← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17351/2015dismissed

Savita Sharma And ORS v. District Magistrate And ORS

2015-08-24Mr. Justice S.C. Datta19 pages

 

         

 

 

 

   

   !"



 

#   

   !"

!"  #$%&'"!()*+, '!")'',+#- $ !" % %""&'%%( )  *

$ +' !"*

$ )   %'"  *  



     

 





  

 

  

 



 !

" 

 #$ % &'()& *+&)

   ,



 "

  -  

.

#$ % &'()* *+&)   , /

 "

 -  

.



 

       +0 +' *+&) 1  2)  

  & -   4   #   

 /

 "

 

        % *+0*

 (' # #  

 % (5 6 /

 *( #  

   

$   

 #7  *++'

   

,. # $  % &'()& *+&) 

  

 

 /

 "

  

    



" 

  

 ! ! "#   ! 

 $% &''%"(& .

/ (8 

          ,+      %     ""%      "    &  %%  

&+ %%%& ( % '  &-  %.(% # "(  "  ""&( " /   % 0 1"  2"% %'   ("3 . , 456& 7$ , 456&  7$ (%%0#("'

8"   7  7'97 

! (,:;;<;=88+><;7!;+ <;08;74;;3>1:;=>;;=4;

??!;=+@ <;08+118><;7!;+;;335689(&&

 (&  *1 ((

& & $

+'( "    (  "7.9 %  %   %%'%&   % 0&%   %   %&9     '        "'%& ("   '    :

9  (  "%     '%  "    ( '# '# %  "%  "%  %     ( " "%%&  "       (  "  (       " 5 9





" " "  

"    

  :



""

  

" 

   

 "

 

 

   



  :  





  









  

 : 



   "   ;

"



 "   

 

 

 

8 

 





 

"

$

  

  "

 

  

     



$ 





    





<     

     

 

 " 

"



"   



 

   =

 

   

 /

   

          





     

           $    ""2 "    

     / 

 

 " >

8



  



 



 



/  

 "  "

<  



7  2  

 

  

/ 

"

 

   "

  

    

  2



 

 

    

 1 

 "

 



 



  

  "

/

"

$ /  

   "

        $   



   

   

/    

"

  / 

  

$ 1 



"

  





 



 >

8 

 

 

1 "

 

   

  "

   

  1 "

 "

 

  1 "

"  

     

  "

 



  

  

 9  

 " 

  

 

 



1 "

  

   ? 

  #$ % &'()& *+&)

    &     '

/ @ "

  *

(

 "

   &

 % '

 

   A  % *+0*

 () # #      '

  )    

  & 6  ) 9"

 / 

 "

 

 &

   '  /

 "

  

  

 % (5

 *( #  

   '

/

 "

6  ) 

  

   !" "

A  % *+0*

 ('

# #  

   &

  '

6  )

  

"





 *&

**  

$   

 #7  *++'

   

,.

   &    "

A  % *+0*

 (' # #  

 %

) (5

 *( #       &       '

    *

( 

  6  '

/

 "

 

   

   

  

   "

 6 % &    +0 +' *+&) 1  2)     '

/

 "

      % *+0*

 (' # #  

 % (5 6 /

 *( #  

     

"  

A  

? 

  #$ % &'()* *+&)

    ) 9"

 / 

 "

   /

 "

  

  

 % (5

 *( #  

  /

 "

6  )



  

   !" "

  % *+0*

 (' # #  

  6  )

  

"





 *&

**  

$   

 #7  *++'

   

,.

   &    "

A  % *+0*

 (' # #  

 % (5

 *( #       &      

 

 /

 "

 

   

   

  

   "

 6 % &    +0 +' *+&) 1  2)    /

 "

      % *+0*

 (' # #  

 % (5 6 /

 *( #  

     

"  

A  

   

  

  B   

   



!

" A:

@

A #   *+" ,(-., (,!  %&/            "   B   

   "  

       

 "

/    

 "

           = 

 ""

 A

! "

B   

     &   

 "    



  

 

 

/     = 

B   

   "

  

 

  )

 

   @ "

 

  /

 "



  

 



/     

  

 

   ? 



"

  

   

     1  "

!

" A:

- ?  #  

+, +.

0      +,  %'!&      1  2  34

 !    $% &''%"(&) )( 8  !

"

- ? 1 " "  

" 

 , A 56768935630 1"" ( /   2   %29 & %&.    %  "        ;

  +     8')     !          %%  1 &( %&"   %%&  %   (  ) %&&9%

  %   %     % #    "& %  

 % ""+ 9  ' ) %

%%     "    "        

%    9  B    9    (    &       %  '  "%9 2""&" % 

"+;

 %&"  '

 '% "(

:

""&  % 

 %8 )("

 %.  '%   "  -% ""& %"-

B              %   6 $  -""&- C0 0C01;

9 % 2( / C0 $222222 '$222222

$222222 $222222 $222222

$ ,"&D   ""&    &  #9  ( '%    '%9   %    %   / 9  '% '% %   

""&D + ( % (  ""& (  ;

( " (')  

  %+ '% ( E( #" ;

 

 ( &  ( &  ;

 %  &  

  &;



 "011 ;

%(  " .(%"01%(  % <(9 ""%%'  

 % 9(% " &%+%"0" "  % ""&  .  "

      "

'% &9 (     (%   

 .9(% 

" ;

 (&'"  "% "  ;

 

 C0 D +     4  ;  .,!   .( ." , 6$+7&9  

"( "

    &'  &9 " ;

 ""%&                 & " &

9 '9(%%2  %%& "(9" %%&   9  "% %%( ( 

"( %%'  '&

&'" ' $  +    7  %%  " '  

