Vinod Kumar Sikka @ ORS v. Punjab Water Resources Management And Development Corporation Limited & ORS
!
"
### ! !
"
!
""
$%& !
!" '!"()!! !*!+,! , - ! !
"
### !",! "
!
!"! . ( # " +/*' !0 !,! !
"# ( #(! !!, ) / +*' !!!
+/
$%# ( # ( /*' ! 0 ! !",! "# !" # $ !, !"! 2 ,! / !' ++!)!" !
!34#53#35678!9 :;<%=2 ' !'+0 !,! !
"
0 ! ) 0 !
!" ! !+=! ,=! " *! %!! !'+!# " ,!
! 0' " " ! ! , !"! ,! / !
" ! 0 "!
*'! 45#5>#3566/ 46#56#3566 46#5;#3564 !",!' *!+=# "%!!++!)! !,! !
+%!!0 "0 !,! !
"2!
! ,! !+=0 !
! !! 2!
!2 !+%= ! !",! "2 = *+$" 0' ! 2 ' / !,! ! " !! +!0 !
!"
! !+=! !+!"! 0 ! ,=! "# " ! !?!" 0 !
" 0 ! ) 0 !
!" 2" %!) ''!, !/ !
""!
*!, ! !",! "+!)+ '!"!!
) !
!" ! !+=! !+!"! ,=! "# + !+=/ !
"0+!& #3@7A50356B8 C(</2 ' 2"","! 0%= " 6>#63#356B !' ) ! !",! " !'!
!+!)+ '! !6@#5A#356B2 ,! 0! # , "'! !" !' )*!%= " / !
!",! ",""! ! 34#53#3567!'+) !'+0 "0 !) 0 !
!" !) !!+= 2" ! + !"!2", '! +/ !
!0 !/ !" ",=%+!# " "!
' ++!)! !, !"! 2 ,! # !,+=/ 2 ' " %!! 0+! %! +0 0 !
!",! "/ !"!" "%!! ! ! !+!"!0 !
+%!!0 "0 !,! !
"2"!+=!! !!'!"" = , '! !!
!0 !
!2",' =00""
2 !0"2!
!'!*!/ !%!!0 "2!
!+!"! !
"# ! !+!* , 0 ! !,+=""!
D6# !
!"!+= !, 0 !"2!
)
!",! " , *) ! ) = +!*!
!'" ! ! ,! !
"# ! !+=/ 0 =/ "
''
!! !'
!",!'! '' ! 0 !,, *+0 +%!!0 "0 !,! !
"# 3# ! !+=/ 0 =/ ''
! ! !+!"! 0 ,=! %= ! "2!
) !",! " 2"
! +# '! !0"2!
!!*+%+!/ !
"2!
) !",! ""% "! !"!, = %"" !
!0 !0+ '%! ' ! !''
% 0 !"2!
) !",! "# 4# !"2!
) !",! "2!
!+2=" != 2++) !+!"! !) = !+!*!!'" ! " +" ! !!'!"" =" !," !9!' ! ! "!# " ,!
! ! !
#6 !, +45/3566!*!%!0 " !! / !"2!
) !",! " + != "! " '"! 0 ,, *+ !% = 6B/ 3566/ !0 !
/ "'"!2",, *!+=6;/3566 !
0"2!
!?!" ! !"!= "!+0# !0"0
,=! 0 " + %!!0 " 2!
! !'!*!
!, !%!
36/3566 !"!2!
!+!"! !
!9 !#!# !, !%!
33/3566#E *! ! !'"!+0 !, !" *!)!
) ! !' 0 !'"!2 ! %+!""" '!# ' " 2) ! !0 !! ! !0
!+!"!0 !%!!0 " !,! !
"""!
.:
# # ! 0 !
!,+=!!
!
0
!! 0 ) = !
0 ,=! 8 =< -!*!
!'" ! !
0 ,=! 8-!*!
!'" ! <
"F
-+ 45#5>#3566 ;>BA3B 33#5A#3566 >>>;@5 33#5A#3566
"
) "F ) ) 46#56#3566 @6>;;5 3A#63#3566 35B547 5>#54#3564
$ ) "F !$ ) 46#5;#3564 @663A7 36#56#356@ 3B;@B5 36#56#356@ % !,!
"+0 !%*!' 2+" 2 !
,=! "2!
!+!"!0 !
,!
))0 5@ " 53 =! "# ) "%!!, ! " 2 = !,=! "2!
& !+=!# !+=$" 0' )*! ! !,+=%= ! !",! "
" !!+=2"! !, '! +, '!"",' =0 0"# !"! 2 ) " ! *+ ) " ! !
