High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16494/2016dismissed

Harbhajan Singh Ahluwalia v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2016-08-16Mr. Justice Satpal,Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal16 pages

!"# $#%&'&()*

!"#$ %& '( $ !"#$ %& '( $#( )(##

* +, *% ' -

+./

2 - , . - +

- + , + . ,,4

2 3 5 /6* . * 7- (.

--,* * , + . - . 7-

,* 3* * 5 /89* + , * * +

+:/ , ; , - . , , 4< ' 1 2

-- # - 1= #! / 2 + . -- # ,->88::99? ,, *,- . , + #>89>8@@: ,

+ '

- .

, +

- - -' , - , , ,,, ' - ( - -7 , .! 5 892* . ,A- . # +

+ . , ' * * . . "( -

, B ,, * ,*

,"*/(**

+ 9?898@@C1 582

7 ,*

, 77 17. 7 ,

.2+

8, - , , D9@( 1=( !E2 (/, F" (/, .F-

+>/ -.

4 *

:6- . (/, % (/, -. ,

8 . , + * - , ,, . 8@@9/@8* , - >*@>*999A/**

+ - -+ .,- ,--

* G C8H6:99?* , 7 , ) , 1

,2* , . .

I( ,, ** ,+

. "(+

1= "(!/2' * G C8H6:99?* - 8896:99?. ,

, * +

+ . .3 ..7 ,) ,1

,2* ( + -* . +, -B + +

"( ( . ,* ,

- <

+D/ '

, #+ 1

2 8?@C9 :99? ! - ( ' -

>989:99?

0( , 8 > 5B'- D - . 3 B

,, ,8@@C*, B , , - ,- 3 , ,, ) 1 * 2 ' 8 > , - 5 B - .< (,3,+/ * - 7 * * 7 *

, "* $,- , , G * *

*- 1 5?A82.. + ' - # ::9::99H

/ 0' , #+ 886:99? . 7 + ",

J .

*. , ,

- .

+6/ . 3 . . 7 , ) , 1

,2* * . +

, 7 , ) , 1

,2* . -

88 .* :99?* + $3 ..- * - - - - - (+ .- *

B , ,,, , , #+ ( + #* - - < (1 5?A82* -

.,,. .*( * ,*

, "* $,- ,

, * *

* - >*6D*999A/' , 8@@D/@6' # B

. . ,A- . 5 . +*

,"**

B #- A , ' #* +* - A , ' # - , 5

+?/ , , - , - '@99B -. 1 #2-.- -. 1 #2'*

., ,12, 5'5

+. # ,- B , ,B , -.1 #2 B .

B # B '3 . , ,

+ . # ,,

. - .

, "* *

,.*)+-*

, 7-* *

+ 9?88:998

I(, , D9@8:9/"(

')+-+ :99H:99: -7-B , + " * , - +7-B, - , * , ,B

, "* *

3 - - +7-*

*+ >99@:99:* , B - ' - + 7- + -- 8889:99: - .

- )+- 1

, 7-2 , B-(, B* - B + - * ,,

+C/ ->69 ,, ,+- . . $ , , 7+ -

* ,-- . -. +

,, * .

. ,, - 8@9H:989 1 5 C2 , ) , 1

,2* 1 :2 3 --

-. - . +

' % 7 , - /,-/ , (- ,*

, "* *

+ 8988:989 - 5C2 ., ,*

,"1$ G2*",/((**

B ,., ' *+*,, * . . ' 7 ,*

, "**

+ :996:9881 5H2

- ,.)+-*

,7-*

. , .,+*,- ,,,- ,., ' 7 ,B

- . , B . )+- *

,7- ' +,

, + - ,

+H/

-. 1 #2* , + - . ,, . -5, - ,,

, - 9H9H:99C 562- . 7* *7 *

," ( ,* 5 6 , ,--A,-- 7- ( --,* )+- , 3 . C9?9:8@@C7 , ,A- . #(+ - *

, ->6 ,, ,+ - . . $ , , 7+ - * ,-- . -. +(.,*,, * 7 * *7 *

," - ,, . - . .,, . .* ( * ,*

, "*$ G**

*, . . -. , + '

.* ,, * ,. 968:8@@:' / 0( * -. - , , , 3 +

5 ' - , + ,,. , + . , , - - " 3+ - -

+@/ +

-. 5, 3 - >*@>*C6CA/1 + 8D8@@82 3 .- - - +

- + 5 ,

,, * 7 * * 7 *

," + ,

, -. 8?9>8@@H1 5@2.

