High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15221/2024disposed of

Haryana State Industrial And Infrastructure Development Corporation Ltd. v. Yashpal And Others

2025-09-08Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

) % ) % ) % ) % ,#!%$ ,#!%$ ,#!%$ ,#!%$ %$ %$ %$ %$*+ *+ *+ *+7 / 7 / 7 / 7 / 8 !3((%"

!3((%"

*B *B *B *B*A* * * *

!#(#(%"!

!#(#(%"! !'%"-!"# !'%"-!"# !'%"-!"# !'%"-!"#

* * * *%$ %$ %$ %$*+ *+ *+ *+7 / 7 / 7 / 7 / 8 ) % ) % ) % ) % !#(#(%"!

!#(#(%"!

!'%"-!"# !'%"-!"# !'%"-!"# !'%"-!"#

!!"# $% $% $% $%

(#,5("6&,("(1-2%3,#! #&!'!#(#(%"! (") % !'%"-!"#%./+(") %$*+,"- %*%$*+ ,-," ,01-2%3,#!4(#& &(5("6&1-2%3,#! #&!'!#(#(%"! (") %* ' (2,#! !'%"-!"#7890,"-%4"!

%$*+,"- <&(",&,("11, @,"

", DDDD 17 ,08 17 ,08 17 ,08 17 ,08 :; (- -!#&(3%55%"% -! 1) % ,"-*%$*+, !<!

!("6 -!3(-!-,<%#& #&!'!#(#(%"("2%02!,5!=>! #(%"%$0,4,"-$,3# % < !2 2(#@1 #&!$,3#, !<!("

"6#,?!"$ %5) %% %$*+ :; @ 4,@%$' !!"#4 (#'!#(#(%"13& &,00!"6!&,<!!"0,(-#%#&!% -! -,#!- A*B* 7""!C> ! E.8 ',!- <@ # #&! (# (3# !2!">! $$(3! E3> >5E ,"-3=>((#(% %"%00!3#% 1> >6 ,57&! !(",$ $#! #%<! !$! !-,F#&! !$! !"

"3! %> #81 4&! !<@ @ #&! ,''0(3,#(%" $(0!- ,# #&! ("

"#,"3! %$ !'%"-!"#90,"-%4"

>"-! !3#(%" BE%$#&!,"-3=>((#(%" 3#1BA+7$% &% #F#&!BA+ 3#H8 #,"-,00%4!- :.; ( (!$0@ #,#("61 #&! 0,"- 5!,> > ("6 *A ,",0 %4"!- <@ #&! -%4"! ,3%E&, ! 1(#>,#!-4 4(#&("#&! !2!">!!#,#!%$2(00 ,6! ,,"1!&(0/ /(# (3#> >6 ,53,5!#%< <!,3=>( !-2(-!%#($(3,#(%"-, ,#!- G***(>!

!->"-! !3#(%"+%$#&!BA+ 3#$%00%4!-<@4, -%G-, ,#!- ****+', !-<@#&!,"-3=>((#(%"%00 0!3#% 7$% &% #F#&!H8 :.; !( ("6 -(E,#($(!- %$ #&! 4, , -1 $!4 %#&! 0,"-%4"! $( (0!-

!$! !"3! !#(#( (%">"-! !3#(%"B%$#&!BA+ +3#4&(3&4,', #0@,33!'#!- -<@ #&! 0!, "!- - -0 (# (3# >-6!1 > 6,%" 7 %? -,0,#8 2(-! (# 4, - -, ,#!- +*.* #&!

!<@ !"&,"3("6 5, ?!# 2,0>! %$ $ #&! ,3=>( !- 0,"- #% #&! #>"!

! %$

.1+1.9E'

'! ,3 !,0%"64(#&,00#,#>#% @< <!"!$(# , !- #&! !>'%"1 #&! ' (2,#! !'%"-!"#90,"-%4"! ' !$!

!$! !"3! >"-!

! !3#(%" BE %$ #&! BA+ 3# <!$% ! #&! !$! !"3! %> # %" *G* )& &(0! ,(- !$! !"3! >"-! !3 3#(%" BE %$ #&! BA+ 3# 4 4, '!"-("6 3%"(-!

! ,#(%" <!$% ! #&! 0!, "!- !$ $! !"3! %> #1 #&( %> # 2(-! (# -!3((%" -,#!- *A*.*B ',!- ("

% %+.+ %$ * #(#0!- F&,"-!

/ %#&! 2#,#! ! %$, @,",/ #&! H !E,! !-5, ?!#2,0>!I ++*0 0,3 '! ,3 !,#! ("(2(0''!,0%78G+E* %$*A1#&!%"H<0!'!C% %> # 2(-! (# -!3((% %" -,#!- **A $(",00@ -!# #! 5("!- #&! 5, ?!# 2,0>! %$ #&! ,3=>( !-0,"-I I .A1+1GGG9E'! ,3 !,0%"6 4(#&,00#,#>#% @<!"!$(#',@, ,<0! #%#&!0,"-%4"!

'! #,("("6#%#&!2(00,6!,,"

"!&(0,"-(# (3#> >6 ,5 :.;

!0 0@("6 >'%" #&! $(",0 -!#! 5(", ,#(%" 5,-! <@ #&! %"H<0! '

'!C %> #1 #&! !$!

