← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4403/2019dismissed

Director Department Of Food Civil Supplies And Consumer Affairs v. M/S Virgo Softech Limited And ANR

2019-10-29Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur12 pages

      

  

 

!"

#$%$!&'

( (

 

 



           

(((((( )) ** &

+,,

!"#$ 

# (((((  %)!&- &%

.....

' /0 ,( , , 1

 % &

'

( ) &&*& 

+# & )  # &&*& 

#

& &

, #  

 & #

-     .&/& 0000000 , 12 (

/& ,1 + 1  # 

      23  # 

   #

)#  # #&- +#1 # #  

 1 /2&42&54/6& 5&

 #  # #

  

  

7   !    #

   

& 8#       #  

          #  +#    1

#  

#

&9    #  + #

   +  )  #  &  : 1     +

  1 # (#  1   52&4;&54/;&8#

+  # 1    1#  +##+ 1 1 #

1 +   #

+##    & 8#

       + +## +    1 #   & 8#     # 

 



 4;&4;&54/3 + #  #  #< 5 52 4= >/4!   ?/4@



 +&&& 4/&4>&54/;  #   

    && 4;&4;&54/3+# ?/5@ + 

+# #

#+#  #  #

# & 2&  #   #



   2;#

   /66A# &- #

 #  +#

 

  1 1  24  1  #     2;B2C  # 

   /66A&8#  +  1

    /2&42&54/6    

& 8#  +   1   #   #  # 

 #   1 #    2;B2C# 

  &

;&  &

'

( ) &&*& 

 +# & )  # &&*& 

  # #

# #&-#    #   # + +  + 1#    

   

 !"   #$ +#   #    # #   

   1   

 ! 1#  +## #) +

 

+#+#

    )   #

     2;#/66A #

  

 1  #1 1 1   #

 & # #   #    : 1      % &

 %"  '

   ((   (

    )      

*+, ' & -"(( .(. #    +# 1           

         B C #  # #  #

   2;B2C# /66A+ 

 1 #    1# !  1 #

1

)  #

         2;  # /66A &    #  #    +  ##

 /5&4;&54/3

#

+  1#. 9#

 5/&4;&54/3 # #

  #   1   5/&4;&54/3

 #  # +&8 ) # 5/&4;&54/3 #   

       #   +  +#    & =&

    & 

 , #     

   #   #   #     # #   +  1  #        2;B2C#/66A

 # #&-#1   #  &    #  #    1# #

 

# 

 

# 

 &  # #

        

       B C  +  



   #  + 1 +## 

 < 1   

 &  

  :   # 

    D 

 #

# &  # #        )/  "!'0     -  1

 ($( 2   '

 #  1##

   

        2;B5C# 

+# # #



 1<  # #1 1 #+ E  F

# &  # #

   )/  "!'0     -  1

       B C #   1 # #  #   +      2;B2C#/66A 1#+ #  <   

    1  #   # # +#

   24  1 & ( #   

 

 1##(# 3  '%4  *  

*    - (## 2   '

 .

5

    

 6 4  )  , 7 7   * 8 *9-2   

#  & A&

 #  #       #



 #   #

 

 + #  + 1##

& 3&



  # # 



1#     4;&4;&54/3 +## +  

  1 #

 #  # &  - 1       /6&4>&54/3& 8# + 

1

  = #$  

 1 # # #  +1#. 9 /3&4;&54/3+##  # 

  #    D 

  5/&4;&54/3

#  #

   +# # 

  +     #    

  54&4A&54/3&8#

+  1#  #  #  #

<  +#  +## #    #     +    //&4>&54/3 B   # #

 24  1C

# ##  +   #  1& >& 8# G

1H#     5B#C#/66A  %  G

1H

1 

 &   2

 

 +## # %          

      

! 



        

            



  !



    !

       

    

 

   

  "      # !

       

         $

 " 

  !



