High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11343/2018allowed

Nahar Nath v. State Of Punjab Etc.

2018-09-11Mr. Justice Amit Rawal6 pages

!"#

$%& &'()(*+

$-$.$%- &%(%(*&. /) %$%& 0*1$2$*3%-&.) &)4*3&*%) "+5 6" "+5 6" "+5 6" "+5 6"77" 77" 77" 77" .&)&*%+ "."7(*89$:3;'$%&:

.%-&4&%(%(*&. ".$*3-&.:3;'$%&:

..&)4*3&*%< ")6$;$*=$$09::0*1$2 77": 77": 77": 77": -& 4.$=&. >$3& (* %-() 4&%(%(* () . %-& ())0$*'& $ 3(.&'%(* % .&)4*3&*% % .&)%.& %-& 4))&))(* %-& 4.4&.%= (* ?0&)%(*$*3%-$*3;&.%-&$>0*%8&*&.$%&3$ %&.%-&)$9& @-&$%%%-& 4&%(%(*&. * 2.(& : *& /(A.$> $%- -&9$ "$-$*% $)@$*% $%- @$) $44(*%&3 $) "$-$*% &.$ (3- $2$ 09$A-$* $%- &.$ 0))$(*40.$ $3-'--(7$9$*:9('&%$%(*"099&40.:&-)(9$*3 ()%.('% $%&-8$.-$-(2(*%-&=&$.

(*%-&4.&)&*'& -&A- -$8@$*%() $;&..&3 %-$% %-& (;(9 038& &*(. (;()(*#: $%&-8$.- $-(2: ;(3& (%) .3&.3$%&3

:-&93%-$%/(A.$>$%--&9$ $2$$)@$*%$%-() %-& "-$%>(> &.$ $*3 >0%$%(* 3$%&3 B

@$) )$*'%(*&3(* $;0. 08$"$..( $(=$%>$> /(A.$>$%--&9$ $2$ $)@$*%$%--&9$$.$$%-C(.($$%-$*3/(A.$>$%--&)$(3

/(A.$>$%-@$)$99&8&39=(*;9;&3(*$ $9)&'.(>(*$9'$)&(*"$.'-

$*3 $..&)%&3 -& 4.4&.%= &.$ @$) 2&(*8 >$*$8&3 2= %-& 4&%(%(*&. 2&(*8-&9$ /(A.$>$%-'>>(%%&&@$)'*)%(%0%&3*

$*3$99&8&39=$44(*%&3*&/(A$)$%-$)"$-$*% %-& &.$@-('-'093 *%-$;&2&&*3*&2=%-&'>>(%%&&$)$"$-$*%'$*2&$44(*%&3*9=2= %-& -&A-D$3-0 $>$1 % () 0.%-&. $;&..&3 %-$% %-& )$(3 4&.)*) 8% 4.&4$.&3$'$9&*3.$0*3&.&'%(* %-&.*

$*3* %-& )$>& 3$= .&)4*3&*% D " $%&-8$.- $-(2 4$))&3 %-& .3&. $44(*%(*8&-)(93$.D.&)4*3&*% $)%-&.&'&(;&.&@$)3(.&'%&3% 8&% %-& )%$*3(*8 '.4 -$.;&)%&3 0*3&. -() )04&.;()(* $*3 % 3&4)(% %-& (*'>&3&.(;&3 .>(%(*$*=*$%(*$9(F&32$*A$*3@(%- 0.%-&.2)&.;$%(* %-$%@-&*&;&.%-&.3&.4$))&30*3&.&'%(* %-&.())&%$)(3& 2=%-&'>4&%&*%0.%%-&*$)4&.%-&.3&. %-&0.%:.&'&(;&.@0932& 20*3 % .&%0.* %-& >*&= % %-& '*'&.*&3 $0%-.(%= -& .3&. 3$%&3

@$) '-$99&*8&3 2= %-& 4&%(%(*&. 2= @$= ""E<<,

(*@-('-*%('& >%(*@$)())0&3*,

$*3 %-&4&.$%(* %-&.3&.3$%&3

@$))%$=&3-&)$(3.3&.3$%&3 ,

.&$3$)0*3&.+ G%('& >%(* 2& ())0&3 % %-& .&)4*3&*%) E

* %-& >&$*@-(9&: %-& 4&.$%(* (>408*&3.3&.@(99.&>$(*)%$=&3H *

:.&)4*3&*% .&'$99&3(%).3&.:(*;(&@ %-& .3&. )%$=3$%&3,

:$*34$))&3%-&.3&.%-$%G*529&0*1$2$*3 $.=$*$(8-0.%:*,

-$)4$))&3%-&.3&. )%$=%(99 0.%-&. .3&.) .&>$(*)%$=&3#*'>49($*'& %-&.3&.) %-&*529&0.%: .3&.3$%&3

%-()

