High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12996/2017dismissed

Ashok Kumar & ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli13 pages

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 1

!"!#$% "&'()* #, &+" -

!#+" .+")" /

+0 #, &+" - "1#,#

+"# $2 3+/

4/#!+,5

3+ #,14,5

+ !#+" 3+ #')+ 3!

74 ,,7 ,5

#+ 74 +0 6!

& 3+/ )+ 8&3 94""!"

#+ 7 +0 4 + &+"1#,# " :& +"

!, 1+"# !" 8!#9 + +,, &+)9& 5!, #+# !#9 "!# 1+ ,!#9" +8!#9 #,) ,!#5!+ 7)+ ; <<<<< & # +5+"0!#575,!# &*

#,+575" +)#,

117!

8!7!

0 / !# =:; !9&

!+ *1#"

+ #"1 +# 0 !# > #, ?)!"!

!#4 8!7!

7*# 4 %# &

" "6&+!# +,)#,+"

!#& > #, ?)!"!

!# @=6 ##)# ,#:+ #,!# ?)"

!# !#+4 +,6 ##)# ,# =

!#"

0+,+ "+9 +,"=A +"!# 7),!#9 #,!#?)"

!#; !*+ #!50 +"1+!+ & **# *# %# = " # #,, 80 & 1 !#+"4 &0 + !# 1&0"!

1""""!# &!+ 7 ?)!+, & 1&0"!

7 1""""!# & " # 8#

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 2

'# #,)+ &+4

& *1#"

*)# + ?)!+,& # 8#

'# &++4 !# 1+ ,!#9" ?) #, !# ?)"

!#& 57 1",!#5!6/ !#=:; % & # +5+"0 +11, )1 +)#, !# +1+

!# / =:; % 6 " 1)

80 & #"

!# # & #B87/)1+*)+ #,!

!# "

&+807 0!#9,6#1+!# !17" +, 7 +!#9 !#,*, & 58#7 1",)#,+"

!#=:; % & 1C )+ & " ,!" )"", !# ,

!7 77 "1 # ""

+0 #, +75 + !# +1+ !#9 "

!# =:; %4 &65++ &1)+1", !,!#9 &*

#,4 &++# # 7),!#9 1 9+ 1& & D),9*# 6)7, 8 ")! #, "

* !" +1+,) ,&+!#876$2 E- ! "

$#$ " %

" !"

! &' ! "(

) !"

! & " % ) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

$#)$! "

! & "

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) %

) -. -., ! "/ "( "

#$ ! "

! & 0

" % "

! ! ! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0"

) %' " ) 0' "

)

'!"

)

' ) 0

,* 1 1 !"

#$ ! "

! & "

! "

" , "/" ! 2

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!" # %$ ! !" !

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 3

"/ "

! "

) "

"""% !

! &" ) ( "

& ! 4 "/ "

) ! !

' "

& ! "

")( 52 !"

#" $

! "/ "("!2 % "

3 ! (!! '"

! & ) 6 %6

! !" ! "/ "

7 " ) "

& $ ! "

' "

"/ "

#$ 2 2 ! "

" , ) ( "

)

( "

& $4%% ! ""

%( !" ! ( "

' " "

"( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! &

) ! "

#$ ! "

$#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

#$)%(! / 9 :"%)

0( "

! "

' ( "

#$ ! "

! &'" ) 0 "

#$ + , ! "

#$ ( ! ! "(

") " ! "

0 "

! ! )! "

! & " !"' "(! "/ ( % ""

, ! ) " ! ) " ) *"

#$! "

! & (

% " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &' '

2) ""

% / ( ! ! 0(

"( ! ! "

! " "/ .

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 4 % & C1"!

!# 7 6 * , !# +"

!, D),9*# # 8 ")** +!F,!# &776!#9* ##++*+ 7 +!

0# &1+!# !17"7 !, ,6#80 &#"

!## &$2 :

; # 77 &" "" 6&+!# !# 1+ "" & , 8# !#!

,8) +,& "# 8# ##)# ,)#,+"

!# @=4# &,

**# *# % ! =4 &+ !" # 7 1" 1+ ,!#9" * 6!77 # !#)4 &65+4 6!

& +!,+

*1#"

!#& 8, +*!#,)#,+ &1+5!"!#" %77 &" ""6&+!# +,)#,+"

@=& "8# ##)# ,1+!+ **# *#

%4 &1+5!"!#" %6)7,& 5# +!#9 + 117!

