Krishan Lal Batra v. Punjab State Power Corp Ltd & ORS

   

       

!"# $#%&'&()

* +,&'-!(.!/!",!

#"&"&(#, '

0#,'1'

1(2!34"!"#5#, ,6,!"&(.&7&"#$!($"-#,' #'6($#(" '

)  8.  4 + .4  ,#'#(")9 ,(&'-!",!:$;%!"#: ,"-#6#"&"&(#, ,+-1//!,:$;%!"#: ,,#'6($#("'  -#"-#,"-##6,"#,' /%!/(#5'6!6#,7!<3#!//5#$" '##"-#21$=7#(">
 3#,# #,,#$""-##6,"#,,(" ? -#"-#,"-#21$=7#("'-1/$3#,#6,"#$&("-#$&=#'"> 99 99 + .4 

.

-#6#"&"&(#,:5-5!'5,@&(=!'!#;#(1#%%1("!("&( "-#,#'6($#("9$#6!,"7#(":,#"&,#$ ,7'#,;&%#(?A
 "#,-&'

,#"&,#7#(" ,7'#,;&%#:-#-!' &/#$"-#6,#'#("5,&"6#"&"&( ,B1!'-&(= "-#&761=(#$,$#,$!"#$

 ((#C1,#99* :;&$#5-&%--&'6/#!" !//5  -&7  "  #C#,%&'#  ,#;&'#$  6"&(  5&"-  #

#%"  ,7  
*:  5!'

$#%/&(#$("-#=,1($"-!""-#6"&((%##C#,%&'#$'-!//3# &(!/-# 6#"&"&(#, 1,"-#,'##@'!5,&" 7!($!71'"-!"-#'-1/$3#=&;#(,&=-""

1,(&'-,#;&'#$6"&(5&"-#

#%" ,7A
*:&('"#!$ 
*1($#, "-#'#%($6,;&' #=1/!"&(D
:

$!"#$D
:,#!$5&"-

&%#,$#,*$!"#$

*
 -#'-,"%(",;#,'<&(;/;#$&("-#6,#'#("5,&"6#"&"&(&' "-!"!&(!(%#
5!'&''1#$(D
:5-#,#3<

9
9 5-&/#&76/#7#("&(="-#,#;&'#$6!<'%!/#':"-##C&'"&(=#76/<##'5#,# !'@#$"#C#,%&'#6"&(1($#,#=1/!"&(D &,%1/!, D
:$!"#$D
!'"5-#"-#,"-#<5!(""$,!56!<&("-# ,#;&'#$6!<'",1%"1,#!66/&%!3/#""-#6'""5-&%--#&'!66&("#$-# 6#"&"&(#,!%%,$&(=/<#C#,%&'#$"-#6"&(&("-#<#!,
&"'#/ :'"!"&(= "-!"-#6"' ,,#;&'#$6!<'%!/#'5&"-#

#%" ,7
*5:"-# 6#"&"&(#,'##@'",#;&'#"-#6"&(5&"-#

#%" ,7A
*:%/!&7&(= "-!"1($#,"-#'#%($6,;&'"#=1/!"&(D &,%1/!, D
:$!"#$D
:-#%!(#C#,%&'#"-#6"&( ,7"-#$!"# -&'

6,7"&(("-&'%!'#:"-#6,7"&(,$#,' ((#C1,#99 5#,#&''1#$ ( 

*
:  5-#,#3<  -#  5!'  =&;#(  &,'"  "&7#  31($  6,7"&(  ( %76/#"&( !($'#%($"&7#31($6,7"&(!/'%!/#5!'=&;#(( %76/#"&( *<#!,' '#,;&%# -#!,$-!'"!@#("-#'"!($"-!""-#6"&((%##C#,%&'#$&'

&(!/!'6#,#=1/!"&(*

:$!"#$ D
!($%!(("3#,#;&'#$!""-&''"!=# -!;#-#!,$"-#/#!,(#$%1('#/ ,"-#6#"&"&(#,:"-#/#!,(#$ %1('#/ ,,#'6($#("'!($-!;#!/'%!,# 1//<=(#"-,1=-"-# &/# -##=1/!"&(D
:$!"#$ D
:&',#6,$1%#$!'1($#,)9 ED
  

       4!;#!'

