Gram Panchayat Garnala v. State Of Haryana & ORS


 

   
  

!"#$#%&'&()  * +!,!(%-!.!"

#"&"&(#+ /#+'0'

1"!"#$!+.!(!!(2"-#+'

#'3(2#("'

  


   !  


  " !

+#'#("

+!+#(2#+!4 -!+25!67 2/%!"#$+"-#3#"&"&(#+ + (80+&""!47 224 7!+.!(! +!(&'-1!&(&7 2/%!"#$+ +91!&(&7 2/%!"#$++#'3(2#("(  +:-!(7 2/%!"#$++#'3(2#("'(;!(2* <<<   " ! #

-#3+#'#("3#"&"&(-!'=##($&4#2$+&''0!(%#$!5+&"&("-# (!"0+#$%#+"&+!+&$+>0!'-&(?$"-#&,30?(#2 5!+22!"#2@* A@3!''#2=.#+,!(#(":8 2!4!"7 ,=!4!75-#+#=. 
  ,#!'0+&(? ,!+4!'4!(2-!'=##(+2#+#2"=##B%-!(?#25&"-"-#4!(2$ "-#3+&/!"#3#+'(&#+#'3(2#("(  !-!20+1&(?- -#  2&'30"#  &'  +#?!+2&(?  "-#  #B%-!(?#  $ 
   ,#!'0+&(? ,!+4!'$4!(2%,3+&'#2&(8-!'+!( A 75&"-"-#4!(2 $+#'3(2#("( ,#!'0+&(? ,!+4!'%,3+&'#2&(8-!'+!( CC CC

7;CA;'&"0!"#25&"-&("-#+#/#(0##'"!"#$/&44!?#!+(!4!7=#!+&(?  

7#-'&4!(2&'"+&%" ,=!4!

+&#$$!%"'!+#"-!"!(!334&%!"&(0(2#+1#%"&(;$"-#0(6!= D&44!?#
,,(:!(2'#?04!"&(7 %"7 $+'-+"E %"$ E 5!'$&4#2=."-#+!,!(%-!.!"!?!&('"+#'3(2#("( !'5#44!'"5

"-#+&(-!=&"!("'$"-#/&44!?#(!,#4.&
-!+!(!''!(2&& -!(!!, $+"-#&+#6#%",#("=#&(?&(0(!0"-+&F#23''#''&($"-# 
  %,3+&'#2  &(  8-#5!"  ( ,&(7  9-!"(&  (@ ,&(7  8-!'+!  (  ,#!'0+&(? ,!+4!'!'3#+ !,!=!(2-&$+"-#.#!+ A;
-!+!(!''

!(2  -!(!  !,  2#(&#2  "-#&+  0(!0"-+&F#2  3''#''&(  5-#+#!'  -!20+ 1&(?-7+#'3(2#("( 7'0=,&""#2&(-&'+#34."-!"4!(2&(2&'30"#&'"-#

=!2&#-!(2-#&'&(3''#''&($"-#'!,#$+"-#4!'" .#!+'!$"#+ %('"+0%"&(?-&'-0'#!'5#44!''-3!(2"-0'"-#+!,!(%-!.!"-!'( %(%#+(5&"-"-#'!,##$0+"-#+'0=,&""#2"-!"&(/&#5$"-#!+.!(! /#+(,#("("&$&%!"&(7"-##30".
,,&''&(#+&'!0"-+&F#2"!%%+2 !33+/!4$+'!4#$!(%-!.!"4!(2!(2-#&'+#!2.!(25&44&(?"3!."-# %'"$"-#4!(2&(2&'30"# 0+&(?"-#3#(2#(%.$"-#3#"&"&(0(2#+1#%"&(;$"-# %"7 !(!334&%!"&(2!"#2  5!''0=,&""#2=."-#+!,!(%-!.!"$+ 2#,!+%!"&($"-#4!(2&(2&'30"#!(2#-'&42!+ ,=!4!5!'2#30"#2$+ "-&'30+3'#5-'0=,&""#2-&'+#3+"2!"#2  !(2!%%+2&(?" 5-&%-7+#'3(2#("( -!'=##($0(2&(0(!0"-+&F#23''#''&($ ,!+4!'$
 4!(2/#("-#1!+3!(%-$+!,!(%-!.!"?" +#%+2#2-&''"!"#,#("=#$+# ''""
44#%"+'"+!2#( ""-# #$$#%""-!"+#'3(2#("( -!'$+!0204#("4.!(20(4!5$044.="!&(#2"-#