& 1+ ,!#9" 6!77 # !#) !# +"1 &" ""4 " !4 & @= & " # 8# +1 7, :8; & 6+, E+B )", !# 8 6# & 8 & # !#9# !" !#=:; %!" 8+ , "-.+ "-. 6&! &* #"

"'7 1"!#9 !#1+ ,!#9" 8 & # !#9# !"*)"

8)7!77,3 #!#9 &+804

& 1""""!# & , 8#

'# 8) & *1#"

!# 6 " # + !5,4 &+6)7,8#7 1"/!*!7 +704! *1#"

!#& 8# ,8) &1""""!#& "# 8#

'#4 &+6)7, 8 # 7 1"!#9 #!"

&&#$ ! 3( $ : ; " "1 *1#"

!# + ?)!+, !" # +#,4 &#B87/)1+*)+ #,!

9+!

770 8"+5,

& C1+""!# 1 !, !# & * !# 1 "

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 5 =:; & % ," # !# 7), ,1"!

*1#"

!#!# )+ &

!"+?)!+, 81+5,!"

*1#"

*)# 6 #,+,6&! && "8#C17 !#,!#

#,+!#9 *)# 6)7,* #

*)# !"* , !7 87 #,6#+

6)7,8 ,!" & +9 &87!9

* ' 0*# #,!#

5# ") & 1+"# ## 81# 7!F,+ &, )7 !#* '!#9 0*# &!7+++!#9 "

!#%:;4%:;4%= @= #, *1 +!#9 &*6!

1+5!"!#"! #,@ %4 &#B871C)+ " 7 +!!,

& #70 #"?)# ##21 0*# *1#"

!#!" * ' 0*# !# +"

"1+"

%= & @= 5# & #B87 /)1+* )+ & )+ &+ 7 +!!,

# 0*# *1#"

!#& "8# +,G #,+, )#,+ "

!# %:;4 ?)!+!#9 &+!

## 81# 7!F,+##21 0*# *)# "+* !# )#1 !,,) +)"

80 #,6#+ 7 +!0!

)+ &+4 &#B87/)1+*)+ ")+ &+8"+5,

! #,6#+ & " !7, & ++# + &!9&+ *1#"

!# &

## 7 !*

&6 "# 1 !, *)# :,; &!7+ ,!#9 &1+5!" "

!#81 "

!#=:;

%4 &#B87/)1+*)+ " 7 +!!,

"4 & + + 1 0*# & " 8# * , 8) # ,1"!

,4 7!

8!7!

0 1 0 *)# 7#9 6!

& !# +"

")8"!"

#, ! # ,1"!

, + * D+!

0 &7,!#9" + !5 0 +" + *+4 *1#"

!# )#,+ & % & 8 1 !, #,6#+" " # & ,

# !!

!# + 7

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 6 )#,+"

!#= @= +,!#9 &,1"!

8# 7 +!!, !# & D),9*#

+ & &!9&+ *1#"

7764 & *#0 "&)7, # & 5 8# ,1"!

,6!

&> #, ?)!"!

!#77 ++!# ")+0 + !# & )+ 6!

& +"1 * D+!

0 7 #, &7,!#9"4 * #!#9 &+80!!

6 ",1"!

,!# #0 &+*," 6!

& +"1 * D+!

0 &7,!#9"4 & &!9&+ *1#"

6!77# 77648) !# +"

)#,+"

!#%= @= 6)7,8 & #"?)# :; "+9 +," &*,

'!#91""""!#4 &#B87/)1+* )+ , 7 +!!,

,+ 6!#9!#?)"

+1+ G**+ #,)* 6)7, * #

1&0"!

7 1""""!# & " 8#

'# & 7 6 6!

&+9 +, 5"

!#97 #,& "# !#8+!

, &7,

# &1""""!#& "8#

'#)#,+"

!# @=4 #,5"

!# &/

&+ ## 8 #0 ,!5"

!#9+7 1"!#9 :; &!7 *1) !#9 &9 11+!,!50 +"8 6# &,

+, #, **# *# %4 #0!# +!*+,+ ")8"!"

!#9!" 8C 7),,6&! &* #"

+C 7),!#9 !# +!*+,+4 &1+2+?)!"!

9 11+!,A0 +"!"# &+4

&1+5!"!#""

!#=:; ## 8!#5', :9; &#B87)+ ")+ &+ 7 +!!,

! !# #,& , +7!+8# & 77#9, !#6 ")1&7,4 6&! & * #" & 1+ ,!#9 "

, # 7),,4 & )*8+77 1+

!#"

!#=:; % ## 8!#5'

,"# +5!5"

7 !*8 ++, 7 !*"

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 7 :&; # 1 %% 4 & #B87 )+ & " * , !

