Hoshiar Chand v. State Of Haryana & ORS.



     



!

 " 
! 

!#$% (%)*+*&,

-. -.  &+/*#0
/#,(

......

%$*$*&,%0

1%0+2+ 3$#$% #04#,# &$/%0+ ......

%+5&,(%,$+

  6 7  .

3
  3 

0%+%,$  0.

#+8*,(%0 3*,9/ /*,(:

(;&)#$% 5%$*$*&,%0.

0.

#<,%%+/
/#(=#>:

 #04#,#.

0.

.3.

*$$#>:

(;&)#$% .

. .  3  :

.

7

.

%$*$*&,%0

&+/*#0
/#,( '*>%( 2,(%0 0$*)>%+  
&,+$*$2$*&, ,(*#:

*,$%0 #>*#:

+%%?*,9 ,#$20% )%0$*&0#0* +%$$*,9

*+#0 !*;*+*&,:

*+#0

+/&0$ 6!*;*+*&,#>
&88*++*&,%06 =/%0%A4 /% 3*0+#

+/&0$ 6
&>>%)$&06:

0%9#0(+ ;*>>#9% %B#(%># C#>#,:

%/+*> 3*0+#.

.

'20$/%0 50#4%0 A%%, +%$$*,9 . . 

-:

#04#,#

+/&0$
&88*++*&,%06 =/%0%A4 #>$/&29/ &A+%0;%( 50%+%,$ )&,$%+$*,9 /%



0%8*$$%( &, #'$%0 )&85#0*,9 (%8%0*$+ )#,(*(#$%+.

.

0*%'>4:

&, (%8*+% 3/0* !*=#,
/#,(:

50%;*&2+

%,%0#>
#$%9&04 ;*>>#9% %B#(%># C#>#,:

%/+*> 3*0+#:

50&)%%(*,9+ =%0% *,*$*#$%( '*>>*,9 ;#)#,)4.

520+2#,)% 50&)>#8#$*&,

82+$0* 82,#(* )#>>*,9 25&, #55>*)#$*&,+ '*>>*,9 +#*( ;#)#,)4:

$/*0$%%, #55>*)#$*&,+

*,)>2(*,9 &,% +2A8*$$%( &$/%0+ :

=%0% 0%)%*;%(:

#))&0(*,9>4:

$/%*0 #,$%)%(%,$+ =%0% 9&$ ;%0*'*%( '&08 >&)#> 5&>*)%.

$0#,+5*0%+ %/+*>(#0:

3*0+# 0%)&88%,(%( ,#8% 3/0* #,<%%$ 3*,9/

 32A

''*)%0

*;*>:

3*0+# 0%)&88%,(%( ,#8% 50%+%,$ #'&0%+#*( ;#)#,)4 '&0=#0(%(
&>>%)$&0.

. /% 25&, #550%)*#$*,9 0%>#$*;% (%8%0*$+ ;*>>#9% %B#(%># C#>#,:

;*(%

.

. /% #'&0%+#*(

 )#8% )/#>>%,9%( $/0%% ,#8%>4:

#,<%%$ 3*,9/:

!%+

#< 205#> 3*,9/

:

0%+5%)$*;%>4

'*>*,9 $/%*0 0%+5%)$*;% #55%#>+.

>> #'&0%+#*( #55%#>+ )#8% (%)*(%( ;*(% )&88&,

=/%0%A4 #'$%0 )&85#0*+&, (%8%0*$+ )#,(*(#$%+.



. %*,9 #990*%;%( #9#*,+$ #'&0%+#*(

50%'%00%( #, #55%#>

   A%'&0%

=/*)/ )#8% (*+5&+%( &':

;*(% . . 

- =/%0%A4:

#>$/&29/ #, &A+%0;#$*&, 8%0*$&0*&2+:

0%8*$$%( &0(%0.

.

#'&0%8%,$*&,%( )*0)28+$#,)%+:

'*>%( 0%>*%'

+:

,&$*)%( #A&;%.

.

7%#0,%( )&2,+%> +2A8*$+ =%>>

/#;% %00%( >#= '#)$+ 0%8#,(*,9
&>>%)$&0.

+2A8*$$%( ,%*$/%0 ,&0

+%$ 7#8A#0(#0:

$/%0%'&0%:

$/%0% ,& &))#+*&, 0%8#,(*,9
&>>%)$&0.

