High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16741/2016dismissed

Baljeet Singh v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2016-08-19Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

"#$ %$&'(')*+ ",-$$#.')/0 $#'#')$1 (!

2$1(3( .#"#$ "14")"")%")#0$1 $(5)%$)# (!

* 67 . 8 7. 1$($)#*9 1.3:$(08')%",;%<&"#$; 1#0$5$#'#')$1 0$#0$1#0$$51#$1( ,&",)$=(5"5$1>"4?$",,=$%# ($$#0$-3%/>$)#@

?$1$ $11$%##0$$51#$11)# A 0$#0$1#0$-3%/>$)#(03,%?$1$51#$%')#0$%'/$(#@ 99 99 7.

0$5$#'#')$11$#'1$%"(.&'",$, "1$

'&$1;8"1)",;) A 01$$('$( ;A")%;%"#$% A B;

0"<$?$$)1$/'(#$1$%"#,'&$.#"#') '<',7')$(;8"1)",;3)%$1.$&#')( ;;+;; 9 ;"/"')(##0$5$#'#')$1")%(>$#0$1')9 $,'/'?,$?$)$ '&'"1'$( 0$&0",,")( ') #0$("'% #01$$&"($( 0"<$?$$) 51$($)#$%?$ 1$#0$&)&$1)$%,$"1)$%3%'&'", "/'(#1"#$(# ,"((")%') )$ #0$&"($(;&0"1/$(0"<$?$$) 1">$% 0$%$5"1#>$)#0"(",( &0"1/$(0$$#$%#0$5$#'#')$13)%$13,$ ?! #0$3)-"? '<',.$1<'&$( 3,$(; 2,3>$9 1$"% ='#0 3,$ #0$ "14")" '<', .$1<'&$(

3)'(0>$)#")%55$",!3,$(;+) B0$')C3'14

'&$1 0"(?$$)"55')#$%"(#0$%$5"1#>$)#",')C3'140"(?$$)(#"1#$% 0$5,$" #0$,$"1)$%&3)($, 1#0$5$#'#')$1'(#0"##0$ ",,$/"#')(')#0$&1'>')",&"($("(=$,,"(')#0$%$5"1#>$)#",51&$$%')/( "1$(">$0$(">$='#)$(($("1$#?$$D">')$%0$1$ 1$;#0$&"($

#0$5$#'#')$1=',,?$51$-3%'&$%;'

#0$%$5"1#>$)#",51&$$%')/(&)#')3$ 0$,$"1)$%&3)($, 1#0$5$#'#')$10"(1$,'$%35)#0$

"3#01'#4 #0$)6?,$.351$>$ 31# )%'"')

; ! 7A ;=0$1$')&$1#"') 51')&'5,$(=$1$&3,,$%3# 1>#0$&"($,"=;=0'&0"1$1$51%3&$%"(3)%$1 ")%=0'&00"(",(?$$)1$'#$1"#$%?4#0$)6?,$.351$>$ 31# )%'"')

;

"(=$,,"(?4#0'( 31#') ! ; !.

A*9 0$ &)&,3(')( =0'&0 "1$ %$%3&'?,$ 1> <"1'3( %$&'(')( #0'( 31#1$ $11$%#"?<$"1$*

$5"1#>$)#", 51&$$%')/(")%51&$$%')/(')" &1'>')",&"($&")51&$$%('>3,#")$3(,4"(#0$1$'() ?"1 ') #0$'1 ?$')/ &)%3&#$% ('>3,#")$3(,4; #03/0 ($5"1"#$,4

''!

#0$%$5"1#>$)#",51&$$%')/(")%#0$&1'>')", &"($"1$?"($%)'%$)#'&",")%('>',"1($# "&#(")% #0$&0"1/$')#0$&1'>')",&"($"/"')(##0$%$,')C3$)# $>5,4$$ '( " /1"<$ )"#31$ =0'&0 ')<,<$( &>5,'&"#$% C3$(#')( ,"= ")% "&#; '# =3,% ?$ %$('1"?,$#(#"4#0$%$5"1#>$)#",51&$$%')/(#',,#0$ &)&,3(') #0$&1'>')",&"($

'''!

