Shri Ashish Goel v. Union Of India And Others



1 


 





 



 !
"#
!$%&%"'(
)*) 





































































  




  

    (


 +,
-)
-
.
-

   


 


 

  
!

"
##$

 

  
 % 

&

 '

(# ))))) .

-/

)

'
  
 

* 
 
" 


++,-++.

( 



"


$

 

 / 
 

 
/

0

&"

(#
*1

#

/1#

2"#

 
 
 
%.

+3%+
 5" 
6%
67
 
*1


("/ 
!"


   (//
 '

(#

5 
 74-+3%%
5  7,-+3%%

5 
 7.-+3%% +
'  
$
##
!



-
( (
 "

"

8/ 
 #
 


(#


/1
 

9

   

//  

! 

 
:/  
   

7

,
 
 * 6
/1

/  


$
 

 1



2   

" 
37
   



9


1 
+33.



# /  
$ 
/


  
 

/
:$  
#

/
/

   
*  

# 



9


 1
#
" "

; 
2"#
*"


9

/
  


$
$
; 
##

 #

9





  
8 

   
  < 
 1

* 
 " 


 1
 


$ 

$ / 


##

=
 6
>4?
 
+7 %3 +33@
 #  
" 



>+3 >3,

%+36&



( 
* 1
 (
 
 


7@
! 

(# + %
'
   
 
 
   
$  #

 


# / 
" 
("/ 





* #
"/* 
+7
+,

+.

+33@
* 
8

("/ 
!"

  
(//

'  1
(#
=
* 1
A! 

(//B

 
 
 
* 

8
! 

(// 
! 

(//


//
 
 +3 3.

+3%3
$
 #
 
56

 "

  
$ 

"/


+4 %33-6
+3 3> 333-6

 +, 333-6

 
* #
"/* 
+7
+,

+.
 

:$
"


1/  /  
/"
$     
 
5 
 
* #
"/* 
74
7,

7.

1 
+3%%
$ 
$ 
  
*1

8
! 

(//


 
 
 
%.

+3%+

 
$
  
" #



3 // 


 

$
1 

5
/ 

 



  + +

 
 
+.

3@ +3%+
8
0(


 
 



/ 
  


=

>4?

 
$
  
+@ 3% +3+3
/
/ *
"9    

'
("

//  
 #
#  


 
 %> 3.

+3+7  
$



  
" #
/ // 


 
3+
1 

3,
/ 





433-6 8
("

 
"*/ 
8
("/ 
!"

="/
 

//
 


 
*"

$ #

 

5 
 

8
("/ 
!"

="/
 

 


 

 


 
$ "

;#
   
 #
$ 
#
"



//






 


 
"




* 
 

/

 //
$
"

C /
! *

 5C
/ #
D
/
/"

*
"


  $


/
  E
$ 

 

( "
3+



+3


( 


:
"  
"*/  

 
* 


*1

8
'
("


 




 
 
%> 3.

+3+7

"/"

 
$ 

/

*"

%3
1 

   

8
("/ 
!"

="/


8
'
("

  

  
"

" 

$ 

" 
 9"  
"
 #



* 
* 
*

/

3>
1 
:
"
1

  $ 
 
/1
*



"
" 



4 >  1
"

 
"*  
 #

 '





#

/ * 1


  
 
:


 


 / 1


 
* 
8
  ("/ 
!"


  
(//
 $
!



* 1
A 
(//B




  
$ 
 



8
! 

(//
 

1
$ 

 1
 / 1



 

# 1
  *  
:
"*/  

 

 
* #
"/* 
43

+3+%
* 
8
  (//

/
$
/ 

 
 
3@ +3++

$ 
 
:
"  
"*/  
$
* #


 

*"

/

3.
1 

$
 


 


/ 
  
*1

8
'
("

 
 
+.

3@ +3%+


$


 
$


 

9"#/ 
 * 


 

 
   
" 

("/ 







6

" 


 6 
=



* #

$



 


$
"

1

 
*1

 # #
#  1


=
     





 #
2"
 



* #
:

 
"

9"#/  
 
*1

:B*
" /
("  



A"0112
-344!0
'2
5&)
6&
52
44)
%& 5%$
728!/
!!57
'2
'5)B

%@??
(
@>

A%$%49
.445$:4
;&
6!0%$4!
$ "59+
 

8
(

+>++?6+>++@

+3%+ : 
8
("


  

 " 



, '

$
"#
 
   
 


$#
 6



5 D

/ 

3% 3.

+3+>

 
! 
 '
2"  


/ * 1


    

; 
  E
.



"

5  

$ 
 # 
" 


++,
 
$ 


++.

$ 
:#
(" 

$ 


*
5   
$ 
#  

 "/




* 
 / 
*1
:C*
" /
(" 

 

"



F 

1
 / 1

 

  
*1


/ 

   #  
:#
(" 
 


 
*1
5  

9"


" 


++,
 

1
$ 

 


  


 / 1 .

  
*
 
"
 
 
*1
:B*
" /
("



   

  


#

 "

* $(
.

F


#

  


    
8 


   
# 
 
 
*1

:#
"

5  

 
5 1
9"


" 


++,


( 

 $
  *1
/;




 


(//

 *

* #
2"   
" 

$ 9"




:#
("



 1
 


/




+.
%  

("

'   $


  

"#





"


$


*
 
5  

9"


*1
:#
(" 
 
$
 
#
"


 


(//



6 ?

  
*
 
"


9"#/ 
 
*1
:B*
" /
(" 



 
           !  " # $

(
 
 777@

+3+7






9"#/ 

 "


* $
6
D

GGG
GGG

GGG
..

'
"



$
"  

 1



 
*" 
$ 
 
9"






 

 #"


5  


6 5  


#
"/ 



 



#




  

$
//


*1
 /

5  

$ 


 /
" 



'

 
"



$ 

("

9"





# 

 
1
2"  
$ 
"



$  
 
 




  $


*"

"
  
*1


("

'
("

%   &  '

 (   ( )  (* (+, "   #  -./0-

 112
*  

D+,
"


$ 


   




++,

* " 1
  

* 
:#
(" 
"

 /

#  
$ 

"* *" 

* 

 


$

1
$ "

9"










 


  

 " 9"


 "

5  

9"



 / 
 



 





 

"




/


5 

 "



/ 
9"

:$ 
5  
9"

/1
*

 /

"





$

#

* 
:#
("
 
 

 

5/

 


 




7  
/"# 

 
$


 
 $
*
; 


 

*
/ E
.?


 $


 
 "
$

   

"

/"# 
 
 
*1

:#
("


" * $


/
   
*

 GGG
GGG

GGG

E
@ 
 $


*  
/
* 




  



  


  



  / 1




$ $ 
 

/  %3  #
/   
  *
$

*
 " 


5 


/  









































































.

-































































 

)*) 

































H



F  
 ;#
-
  


I -
F  
  *















I -