   

           

            % &        

            &      

            '



    2/B=C    1# +     #

1& 8#      +# 

  2;B2C#/66A

# & 6&

#    #    +#

#

 

 #

# 

1&&

1#  +# 

1 #

  2;B5C#+# #      2;B2C#/66A&8#   #

# #  # +#

<  24 1 #+              +#   & /4&    #

 #  1       B C

 $3 #4 *  #4&!

&5$& 6%

  B C   

  #   #  #   + 

+#        1 #    D 

   5/&;&54/3&

        

    B C



#> 6D /4#  ## % ( &      

   )*  +

 *          

  ,       ,  

      *   

          

      

 *  %    -  &     

   

 !   !

   ..   

  &       



     

           

      

 

                 /    *   !



      "   

   *  0

 

           *  0

 

 -        

  

             

 



 

       1 

    1    

             



     !        

      

       

    

       

 2 ,    1 

 3   "   !   

              

 "       

            

    

  

 "           

    ) *  

 +

 *     )*  

 *  0 / ,     !   4  5    

  

     ,     

 ,   

   4  5

       ,

    !   

    -  !      4  5 5   

             ,     6  4  578  4  ! 4   &  4  5      -  !

   '    -   

   

    4  5     "      



   #  

       &  8

                  

 #       :              #  

            

    !

         



            

  

       

      

 )   



 &  !  

 !   

    8

   

            "      

 

    6

 

"

               

         

       

  *  0

   - &          5  2%//        

 

   

        4  //& 8#: #  +###  1# #

  

    B C+

#  # 

 &

#  

         B C #   + 1       +#88#17  D     &8#   +  1## #  

  +#+ ##7  &9   #*  



 

  +# # 

 1#

+  #   # *  

  #   + 1   /5&42&544/ +#  # # 7    #  1  #   8

 /6&42&544/&8##7  



# +#

 

 1   # #+

 #  /6&42&544/

 #   

   #        #   #  +  #*  

 /5&42&544/&

# )  #

        

       B C+ 

+ ## + ##   +# #    #

 #     #

   #  

 # *  

  #  + 1   +#  #       /5&42&544/& 8# *  

+ #

 #1 #





+#  ) +#    

   #      #       #

 

 )  +### + : #   &8#  ## #  1 #    # # 7     #   +# < #

    +  #         #   #

 & /5& I#  # %"  ' 

B C  1 # #   1  #

1# ,     /4&//&5443 B    1C +## +  

 # 1&

//&//&5443     1 +   # 1&  +   1 # 7<7   /5&//&5443&8# # +  

#  ## % :( ;

         

      

   ) "  !      



                  

  &                 



  ) " 

     

                    

  !     

  *  +

   - <        

 

   1  "   /2&    2#/66A+ 1

 #

 

1#  #

1

 +     #           # 



1 #    #   

 & 8#

 + #  1#

1 # 1&8# 1# +  # 8# D

 /5&4;&54/31 

 # 1#.  5/&;&54/3& 1 # + #

1# & 

 # #

 +

 #  #

+   # & 8#

 

  +   )   

   #  

    1    

   #

1#   # #   

# 

#

  &8# 1 # 

 & /;&

#  #

 

 2/&42&54//+    +  #     



                

 +##  -

  ,   /3, #

 #

#  # &8# + #   1    # 1 

    43&4;&54/3 

 # 

+  /5&4;&54/3&8#   # # + 1     # 

 #1   5/&4;&54/3 +   

 # #   ##  

 /5&4;&54/3& +  

+#+ #

   )  +##  + &8#  +  1#     

         B C +#  1  #  +     # *  

  +# +  

1# + #

 + 

 # 

 & ++#+# # #

  

 

   

 

  +#  #   

#   +  

    &     

'

)# + 1&I# #



 2 B/CB C#/66A #  +

 #  +# # + & /=& 8#     )/ "!'0   -   B C#  1## #    

# # +##   <   1 24  1

 # & 8#    # #       #

& 8# 

1 # #    # 

  1+##

 & /A& 

 &

, 1 ( (

  *   I## ) !   % J I##   % J