1+5!"!# "

!# =:; & % !" * 8 !#5',80 &8#! !

+!"!7 #,6#+"6&6++ +,, "

!*!"") # # !!

!#)#,+"

!#= @= #0 ")8"?)# 1)+ & "+4 &7,+ + &+6!"4 ## !#5' &1+5!"!#""

!#=:; % = " 1+ " 1) + &80 !#+"4 &0 +6#+!# 1""""!# #, * ")+!#9 '

7 * +7 := !9& !"6 "; +!#9 (& "+ A= "!

, !#

! #"

+4 &"!7 #, !"

#!1

&!+7 #,6 ?)!+,80 &/

+0 5!,# !!

!#" ,

,%@ #,!""),)#,+"

!#= #,"

!# > #, ?)!"!

!# 4@=4776,80 +,,

,:+ #,!#?)"

!# !#+4 +,6 ##)# ,# =

!#"

0+,+ "+9 +,"=A +"!# 7),!#9 #,!# ?)"

!#;+ &1)87! 1)+1"# *704+,571*# #,) !7!F

!# "!,# #,**+ !

7/ +%2

#!1

) &!+7

?)!+,4 #,* ")+!#9!9& !"6 6 "+7 ",)#,+/ A @=,) #"

+) !#&1 !#+" & 77#9,

!# 1+ ,!#9" 80 !7!#9 =% 6&! & 6 ,!"*!"", 80 &!" )+ 5!, D),9*# ,

, = = 8 ", )1#

'#!# &6+!

&+!9& 7 #,"

#,"+7 ", &"

!,D),9*# 6 ""

!7,80!7!#9> =%=A6&! &6 ,!"*!"",80 &!")+ 5!,D),9*# ,

,A= 77 &+)9&)

)"?)+* !#,1+

!5!# &!+ 5)+ ")+ &+8# # #,,

,"1!

#, & 5!#9 8# ?)!+, 7#9 8 ' 5!, +, ,

, :+ #, !# ?)"

!# & 1 !#+4 +, 6

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 8

##)# ,# = &5

!#"

0+,+ "+9 +,"=A

+" !# 7),!#9 #, !# ?)"

!#; #, ,"1!

& ,!"*!""

7 >

11 7!7,80 &*!# &0 +=4#!

&+ &1&0"!

71""""!# #,!#?)"

!#& "8#

'##+ & *1#"

!#& "8#1 !, + *!#9!# %4 &0 11+ &, &!")+ 80 !7!#9!5!7+!

!#=A6&! &6 ",!"1",80 &!" )+ 5!,+,+,

,AA &+804,!+ !#9 , !, !*

!#+ 8) !#1+ ,!#9"& 5!#98#7 1",!#7!) / !#=:; & % " 1+ !#+"4 &+ 7 !* 6 +D ,5!,+,+,

,= 6!

&) #"!,+!#9 &1+5!"!#" / !#=:; % "+9 +," &1&0"!

71""""!#& 5!#9 # 8#

'# & *1#"

*)# 5!#9# 8#+ !5,80

&*&)"47!#9 99+!5,6!

&+,+,

,= 4 &!#"

!# & " 8# 1+++, "'!#9 , 7

1+ ,!#9"?) &!+7 #,& "7 1",!#5!6/ !#=:; % "8 & # !#9# !"1+" +!8,!#"

!#=:; % + )7!77, A 11"!#9 " "

)1 80 & 1 !#+" #, 1+ 0!#9 + ,!"*!""

7 &!#"

6+!

1 !#43+#')+3!

747 +#,,,!

!# ,5

#+ +!#9 + & /

+0 ")8*!

# !# & 1 !#+" 8!#9 !# & 1""""!# #, !# ?)"

!# !" ,5!, *+!

& 1""""!# #, 6

'# 80 + +,!#9

F# * & #=,

, = #,"

*6 "& #,, 5+ & 8#! !

+0 ,1 *# )+ &+4 & # #,"

*1#"

!# + 7 #, !# ?)"

!# 6 " ,)70 #,+, !4 6 " * ,

!7 87 & 1 !#+"H &65+ &0 & 5 &"# # + !5 *#+,+ ")8"

*4 &+7!

# & "8#17 ,#

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 9

& * D+!

0 *1#"

!# & 7+ ,0 8# ,!"8)+", #,6#+"&++4!

!"")8*!

