Life Insurance Corporation Of India And ORS v. Dalip Singh
-1- 2023:PHHC:048535
!"
#$
"%&'&#() * + +
, -
-
"!&!&#(".
/".'0'
, -
1"'2#(3"(!
)
4 , - /
-
/
-
,
! "
#"" #
$%&%'
()&* !+
, " '!"
-
+ * . " (
#
)/ ,#"
&$0 '
1 &$02* !+ "
!
!+
)"
! "+""
-2- 2023:PHHC:048535 3 "+ 4
)"
# "
/ + "
+ .&0006 6&&
" 7 %8)
6&&
" 99&
)"
"
- " :
" : 5
7 9&& :
" + !
# # / + + ;
"
! (!+ ! :
" 9&& :
<&&
( "+7 8) " !
" "#
) / +
&9 "
90&9 ##
" "
)/ ,#"
&$0 !
, " '!"
-
+ *. "
)5 / +
# "
!=
"
# "
! !
!+
)"
!
" !+
)"
!"5 " "
!
!+
)"
"
4
- ":
" : 5
7
+ #+
5 :
"
4
" " ! ""
-3- 2023:PHHC:048535 "
+ " #+ # !+
)"
"
# "
+
:
!" > !=
" -
!
!+
, " '!"
-
+ * . " "+ "" "
"
) "
" # "+7 &<8)" #
?$@
90&9
""
!
7 &%8)
" ## !+
! "!+ 5 / + , "
)5 / +
"
# !+
, " '!"
-
+ * . "
""#"
+
, " '!"
-
+ *
#
)/'6* '*
&$0:" "
" "
! " !+
"
, " '!"
-
+ * +!
#
)/'6* '* &$0 = + / !
)/'0* &$0 "+
#
-4- 2023:PHHC:048535
)/'* " " !"+:
"
)"
# "+ !+
5 / +
# # !+
, " '!"
-
+ * . " # )
!=
!+
) / +
, " '!"
-
+ *
"
+
!
!+
) "
#
)"
"
""+
# !+ +
#
"
+
, "
)"
"" ! "+
!+
, " '!"
-
+ *
""#"
+
+ + )
!+
, " :
, " '!"
-
+ * # !+ AB
+
"
" =
C !=
+
" =
); &$0
# !
)"
+ "! ""+ ) + B
# :
)5 / + #
! ("
# !
"
"
-5- 2023:PHHC:048535
""+
"+
#
"
# , "
!+
, " '!"
-
+ * . " "+!
(
#/
! !
)"
5" "
# #
" #
+
" ! "
+
&$0 ( )
!
!
!
" # !
!
!
!
$
%" # !
!
!
!
!
$ !
%!
#
&
!
" # !
!
'#
!
!
# %! !
!
-6- 2023:PHHC:048535
(
!
!
!
# $ !
) *!
(
!
!
!
% !
!
!
!
! !
!
! %! !
#
%! ! !
!
!
! !
%! ! !
#
!
!
+ ,
!
!
+
!
#
!
!
!
!!
!
- *!
!
(
) !
!
!
%
!
!
! !
!
.
/!
!
(
- !
!
!
!
-7- 2023:PHHC:048535 0 1!
!
!%!!
!
%!!
#
!
2 *!
!
!
!
&
!
%! !
!
!
# !
!
#
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
% !
!
!
3 *!
!
(
2 !
!
!
4 5 !
)/ '6* '* "+ "!
, " '!"
-
+ *
# #
#
"
#
! "" !
!+ ,# " =
#" "
+ ! " " =
"+
" B
" ,# "
!= =
! !=
#
-8- 2023:PHHC:048535 D B
# + +
(
!+ : 2!" /
#$ % & ' !( ) *+ , -
"!+ : 2!"/
# + = + " !
!+
, " '!"
-
+ * "
"
)/
&$0 !
" "+"" !+
, " 7"
(
# .&0 =#
) 6 777 8
!
(9
)
!
%! (9
- !
%
!
: !
(9
- (9
.
!
!
!
!
8 !
!
!
(9
0 !
%! !
!
#
; , !
!
9 (9
2 % !
%!
!
!
& %
!
!
! !
1 !
!
!
!
% !
#
!
<
-9- 2023:PHHC:048535
!
(9
2
!
(
3
4 "
!+ : 2!"( / E
# +F
)/ &$0 E
, " = +
&$0F : 2!" ( / "
#
# ! ) 6)* % !
%!
!
!
- /!
#
(9
( #
((
!
!%
/!
!
%! ! !
$ !
#
%! (9
/!
!
,
!
%! (9
) 8!
!
!
# !
!
%
!
%! (9
- .
0 9 , !
!
%! (9
2 !
% !
!
!
!
1
!
% !
8
!
-10- 2023:PHHC:048535 !
!
!
!
.9 !
!
%(= > ! ! # ,
%!
!
?1( 9 % !
9
!
> ! =
@A !
!!! !
!
%
$
%
!
"( !
?1( !
BB !
C32 # (
7/!
#
%! !
!
! !
!
!
!
! $
! !
!
7 )/!
9 8$
@
!
!
?1(>! % !
#
!
!
!
!
!
! ! !
# !
!
!
!
!
%
!
$
! !!
!
&&& &&& &&& 0 1
!
!
#
!
-11- 2023:PHHC:048535
/!
!
#
! !!
1 !
!
(
9
( !
!
!
/! %
!
#
!
!
D% %!
#
!
%
!
! ! !
, !
$
#
$
#
!
#
%
$
!
!
0 /!
E !% !
!
%! !
! % $
9
( 3 *
! 5# !
!
%!
((
% 9
(F 9
() % , !
!
!
!
!
1 !
!
!
!
!
!
! ! 9
( - 1 !
9
( .
!
!
-12- 2023:PHHC:048535 %! 9
( 0 !
!
! !
/!
!
!
!
!
%!
!
!
!
1
!
!
!
$
9
( 3 G
!
! 9
(: !
!
!
$
%!
$ !
!
29
(3
!
9
(2 !
/!
!!
!
9
( 2 !
1
%
!
$
%
!
&
% %! !% %
# /!% !
%!
!
9 . / 0 , 1
' /0 / 1. 0
20 , ' / 0 0 .
% 3 , 0 %( ( 4 !
-13- 2023:PHHC:048535 +
" "+!+ = "
!
#
" B
#
)/'6* '* &$0 +
, " '!"
-
+ * B
"
"+
=
" #
= +
)/'0* &$0!+
, " '!"
-
+ * !=
"
# + #
! + ! ""
!"" :
#
#
# + " B
! "" !+
, " '!"
-
+ * . "
"" $%&%'
()&*
, " '!"
-
+ *. "
#
"
#
+
#
-14- 2023:PHHC:048535
!
, " '!"
-
+ *. " &&69 .%5 *6 +
/
-
5"!5".
'2" 7&(89." '#("3
)
"'9#
5"!5".
."2#.! :;"
)
"'9#