Ashwani Kumar And ANR v. The Central Administrative Tribunal And ORS




    
  
 

!"#$#%&'&()* * '+,!(&-./!0!($!(0  #"&"&(#0'

1' +##("0!2$/&(&'"0!"&1#0&3.(!24+!($&5!0+!($0'  #'6($#("'

 7* 7

+#8#%0#"!0940!('60"#6!0"/#("0!('60"4+!($5&!0+  #"&"&(#0 1' +##("0!2$/&(&'"0!"&1#0&3.(!24+!($&5!0+!($0'   #'6($#("'

0!/) (:32#0.'"&%# !;&18+!0/!

(:32#0.'"&%#!0&($#08&(5+8&$+.

0#'#(")< 0 -!('!24$1%!"#0 0 8+!0/!4$1%!"# 0"+#6#"&"&(#0'&(  !($

#'6($#("'!($=&( 7* 7 '!>!(>'+!8!,+(#94$1%!"#!($ ' 0&9!(>!!2!24$1%!"# 0"+#6#"&"&(#0&( 7* 7!($ 0#'6($#("'"&( <  0 9!24$1%!"#,&"+ '!0"&9!24$1%!"# 00#'6($#("&(3"+%!'#'

< 
 

8&(%#%//(?.#'"&('2!,!($!%"'!0#&(121#$&(3"+ "+#'#,0&"6#"&"&('40##00#$"!31#4"+#0#0#43"+"+#'#6#"&"&('+!1# 3##("!>#(.6"5#"+#00$&'6'!2 ,#1#04"+#!%"'!0#3#&(5"!>#( 0/  

<< +#6#"&"&(#0'&( ( +!1#'.5+";.$&%&!2 0#1&#,    "+#  0$#0   0#($#0#$  39  #("0!2  $/&(&'"0!"&1#  0&3.(!24 +!($&5!0+#(%+ +#0#&(!"#00##00#$"!':"+#0&3.(!2: 6!''#$&(     *@@   $#%&$#$  (  = A =  +#  8#%0#"!094  0!('60"

#6!0"/#("4+!($&5!0+4+!'!2'%+!22#(5#$"+#0$#0$!"#$= A = 0#($#0#$39"+#2#!0(#$0&3.(!239,!9 (7* 7 +#30&#!%"'(#%#''!090$&'6'!2"+#60#'#("6#"&"&(' !0#"+!"6#"&"&(#0(,!'!66&("#$!'2#0>( 

,+#0#!'

6#"&"&(#0(,!'!66&("#$!' #( ( A 

 +#6#"&"&(#0'

/!$#0#60#'#("!"&(''##>&(5"+#&00#5.2!0&'!"&('4,+&%+,#0#0#;#%"#$
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
"&'&("+#'#%&0%./'"!(%#'4"+#60#'#("6#"&"&( +!'3##(&2#$

#"&"&(#0(+!$3##(,0>&(5!'2#0>'&(%# 

 !($6#"&"&(#0(!' #('&(%#

D#!0(#$  %.('#2  !66#!0&(5  (  3#+!2    "+#  +!($&5!0+ $/&(&'"0!"&(,!'$&0#%"#$"'##>&('"0.%"&('!'",+#"+#0"+#6'" 2#0>+!'3##(%0#!"#$0("

<< D#!0(#$  %.('#2  !660&'#$  "+&'  .0"  "+!"  1&$#  0$#0  $!"#$

* * 0#%#&1#$0/1"
($&!&(&'"09 !$0!('60"!($ &5+,!9'4 0!('60"8#%"&( 1"
($&!+!''!(%"&(#$"+#%0#!"&( (#6'"0&1#0!($(#6'"2#0>&("+#8"!"#0!('60"."+0&"94 +!($&5!0+ 8!0!'6#"&"&(#0(&'%(%#0(#$4+#%!(3#0$#0#$"3# 0#5.2!0&'#$  !5!&('"  "+#  6'"    2#0>  '!(%"&(#$  1&$#  0$#0  $!"#$

* * 
"&''#""2#$2!,"+!"!%("0!%".!2#/629##%!(("3#0#62!%#$ 39!("+#0%("0!%".!2#/629## 8&/&2!0294(,,#!$1#0"""+#!%"'"+#%!'#6#"&"&(#0 (<"/! !/4,+,!'!66&("#$!' #((A 

D#!0(#$  %.('#2  !66#!0&(5  (  3#+!2    +!($&5!0+ $/&(&'"0!"&(+!'$0!,("+#!""#("&("+&'.0""1#0(/#("0$#0 $!"#$  =,+#0#39!'6#0"+# .(;!31#0(/#("&('"0.%"&('$!"#$ *    %.62#$  ,&"+  "+#  0#%//#($!"&('    "+#  7"+ #("0!2  !9 //&''&( #60"4!22"+#0.6::6'"'!'!($,+#(!22#(1!%!("!0#" 3#&22#$.6"+0.5+."'.0%&(5!"#022,&(5606#060%#$.0# +#&('"0.%"&('$!"#$  ='+!22!662960'6#%"&1#29!($ ,&22("$#60&1#"+#0&5+"'#/629##'0%('&$#0!"&(0#5.2!0&'!"&( 1#0!66&("#$(  =

#"&"&(#0(&',0>&(5!' #('&(%#A 


"60#< '.66'#'"+!",0>&'6#0#((&!2&((!".0##+!',0>#$0/0#"+!( 9#!0'+#+!($&5!0+$/&(&'"0!"&(%!(("3#6#0/&""#$"#E"0!%""+# ,0>0/"+#,0>/!(09#!0'!($"+#((""0#5.2!0&'#+&/#,!' !2'("6#0/&""#$",0>!"#09#!0',&"+."0#5.2!0&'&(5+&/

<=< %%0$&(529"+#,0&"6#"&"&(( *&'!22,#$+#0#'6($#("'

!0#$&0#%"#$"!3'036#"&"&(#0(!5!&('""+#6'"2#0>,&"+&(= ,##>'+#"#0/&(!"&(6#"&"&(#0(&''#"!'&$#!($+#,.2$3# $##/#$  " +!1#  3##(  0#5.2!0&'#$  !'  #( 39/.2$&(5 "+# 0#2&#4 3."

,&"+."  3!%>  ,!5#'  ('#?.#("29  "+#  ,0&"  6#"&"&(  (7*     7 60##00#$39"+##("0!2$/&(&'"0!"&1#0&3.(!24+!($&5!0+&'$&'/&''#$ 

!;&18+!0/! .$5#  !0&($#08&(5+8&$+.

* * .$5# ".2@!1&($#0-./!0 +#"+#0'6#!>&(5@0#!'(#$#'@ +#"+#0 #60"!32#) #'@