"!# ## & # !#9# !" *# !#,!#/ !#=:; % +)7!77, "1""""!#

#, "

#," ,)70

'# & 87!9

!# & /

1 0 *1#"

!#"

#,",!" & +9,6!

#,+G1 0*# *1#"

!#H

&1+"# 1 !#*+!

",!"*!""

7 )+ &+&&

'# &8D !##

&* !#

!# 8!7!

0 &!#"

1 !#8017 !#9+7!

# #1 %A #,+571*# ) &+!

0:/)1+ ;6&+!# &#B87/)1+*)+ #,!

9+!

770&7,

""6&+!# #,6#+:";& "7"

!# +7!+ +)#, 7!

!#4 / !# =:; % ## 8 !#5',

&!+!#"

# " "

#,!" # +#,4 !#+" , & 77#9, !#1+ ,!#9"80!7!#9!5!7+!

!# =%6&+!# &!" )+ ,!+"

70"

0, &,!"1""""!# !#+" &+ + ,!"*!"", & 6+!

1 !# 5!, +,+ ,

, = =&!"6 " & 77#9,80!7!#9>

11 7=%= A6&! &6 7",!"*!"",5!, &D),9*# ,

,A=6&! & !*17!"

!#1+ ,!#9"6+)1&7, 8!#9"4 &!#"

!#1+++,

&!#"

# !#"'!#97 1"!#9!"#

77 * !#

!# 87 & 1 !#+" &+ +4 11+ &, &!" )+ 80 !7!#9

# &+6+!

1 !#8 +!#9!5!7+!

!#=A &+80 !#5'!#9 & 1+5!"!#" / !# =:; 6&! & 6 " ,!"1", 6!

,!+ !#" , !, &!+ 7 !* +,!#9704 & "1 '!#9 +,+ ,

, = 6 " 1 "",4 6&+804

'!#9 !# #"!,+

1""""!# #, !# ?)"

!# & " 8#

'# & *1#"

*)# 6 ",)70 #,+,4 7 !*6 "+D ,)+ &+ +9),

"#!#9"9!5#!# &+,+,

,= + 7 +70 5+,6!

8"+5

!#"* ,80 &#B87/)1+*)+ !##,+571*#

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 10 ) &+!

0:")1+ ; &)"4 &"

*!"+?)!+, 8)1&7, 1+++,6 ++ ,!"*!""

7 +& 5!#91+)", &17 ,!#9"8 & # !#91 !"

#,+ +,!#9 &!+ # !#"46& 5#&"!

# 7),

& #, !" "?) +70 5+, 80 & 1+!# !17" 7 !, ,6# 80 #B87/)1+*)+ !# "

;

& 1+ 0+ & 1 !#+" 7 !*!#9 7 1"!#9 !# 1+ ,!#9" ,"+5",!"*!""

7!#5!6 &776!#9+ "#"$2

;&)9& !#+"& 5 # #,,

&0 +!#

1&0"!

71""""!# #,!#?)"

!#4&65+4 &"

5+*# !" # 87 !# 5!6 & !# +1+

!# B * , 80 & #B87 1C )+ !# #,+ 571*# ) &+!

0 :/)1+ ; 6&+!# & #B87 )+

9+!

770&7,

&6+,1""""!#)",!#

& @= & " "

* * #!#9

1&0"!

1""""!# )",!# / !# = :; % &# /

5+#*# ?)!+" #,,+ 6"**+ #,)*

'!#9 1""""!# 6&! & !# & 1+"# " !" 80 + +,!#9

F# * & # = ,

, = &++4 # &# * 6 ",+ 6#1+!+ &+,+,!"1""""!#6 "",80 &!")+ 4 &++41&0"!

71""""!#

#,"

'# #,# &1""""!#!"

'#4 &+!" 8"7) 5"

!#9 #, !# & /

&+ + 5# ! #,6#++

!#" &1""""!# #,4&!" +"1 ""+4

#,") &1""""!# +"1 ""+#)+"+&!"8#!

#,# 8& 7 &6#+!/

/!# 1""""!#& "8#

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 11 80+ +,!#9

F# * & #=,

, =4 !#+"

&0 +!#1&0"!

71""""!#

#,!" &)"4&+80+D ,

771""""!#& "8#

!#,80 &*4!

!"#70 +"1 ""+" #,# "6#+""

#"?)# 4 &+ # & ""# 7" + 7 !*!#9 1"!#9 !#1+ ,!#9"9" 8;" "1 *1#"

!# !" # +#,4 !

!" "1 !!

