High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1744/2015allowed

Vivek Kumar v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2023-03-15Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj16 pages

!"#$$ CWP-1744-2015 (O &M) VIVEK KUMAR

STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS .. CWP-2697-2015 (O &M) DINESH KUMAR

STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS .. %! &'% $ () ($ * +++++

Mr. Deepanjay Sharma, DAG, Punjab. Ms. Promila Nain, Advocate alongwith Ms. Harleen Ahluwalia, Advocate for the respondent-PSPCL. ) ($ *,$- ./0 This order shall dispose of two writ petitions bearing

"#a common judgment as!$!"

-2- % & !# ' ()*+,-- %.+/ 0 " ! 23 4$ 3 .5./%.+0 '$ */ "#

6 &!7 .-.,%.+0 '$ *58!! +,+%%.+0 '$ *+. "# 6 ) $ !!$ # - 9 !# $ : .0 ! #$" 3$; 0<=.<-< *0<=.,50 * 0<=5++ " !! $ 8!! >$ ! $ $6"" ?$ / $" ! !! 3 $ "$!$ ( 1234"" 6 @$ !;<%%0%0 ?3 ;<-<%+A ( 123252 ( 12364

2@$ !;A0-//+0 ?3 ;A0-/0,5

2@$

! ; .A0-/0,5 ?3 ; .A--//+. A ! " 3$! !# #3 ! #"!! "# * (?3 $ ! # 7 %A.-%.+0 3!

: !! $ 8!!= $ ! $ B ' ! #$ 8 8

-3- ! ! # 1 8 13?" # ! 23>8 "# (?

! $" "! !!#8 !3 =$ 1 8 8 8 ! 23 1 8!3= 3 ! 8! $"!38 $! 8!3B! " "!3 (? 8 $! 1 * (? 8 $" ; 0%-< +,.,%.+0 3 $

+0/ 8 +/- /= +%A A ! # %..0 $ ,A//5%=* ! !# .5./%.+08! $ +<<,%,A=*4$ &> " 3;%00+/./%.+083 3 3 ! #$ +0/ ! # %..0! 8 1 ?$ ;&> 8 8 3!33 " 3; *0<=.,509 8 !!3"# " 6$#( 3 )6?$ ! +-./%.+/C$ " 3; *0<=.,50 6$#( 3 "# ! 8 3 $" 8 !3 "# (! 2 $33 1 8 $ ! !"! # $ 1 6$# (

3 ! ! # 3 3 !

! 3 3 " B8

-4- ! 8!8 !'3 $ 3 ; *0<=.<-<1 8 .-.,%.+0 ! 8$+,.,%.+0 $ ,.//5%=* $3 3 % !2 8 ! , 33 ! $ +%,

! # %..0 8 " ;% 8 8 ! 3 $ * /.D $ ! ) ;+,-- %.+/8 $ !3 <

! !# (! 8 ; %A5, %.+/ $ ! # ; *0<=5++4$8 &> ; %0%+/./%.+0 " 3 3 1 3 8 ,,+A0A=* 5 33 "# 3 $ # 8!! !! $ # "* 8 " ! +. $ $ $ 8 8 ! " !

"# * (?()*+,-- %.+/; !#8

!()*%A5, %.+/ " !#8> " = 3! (?$ $ ! # $3 $$ :

! # * 3!3 $ E

E!$ ! 1 8 3!#$ ($ E3$

-5- $ : 8 !" 8 "# 3 7

+%A ! # %..0 7"F 8 $!# "# $ #6$#(

3 ?$ 3 8 ++ ! 8 $ +%,

! # %..0 8 $ "# $" 6! 3 > ! " 8 ;</0,A0 .A0-/05 !! ($ ! 3

!1 $" $ $ !3 "2"#

!!# 8 $ 3 $ 3# 8 $3

2=$$ : 1 ! 3 8 $ $ 3 !!# $ ! # 8! 3 3 3! $ +% ? $! $" * $ 3 3#!!33 "# 3 3 4$ ! !! "# * 6 B &> 3 3 $! 4$! F$3 .<.<%.+, "# ! $3?$ !!#3 !!#8 !! 3 3 8