'20$/%0 +2A8*$$%( )#,(*(#$%  /% 0*9/$>4 7#8A#0(#0.

,%@$ +2A8*$$%( #55%>>#$% #2$/&0*$4 =%>> 0%;*+*&,#> #2$/&0*$4 /#;% '#*>%( #550%)*#$% =%>> +%$$>%( 5&+*$*&, 7#8A#0(#0:

)/&*)% >*9/$>4 *,$%0'%0%( 2,>%++ $/%0% 5#$%,$ *>>%9#>*$4 &0 5%0;%0+*$4 $/%0%*,.

)&,$%,(%( +*85>4 &A+%0;*,9 )&85#0%( ;#0*&2+ (%8%0*$+ ,%*$/%0 (*+)2++%( #>>%9#$*&,+ )&2,$%0#>>%9#$*&,+ 0%+5%)$ %;%04 )#,(*(#$%.

7%#0,%( )&2,+%> 5%$*$*&,%0:

=/*>% 0%'%00*,9 &0(%0:

+2A8*$+



)&85#0%( $/%0%#'$%0:

50&)%%(%( /*9/>*9/$ /*8 7#8A#0(#0.

))&0(*,9>4:

50#4%0 A%%, +%$$*,9 *8529,%( &0(%0+

 - A%*,9 2,+2+$#*,#A>% %4%+ >#= 0%+$&0*,9 &0(%0:

#55&*,$*,9 7#8A#0(#0.

.

%0 )&,$0#:

)&2,+%> 205#> 3*,9/ &55&+%( +2A8*++*&,+ &, A%/#>'

+2A8*$$*,9 *8529,%( &0(%0+ (& )#>> *,$%0'%0%,)% $/*+
&20$ &,>4 A%%, )#, ;%04 =%>> #9*$#$% /*+ )>#*8 A%'&0%
&>>%)$&0.

+2A8*$$%( =/*>%

:

'#*>%( 5&*,$ &2$ /&= $/%0%'&0%:

#55%>>#$% #2$/&0*$4 0*9/$>4 )#+%.

'20$/%0 +2A8*$$%( %;%,

8#*,$#*,%( 0%8#,( $/%0%'&0%:

$/%0% ,& +)&5% #,4 *,$%0'%0%,)% $/*+
&20$ %@%0)*+% *$+ <20*+(*)$*&,.

*$/ #'&0%+#*( +2A8*++*&,+:

50#4%0 (*+8*++#> A%%, 8#(%.

.

 /#;% /%#0( )&2,+%> 0%+5%)$*;% 5#0$*%+ /#;% 5%02+%( 5#5%0A&&?

$/%*0 #A>% #++*+$#,)%.

.

%0%:

=&2>( #55&+*$% +$#$% 0%>#$*;%

,&$*)%(
&>>%)$&0:

=/*)/ )#, +288%( 2,(%0 



#0$*)2>#0+ %$*$*&,%0

%+5.

%+5.



%+5.



&+/*#0
/#,(

#,<%%$ 3*,9/

!%+

#<

205#> 3*,9/ (2)#$*&, ..

#$0*) $/ ..

7#,(  )0%  )0%  )0%  )0% 9%  4%#0+  4%#0+  4%#0+  4%#0+

%)&88%,(%( 32A

''*)%0

*;*>:

3*0+# %/+*>(#0 3*0+#   .

A#0% 5%02+#> #A&;% )/#0$ =&2>( +/&= 4&2,9 8#,

 4%#0+ 5%0 &0(%0F =/%0%#+ '#>> +#8% #9% 90&25 (*''%0%,)%  4%#0+.

%$*$*&,%0  #0% %(2)#$%(

90#(2#$% .

%$*$*&,%0 +2''*)*%,$ >#,(/&>(*,9

 )0% /*+ ,#8% 0%)&88%,(%( 32A

''*)%0

*;*>:

3*0+#.

.

 

       



*;*> :

&,6A>% 3250%8%
&20$ /%>( 0%9#0( 3$#$% 2,<#A:

#9% )#,(*(#$% 0%>%;#,$ '#)$&0.

