← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12820/2017disposed of

Ramesh And ORS v. State Of Haryana ORS

2019-07-24Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

  



      

$'( %()!*!"+  ,  $-(*.$"%'.(/* 0('!'!"(/* 1(/*2* 3'$'( $/4$"$$"%'.(/* 0(*5"%("'* ( /(+

"678(/2*'!)(3&$8!$ /(*("'+ /9.288$/:%;)$'( /'.(5('!'!"(/* / $/!*.$'.((:3/ : $/4$"$ <<<   

   => (*5!'("'!)( '.($558!)$'!"!(

  .$;!"?7(("!**2(%" $"%'!-('$@("' !8(/(584:"/(584.$* 7((" !8(% '!88 %$'( %(*5!'( 8!*'!"?   '.( )$*( '.(/($ '(/ "  ,:  ,:  ,:,:, $* A(88 $*'%$4  ' $8* "((%* "'!)!"? .(/( '.$' "  , A.!8( $%B2/"!"? '.( )$*( '

 ,:!'A$*"'!)(%'.$'/%(/%$'(%C  .$%7(("5$**(%74 '.( "?!"((/:/;!")!$8!;!*!":&E:$8A$8F2$$88 '.(5('!'!"(/*:4('/( (/(")( '.($//($/*$%-!**!78(''.(5('!'!"(/*!" '(/-*'.(/( /(*'/!)'(%'C -"'.*.$%7(("$88A(%"84F2$5('!'!"(/  %(*5!'( ("'!'8(-("'   $88 '.( 5('!'!"(/* ' $//($/*   C  -"'.* !" '(/-*   '.( $ /(*$!% /%(/ %$'(% C    G($/"(% 3/   .$% /(F2(*'(% /$*./'%$'('/(*5"%''.($ /(-("'!"(%58($72'$*.$* 7((""'!)(%$7;(:'!88%$'("/(584.$*7((" !8(%"'.()!/)2-*'$")(*: $-"'!")8!"(%'$%B2/"'.()$*($"4 2/'.(/

=> => /!( $)'* '.()$*(8($%!"''.( !8!" '.(A/!'5('!'" $/('.$''.(5('!'"(/*A.$/( !;(!""2-7(/*A(/(A/@!"$*(8%$/*" %$!84HA$?(* *!")( ,,#,C $"% '.(!/ *(/;!)(* A(/( '(/-!"$'(% "  ,,  ( (/(")(   '.( !"%2*'/!$8 %!*52'( $-"?*' '.( 5$/'!(* A$* -$%( ' '.( G$72/ 2/' A.!) %!*-!**(% '.( *$-( ;!%( $A$/% %$'(% CC('!'"(/*'C:'.(/($ '(/: !8(% &*, C:, $"%,  $?$!"*''.($A$/%%!*-!**!"'.(!//( (/(")( .(*$!% A/!'5('!'"*A(/($88A(%74'.!* 2/' .($ /(-("'!"(%5('!'"(/* A(/( /%(/(% ' 7( /(!"*'$'(% A!' )"'!"2!'4   *(/;!)( A!' I 7$)@ A$?(*;!%(/%(/%$'(%   .(/($ '(/:3G   !8(% 74'.(/(*5"%("'*$?$!"*''.(%()!*!" '.( "678(!;!*!"("). '.!* 2/' !" '.

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

(* '.(5('!'"(/*$*(8%$/A( C =C> "   A.!8("'!)"?'.$''.(5('!'"(/*A(/(*((@!"7("( !'  !D$'!"   5$4 "'!"$884: '.( /(*5"%("'H3'$'( A$* %!/()'(% ' 5$** $55/5/!$'(/%(/*$ '(/?!;!"'.(-!"$%;(/'("'84'45(%$*K.!-67("( "'!"$8 !D$'!" 5$47( /('.("(D'%$'( .($/!"2/*2$"''.

=C> 

!)(/%(/* ,' C%$'(%C  A(/(5$**(%74'.(

"?!"((/:/;!")!$8!;!*!":&E:$8A$8A.(/(74'.(5$4 '.( 5('!'!"(/*A$*/( !D(%"'!"$884A( C 5!(* '.(/%(/*$*

2/"!*.(%74'.(8($/"(%3/ $/('$@(""/()/% = > " 5$/$?/$5.     '.( $558!)$'!" !(  

   :!'.$*7(("$;(//(%'.$'5('!'!"(/A$*5$!%$//($/*$ '(/ !D$'!"  "'!"$85$4A!'.(

/-%2(%$'(72'"/%(/.$%7(("5$**(%A!'. /(?$/%'5('!'!"(/*' //($*"*7(*'@"A"''.(/(*5"%("'* $8'.2?.5('!'!"(/*'A(/(*!-!8$/84*!'2$'(%$*5('!'!"(/(;(" '.2?. /%(/ %$'(%     .$% 7((" 5$**(% 74 '.!* 2/' F2$ $88 '.( 5('!'!"(/* => /(*5"*(.$*7((" !8(%''.($558!)$'!" .(/( /(:'.(/( !* " /($*" ' %!*7(8!(;( '.( $;(/-("' '.$' $ '(/ !D$'!"   5$4   '.( 5('!'!"(/* "'!"$884 A(  C: 5('!'!"(/  .$* 7((" 5$!% $//($/* => G($/"(% 3/   *'$'(* '.$'5('!'!"(/ A$* 5$!% $//($/*