5!+2$+,"-##+,!(#(":8 2!4!"(@* '3#++#3+"$ #-'&42!+7
-!+!(!''!(2+#'3(2#("( 5#+#$0(2&(0(!0"-+&F#2 3''#''&($ ,!+4!'!(2 ,!+4!'$4!(2+#'3#%"&/#4.5-#+#!' -!(!

!,-!'("=##($0(2&(!(.0(!0"-+&F#23''#''&( (  /&#5  $ "-# !=/# $!%"0!4  =!%8?+0(27 "-# !5!+2  2!"#2 @*7  3!''#2  =.  #+,!(#("  :8  2!4!"  &'  "-#  '0=6#%"  ,!""#+  $

@ %-!44#(?#&("-#3+#'#("5+&"3#"&"&( "&'!+?0#2=.4#!+(#2%0('#4$+"-#3#"&"&(#+"-!"!'3#+"-# 3+/&'&('$1#%"&(@$"-# %"7"-#60+&'2&%"&($"-#
&/&4
0+"&'

=!++#2"&'$0+"-#+!+?0#2"-!"4!(2&(2&'30"#&'"-#
 !(2&( /&#5  $  "-#  3+/&'&('  $  04#   $  0(6!=  D&44!?# 
,,(  :!(2'

#?04!"&('04#'7

$+'-+"E04#'$

E73+&+!33+/!4$"-# 1"!"#/#+(,#("&'(#%#''!+.$+#B%-!(?#$ 
   =0"&("-# 3+#'#("%!'#('0%-!33+/!4-!'=##(="!&(#2!(2!''0%-"-#&,30?(#2 !5!+23!''#2=.#+,!(#(":8 2!4!"&'("4#?!44.'0'"!&(!=4# 0+"-#+!+?0#2"-!"+#'3(2#("( &(%440'&(5&"-"-#"-#( 1!+3!(%-0+2#/1&(?-!(2"-#!(%-!+/&(2#+9!0+7+#'3(2#("'(; *'0%%##2#2&(3!''&(?"-#+#'40"&($+#B%-!(?#$"-#4!(2&(2&'30"#!(2 %('#>0#("&,30?(#2 5!+2=.#+,!(#(":8 2!4!"

("-#"-#+-!(274#!+(#2%0('#4$++#'3(2#("( "* -!/#  33'#2  "-#  3+!.#+  $  "-#  +!,  !(%-!.!"  !(2  '0=,&""#2  "-!" +#'3(2#("( -!'?&/#(-&'/!40!=4#4!(2&(#B%-!(?#$"-# 


!(2!''0%-(4''&'%!0'#2""-#+!,!(%-!.!"!(2"-#+#'3(2#(" ( -!'!4+#!2.%('"+0%"#2-&'-0'#!'5#44!''-3(4!(2&(2&'30"#7 "-#+#$+#7  "-#+# &' ( 60'"&$&%!"&(  "  #("#+"!&(  "-# 3+#'#("  5+&"  3#"&"&( !?!&('""-#&,30?(#2!5!+22!"#2@* #!+2="-'&2#'!(23#+0'#2"-#3!3#+=8

#$+#3+%##2&(?$0+"-#+5&"-"-#,!""#+7&"&'(#%#''!+." #B"+!%""-#+#4#/!("3!+"$04# $"-#04#'$

5-&%-&'!'0(2#+)A

   



   
 
   

         



 
    

 

  

 

           

       

   !

" 
   

                   

    !

