← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18268/2014allowed

Nisha Sharma Etc. v. National Institute Of Pharmaceutical Education & Research And Another

2018-10-22Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri10 pages

 

        



 !"!

#$

% &'   

 

  

    



 

 ($ )*(+, ,- 

  

 

  

!

 

  





"    



   

$ 

%

'( )) **++,*-$

./*0(

1# 2



+ "1#  

 &  3  

  $  #(  +,,4$ 

% +,,4'(

    " # 1# 

!  1# 

  56   )

+70+,*+  

  

 *8 

 

 

 

1

#

) 2

        #       9  3 :





 *

5  # )    

)   &

 "  

     6    

#   #    

)   &  

 

     ;  

 4     # 

 &



   3 */*/+,,4& 0,,4+,,4

   



6 

#



 







  

    *-  3  

   )  

0**+,,4 

6 

#



  

 ) :

 1<

#   # 3  

  ;*,+,,4.



3    +,,4

  



  )

 

"

 3 

   

# 

    

  



"  1# 3

 

#  "   **+,,6 =  

     1#   3 

 

"  56  



+70+,*+



3 

" 1<

#   



 " 

 57   ) 

 +00+,*0  

  

  "  

 +,4+,*0 $

./**(1#



 0 2 

 )1   

  

  +  "   )   #    #  

 

#

 

    

9 

*774$ 

%  '(

  #



 )# 

  )

**++,*-$

./*0( 1#  )

  

 &  6  

#



=

!> 

 1  )  )







   

 1  ) - #

 1 !

#





 )

& &

1



&



#1# ?

  #  

3 :

  #   

 

      )

& &         

     





 =

 )

& & 

 1)

#.





 

 

  

  )    .

    = 

     1   )          

   "

  )  

 

.  $32(

 

  



     

 1



/    )#  

  #  )     

  

   "    1! 



 

  

&

 

#/  

1>

   

 

 

)   #

" " 





)

 #

"



#1  # "



1    1 #   ) "

 1  #  1

  

 #

 

1# 





    #



 #

 1 # 1)

.

 " 

"   #



"

 

  

 

      

  

)   

  

 = 

!



 56  ) 

+70+,*+ 

1)  "  

 

=

 



 



 1

1!

# " )  



 = 



 .

 1 #

 .  #-,,,!1#"# # 

"*&*& +,,6 

#"

1  

  # 

< 

  #

)   

     "

    !      

 

   

 

    



  

 

   #) ) 

*-++,*-$

./*(

 5 " ! #+,,4  

   # 3  2

.

 @

;*,+,,4$

./0(  #

 1#  &  3  

+,,4 "

1

   #



"   "> 



 &      3      " 

 

#  1 

  

1



  #

 "



!

 "  "# 



 

1    6 A     

  ) 

1

  ; B )

 1 

  1#    

 



  



" 



 



 

 

1

#

) 2

     #  93 : 

=

   3 */*/+,,4&

0,,4+,,4

   



 6

#



./*= 

"1 

  

    ) 

0**+,,4   

 

  

       *-  3 



*,*,+,,4



<

# 

# !     1<

#     @   

 

0,,7+,,4   

  

  .

     #   

   







  # 

  

 ) :



;*,+,,4$

. /0(   # 3  

 .

 & 

3  

+,,4

  



"

)  

1

#  1 

1 

.





)

 "   

#  )    #"

 1

  )

" &  "      &  3  

 +,,4 4 =  " #. 





1# 3

 

#

 



"  1# 3

 

#"*&*&+,,6 .

1   &  3  

 +,,4 =3



 ) )

 +64

     

   &  3  

+,,4

  

=)

" 1 +6  )       3  

    

   

60+,*+

 "



"     

 &  3  

+,,4"*&*& +,,6 =

  1# 3

 

"  



1  

        56   )  

 +70+,*+  

  



" /

  



 

  B "

  "  

 

 

#

 )  

        

 "  <

 1  !   



1  

;*,+,,4

"



! 3





 

1  



"  "

  

 )1 

  

  





 #    #  

  #"

!

  "

  1  )   

"

1 

    

 7 C ! )





  ! 



  

 "  





 



  ) 

"  

  3   #      0*+      

" " 3



 "

  .

 1 "D& .++ /# !

#"#0 &"







 

   " ) "D& $(

  1>

1 # 

     1

  

    

 



     $1(

 

          

    

    < 

)   # 1

#









  E $(

) 

   

)  #

 "    @ 

)

E $ (

2#3 #0  & 3/4

 !## "'   /# "'

!#6 "

# "'  7& 8'

%/"!# ""

#0 44

02!#!"

& !6 !&" #"

!

/

#0 & 5 7/&7 "

'

77 !# "/ 53 # ""!

28 5!#9!

:

$(

.        )  

 

& ) .

 #



3 

E $( 1>





 #

# 1

)

  ) #  

# 

    !            

1   # 

E $)( 1>





  

   #

1 

1  #

1

 E $(



1 )      

    #

"

! E $(



 

#' #

 



1 E

  $>(





>  

 ) 

  #)    E $!(

 

 







#

 E $(

)    #        " 

   

2

2

)  

  #   #





1#

 #   : $ (

.

 "

  



 #1

   

 '   +

    



 " 2



 1  

*6   " *-  

*6   .

 1 "D& ;,

!

# $ $*( =2

1

"   

 

 $+( =  2

    1           

.  

1

1

   

     

    

 

   $0( =  2

    1   

 

     



 $-( =  2

    .   

   "  

  

  #1)

 1# 

    @ '

** 



"# )



3

 "

" 

# 

      

  

 1#

" " 

! 

     



    )   

1 #

  

 

  

  #



 +  2





  )    **++,*-  $

.  /*0(  1#

& 

  1#  

  #



 C  ) 

 + )

 > 

  #"



  

    

           )    1# 

+ 1

1 &  *+ 

#   

 "  

     

 ) **++,*-$

./*0(  1#

 +

 &  <,- =  

% &' +   C ! )/

F D G C  1F G