High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16484/2016allowed

Dilbag Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2024-04-02Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary7 pages

!"#$"

%"" ""&"

()*+,-.+/010,2 3 (045)6780267 3333+*0*0,2+9 :+91;1 8*)*+,-;2<)5)2. *7+91 333=+1>,2.+2*1

"?@ A#B?

D"?""

% EEEEE 9+1+2* 93=3F3G9,9)HG.I,/)*+-,9*7+>+*0*0,2+9 93G9;2J;>*)H(GJ;2<)5 EEEEE "?""

%K!C 3 L7+ >9+1+2* >+*0*0,2 7)1 5++2 -04+. -,9 .09+/*026 *7+ 9+1>,2.+2* *, *9+)* *7+ >+90,. ,- 4+)I+ ,- M02. .;+ )1 .;*N >+90,. )2. *, *7)* +O*+2* P;)17 *7+ 0Q>;62+. ,9.+9 .)*+. R3 3 H G22+O;9+ H S0*7 ) -;9*7+9 >9)N+9 *, *9+)* *7+ 1;1>+210,2T .01Q011)4 >+90,. )1 .;*N >+90,. -,9 )44 02*+2*1 )2. >;9>,1+1 03+3 69)2*,-1)4)9NH02/9+Q+2*1)2.,*7+91+9I0/+5+2+-0*13 3 U+)92+. /,;21+4 1;5Q0*1 *7)* *7+ >+*0*0,2+9H )>>,02*+. ,2

V33VV )1 ) ;4*0 +)4*7 ,9M+9

)4+ ,2 9+6;4)9 5)101H S)1 1;1>+2.+. )2. /,21+P;+2*4N .01Q011+. -9,Q 1+9I0/+H ,2 *7+ 5)101 ,- 701 /,2I0/*0,2 5N *7+ 4+)92+. G..0*0,2)4 8+110,2 W;.6+H J;9.)1>;9 I0.+ <;.6Q+2* .)*+. '33

02 )2 XY= 9+601*+9+. ;2.+9 8+/*0,21 TTV Y )2. 8+/*0,2 'T'R ,- G9Q1 G/*H 5;* S)1 1;51+P;+2*4N )/P;0**+. 5N *701 ,;9* 02 =GV'

(Z I0.+ <;.6Q+2* .)*+. 3 ' )2. )1 ) 9+1;4* *7+9+,-H 9+021*)*+. 02 1+9I0/+ I0.+ ,9.+9 .)*+. R3 3 H G22+O;9+ 3 ,S+I+9H *7+ >+90,. S7+2 7+ 9+Q)02+. ,;* ,- 1+9I0/+ ,2 )//,;2* ,- 1;1>+210,2 )2. .01Q011)4H S)1 *9+)*+. )1 4+)I+ ,- M02. .;+ 021*+). ,- .;*N >+90,.[ )1 ,>>,1+. *, *7+ /)1+ ,- ) 10Q04)94N 10*;)*+.

!"#$ % &!" '# ( ('$ %# % ( )*!)'+ ,+ '# *'! -

,'! .)' /,' ' $

)0,!''

$ % (

!('

'+ *!+ + + '+ 12 2 3$ .4, $ %# / '# !+ # ('

+ ,' - ( *!)$ % (

( +,' !+2 5!

) !( )+ '# ,+"' ((+ / '#!( , ' ! '# ) ( - 6789:;<=> ?@ABCB;D8 ?D8EB ;8F G:B>H9 I9J ?:;:> 7K L@8M;< ;8F G:B>H9 $ 3 $ +)!++ 2 N ?BJ O;=AD;: ?D8EB I9J ?:;:> 7K L@8M;< ;8F G:B>H9 $ 133 $ +)!++ 2 2 N ?@CB; ?D8EB I9J ?:;:> 7K L@8M;< ;8F G:B>H9 $ $ +)!++ 2 P2 N Q;=<DH R@S;H I9J ?:;:> 7K L@8M;< ;8F T87:B>HU $ +)!++ P2 3

+ ?BDI R@S;HV7W;=I9J?:;:>7KX;HW;8; $

1 Y1P2 2 '

+ '

' ),( (,/!'( '# ' (!) '# '!'! % (

)0,!''+ - )#

"( '# / (!( - /-!' - +,/'$

( (,)#$ !( ' '!'+ ' + % )(- '# !+# !+,'-( *!)2 2

+),(!'# (!+2 32 Z'

/$ ! '#

-!+ / '# '!'! $ # % (

)0,!''+ / '# [!*!(!

