← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3680/2007dismissed

Nachhattar Kaur And ORS. v. Satwant Singh Bhangoo And ORS.

2022-07-28Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj14 pages

  

!

"

#

$ %# &'

( )

" ( ! ( * ++ , --  . , - -  -

 /0  ---1122 3- 4 +5 '5  ---1 -  

 /0  ---1122 3- 4 +5 '5  ---1 -    !06 +5 ---1122 3- 4 +5  ---1 "

,

7'8 - &#

"



& '&& 

         

  

 !"#$%!&%%'( 

   )" !"#$)!&%%'

 *+, 

  !)'#)!&%%$

-       .

     + /  *    *,      )



& '&&:

&- 

  (  0



      *.         &"

%

&%%' 

  0,    1 

2* 0,*.  %& %# &%%



  *   &$     %$ %# )33"  0,  2  +*  +*  4(  -*

.*0,    )(5 

    .

  * 

    / 

  2*  

 

0,   .0 0  "  0, 

6,     

6 

( *  ..0     . *'#5 )'.

 .

5

 "$)"$& 5  *

#   '5  )") )   $5  ))   35  &&7)   #%5 

7&#))#7))#7&)#7" &7)  *     * *     ,  ,       

* ,  8*  ,   .

*  ..    * ,!

   

 9*7   

 * ,

 

:.

,#, 0 5

0,   .,*

* . .,;

 .

*8*   -  * .;

 .

** ,* *

* /

0*9* .

 *<(

  *

* *  2 *    , 

  **

*  * * 

 *  

*

* :* = *%

%$ )33&  *. 

*0  2 *

*

*

.4 ,   2 ;  -* 

 %

%& )33" % %& )33"

/  )"   *

*<0!;

  ! *5 

* !

9*. ,:*  

 * , . * '5  ' .

      *   "

/*   . *)#5 %.

  

  0,  * 

*                )$%%%%7!   

  . *)5 '.



       )'"%%%7!

 *

*

  :*  

**   > .  *. 0,   ?

 *.0 ( 4 

 ( . ,=  %

%& )33" ,:*0,*

* .

 . *&35 )%.

  * 

 .,60    ( *

* 7  

*. /  .  0*:*      =    .*       

       *     /   .     *  8*.

0,    .      *  ,  ,     *    5      .  * *5 

*

/         *  0,    

    .  4    )    "           .   

. ,0 .

  0,*

 5 *  .

  *

*

;     2 *               

     * *0*  ,     ) "   0!!

   , 1*

    *

* =  %

%$ )33& * 0, .    0    *.0  .

 :*=

 *0, . :*=   *  )"%"

%& )33"

=,  . 

, *0.

/ 

   .

 .  . ,0 .

  0,*  . .   

,. *

/            @    

 2*  .*  

 *    

 2*.**.  %& %# &%%0, 0= *0,

   * 0, 

   *.  %& %# &%%    

0 

"0 4 +*-*  0    00  " )# %'

&%% 

 %3 %$ &%% *A ) *&&22 *0, 2* * #'  '! /

2**..

< *.  &"

%

&%%'  

0, 

 00,  .

4  *.  &"

%

&%%'

 0,1

2*- < 

     

  0      "#$%!&%%'    "#$)!&%%'       )'#)!&%%$ 00,9*.   "( 

 *

0 

 -< 

  ( * *

*  * *4-*  -*    2 * :*= %

%$ )33&

!)(  *0,  ;**0.  = ,    0 *.0.

   

 = *.0.



- ** * *

*

  , 0 ,=  +  

 (  .

 - * *

 2*     ., *5*6 =!"( +   =!

(*0.  *5*6



  0   *

*   

   . ,  +  

    .!:

.   5 = - * *   =     ,   ,  

            **    * *  *. 

  *   8** #"C *)3& #$C B)$'& .  2* , =0*

2* *, 0,.    *= %

%& )33"

4!

(  *  0,     

   

   ,    

  

0,:

.0  !4 

4=!)( ?  4=!&(0* = 0 0,0 2** 0*0,,* =! =!# ;* *   = !)( 

  ,*.     .

,8*.*#" (C *)3& C*

 *. * * D 

  

      

!  "   

  !#$"

$ % % &'( ) ')*(+  ; , .

* *. 

0,1

2**  0  .0  00,

0

 

 *+, *

0 



  "(    *. 0,**

*  = !)(

00, * *.

 0* 

:

. ; * 

  

= *.0.

  :

D

   E *      * 0 ;   =!

+                *   B           :*=0.*,*0*   +,  ** *   5    ,     ,)33

*.  5  ,)33&0*0 0 

*02 * :*= - * *

* *.0.

  0 5

 = *.0.