-6- $33 !!"# > $ 3$ +0/ ! # %..0!8 ! # +0/ + 6 "$!"!3 ! #$!# $ 3#1 $ ! $!#" $1 $ $ " $! $ +/- ! # %..0 8 $ ! # %..0

! ($ "!3 ! ! !"!# 3 $ 3# 1 ! !"!# = $!"!!$! >8 $ 8 !!3 $ # 2 $3

# $3 3 !38 $ +/% ! # %..0B$" ! 33 $! 38 $ " ! "# $"! 6 ! !"!# "3 8 '!$ ! ($

! ($ 3 $ !"! 3# !3#!!"!#3 $ " "# * "$! +0 ($! * (? " 8 3 3 4$ 3 !#" 3 $" !3 $!!#8

-7-

8 $! $ ! # 3"# ! ($ *! $3?$ ! 3 8 3 3

!$" != 3 3 " "# (? $ !# +- > ! $! 3 " !

3 $3 $!38 +/ 9 3' ! "# 8$!" $ # # #1 $

!"#

! "#!$$

% !

#&&' ! ( '

" & " !

&' ! & &" "& %%"

! ""

% ! &

(

! "% && # & '& ' &&

% % (

! & "

( "& & &

' "

' # "& &# " '

) &

( # "& & ! %%

! * % ! ' &

""'

( #

'% % &&

("& &#!

-8-

"& &# (

% )

"& &# % % '&

("& &#'

& &

"& &# "" % " ' %

# + #

' ', &

' "

&! &

! %

& % &

% % - +& ."'

! %

&& "" "

& "( && &"& &# & * && % """

+ & "( && &"& &#) +& ."'

! %

&& """

& " ( && & "& &# & * &&! &

"" %

+ ! '&

#+#

+ & "( && & "& &#, &

* && %

' "

&! &

! %

& % &

% % +& . "'

! &%

"" "

((

# %%"#"& &# % '& "" "

#+'#

"" "

(( %%"# "& &# % # & (

(

-9- "

% #

& "

/#0

"& %%" !

#!+

&! &

% "& &##&

! "" %

! " &

# % ! #

&! &

% "& &#

"#&

# &&

2 % &% 2&! "& %%" !

#! % & & "& &#!

"# && %%"#"& &#, "# & & "&

%%" !

/ % % #2%% % 3

# & "&

%%" !

(

"" && %%"# " "& &#, && "&

%%" !

#! """( & %"

( "

( &

& & %"& ( &''#

& &&, "

"& %%" !

# ! % % #

"& &# &

( && & ' % 2&! ""! ' % & "( "( & %"

& % &"

! %%"# " "& &# ' #$(

& % % # 14

2#& "& %%"

# !4 / " # 6

-10-

! %&! %

& #%"

& % '&

" "& &#5

(!4 "#)

&! / "" & & !

! ' # &"

&" '&

! (! / "& &#) & +

/ # && & '& % "" "

" ! # % &( %& & $ &

""' %

' & # & && &

&% +

& % &1 7 8 && % %"

& # %

" ""

% (

& " ""( /&

& ""% %

" &&& % %

' "" (" , %&!

& /

# &%"

& &% ""&

' +&%% &

" && %#( &% 1

9 8 % 3 3 " & ! :;7! "

(

& / ""

%%"#!

& / 2&1 <+ +++ +++ +++ +++ +++ +++ +++ ++

$%&'(

=' ( #( & 3 " & :;7! 2%% % 6 #& /# "

# &&% #&

-11-

%& ( &

& "& &# % " 2&!

##'

#& % (&

%& 8 ""', 820>? $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ = & @ '&

# 3 % (&""&% "'

B %

>'8 >8

%%"# % ""2 % 2 &

B( 8 B8

5 $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

1C " & '#

% ) 513

& " &

% ) 712( & "

" &'

% ) 91 &

% , $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ 2%% % 6

#!# & & " 6 /!