" 

# #+0'!4$04# 7%4#!+4.+#/#!4'"-!"3+&+!33+/!4$1"!"# /#+(,#("&'(#%#''!+.$+#B%-!(?#$!(. 
   =0" &("-# 3+#'#("  %!'#  (  '0%-  !33+/!4  -!'  =##(  ="!&(#2  =#$+#  3!''&(?  "-# &,30?(#2 5!+22!"#2@* -#+#&'(2&'30"#"-!"$+, " 7+#'3(2#("(;!(2 -&'  5&$#  !45!("  9!0+  +#,!&(#2  !'  1!+3!(%-  $  +!, !(%-!.!"  !(2 +#'3(2#("( &'"-#'($+#'3(2#("(;!(2-#&'&(3''#''&($"-# ,!+4!'$4!(25-&%-&'/#'"#25&"-"-#+!,!(%-!.!""&'!4'("&( 2&'30"#"-!"5-#(+#'40"&($+#B%-!(?#$4!(25!'3!''#2=."-#+!, !(-!.!"7"-#$!"-#+$+#'3(2#("( 75!'"-#1!+3!(%- "&'!4'(#%#''!+.",#("&(-#+#"-!" ''""
44#%"+'"

+!2#-!'!4+#!2.!%%#3"#2"-#3#"&"&($&4#20(2#+'#%"&(;$"-# %"

!?!&('"
-!+!(!''75-5!'$(2&(0(!0"-+&F#23''#''&($ ,!+4!'

$
 !'3#+"-#2#,!+%!"&(+#3+"+#$#++#2!=/#!(2-#5!' 2&+#%"#2"-!(2/#+"-#3''#''&($"-#'!,#!'5#44!'3#(!4".G 
7CA3#+-#%"!+#3#+!((0,A=0"&(/&#5$"-#3#(2#(%.$"-# 3+#'#("  5+&"  3#"&"&(7  "-#  3#"&"&(  0(2#+  1#%"&(  ;  $  "-#  %"  !?!&('"

+#'3(2#("( 5!'!260+(#2  "&44"-#2#%&'&($"-#3+#'#("5+&"

3#"&"&( (/&#5$"-#!=/#7&"&'!33!+#("4.%4#!+"-!"+#'3(2#("(

&(%((&/!(%#5&"-+#'3(2#("'(;!(2*?"3!''#2"-#+#'40"&(!(2( "-#=!'&'"-#+#$7="!&(#2"-#&,30?(#2!5!+2$+,#+,!(#(":8 2!4!"

5-&%-&'"-#&($+!%"&($"-#04# $"-#04#'$

!(2!''0%-("

4#?!44.'0'"!&(!=4#-#3+&+!33+/!4$"-#1"!"#/#+(,#("&("#+,'$ 04# &',!(2!"+.$+#B%-!(?#$ 
  !(2&("-#!='#(%# "-#+#$7"-#!5!+23!''#2=.#+,!(#(":8 2!4!"&'((#'"&("-##.#'$ 4!5 /#("-#+#&'(2#"#+,&(!"&(=."-##30".
,,&''&(#+!'3#+ 04# $"-#04#'$

"-!"4!(25-&%-&''0?-""=##B%-!(?#2&'$ #>0!4/!40#
('#>0#("4.7"-#5+&"3#"&"&(&'!445#2!(2"-#&,30?(#2

5!+22!"#2@*73!''#2=.#+,!(#(":8 2!4!"7 ,=!4!&''#"

!'&2# '!+#'04""-#+#$7 ''""
44#%"+'"+!2#&'2&+#%"#2"3+%##2 $0+"-#+  5&"-  "-#  3#"&"&(  3#(2&(?  0(2#+  1#%"&(  ;  $  "-#  %"  !?!&('"

+#'3(2#("( !'#B3#2&"&0'4.!'3''&=4#=0"'"+&%"4.!%%+2&(?"4!5 !(25&"-0"=#&(?&($40#(%#2=."-#='#+/!"&(',!2#&("-#3+#'#("5+&" 3#"&"&(     !   " !  

!" 

!"  $ %&%'& ()'()*+,)&-./01*)&+/)2 3)+1 ()'()**),*'&45) 3)+1