)# - '#!( , ' %!'# '# /( * '!( '# '$ \222] '#

/() -

"!/ )*!)!" *!+)

!('

!"#

+ [!/ "# !"#$ % + !'

' ' 4'+ /-!' - +,/' ' /'# - '#2 ] *!% - '#

/* +!(),((!$ %#! +!(!((!" '#

'( )## !"#

+ !+ ^ , _

#!$ %

)0,!'

!"#

+ [!/ "# !"# - '# )#

!(' '# / "

'!" /-!' - +,/'2 Y# (# /(' '!/ '- '#%!'#$!-' 0,!

+! '# ) (2` 2 ]' !( *!'

' !' ,' '# ' '# ) !' !

- +)!+!" !-

+ %# '#

/() !( ' / '

(

!+ - +,' !( )'

!+ ! 5, 12 - , /

!" # $% # &'' ($ )$*! )!+%$, !

%!) -$, &%' .$/ %! .$+% !0

$$, / +.

-+ !+ -!/ $-!-!

&'' % &!

/ ( $--!

% %! 0 %! %'

$+% -$$ !0 &'' $/ %'

12""

'+ $ 3!+)+% )-!, &'! '$ (+ / )

/ )!/ ! !)- !, %/ + %$%/ $ $

% !0 $--$ !+ ! & ! &!

/ '$ (+

! + %$%/ ( % 0! ' %)+% !+

-$++ $%!+ &'

-+ !+ ! +!% %' $ %'!%, !)-%+% %! !/ + %$%)+% '$!+ /$+/)$4$ -0!/5

$ .$/+. %' -$, $+/ $!&$+ %! ( -$/ %! %' 3!+)+% )-!, 0! %' -!/ !0 ' $( + 0!) / %, + /+. %' -!/ !0

-+ !+ -/+. ' / )

$ )!$ ! !)- !, %)+% $ %' $ )$,(6$+/

( &'%' ! +!% %'

$/ -!/

'$ ( %$%/ $ $ -!/ -+%!+/ %,"

' %' $ %'!%, !)-%+% %! !/ + %$%)+% !0 !-+!+ %'$% %' 3!+)+% )-!, &'! '$/ (+ / )

/ )!/ ! !)- !, %/ '$ (+ , 7!+$%/ %' 3!+)+% )-!,

(*% %! %' -! !+ !0

(

( -$/ ' -$, $+/ $!&$+ %! &'' ' &!

/ '$ (+ +%%/ '$/ ' +!% (+ / )

/ )!/ ! !)- !, %/ !

-+// -! %!

' / )

$ )!$ ! !)- !, %)+% $ %'$ )$,( !// %'$% &'

' $ %'!%, !0 !-+!+ %'$% %' %)+$%!+ !0 %' -!/+.

+ %% %/ $.$+ % %' 3!+)+% )-!, '$/ (+ /$,/ / %! $ !+ /%, $%%( %$( %! %' 3!+)+% )-!, % )$, $0% .+. ') $+ !--!% +%, %! )$4 - +%$%!+ $+/ $0% !+ /+. %' - +%$%!+ 0 $+,

()%%/ (, ') /% 0! $ !+ %! ( !// + &%+. %'$% %' 3!+)+% )-!,

(*% %! %' -! !+ !0

(

2 ( -$/ 0! %' -!/ !0

' /$, !+,

' $)!

+!% (+. %' &'! !0 -$, $+/ $!&$+ $ % )$,/%)+"

#+ $ $ 0$+.

(

%' -!/ !0 $( + 0!) / %, + /+. %' -!/ !0

-+ !+ -/+. / )

$ )!$ ! !)- !, %)+% $ %' $ )$, ( '$(%$%/$ $-!/ -+%!+/ %,0!$- -!