('&:()%$A&*2$'A .&'$99&3#@(%-(>>&3($%&

&'%&-)(93$.'0>&'&(;&.$%&-8$.-$-(2()3(.&'%&3%)02>(%.&4.% (*%-()

('&:$ %&.(>>&3($%&9=-$*3(*8;&.%-&4))&))(*:$)4&..09&):% %-&'*'&.*&34$.%=:%$A&*(*%-()'$)&4&'($9$%%&*%(*2&8(;&*%%-& $'% %-$%$*=.3&. $*=*529&0.%2&*%3()2&=&3H % () $;&..&3 (* %-& 4&%(%(* %-$% 3&)4(%& %-& $ .&)$(3 .3&.: .&)4*3&*% (99&8$99=-$.;&)%&3%-&'.4 %-&9$*3>&$)0.(*8,$'.&) $*3)93%-&)$>&*

%-.08-"D) &&.>$**.$3(*8>4$*= $*3>>())(*8&*%(.-(*3"$*3($*30*1$28.-$340.'-$)&3%-& )$>& . :

<:B B-&4&%(%(*&.-$3$99&8&39=>&%.&)4*3&*% : @- -$3 $99@&3 %-& 4&%(%(*&. % -$.;&)% %-& .&>$(*(*8 @-&$% '.4 20% @-&*%-&4&%(%(*&. %.(&3 % '99&'%%-& @-&$%: '-$

&%': .&)4*3&*% .&)%.$(*&3-(> .>&*%&.(*8%-&4.4&.%=(*3()40%&%()$9)>&*%(*&3%-$% .&)4*3&*% -$3@.(%%&*$9&%%&.%%-&"$*$8&.:%$%& $*A *3($:

.$*'- (.-(*3 "$*3( % )&$9 %-& $''0*% &.$ * $''0*% (>4)(%(* &'%(* E %-& . 20% * <

3(.&'%&3 %-& >$*$8&.%4&*%-&)$(3$''0*%-&4&%(%(*&.-$3$99&8&39=$44.$'-&3 .&)4*3&*% $*3B ..&%0.*(*8 %-&$>0*% %-&@-&$%'.420% *&(%-&.%-&>*&=-$)2&&*.&%0.*&3*.%-&4))&))(*-$)2&&*3&9(;&.&3 2$'A&*'&:%-&4.&)&*%4&%(%(*-$)2&&* (9&3 &4$.$%&.&49(&)$.& (9&3*2&-$9 .&)4*3&*%)% ! < * $449('$%(* @$) $9) (9&3 0*3&. .3&. 09& %-& (>49&$3(*8 .&)4*3&*% , % @-('- .&49= -$) $9) 2&&* (9&3 2= %-& 4&%(%(*&. 6&$.*&3 '0*)&9 . %-& 4&%(%(*&. -$) )02>(%%&3 %-$% * B

:.&)4*3&*% @.%&$9&%%&.%.&)4*3&*% .3&9(;&.(*8 4-=)('$94))&))(* %-&4.4&.%=(*?0&)%(*%%-&4&%(%(*&.@-('-@$) )021&'%>$%%&. %-&4.'&&3(*8)(*(%($%&30*3&.&'%(* %-&.

$*3$%%-&)$>&%(>&*B

:.&)4*3&*% $)A&3%-&4&%(%(*&.% '>& 4.&)&*% * B

. %$A(*8 ;&. %-& 4))&))(* %-& 9$*3 (* ?0&)%(* @&;&. * B

: %-& 4&%(%(*&. @$) *% $99@&3 % 8(;& 4))&))(*2=$*0*.09=>2@-('-8$%-&.&3%-&.&$*3@$)*%'*%.99&3 &;&*2=%-&49('&%() 0.%-&.)02>(%%&3%-$%* B

:.&)4*3&*% 4$))&3 %-& .3&.: @-('- () $%%$'-&3 $) **&I0.& ED @(%- %-& .&49= .&)4*3&*%)% :%-$% .%-&40.4)& -$*3(*8;&.%-&4))&))(*$% %-&)4%:$-$.$%-D4&%(%(*&.@$)(* .>&320%-&3(3*%'>&4.&)&*%$% %-&)4%$*3%-&.& .&:%-&4.'&&3(*8) .3&9(;&.= 4))&))(*'093*% 2&(*(%($%&3D'>49&%&3%@$).$%-&.2)&.;&32=.&)4*3&*% %-$%%-& &-)(93$.'0>&'&(;&.)-$99*%%$A&$*=$'%(*:%(99%-&.&'&(4% .3&.: 4$))&3 2= %-() 0.% % @$) )4&'( ('$99= >&*%(*&3 (* %-& .3&. 3$%&3