! !"3! %> # 2(-! (# -!3((%" -,#!- A*B* -('%!- %$ #&! !$! !"3! >"-!

!3#(%" BE %$ #&! BA+ 3 3#1 #&! !<@ 6 ,"#("6 #&! <!"!$(# # %$

5, ?!# 2,0>! % %$ #&! ,3=>( !- 0,"- I .A A1+1GGG9E '! ,3 ! (" $,2%> %$ -%4"! #%#&!!C#!"#%$#&!( !'!3#(2!&, !<!(-!,4, - -("6 #&!5#&!%#&! #,#>#% @<!"!$(# :+; 5'

'>6"("6#&!,$% !,(-4, --,# #!-A*B*10!, "!-3%>"!0 $% #&!'!#(#(%"! 9 ><5(##&,##&!,''0(3,#( (%">"-! !3#(%"BE%$#&!B BA+ 3#4,' !$!

!-,##&!("#,"3!%$#&! !'%"

"-!"#90,"-%4"! ,$#! ,6,'%$ $* @!, %$#&!4 4, --,#!-+*.*',!-<@ @#&!0!, "!---0(# (3#>- -6!1 > 6,%"7%? -,0,#8#&>1#&!,5!<!("6<, !-<@0(5(#,#(%"14,0(,<0!#% %<! -(5(!- "#& &!%#&! &,"-1) %*%$ $*+&,<!!"$(0!-,##&!("#, "3! %$' (2,#! !'%"

"-!"#90,"-%4"! 4(#&#&!' , ,@! #&,##&! !'%"-!"#9 <! -( !3#!- #% !0 !,! #&! ,5%>"# %$ 3%5'!" ,#(%" (" #! 5 %$ 4, - -, ,#!- A*B*', !-<@#&! !$! !"3!%> #("!C C! 3(!%$'%4! >"-! !3#(%" BE %$#&!BA+ 3# :; & &,2! &!, - 0!, "!- 3%>"!0 $% #&! ', #(! ,"- '! >!- #&! ', ,'! <%%? :G;

% %5#&!$,3#,2,(0,<0!%" !3% - -1"%3,!$% ("#! $! !"3!(5 ,-! %># ,# #&! ("#, ,"3! %$ '!#(#(%"! 9 &! !$! !"3! !#(#(%" >"-! !3# #(%" BE %$ #&! BA+ 3# 4, ' !$! !- , ,# #&! ("#,"3! %$ #&! ' (2 2,#! -%4"! %" *G* <,!- %" #&! 4, - -,#!- +*.* * ',!-<@#&!0!

!, "!---0(# (3#>-6!1> 6,%"7%?-,0,#8("$,2%> %$ #&! %#&! (5(0, 0@ '0,3!- 0,"-%4"! %" #&!( !$ $! !"3! !#(#(%"78' !$! !->"

"-! !3#(%"B%$#& &!BA+3#,"-#&!,5!4,1# #&>4(#&("#&!' !3 (<!-'! (%- -%$ 0(5(#,#(%"%$*. 5%"#& :; " #&!%#&! &,"-1%"3!#&!4, -<@#&!0!, "!- !$! !"3!% %> # >"-! !3#(%" BE %$ #&! BA+ 3# 4, ',!- (" $,2%> %$ #&! ' (2 2,#!

-%4"! %" A*B*1 #&! '

! (%- %$ 5% ! #&," *+ @!, &, ',!-1#&!'!#(# #(%"! 9(1#&! !$% !1-( !3#!-#%!"> !(#3%5'0(,"3!, ,"- !0!,! #&! ,5% %>"# %$ 3%5'!",#(%" -!#! 5("!

!- #&! !(" (" $,2%> %$ #&! ' (2 2,#! -%4"! 1,##&!!, 0(!# :B; # #&( #,6!1 0!, "!- 3%>"!0 !

!' !!"#("6 #&! '!#(#(%"! 9 ><5(# #&,# #& &! ' (2,#! !'%"-!"#90,"-%4"

"! 5,@ $> "(& #&!( !'!3# #(2! ,33%>"#">5<!

#%#&!3%"3! "!-,>#&% (#(!4 4(#&("*4!!?$ %5#%-,@,"- -(" 3,!#&!"!!-$>0 0(-%"!1#&!'!#(#(%"! 9 &,00!"> !#&! !0!,!%$,5% %>"# %$3%5'!",#(%"

"("#&!( $,2%> 4(#&("$%> 4!!?

?#&! !,$#! :A; " >3&3( 3>5#,"3!1<%#&#&!4 (#'!#(#(%", !-('%!-%$ , # #(! , !-( !3#!-#%- -%#&!"!!-$>0("#&!,$% !,(-3% %"#!C# :*;

"-("6,''0(3,#(%"781($,"@&,00 ,0%#,"--('%!-%$ 7 8 7 8 7 8 7 8 !'#!5<!

!'#!5<!

!'#!5<! *B *B *B *B1 1 1 1 #(? * * * * )& )& &!#&! '!,?("69 !,%"!- ! &!#&! !'% #,<0! ! 9% 9%