%&8 " 1

5% #

# && & ' $ &

! #%

& #&& ' & "" " # % &(

"" & ( &&

#& "& 1

7 8 &&% &

# & % ( & && & ' $ &

# 2%% % 6 & %' " %' " ""

&* "' ( &7..33 " & ! :;71

983 % ( & $ &

"" ""'"#& #%

1 <+ ++ +++ +++ +++ +++ +++ +++ +++

-12-

!'&! *'

%+!

%* &!#

=' ( #(& 3 3 " & ! :;7! # & % " & 7D 9. & D.4 "" ""##%& "3 '' &

5 %%

#& &

# * # " & % "

& 7D 7: %& #& &

'& " # %& " 3 & 2&

'& &&

! ""

& &

& %& " 3 ! % & &

"" % #

&%& "3 && &'% 2&, """

' " &%& " 3 &&! #! & # #& &

% & &&

#%& "3 , & %& " 3 % +

! &

# '

' &

# & ! * &!

# $

# &'

& +

! #!

"" &

7 8 %& " 3

#! ' (

#( & &

& 5E.

&5E533 " & ! :;7! # &

& 7D 7:

# '

# && & ' % & % &

3 % & 5E75ED

3 ""!

#! %%"# & ",

-13- ' &

# " &! %%

%& "3 &

" # & &

# '

#! %& " 3 ""

& "" # '

# +

% & $

% # %

3 " &&, &

#&&

# " &! """

' "

%& "3 %

& %

+&(#

9 2 %& " 3

#! ' ' ( & #%

%% &"# &"# && % # ! # & %

( ""

& &

& ' '"( "

( & # %

&& '

% &% " &

! #%

""! % % & 7.F 3 3 " & !

:;7!

&7.; 1 D8 %& "3 ""4

&"" "#

( &

# (# '& "" "

* "'

%%"& " % '" % &( & (# + &%

'& "

&" " "#

"" &

' & &"& 1

EC&

&"" "#

""## %& " 3 "

% #

-14- &

!+&

% #&

"& && %

# ! ""

# 0

"& && %

# ! ' ( &

& %& "3 ( ' % "( @ 0 C % "(

&% "" % # 1 ?+%"

1 $ G % % &! &" " "# "

"& && %

#! &

& 7D 7:1 ?

%%" +A $! ! #%..0 8 $$ :$ 3# ""# 6 $! 8 !"! " !! $ # +%,

! # %..0 1 3# ! 8 $ $ 1 !!"!# +/-!#""# !($ !!"!# " $ "# *6 "$ ! $ +0/ + ! #%..0!# $ ! #$!#> $ $!$ +/-

A ! #%..0 ! !"!#"# !($ $"3! $ "# $ +0/ + "$

-15- !!"! $ '$!!!38 B = $ $ +0/ +

! #%..0!# "!3 $!#2 # !$ "# "$ ! 6 # $ ! #$ " "# !($ ! ! ($ 3 $ #

3 4$ ! !"!# 3 "# ""! +, $3 $ $ +0/ ! # %..0 8 ! E" "#+0/ + ! #%..01 8 "3 !#$ +0/ + ! #%..0* !!"!# $ +%A ! #%..0 # $ 8 !# $ $"F "# !($ >$ 3 8 !$!#!38 !

$ $ $ # " !!8 3 $ # !# $ 1 # !3!" !!$ # $ +%,"# 8!!"!8!"! !81 !!$ # $ " 3 3 E G" F$ +< $ ! *0<=.,50 ! #28!

-16- !$ (! 2 *6 3 !3 B ! " $ $ +5 $!!81 $3 $ # "# 23 ! #

+0/ + ! # %..0 !"! " $=F$ "# !38 H A D $ (VINOD S. BHARDWAJ) JUDGE MARCH 15, 2023 ,) * ) *!$* % (A

,H A= % " ,H A=