+ '#0 0%)&88%,(#$*&,+ >&=%0

%;%,2%

''*)%0 )&,)%0,%(:

#>$/&29/:

A&2,( 0%)&88%,(#$*&,

%;%,2% 2$/&0*$*%+ '#;&20 )#,(*(#$%F (2% )&,+*(%0#$*&, #))&0(%( +2)/ 0%)&88%,(#$*&,+ $/%4 #0% 5&+*$*&, #++%++ +2*$#A*>*$4 )#,(*(#$% +2)/ 0%)&88%,(#$*&, =&2>( /#;% +&8% 5%0+2#+*;% ;#>2%.

$/*+ 0%9#0(:

0%'%0%,)% )#, &A+%0;#$*&,+     

        



   

  !:

 



*;*>  "    

   #

   



    !  



.



.

>$/&29/:

 &=, >#,( 5%$*$*&,%0F &A+%0;%( '#0 /&>(*,9 >#,( )&,)%0,%(:

+#8% $#?%, *,$& )&,+*(%0#$*&, &,>4 5205&+% +%)20*$4 $&=#0(+ 9&;%0,8%,$ 0%;%,2% )&>>%)$%( 7#8A#0(#0.

%$*$*&,%0 #A&2$  )0% >#,(:

=/*)/ +2''*)*%,$ $#?%, *,$& )&,+*(%0#$*&, 5205&+% +%)20*$4 0%;%,2%:

)&>>%)$%( 7#8A#0(#0.

&0%&;%0:

$%

             



  

 !   

*;*> :

$/*+
&20$ &A+%0;%( >#,( 0%;%,2% +$&&( #A&>*+/%( A&$/ 3$#$% 2,<#A #04#,#:

>&,9 A#)?:

$/2+ &=,*,9 >#,( 5&+$ =&2>( 82)/ +*9,*'*)#,)% #,4 '20$/%0.

.

20$/%08&0%:

%           



"%%  &'' !:

  

*;*> F /%>( !*;*+*&, %,)/ $/*+
&20$ )/&*)% )#,,&$ >*9/$>4 +%$ #+*(%:

%;%, *'

$=& ;*%=+ #0% 5&++*A>%:

2,>%++ $/%0% #,4 5#$%,$ *>>%9#>*$4 &0 5%0;%0+*$4 $/%0%*,.

=%>> %+$#A>*+/%( 8#*, #2$/&0*$4 7#8A#0(#0.

=/& &,>4 #550%)*#$%+ #,$%)%(%,$+ '0#4 A2$ 5%0+&,#>>4 *,$%0#)$+ $/%8.

/2+:

+2A<%)$*;% +#$*+'#)$*&, +/&2>( 0%+5%)$%(.

. &0%&;%0:

#))&0(*,9 <2(98%,$ 0%,(%0%( &,6A>% 3250%8%
&20$      

        -



*;*> :

:

A%)&8% '*,#> +#8% +%$ =/*>%



0%8#,(*,9 '0%+/ (%)*+*&,.

/2+:

<2+$*'*%( 8#*,$#*,*,9 0%8#,( 8#$$%0.

-.

/#$ #5#0$:

*8529,%( . . 

-:

A%%, &A+%0;%( #>$/&29/ 50%+%,$ )&,$%+$*,9 /% 0%8*$$%( &,

#'$%0 )&85#0*,9 (%8%0*$+ )#,(*(#$%+.

0&8 &0(%0:

%;*(%,$ /% )&85#0%( $/%0%#'$%0:

50&)%%(%( /*9/>*9/$ /*8 &A+%0;*,9 2,(%0 

  

   

               



   !"    #! "$!   %    

     

           &       '   (  

 "
) * 

     

)+ ,- .

) %%  % 

 % % 

       )! )/)(0% 

  "% 

12  3 

    +   )     

     %   )  +"          %      * .

#'&0%8%,$*&,%( '#)$+ )*0)28+$#,)%+:

 #8 )&,+*(%0%( ;*%=

. . 

-

-

#0% 2,+2+$#*,#A>% +#8% #0% #))&0(*,9>4 +%$ #+*(%.

%+2>$#,$>4:

#>>&=%(

 #55&*,$*,9 ;*>>#9% %B#(%># C#>#,:

%/+*> 3*0+#:

25/%>(.

 .

%,(*,9 #55>*)#$*&,

+:

*'

#,4:

+/#>> +$#,( )>&+%(.

 3  

!

-. -. 

+<?+ /%$/%0 0%#+&,%(

"%+

& /%$/%0 0%5&0$#A>% "%+

&