

A4 9"             -   

  -<

    -

1     - !6*7!6*),-

!6B&- - 1

 "  

1 

1 (  (  

  1  

 "

1        (   (   "         -< 

1 

1 (  (      1           -    G

  H  1      

      -< -  

   (

 1      4  

  "  

 ( ( 1--

 -      !6B&        

  (  1   -                ((   1   -    -   &/45

-

    (   1         ( 1    -

  1 1-1    1  

1     (     ,          -  5(+  1      ,  - ( 1    



1        (      

 -     ,    

 (  1     (      -         

 1 

 '

-

  (

1 

 5(+ 

(    (  - 

5(+  1

:

!! , 

    -<    &70 1

 

(1   -<  1 &/4F,

  1    -<            -  =   

"

=      

--( 

   ( ( !6*7!6*)-  - 

1

!6B&  "     +            

      ( -

<    ( 

 -< 

1 (  (  --



  # **

*B,

   G+  H# !6/*-  

 

  ( 

-



(   !& "=   - - -

( ?

 9  -< :  &/4F  (4 

  -<   

1 (1 1 &/4F  ?



  -<

(  1 &/4F !@ #   **     -        1     -<

 *B-4

  -<  #  *B=        1 (  1 

  -< --9 (

   :, 

 8 ; + 

  -    (  

 

-  <

,

       -  

(  

 (       





  ?

 1  

 +  ,  20, : 1

 +3 0G&00)H7++!

       &70  1     1      1         -   

1-

+ 

(4



(

 -  1  <

   (  



 

  -        

     

 ? (-  1 ( "=  -      -   (    

< ( 

   -

    " 

 (

? (

<

 !- 1     (  

 -    

        1 <

    -  (  

1   1  (         1   

 

(

  ( 1   1         ,    -  

1(  1               

      !7   D    - >=, 64  '  

!

  $1  6        6  ,  2 (3 0' 

4 5&007G7H#./&!6! 1 + 

  4   ?

 !



.

 

4 5 &0!/  G!H  #.  6@  

:3=  %2   +=

 !3

#4 2 

4   

   -  "  3  + 



  -        1 

 5-                      -

 + < (  -2 ! !66&-  (  + <!6*0 !6B/,-  D  (D=  1

    

           

    (  -  

 + <

+    (  - - 

   - 4-<   

        

- 3  +  

 (

 &/4F (1

-  (  -  1  !/ ,-

 

 

   



  

  <-

  ,   -3  +      

    1 

 "1

=  

 ( 

  !) "+ 

 < (

  

1  

4-<  &/45 ,1     (

( 1

 -  1     (       3    +     

 (-   <   

 "-

   1



   (2

 (    -

  

 13  +  1 -   + - ( 

<-(

 

 &00@-

1  

 -  1     

     -



     -  ( -  ??     ?-< 



- <-(    1(-  

 (



-

1  (        

(  ,   1        

       

1    

 

#   ) 6

0  <4

 !3

 !



 #

4  >3, 640&0!@ G/H++!@)

 

(  

-          1    =    "  

4 -< 

 

  (

    4 

      *B!6/*   !* ,    (                -   

 1 

( 1



+   -           -  

     (     (  

  (      

  1  

     -  

,    -  

           (               

  

     1

- " -  .

!/&0!&  @ #*.

# #.

 #.

#A *+>)

3=  0