%-$%@-&*%-&4))&))(*@$))08-%%2&3&9(;&.&3:$.0'A0)@$) '.&$%&32=%-&4&49& $31(*(*8$.&$@-@&.&.$()(*8)98$*)$8$(*)%%-& 4&%(%(*&.$*3(* $;0. "$-$*%D.&)4*3&*%<:@-@$)$44(*%&3$) "$-$*% *

-0): (% () )02>(%%&3 2= 9&$.*&3 '0*)&9 . %-& 4&%(%(*&.%-$%%-08-%-&4))&))(*()%2&3&9(;&.&3%%-&4&%(%(*&.=&% 30& % 3()%0.2$*'& '$0)&3 @(%- %-& 0*.09= >2 2= .&)4*3&*% <: .&)4*3&*% &;&* (* 4.&)&*'& %-& 49('& -$) $(9&3 % 3&9(;&. %-& )$>& 6&$.*&3 '0*)&9 . .&)4*3&*% < -$) )02>(%%&3 %-$% .&)4*3&*% < -$) 2&&* $44(*%&3 $) -&9$ /(A.$> $%- (* -&A- '&.&>*=-&93*

$*3%-&4))&))(* %-&9$*32&-$*3&3;&. %.&)4*3&*%< *%-().&8$.3:9&$.*&3'0*)&9 .%-&4&%(%(*&.-$).&9(&304* $3&'()(* %-&04.&>&0.%(*%-&'$)& G -0%$*( G -0%$*( G -0%$*( G -0%$*(/)"())"$* "())"$* "())"$* "())"$* &)$($*3%-&.)H &)$($*3%-&.)H &)$($*3%-&.)H &)$($*3%-&.)H,B #

%'*%&*3%-$%%-&&*?0(.=0*3&.

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

:$44(*%>&*% .&'&(;&.0*3&.&'%(* B %-& .*

.%-&4))&))(* %-&4.4&.%= (* 3()40%&: $99&8&3$44(*%>&*% /(A.$>$%-$)"$-$*%* B

:)%$= %-& .3&.3$%&3

:.& &.&*'& %-&.3&.3$%&3

$*3

2=%-& ":%-&4.'&&3(*8) B

$*3 B

3&9(;&.= 4))&))(*%%-&4&%(%(*&.$*3(%) $(90.&30&%(*%&.

&.&*'&2= %-&)044.%&.) .&)4*3&*%, -0): (* ;(&@ %-& $ .&)$(3 $'%) $*3 '(.'0>)%$*'&): (% () 49$(* $*3 )(>49& %-$% %-& 4))&))(* %-& 4.4&.%= (* 3()40%& -$) % 2& -$*3&3;&.%%-& &.$%-.08-%-&4&%(%(*&.$*3%-&$>0*%.&$9(F&3$ %&. %-& )$9& @-&$% 2= %-& .&'&(;&. 30.(*8 %-& 4&.(3 @-&* %-& 4.4&.%= (* 3()40%&@$)(*-()4))&))(*-$)%2&%.$*) &..&3%%-&2$*A$''0*% %-&

&.$ -& 3()40%& $) % @-&%-&. %-& 4&%(%(*&. () 9$@ 099= $44(*%&3 $) -&9$D"-%>(>..&)4*3&*%<D/(A$)$%- /(A.$>$%-()*%%-& )021&'% >$%%&. 3()40%& % 2& 3&'(3&3 (* %-() '$)& $) $99 %-$% -$) % 2& 3&'(3&3()%-$%$)%@->%-&4))&))(*()%2&-$*3&3;&.2&'$0)&%-& 4.4&.%=(*3()40%&())%(99(*%-&-$*3) .&)4*3&*% D.&)4*3&*% 3&)4(%&%-& $'%%-$%%-&.3&.2=@-('-4.'&&3(*8)0*3&.&'%(* %-&

B .@$)(*(%($%&3-$)$9.&$3=2&&*)%$=&32=%-()0.%*)&?0&*%9=: %-&@.(%4&%(%(*()$99@&3$*33(.&'%(*()())0&3%.&)4*3&*%) $*3E %&*)0.&%-&-$*3(*8;&. %-&4))&))(* %-&4.4&.%=(*3()40%&%%-& 4&%(%(*&.@(%-(*$4&.(3 %-.&&3$=) .>%-&3$%& .&'&(4% '&.%( (&3 '4= %-().3&.$*3$9)%%.$*) &.%-&$>0*%9=(*8@(%-(%:2&9*8(*8% %-& &.$: (* %-& 2$*A $''0*% &.$: %-& 3&%$(9 @-('- @093 2& 4.;(3&32=%-&4&%(%(*&.%()*&&39&))%>&*%(*%-$%$*=;(9$%(* %-() .3&.@093$%%.$'%%-&4.;()(*) %-&*%&>4% 0.%)'%:,< 77"# 77"# 77"# 77"#

-&%-&.)4&$A(*8D.&$)*&3 +

&)D -&%-&.&4.%$29& +

&)D