" "% " "  %  ""&  .D +   (         '  "     %    "  ""&  " "%

 1"  '&%  / & #

  "  ;

9  ')   % 9 " %%&"  )    ;

  C0

D  +!,,"(,+;! % %%)  "  & ( &" ;

""% ) %%' '&&% "  & ( ''&

;

D

  '     6$      

       ;

 / 7# %  &   "

" ;

(  ( %"%& 0%" "  % ""&   .    %  6 $   '   6 $ 

 

 ;



 +)  '&""%%

2         "           

% # & %  

9     9  '&       ; ( % "%%""%%""  

; %

E3

   1

F 1 2  

'  " ;

9((" %&.( 

% /   C0 <+%&=0 + " '   (& '

 '&  / 

  "%       1    %      &     ""&""&+ 

 %%   %&""%%1 9 

  (   9  ""%%         "%  

 " (%%("%  +    )     '%        ""&        )  < %&  ""&  +  % 9 (     '  '

    ;    @ +&9 9/ "  

  (    

       ;

  +     % / ''& 

% .

 &  "

" ;

  ' 6$  

 ;

+!

%( ")    %& "(90%"  "% " ;

  '

 6$  

6 % 6$  ' 6 $

 

$ " "% " "  % ""& .  '

 6 $  

6% 6 $  ' 6 $

 

$

!

%' +    ' '  !

% 

 "   "  % ""&  .   '& % %  " A    " % %%/ % ""&'"   

6 $ ;

( %

1  ' 6$

 

 ;

/ 7

 "("      " ;

""%&  +'     "% " %%&/ "  ""& 

;

(2  2

"'%9'

   "  

%&'

"& "   ""%%" %%&(%0          ""%%         %  * %& )< %&""&( % 

1'%""&'%  ) %&9 ''%) %& 



%   / % ! 1''4! %$&  &G "

9%%  

 %

 ""%% (  %.    "

     "%      !"  %%%   %%& %  / "% # %  ""%%'&(&   (%  ""%%        "%       :%  8     '%/  '""& #" "  ( (9

'1 9(/  %  

  %&" ( """%%%(""&" ('

( '(%""& %

&  

E 1 >!+  *   !     1  ?!!  %:& //' %'& " ( 

 E < 

;

9B E9 

$ %      % ""&    0 "           '      (   BB 

  0" '  " '&' ( %'% +%&2 "  (" %#"% '   F( &" ""&''  

 1 '

 9( " ('% ("

"9( "% ((9 ""%%" %%&""%% %'

"%%# #  %    % %'%'2 % " ""& +( % &"

" ;

(  0 

 / & (

   ;

1 9% ' " %       &    /   ( )   ;

" %%&'  &) !"  /    """"%%% "     %  "      '  %&  /     %   "  #"     ""&       '

  (   &   ) 1(& " ( %&#"&  #  ""%% % '%  #( 

%%&(%%    %"  

&'   %  ""%%1

9&')  " 

A +  %&%'

  " (   ' &     0""%%  "%( (%9%%"%"

  



" %&   '  & )   (" (%%&( '

%'& %&  9'

& ("( ( %&%(- %      % %%  &   ' ;

     ""%%  % " 

%%&     ( '   

" 5

*+ #      

 #7

 *++0  

 , ,( .,(!..4 ,@A6$ +     "  

% 9  %%  #  %%   &  "9   ')     

%7&   9      "     %     ""&    

. $  ")   %&  '0 %6$90 6$  "% %% "00 %  .% ()  9 " %%&(% '&%6 ( ' &' % ( .$

) 6$ " "%  9  "'%9( %(#% 9 %%

 . %%

% 9%%99 / #%&"'% " / 

   6$

"%3"'%  .%%' ""%&9'&% %"%  6$ % -6$%%'

  % ( %%   %  '( .9" %%& % '&%9H "%   ; 6$  " % %%  '"

'% .(%&  "% 9 %%9"' # "  % ""& 

. 6$  % %%"    %%""

%% 

    .

7&9'&9" & 6$    % 6$%%' #"%'% "

'% " 9&

 "  % %%'%&(   %   6$ % %%%&" 

  " %  '& & 62$ % - -' %%('&

.  &(%%'(%& "

'% . 62$             (#   .%%'""%& 9

/  

 . 62$

 &"%   

& 

.(%%' # ) ( . %       ' 9  !  %  ; 9  =   % 9  07 8 .9 62$      "    %   %%  '1" 7% % 

  9%&"'& & &9'      .  " 9 %  "          "

  

 

 9""#   62$    %% " '"% ' G%0

0      %

62$ +1" 7% % %%  " '  % 62$' "%9  / 9%% '  7&/ (%%&& 9 %9' "% '  % .    % 5  



 1  C 

 A  % *+0*

 ('# #  

  *5 &* &0D)

 % (5

 *( #  

 

"

 % &)''0  *) +0 &0'&   % )

4 "  6 % )   

 

*++D



 

   / 







 "

 ;    





/ % ) ?

 

  

  "

 % (5  *( # #  

     % *+0*  () # #   

 "

  "

 



  

    

 

        % )    "



    

  

 6  )  



 "



   "

 "   



    % )  



  "

4 "    

 "     

 =   ! A

"



        7  

 "

    

/   

 

 

= "  

  = 

   "

    )

  "   

 "  

 "

   "     "     

*++D  

    

 % )

 

 

 "

        % ) 

 



   !"

 "



:

 "  "

 



 

 6    "

   ""

  

      =

   "  

 (  8  !

 

  

 

 "

 

 "



!

   



    -    

    "  

     % )

        

    B   

       

 





   < 

 =     

 



 #   #      "  "  "





      8 

   

 " 



"   

 " 

" % 

  

 

0 1+ 2 /

)