/C -"'.*5/!/''.( !8!"? '.(A/!'5('!'!"*!")(%!/()'!"*5$**(% !"/%(/%$'(%   A(/("84F2$5('!'!"(/ = > .( $ /(-("'!"(% *'$"% !* ;(.(-("'84 55*(% 74 8($/"(% )2"*(8 /'.(5('!'!"(/*A.)"'("%*'.$'$.45(/'()."!)$8$/?2-("'!* 7(!"?$%;$")(%!";!(A '.($55$/("''45?/$5.!)$8-!**!"!"'.(/%(/

/ $8'.2?. !" '.( /%(/ !' A$* "'!)(% '.$' '.( 5('!'!"(/* A(/( *((@!"? 7("( !'  !D$'!"   5$4 "'!"$884: '.(/( /(: /(*5"%("'H3'$'( A$* %!/()'(%'5$**$55/5/!$'(/%(/*72''.(7("( !'A$*/%(/(%'7(?!;("' .!-!(5('!'!"(/G($/"(%)2"*(8*'$'(*'.$''.(A/!'5('!'!".$* 7((" !8(%74 !;(5('!'!"(/* .(7("( "'!"$85$4 !D$'!"*2?.'!* 74'.(5('!'!"(/*$"%!'!*"84$'45?/$5.!)$8-!**!"!"'.(/%(/A.!).

= > !**2?.''7(/(8!(%25"74'.(/(*5"%("'*'%("4'.(7("( *!-!8$/ /(8!( 7(!"?(D'("%(%'5('!'!"(/*' = >  .$;( )"*!%(/(% '.( *27-!**!"*   8($/"(% )2"*(8 / '.( 5$/'!(* =,> %-!''(%84: '.( A/!' 5('!'!" A$* !8(% 74 !;( 5('!'!"(/* /%(/%$'(%   "'!)(%'.$''.(5('!'!"(/*A(/(*((@!"?7("(

!D$'!" 5$4"'!"$884"'.($ /(-("'!"(%)"'(D':%!/()'!"*A(/( !**2(% ' '.( /(*5"%("'H3'$'( ' 5$** $55/5/!$'( /%(/* $ '(/ ?!;!"? .!- !"$%;(/'("'84 '45(% $* K.!-6: A.(/($* !' $55$/("'84 !* K'.(-6 7("( !'  "'!"$8 !D$'!" 5$4 .(/%(/*7;!2*84/( (//(%')8$!-74$88'.( 5('!'!"(/*:'.(/( /(:!'!*"'5("''.(/(*5"%("'*'$%5'$%!

(/("' 4$/%*'!)@!"'.()$*( 5('!'!"(/*' ))/%!"?84:'.(/(*5"%("'*$/(%!/()'(%'/(8($*('.(7("( !'* 5$4$78('5('!'!"(/*'$*A(/(/(8($*(%'5('!'!"(/A!'.!"$ 5(/!% 2/A((@* /-'%$4 $!8!"?A.!).'.(*$-(*.$88)$//4!"'(/(*' LI5(/$""2-A( '.(%$'( ("'!'8(-("''!88%$'( 5$4-("' =,> ))/%!"?84: *'$"%*%!*5*(%  =>  ''.!**'$?(:8($/"(%)2"*(8 /'.(5('!'!"(/**'$'(*'.$''.( 5('!'!"(/* $/( ("'!'8(% ' /(8($*(   $//($/* A!'. (

/- '.( %$'(  /(?28$/!J$'!"!(C$"%'.$''.(5('!'!"(/*7(?/$"'(%8!7(/'4' ).$88("?('.($)'!" '.(/(*5"%("'*!"/(*'/!)'!"?'.(7("( $//($/*' C  -"'.* $* .$% 7((" $88A(% !" '.( )$*(   5('!'!"(/  74 '.(

"?!"((/:/;!")!$8 !;!*!":& E: $8A$8 $"%$*.$* "A7(("$88A(%!"'(/-*'.(/( 74'.!* 2/' =>  "'.(8!?.' '.(5*!'!"$*"'(%$7;(:'.(A/!'5('!'!"!* %!*5*(%   $* $7;( A!'. '.( 8!7(/'4 ' '.( 5('!'!"(/* ' '$@( $)'!" !"

=> $))/%$")(A!'.8$AF2$'.(!/?/!(;$")(* /5$4-("' $//($/*A!'.(

/-'.(%$'( /(?28$/!J$'!"$*5(/8$A:!

*("'!'8(% 3&$8!$

 ,  2%?( $-!' 1. Whether speaking/reasoned:

Yes/No.

2. Whether reportable :

Yes/No.