"-#,5&'#6,;&$#$&("-#'##=1/!"&(': !!,$#76/<## '-!//$,!56!<&("-#,#;&'#$6!<'",1%"1,#!66/&%!3/#""-# 6'""5-&%--#&'!66&("#$F ,;&$#$"-!"!!,$#76/<##7!<6""%("&(1#" $,!56!<&("-##C&'"&(='%!/#:1("&/"-#$!"#(5-&%--##!,(' -&'(#C",!(<'13'#B1#("&(%,#7#("&("-##C&'"&(='%!/#, 1("&/-#;!%!"#'-&'6'",%#!'#'"$,!56!<&("-!"'%!/#F

9?9 ,;&$#$ 1,"-#,"-!"&(%!'#'5-#,#!!,$#76/<## -!'3##(6/!%#$&(-&=-#,6!<'%!/#3#"5##(
*!($"-# $!"#    ("& &%!"&(    "-#'#  #=1/!"&('  (  !%%1("  

6,7"&(:16=,!$!"&( 6!<'%!/#1($#,"-#''1,#$ !,##, ,=,#''&(  4%-#7#:  &7#  1($  ,7"&(!/ #;&'#$ ,7"&(!/4%!/#':,"-#,5&'#:"-#!,$#76/<##'7!< #/#%""'5&"%-;#,""-#,#;&'#$6!<'",1%"1,# ,7"-#$!"#

'1%-6,7"&(:16=,!$!"&(#"%G -#  6#"&"&(#,  '##@'  "-#  3#(# &"    '#%($  6,;&'  

#=1/!"&(D
:$!"#$D
-# 6#,1'!/ "-#'!&$6,;&''-5'"-!""-##76/<##':5--!;#3##(6/!%#$ &(-&=-#,6!<'%!/#3#"5##(
*!($"-#$!"# ("& &%!"&( "-#'# #=1/!"&('7!<#/#%""'5&"%-;#,""-#,#;&'#$6!<'",1%"1,# ,7"-# $!"# '1%-6,7"&(:16=,!$!"&(#"%-#6/#! "-#6#"&"&(#,&'"-!"

'&(%#-#-!'3##(6/!%#$&(-&=-#,6!<'%!/#(%76/#"&( *<#!,'

'#,;&%#:;&$#,$#,$!"#$

*
 ((#C1,#99 :"-#,# ,#: (5-# '-1/$3#!//5#$"#C#,%&'# ,#'-6"&( !7 "-#;&#5"-!""-#,#!$&(= "-# &,%1/!, D
:$!"#$D
'-5'"-!"&"6#,"!&('""-#,$#,6!''#$ 3#"5##(
*!($"-#$!"# ("& &%!"&( ($#,"-# &,'"6,;&'" #=1/!"&(D
:$!"#$D
:"-# #76/<##-!'"-#6"&("%("&(1#"$,!56!<&("-##C&'"&(='%!/#:1("&/ "-#$!"#(5-&%--##!,('-&'(#C",!(<'13'#B1#("&(%,#7#("&("-# #C&'"&(='%!/#,1("&/-#;!%!"#'-&'6'",%#!'#'"$,!56!<&("-!"'%!/# -#  6"&(  #C#,%&'#$  3<  "-#  6#"&"&(#,  5!'  1(%($&"&(!/   #  (#;#, #C#,%&'#$%($&"&(!/6"&("-!"&(%!'#-#&'6/!%#$(-&=-#,6!<'%!/#( !%%1(" 3#&(=6/!%#$&("-#-&=-#,6!<'%!/#!

"#,%76/#"&( !($* <#!,' '#,;&%#:-#'-!//-!;#,&=-""#C#,%&'# ,#'-6"&('6#,

99 #=1/!"&(*  
:$!"#$D
:"-# 6"&((%##C#,%&'#$'-!//3# &(!/!($%!(("3#,#;&'#$4&(%#"-#,#5!'

(6"&(",#;&'#"-#6"&(:"-#,# ,#:"-#6#"&"&(#,%!(("3#!//5#$" #C#,%&'# ,#'-6"&(&(;&#5 ,$#,$!"#$

*
 ((#C1,#99  -#6,#'#("6#"&"&(&'!%%,$&(=/<$&'7&''#$

+ .4   


* '2@' -#"-#,'6#!@&(= ,#!'(#$ ) #' -#"-#,#6,"!3/# )