! !"#$% & %%' () $(*!+,' %+(* +* -../0 12/3242 50670 80./24 90:2; 24< 24=.>?/ @AB C>2A>0 DE;2/ F +G+ HII J( ()

,$+,, (* K F L ', "M (*N" %L OI'& ('% (*P +%L %L' !+&+ ' II !F )(' ,$+,+*P %L $ +&! () II *%! L( L , "* $Q+%%, () $L 'P! *,' R *, 'G*%+(* () (''I%+(* H$%F ! %L $ ! & M "F L'+* +% ! ("!'G, *, L, %L %F S * I +* ' ,+*P () %L "(G'I'(,$, 'F +% "$(&! $ ' %L % L* T(G'*&*% &I(M L( L ! "* ,+!&+!!,F '&(G,F $(&I!('+M '%+', (' !!I*,, +! '+*!% %, (' (, L G "* '+*!% %, "% )(' L+! '%+'&*% (* !I' ** %+(*F %L %L('+%M $(&I%*% %( (',' '+*!% %&*% L ! %( $(*!+,' *, & U !I$+)+$ (',' 'P ',+*P I M *, ( *$!

%( " I +, %( %L T(G'*&*% &I(M )(' %L I'+(, () L+! "!*$ )'(& ,%M ($$ !+(*, "M !!I*!+(* *, V (' ,+!&+!! F '&(G (' $(&I!('M '%+'&*% *, !( L%L' (' *(% %L ! +, I'+(, !L " %' %, ! !I*% (* ,%M R) %L %L('+%M $(&! %( %L $(*$!+(* %L % %L &I(M L ! "* )M W(*' %, (' L+! !!I*!+(* ! L(M *#!%+)+,F %L* +% L ! %( I !! * (',' )(' I M&*% () ) I M *, ( *$! R* (%L' $ !F * (',' )(' I M&*% () I'(I('%+(* % I M *, ( *$! L ! %( " I !!, R* %L )+'!% $ !F %L I'+(, () "!*$ L ! %( " %' %, ! I'+(, !I*% (* ,%M R* %L !$(*, $ !

F %L $(&I%*% %L('+%M L ! %( I !! II'(I'+ % (',' L%L' %L +*%'G*+*P I'+(, !L(, " %' %, ! I'+(, !I*% (* ,%M )(' *M !I$+)+, I'I(! X( I% +% ,+))'*%MF W$I% +* %L $ !! () $(&I% W(*' %+(* %L $(&I%*% %L('+%M L ! %L ,+!$'%+(* %( I !! II'(I'+ % (',' )(' I M&*% () I M *, ( *$! %( %L &I(M ,'+*P %L I'+(, () L+! "!*$ *, !

!" #$%

& &' () *+

-./

0 12345621 78 9:2 ;29595723 <232 923=5>92? ?@2 97 :51 67456957 @?23 .269571 0 A >? 32>? <59: .26957 B;7 :51 >6C@599>D EF 7GED2 9:2 .@;32=2 7@390 > 6D>5= <>1 3>512? 873 8@DD 1>D>3F >? >DD7<>62 873 9:2 ;2357? 78 1@1;2157 >? ?51=511>D0 7;;715H <:56:0 9:2 .9>92 :>?0 >1 5 9:2 6>12 >9 :>?0 9>I2 9:2 ;D2> 78 9:2 ;29595723 6>79 E2 H3>92? E>6I <>H210 :>45H 79 12342? ?@35H 9:>9 95=2 J:2 K545157 L26: 5923;3292? -@D2 A 78 @M>E 545D .2345621 -@D210 >1 >;;D56>ED2 97 9:2 .9>92 78 >3F>>0 59 E25H ;>35 =>9235> 97 -@D2AN OPOQN >?:2D?9:2;295957232959D2?97 9:232D528>1;3>F2?873 R S5I2<5120 9:2 ;29595723 5

"T"

