High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/29368/2019dismissed

Jarnail Singh @ Jaila v. State Of Haryana

2019-12-18Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh8 pages

+,-./0, + 2+3 -+4 56

+ %+78/96+-./:6;: +/55,&5+ %+-3+6+-./::+4

#$%&'($%)* /;. < 36 / 55,: 8. 6;=/6/+./=54.5: 9/3.:/55,/6<;+3,,4,,96 >

,:9//=+6?3+6,,64+,+.3= @3,4:/55,6563/ ++$*#,'($%)* 4/5:/5+8//=56 35/=<4/,+6+,3+/3,6+33++,4:/+/;. <=565+6.+ :66 !> !!A:/6< +.+6./=:6/+/3<@3 A(:66 !

>:/6<+.+6./=)</36+/5+;

& & - >/ -: >$ +,35/5+; -A #/+ 3+/+/5+4+ ,+,35+6++6// 3+:-.

/0!

.0(!1) ""#$ 7 ( > 5+3,/+6+/9//5+/: ,,49;6+/==53/<,36+ - '"> 6 '"# / 6 6 36+. +.+3 =5+=+#4+)9/,=5635/=$:53+3

>A: 66 '!

: /;. < +.+6 , - -=5,:+ /8 -3<@3,4: (!: 66 !A!'

: 9 +.+6 ./=/=5,:,,../+/== 53/<,36+-'!#:' ':'"'6A> / :+ /==9//,/9;666 36+.+.+3=5+=:+>4++/+:9/,+ =5+==56+/==/+=./ =56+/9+,9++6+6+33++,4 /3+:)/$:+.//5+9 +65+,4/969;6,5+,4:9/, <+;.//5+;3;/6<<+3.// /3+/9+4./=/6:/+/6< +/3+6+9//+/=5653+3 /9+,/3,6<+6+6+33++,4+3;,4

&'& .<;:9/++=5,4+6+6//4 9++33++,4 =,+/++6++6// 3+:/

/0!

.0(!1:) A$ 7

'"A 7+63,+/5+,+,35?36.= ;//=<4./3+:2 /3 4 53 !6 7 .0( !4 !:) !

A$" )+,$

A:9////5+/6<+66;6 (+=,+/==;+3:,,9 B$

6+-'#"+C9'A: ! 3+- + 4+'=/ <$

6+-A(>+C9'A: ! 3+- + 4+ $

6+-A(#+C9'A: ! 3+ -+ 4+"=/ 6$

6+-A( +C9'A: ! 3+ -+ 4+ $

6+-A# +C9'A: ! 3+ -+ 4+ $

6+-A !+C9'A: ! 3+ -+ 4+D /;//=<4./3+:+. 9/6-A #/+ :+<+;6,,9 B"

5,+6.-A #=8,+/ +6+,4 3<@3 =5+= == / E5+/=5+=:<.,=5+=:9//

&A& 5+/<5+;3,463,/3+6+<;3/ 3<&) $-A #+59+35/3++6+ 3+++3.3<@39//5+;3 =5+=++=6/59+<.6++43+:/ <E+65+36,455+5+-:9//59+E: <=5+53<,634/3+55,4=6/ @3E+/59+94+//+D ;3,,4:+,4.35?36.=/-35+=3+ /3 !544 .44 408!(544 7!0.0 "

0/2/:

- A':/+7+6/5++66//;.

<<4/-35+=3+//5+<+/=9 666<446;:+9+64,.,6<4/+,3+ 6//<,.65+=,4:9//==<+/=,4 65635/=:9//+/;.<6+6<4 /+,3+:/9,6/ <6++459+ ++636+3<&) $-A #/+ :%+-3+6+-./:,+6:+4:/ +,6359?36.=:/-35+=3+ /6 !0. 0(!1) !

>$( )+,$"A:6/ 3,,// 3+

.0(7592:) !!

$ )+,$' '

/?36.=/-35+=3+:/,9+ //5+/+/6+<+66;6+5 53/<,36+-

/ -:53+3

#> 66 !> ""

/;. < +.+6 . /= / ?3+6,5,+/9:9//=3<@3,4

&>& /;.<,+6+/==/=: 53/<,36+-

/ -:53+3 '>66

> !

"">/;.<+.+6./=/?3+6,5, +-+ / : / 9 6 36+. +.+3 =5+= !4+:66 !,/;.< =5635/=/+, +./5+;/+ :-A # /+ :/+7+6/5+++6-'

/ -: >:

</9//++5+636/+<,9 /0(!

7!80/5!0)*:# ;<$: 0080 ((0/0! !0/1 40080/ (! 0!((080+ ) $F/ 5+ ,+64 36+.. =5+=63<@3;=5+=+ =5+=+,:3/=5+=+=5+=+,/,, ==/E5+/=5+=9////< 5+;3,46:3,/3+6+//3<@3 /,,+33++,49/3/5+;3 +;66/9/+ 5+9//<6=5+&=<4+6+36+ 63,3+/.3+4:9/,36+..3/ :6=5+=+==65++/ =8.3/+6+:/,+/,,====6,4 ) $F/ 5+ ,+64 36+.. =5+= + , 6 3<@3 ; =5+=++=+=5+=+,:/3<@3 /,,+3&3++,49/3/5+;3D EEE EEE EEE

&(& -78)*'& B#) 80/=5 0(!((0804(0!=!0.

54 8.

8 )"45+9//<;6/== : + =5 ==: + <= : + +=, 5+4 ==:4/53/<,36+/3<@3,4 ;6/==:+=5==:+<=:+ +=,5+4==:53/<,36+/9/ /==353/=/,,<53/6+/66;+4 3<@39/+.

+3=5+=++=9//=4 E6&/,/=E=3=+==5+=6,< ,<,9///,,E6&/,/=E=3==3 ) $F/+/5++++63<&) $,<, <53/69/==3=+==5+=6==3= =3:/==3=53/=+3/5+/,,<&/, /==3=+==5+=6&/,/==3= =3 +;66//3+=4:++<++66 /?36.=:=5E6./+9//5+,<, )'$F/+45+;6<4=53+ +=, ?3+6 36 6 36+ 4 ++56.

/ >:/+9+=+63<// /,.,3++56;36+/ -:9 ;+4,+:/653/=<=5635 ; /++:93+/+<+;6//55,,<+ /+7+6/59,,96/<-A #/+ :

&#& 93,63,,4=3+63/9//9<;3,4 //,.,3+9/,+5+.-' / > @3,4: , . / / 9+ 5+6<+/-35+=3+:9/,6//55,,<+ /3+9,6/<-A #/+ :9/ /55,/++6=6 /<.:/6,9//</,6<4/ 3,, //3+)/,<+,635<4/,+6- 3,$6<.<4/3+:5,,4/<+ / 3,,/5+6==6<4/55,&5+ 9+,,53/<,36+/5+;/6 ,6:

/3./;/:+.-A #/+ :/9/,6 <,6/</<G6G/+ /5+:6=6,4:<// +.+6. /5+++/==953/<,36+ - >/ -: >:9//6 +.+6<3 !H 4+5+ :/+<.34/== 9///+:<,/,+63,+/5+ /9//6 93,,4@3+3,/+

/;.<+.+6:+//6<+.+63546,3+ =6/+ :69//-35+=3+/;.;+4,+,4

366I/+G)35+$:/-A #/+ 93,655,4/<;/-' / - : >: .+36 ,,9 / 5: 9// @3,46=6 "

;.+.