  

        2*               !0    =

*0, 0*

2**,   - ** *0.            :* *  "0, *

*0*  0      :8*  .* ; , *  

  0         .

*  *.        &"

%

&%%'0  00,

0  

A  

-   *   * =* 0,  =  0 , 0,:

.0  

  ,  ,5 *

*  **.0 .

  . *. 0       *     

         0    *.0

 .

  .

5D

   E* :

. *

 02 *  .  

0,+      - * *0.  *,  .  = 0.

 

2*     2* *       * 

 2*  =! =!# *0. *

*

.   %

%& )33" %'

%

.

: ,



0,:* =       * *  * 0,     ,      0     *.              .

* , ; , 

0.

  *

 

  2*  *0   

   * , 

*,  0,*

* 9*     .

 * *. , /

     *    =     %

%$ )33&  !)(     * = %"

%& )33" 4!

(    .   4 '7)B:

'7&B:

'7"(   %

%& )33"

/ 2* .

  *. ,* 0,0



.* 0*

2**  = %

%$ )33& !)( * 

= *. 

   ,  :*     *        /     

0, 2** *.* 0, .   = 4!

(  .0,

2*  0 .

2* . 

 :

.  

    :*=   #"C *)3&   :*=  .  *!

,-&./,,

, +            

 

   

   

  !      

"     

  #

$%&    ' 

    

     

   

  $ %&        '          



       

     

$%&  

           '          



    

           '          '

   (                                

) 0  *  0 .

5 0*,   , 8* :7.

5=  00,.      /8*. .   

 *  . ,*. 1* * ( 0 .

 = 0 0, .  .

 0

/*  =8*,5  * 02*     #$ C B)$'& , .

,8*.  =: 0 !

0,-1./2*,, 13 * +    , 

   

-   , 

  

    

                                       . /    

 # 0!+

       

                        -

 1   2 034*$0034*%

    

 

          

"

  0    * *  =.

,* * *

 0,:

.  :**.

 08*.* *. 0*  /* *.0  *

     = !)( 02*  , *.   *.    

 * ,. / 2 *

(#"C *)3&  

 



.

    :.

5

 =  

   

 .  *.   

C '

5  6 7 * ( ;<0* .2* :

.    #"    *    )3&    .

      0 !

8* &               ,          $%  $ %    $%            2   



$%    '      

    

 

  ($ %   '       

            

   '        

             ( $%  

                           

      

         '          



           '      '

          

  -  ,     

        

               

) C   00,;<0* .2**  : *0,    .* .

,8*. 00 , .

5= .0 /2*   * 0, 

  *F  79: .:7  * (G ,  

   *0 0, 

 0, 2* 0, = !)(, * **0,* **.  *.

 

 5 :* / 2*.

* *.  0  = !)( . , = !&(    ,  ,

5!)(0 **.0.

    ,=   , 

. 2*0 

    :*= * .*%

%& )33"0 *  % %& )33"

1, :

.2*  B:

!&  , = !)( ,  0*  *0, *      *.0  .

               

         :

  D7!E             *7*.0  .

               

,  7&(    ,.         =!

(         =   ' * 0(   :

D

   E 0   ,  .**  =!

/ *.0, 

+, *    :  .* *  * 0, .

* *  0  ,.0 * *. 0   ,  

 

.   :*0,  A * = **, *0,:

.0 

.#$B)$'&



  0*  ;    =  !)(       *.       *.

    *. ,:*  8*=* *. * 0*  *.

         * ,* 

1* *0,      0      .0,;

  4=!'(     0H , 

 2 *

64  4=!)( .* :

.  *

* , 

  * 2 *

/  ! *5*60* 0 ,

(   !+    

      

  0,       2*       

= !)(   .  /  0, 2*  =  %

%$ )33&

!)(**0,* **.    * . /*= !)(  *. 0 0, * 0  :* 2*.. 

  **0,*   C *2*    

2*,:*  * 0, 2** B:

!)     *

0,

2*= %

%$ )33&

;    0  *  

    28*,        

   ,    0,  :  *  * )%%22

 :

.*02*

0,*. ,* 0, 7

 02*  2* 

2* * 0   . 

.,*

*  (

  >%

%& )33" %'

%

.

% %& )33"  2* *  =!+ -     4 2-* 4

 =!#(  * . *

* = !#7&(            * 

* 

  :

.  0,  =!#   %"

%& )33"    * 

        .        =   ,:*0,*

*  %

%& )33"0* .  *

*

.  %

%& )33" :

% %& )33"

/*  0  ..

0,    :*=   

* ,  0*2*  ,.

.*. ,*0  8*



 . 



& '&&   &#(!

--   

= 57  I  =   0 I