!" #$%

& &' () U V W 0 R 0 ?265?2? 7 0 <:7 <>1 ?51=5112? 837= 1234562 7 9:2 H37@? 78 67456957 @?23 .269571 >? RX E@9 >6C@5992? 5 3245157 >? 7 ?2;>39=29>D 2C@53F <>1 5595>92?0 <>1 :2D? 2959D2? 97 H3>9 78 ;>F >? >DD7<>621 EF 3282335H 97 -@D2 A 5 N POQYN 873 9:2 ;2357? :2 :>? 32=>52?7@9781234562032D24>9;>3>1<:2327832>?9:@10 ZD>5= 78 9:2 ;29595723 51 1@;;7392? EF 9:51 7@39 5

"# [

* \('] #$

& &' () *+

^ (&"'*$

.J AR <:2325 59 :>1 E22 7E12342? 9:>9 58 9:2 35=5>D 7@39 32673?1 > 85?5H 9:>9 9:232 51 7 245?262 97 ;3742 9:2 6:>3H2 >H>519 9:2 2=;D7F220 79<59:19>?5H 7E1234>9571 >1 97 >6C@599>D EF 9:2 E22859 78 ?7@E90 59 <5DD E2 6715?232? :77@3>ED2 >6C@599>D >? 9:2 2=;D7F22 1:>DD E2 2959D2? 97 ;>F >?>DD7<>621 23@1>D 78 9:2 ;37451571 >? 9:2 M@?H=29 3282332? 97 EF 9:2 67@12D 873 9:2 ;295957230 59 51 6D2>3DF 219>ED51:2? 9:>9 9:2 ;29595723 7 :51 32519>92=29 51 >D17 2959D2? 97 9:2 H3>9 78 ;>F >? >DD7<>621 873 9:2 ;2357? :2 :>? 32=>52? 7@9 78 1234562 21;265>DDF <:2 9:2 1>5? ;2357? 51 932>92? >1 ;2357? 1;29 7 ?@9F 873 >DD ;@3;7121 J:2 <359 ;2959570 9:23287320 19>?1 >DD7<2? =;@H2? 73?23 ?>92?

X2_@32 <:56: 321935691 9:2 H3>9 78 9:2 E22859 78 9:2 1234562 97 E2 932>92? >1 D2>42 78 9:2 I5? ?@2 1:>DD 19>? 129 >15?2 >? 59 1:>DD E2 932>92? >1 > ;2357? 1;29 7 ?@9F 873 >DD 59291 >? ;@3;7121 XDD 9:2 6712C@295>D E228591 E2 32D2>12? 97 9:2

! " !

# # #$ "%& % ' ()*+, -./012345 678 9:/;451 </= *3731 4> ?75@7.7 7.A 7.43;15 B

CD B B #

E #" F C#" GH H HHI H J '

IHHGH K#B

L "!"" ! "M#

##F B

#NF L$ O F

! O NF$

L #F#%

O O "

O $

F "M#B L$ O$E CFL PFO PFO I%Q RSRTUQ

O" E F

#" #!

F $

" # #$B

" "

" M ""

O $% % K F # # L !

V/;4W 9+875 </= *3731 4> ?75@7.7 B GB #

% % B

#NF #

E" F "#" GH HIHHI

X F '

" L L "

OO #"NF O L "

E " Y F! "

" FO % " F *;= Z7[W:73 *:.\;

"F B

#NF O #! O #E" "F

"FL"NF E #

E "

""F

!B "F"" L "F$ "O M ]F% % "FL!"" O C #F"O

E L FL

ME L E

#NFE

!B F

" !

E F "M# # L F$B # L #F #B "!F#

" "!O O " L

O C

MF # " ^4./3= *+W;2;7:. *:.\; </= *3731 4> _+.`7, 7.A 43;15/ B X

B # X% %

!"# $$ %!% & & '

$"( ) $ * + ,-( .- .

/ $/

!% ( .-$ - ,

, - % . ! + 0( .

1! $

- % - "

# / .

!" % .-

$ /

# - 2 !

# - % ( .--

, 3 "(

( -

# - % /

# 4!$ &

$ - *!,3 # #& 5& 6

1!$ -

/( - % . %

$$ .

- % -$ $

$ "

- 1! $

# , - % # .-- - 3

# /

!"& 7#!$

# .

-( # 3 - .-

. %

# - *!,3 /& 89:9;<=9>?=9@AB C>?DE FGHFIHGFGI &J 3 --% 2 ,K

LK7 --%

$ LK7