High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11528/2018dismissed

Surinder Kumar And Others v. Sh B L Sharma And Another

2018-05-09Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh3 pages

!" # !

$"%& '($)#*+ # !

,- ./-0$$ .1&

& &-& ,1 ,1$0$+,$ .$ 1

&3 . &

& '( $4$/-+.%$+"13 & 5

6 $7 1 3 & $ 89 4 $& 69 :3 % &-%&7 1.-%$ 3$0 +1$ .4$1.0 &$

1) &9 ;-$&1 4 " 1 . .$.

< . 81%1 1 $ .0 &$=- $+1$ .4$1 %11$&.&0&&.1% 03 3 $4 4 8"- =$%1 $ . .&=. % " 1 . .$.

#> <3$&&.=)1&$.=- $ #>#?##>@*? # <

A B &-1$1801$ - ."4$

=8 13 &$ .1$ .4$1.0 &$ +&3%$)81 4$. 1%$0" 3$)5&%$ $& 8 $& 1= "& " &%& ..=)10$&9:3 % &-%&="1.&4 $

$&$ .$.-$$%1&

ACB 1% 4& ;-& +18+$&-"$ ="..$.# #> <3$&&.=)1=- $81%1$.&$&- .'5

10$ % "$ .%- &+$1& &$4+&1$$1-411$33%$ &&.$4$ % .$.

#@ <6

:-5<7+" .&&$"1 4$ %+=- .%& 1$&)= $9 =)1 %03 $-1)

$ 41$.$ .%- &"13$&+1$ 4 1-411%.+811$-$=$ .81-

:3&& 4$ )3 10&+&0$)3E-.% 1%$&"1&.+1 &$ &.&3&."+81 $ .% 1 ,%$)+ .-%$ + 1$ .4$1 &3 .

7.%.1 .%$.4$ %+=) 3$&& 4$&3$9 4.+$ . $%%.$ %81$8+ 81 $3."80 1&"01.$"%3"

%".%3)"1&.

A@B 3-3.%03$ %"1$=5&$..+&3 .

3$&&.$ ..$.#

<+13$3$81"$.&$& "8&'5

"4 41-411% &"4$ % .$.

@ <+." G=.$. > <+ %00 .$ "%00$ .$ 3& &"

1$ .4$1 .-%$ ,% 6,%1 $.7

%-0 -&+ ** $&$0 .."000+ - .&4 .&"1% &..81$1& 3& 1$ .4$1 .-%$ ,% 6,%1 $.76-357 %-0 -&+ ** $&$0 ..

"000309:3 % &-% .%)13&" 9:3 % &-%& &3$$%$.$ .100=&"1&$.%$.$= 30.13&"($&?(&&&&$ .

30 +1".%$.&$&31

%-0 -& ". . 5 5,

@7 * ?,3 $.#>

** $ .$&$0 .."00 0 %%. 4)+1;-&"1$33%$ &3$%

1& )&"($&?(&&&"30 1 3&" &1=)% &..$ .E%.

AB 13 &".% 4&$4 41$1 .% &&&-.=)1=- $ # #> <1$ = %03.

81 -$ .&3 1 03 + 1&&+1$&=

.&0&&.=& 41$1=- $8$&&$&".811.3$&&.=)

1$ .4$1.0 &$ 4$. 4%03$ %"&.+1 %+- &$ .&.&%1$4.81=)13 &$&14$ % ="$ $333$"-0

A>B , $44.+ 1 3 & 1$ ". 1 &$ 8 3

A<B 1$ 1$. $ . %- & " 1 3 & $ $ % &.$= 41$ .4 1-411%.

A!B , %1 ).% &&-.=)1=- $8$&.%. 14$ % $%%.$ %81$8$ .=)8$)"$$& ..+ .&$33$1$1&$..% &.%03.81...$.

< -1$18$&&0.$) 3$&& 41&$..=- 1$ .& 0$ 8"-=$%1.&=. %"1- .% & &-%1$&-$ +1=- $&41 .&3& 4"1 % 4&81=)13 &%1$ 41. .$.#

<81=)1%$01$&= - ..8 =)8$)"$ $& .. . " .$ ) 1:%&"&E-&.%

=)1=- $+%$"$ ) " %=)1&- .&&&$) 1$"13 &$$44.=)1&3$9 4.+1$333$ 0.) " 10 8-. = $) %1$ 4 1 &$. . .$.

<=)8$)"$333$3%. 4& A*B 1=)$"0 .+183 &$ .&.&3&.

($)#*+ # !