,!" =%!!0 "0!,+=!!# "%!! !+%= !*" !' 0 " !*!,' =00"" *+) 2 + !,!" =%!!0 "# ! !+!* , 0 !*" !' $)! 0 " +!" '()'*'+,-'+'./+.
/*012*"03-4'5*'+-3*2*3*'2/+'+5'+260*"355@84<
- @;5""!
!
"
# $
% #
&
# #
"#
"!+0 !,! !
"0 " !" !'"!0 """? !+='*!
!",!
!!'" !!
!%= ++!' 0 " '+56'7',-2'20 4+8'9 #%$&
"'' ) 2 ' " !,! !
" !! +!0
!" +" " *+ $" 0' " %!! )*! %= !
:
!",! "% !!+=! !+!"!0 ! +%!!0 " !
"# !%"!'!0=$" 0' / !,! ! "'+ != ! ! +! 0 !
!" ! !+=! ,=! "# !
!+!* , 0 !"$)! ""!
'! )*!
! !,+=!! " !! %!'!" ! !+= ! +! ,!" !
%!!0 " !
" 0 ! !" +!"/ = "
"+ !"+= '" ! ! !" ! !
"% "!! 0,!" !
%!!0 " !
, ,!
!#" 2 ", ,!
!2++!,! !0' "' '" '!"0!' '"!% ++= 2+ !9'!! 2 "0 ! !0 !! 2 ' !+ "%!!+2%= !,!9 (# % G"'"!8", <#0 ! !' "
=!0+ !,!
0 '!0 " = !
!%=!=) ! !! ! %!!0 0 ! ! ! "! 0 " !=/ !
!")"=) !0' !)! " ) %!',!" !/ ,/ !+=2= ',!" ! " ,= !
!" 0 !,!
0 !+= ! "2"! ! !0 "
!! #E += "/ " 2 +!!') 600(',- 2'20 '*;'+''+5260*-" &#%$#/</=$%:: +" !+ '! ! "%!! ! !/ !!,+=!!2++%!'!
! +!0 !) 0 !
!" # ! !+!* , 0 !" "
"!
D !$ ", ! +%""0 ) 0 !
!" " !0'
!,!
"G"!= "%!!"!%="!%=!+"!# " "!"! ! 0 !")!0!=#0 !"!
"
',!%==!)+)!'! !, 0 !,!
" 2 2 !!="+=) = !"+ ) !
!
%!'"! ! ' +" '+! ! ',! 0 )!"8 !0 0 !
!" <# !' '" '!"/ !*!0 !
!"!)+)!'! !, 0 ! ! ' %!!! !=2 ' ) +=%!+)! 2" !'" =0 ! !2"
%!)"!%= #E *!20 !%*!/ !,! !
" !0! +!0
!" !!+=! !+!"!0 !,=! "HAI,!
# "!+0 ! !",! "" !" ",!
!
,""! %= " & #3@36> 0 356B/ !'! 3A#5A#35672 ' +" !+ !" !"!!, ! / ! !
!"
"%!!++2!0 !
!!9, =0 !! "0 ! !0
!! ++ ! !0' +,=! 0 ! # ! !+!* , 0 !" ""!
D ) '"!
!0' "' '" '!"0 !'"! / " "0 !'"!
!*!2 ) 0 !
!" H AI ,!
! !+=! ,=! 0 ) = +!*! !'" ! !
/0 !
!9, =0 !! "0 ! !0
!! ++ ! ,=! / " +!)++= 0' ++= $" 0!#'' )+=/ " 2 " !
!" HAI ,!
!!+=!,=! 8"< 0) = +!*!!'"!! !,! !
/2 ' 2++%!,=%+!
0 !
!9, = 0 !! " 0 ! ! 0 "
!! ' + !0,=! !' , '+
+ %!!0 "/ " ++ %! , ! ,! ! %= !
!",! #6 0 !
'+'+ ) ! "! 2 ,!
0 2 "0 ! !0 !'!, 0'!
0! ',=0 "$)! #'"!0:',+'!0 " / ,! !
" " ++ %! +%!
= ,, ' "
#E *!20 !%*!/ !,! !
"2++%!! +!0
!" HAI,!
0 !
!!9, =0 !! "0 !
! 0 !! ++ ! ' + "% "!! 0 ! "! "
!,' !%*!#-! ! !
!" %!'+'+ !2 ,!
0 2 "0 ! !0 !'!, 0'!
0!',=0 " !' +,=! "0 !'+'+ ! %! !+!"! ! 2 ,!
0! !
!0 !
# !2 ,! " "++2! !%*! !
"# 09*4'*; " 82 #!$ ! & ! !
",! )F !"!.!"F & ! !
!, %+!
.!"F