#, & +"1#,#

& *1#"

*)# 6 ,)70 #,+, #, 6 " * , !7 87 #,6#+" !# 7),!#9 & 1 !#+" # +,+ ")8"

* ++# & " 8# * , &

)

*1#"

*)# " 4A4%4= @G24 # *)#

"%4==4A 4@G2!* D+!

0 & *1#"

!#& "8# ,!"8)+",&!"

!"")! !# "&6

& *1#"

",)70 #,+,4 !#+"& 5 &*"75" &"# # + !5 &"

*4 6&! & &0 +

7!8+ 0 + !5 # !

!" "4 & " #, # !#9# 0 1+" +!8, !# "

=:; % 7" 9" &)"4 " ## # !#9# !" 1+" +!8, !# "

!# =:; % !" )7!77,4 &,*!#9!

!#7 1"!#91+5!,,)#,+"

=:; % ## 8 !#5', /!# ## # !#9# !" *# !#, !# "

!# =:; % !" )7!77, " 1""""!# #, "

#,"

'# *1#"

!#"

#,",)70 #,+,4 &++4#, 7

+9 +,"7 1"!#9 !#1+ ,!#9" #8* ,!#

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 12 ;5# &+6!"46 +!# *17 9+*# 6!

&3+3!

&!#"

1 !#!"# * !#

!# 87

&!#"

& 1+"# 1 !#+" &0 & 5 7+ ,0 7"

+7!+ 77#9 !#1+ ,!#9"* ,80!7!#9!5!7 +!

!# =% 6&! & 6 " ,!"*!"", 5!, +,+ ,

, = = &!" 6 ""

!7, 80 !7!#9 >

11 7=%=A6&! &6 ",!"*!"",80 &!" )+ 5!,D),9*# ,

,A=&++4 "8"+5, 80 &#B87/)1+*)+ #,!

%A#,+ 571*# ) &+!

0:")1+ ;!7!#9 &1+"# 1 !#!" # * !#

!# 87 7"4 !9& 7 #, "

#," 7+ ,0 +7 ", +* !#1+ ,!#9")#,+"

!#A2 @= &)"4 + 77 !# #, 1)+1"" 1+ ,!#9" "

#," # 7),, #, "

* ## 8 +1#, )#,+ &9)!""

!#=:; %

3+ #')+ 3!

7 # & "

+#9 & &

" 17 ,, !# 6+!

*# "5&*# 70 # #,,

?)!+, + &1)87! 1)+1"1)87! 1)+1"+) !7!F

!#7 #,+ "!,#

#,**+ !

7/ +%2

#!1

&7 #,!#?)"

!#!"5+0*) & ""# &!5 &1)87! 1)+1" #,!

&17 ##!#9#)+"!#9 &*"!

4@17 "* +7 #,* +4!# +# 7"

++ ," "1+ 0) 17 # & 5 #"!,+, &!" 1 +9)*# + !", 80 +"1#,# #,6 +!# *17 9+*# 6!

* &!"!" # !*1+

+ 8'1 !#*!#,6&!7, 7!#96!

" +!"!#9)

!#7 &!5 &1)87! 1)+1" #,!

!" &"

&+!

06&!"!# &8"

1"!

, !, 8) ) !7!F

?)!+,4 +!

5!#98#5"

,!#/

CWP No. 12996 of 2017 13 @ " "?)7 85 ,!" )""!# #, !# 5!6 7 6 ")** +!F, !# 1 %% #,+ 571*# ) &+!

0 :")1+ ;4 "1 !!

770 + & 5!#9 + +,,

!# " !# & #,4 & 1&0"!

1""""!# #, !# ?)"

!# & 5!#9 8#

'#4 & 87!9

!# + 0*# *1#"

!# "

#," ,!" & +9, 7" #"!,+!#9

#,!#?)"

!#!"5+0 *) &""# &!5 &1)87! 1)+1"46 5 # &"!

&7,

!# & !#"

"4 & "

& " )770 ,!" & +9,!

"87!9

!#?) 8 & # !#9# !" )++!#9!#"

!#= :;% #, !

8!#9"4 &1+"# 1 !# *+!

",!"*!""

&# 4 &!#"

1 !#!",!"*!"", 5!#9 ,!"*!"", & * !# 6+!

1 !#4 77 1#,!#9

117!

!#"4! #0 7"* &"

&6+!

1 !#!",!"*!"", /

)"?)! #0"

#,"5

, :

./( ; / :

>>; % 5!#,+ & &+"1 '!#9G+ "#, "G & &++1+

87 "G