0$#0$1#0$)"#31$ "&0"1/$')"&1'>')",&"($ '(/1"<$")%=0$#0$1&>5,'&"#$%C3$(#')( "&#")% ,"="1$')<,<$% ') #0"# &"($;=',, %$5$)% 35) #0$ )"#31$

$)&$;#0$)"#31$ #0$&"($,"3)&0$%"/"')(# #0$ $>5,4$$ ) #0$ ?"('( $<'%$)&$ ")% >"#$1'", &,,$&#$%"/"')(#0'>%31')/')<$(#'/"#')1"(1$ ,$&#$% ')#0$&0"1/$(0$$#

'<!

0$ "&#1( >$)#')$% ') ''! ")% '''! "?<$ &"))# ?$ &)('%$1$% ') '(,"#') # (#"4 #0$ $5"1#>$)#",51&$$%')/(?3#%3$1$/"1%0"(#?$/'<$) ##0$ "&##0"##0$%$5"1#>$)#",51&$$%')/(&"))#?$ 3)%3,4%$,"4$%

#0$&1'>')",&"($%$()#51&$$%1'#(

9A9 %'(5(", '( ?$')/ 3)%3,4 %$,"4$%; #0$ %$5"1#>$)#", 51&$$%')/(;$<$)'

#0$4=$1$(#"4$%)"&&3)# #0$ 5$)%$)&4 #0$ &1'>')", &"($; &") ?$ 1$(3>$% ")% 51&$$%$%='#0("(#&)&,3%$#0$>"#")$"1,4%"#$; (#0"#'

#0$$>5,4$$'( 3)%)#/3',#40'(0)31 >"4 ?$ <')%'&"#$% ")% ') &"($ 0$ '( 3)% /3',#4;

"%>')'(#1"#')>"4/$#1'% 0'>"##0$$"1,'$(#F #$1/')/#013/0#0$("'%"3#01'#'$(;"> #0$<'$=#0"# #0$1$ '( ) ?"1 ) ('>3,#")$3( %$5"1#>$)#", 51&$$%')/( ")% #0$ 51&$$%')/(')#0$&1'>')",&"($#%$5$)%()#0$ "&#( $"&0&"($ $1$;#0$",,$/"#')("1$ &0$"#')/ 135$$(($<$)&11$(?4 /1")#')/ 5$)(')##0$')$,'/'?,$5$)(')$1(")%%35')/#0$ <$1)>$)# "> #0$<'$=#0"#3(3",,4#0$#1'",')(3&0

$)&$(;=0$1$"

,"1/$)3>?$1 "&&3($%"1$')<,<$%;#":$("<$14,)/#'>$0$);#0$1$'( "55$","/"')(##0$("'%-3%/>$)#?4",,1")4 #0$"&&3($%1.#"#$")%

31#0$11$<'(')?$ 1$#0'( 31#0"#=3,%>$")#0"#'

#0$%$5"1#>$)#", 51&$$%')/("1$(#"4$%#0"#=',,)$<$1($$#0$,'/0# #0$%"4 ) #0$ /'<$) &'1&3>(#")&$(;#0'( 31#%$()# ')%")4/13)%#(#"4#0$%$5"1#>$)#", 51&$$%')/("/"')(##0$5$#'#')$1 #0$5$#'#')$10"(")4?-$&#');0$ &")",="4(1"'($#0$(">$%31')/#0$')C3'14 0$51$($)#=1'#5$#'#')'(%'(>'(($%

7. !

+ (-:( 0$#0$1(5$":')/1$"()$% * $( 0$#0$1$51#"?,$ *