,.*B ,., ,- -. - / 0( - , . ! % , % .,, + ,.,- ,., B ,, .- <

, - 8C89:999 1 5 892 . 7 , . # , +. * (- * , . 7 , . , 17, +2* * ,, ,- * *-B ,,- /,, - , .

. # - , , D9@* >C@ D9? ( , ; ,- ,(-

+89/ .,, 3 5 + ,- . ,, ( - . , .#

. ,, * * - (

. + + , - , , ,3 . 7 + % ,

*F+ 8@9H:99: '

+ ,

, ,,1 2 - -,- -

, 7-* ' , + ,

+., ,,1 2

, ,, ,-,,* , -. +,

, - , ,, - A-;;

-,-- # (-. , , * 8C89:999 1 5 892 7 , . # ,, (,* .

+, -*-.

' -. , (

,, ,

+88/ (,!-&.&/!'01,"!"# 1:99H2:

D9@ .! - +, ,

I( , 86D - ,1= !/2*,, , , 86D1>2 .

$+ .

. ,. I(

, 86?1>2

,,(, , 86?1>2

, ,I(

, , +

-* ,* ,,

+* +

- (2#30# !$!4'##1 (&( ($&!1:99C2?

8C8*

+ , ,-- , ; , ' ,,*

* - ,

B . ,-- -. , B. , ( ,,-. .,-

+ , 8@9 , :99 ,- +

K ,,* * - ( , ,-,* +

- +

I( +

, . - *

+8:/

8?9>8@@H1 5@2.

,.*B ,., ,- -. * ,

- + ,- -.+ -. '- - + , .

. ,

, ( -. ,

G 8?>>@ :99@* , - :C89:99@

/ -- * B + + . .,.3 . $ C8@@C- .

,"*

, 7- - -! :8@:DA

, "* /6* :@C8@@H B - - ' ,,

. - ..< '

G 8CD?D:98:* , - - :C98:98? 1 5 8>2 ( * 3 9C9?:99: 1 5 6 2 8C89:9991 ,8C89:98921 589 2 ' 9C9?:99: , ,--

+ .

+8>/ )+- * 7- ( --, 3 . C 9?9:8@@C* 7 , * ,A- . #* * 7 , ( ,--* - ->69 ,, ,+- . . * $ , , 7+ - * ,-- .-. +'8C89:9991 , 8C89:9892 ,7 , .# * , . , ,7 , .- ,17, +2*,, ,- -B , ,- /, , - , .

. # - , D9@*>C@D9?( , ; ,- , '

% * + :C98:98? 1 5 8>2 - .

/ 0. 3 C?:99: 1 5 /D2 8C89:999 1 , 8C89:98921 5/892 5/D*)+-, , . , -

5/89*,- -.

. , , # , , - ,- ::

+8D/ , 5/- .

-- # - ' - L - * , ::::99H

+ . B -- .7 ,) ,1

,2 - -

) - . 8@@C ,-'

, '. - .

B 3 .

5/D/89C?:99:8C89:9991 , 8C89:9892* , + . '

-* :98: ( - , - ' -L - * ::::99H

+ . +

-.- . 7 , ) , 1

,2* +* , - , ,

- , -

. .L - ". 3 - * .

+86/ - '

,* ,

, - - < #, -

. - . 7 , ) , 1

,2* ,,, - , ::9::99H 1 5 ?A:2 .! - - (-.*+ , 8> * , ::9::99H .! - +.5 *

8D* , .

. ,,* 7 , ) , 1

,2* 1 :2 3 -

-. . +

,. 8@9H:9891 5 C2 - '* . -+

- + , , ,

.+. .

. ,,(, .+

+8?/ .

-. - '* 3 + .+

-$+ * +

* -.

(- ,*:996

1 5 C2 8@9H:989 $C/@C 12 A

-- # - * * *

- . +* B* - . " * .

(- , (, ,-,* * + *-.+

-.A- +

- +* - - ,,

. - 1 2 % 1# )

2 % 8?9H:98? - GB A M G M