Supreme Infrastructure India Limited And ANR v. Punjab State Ware Corporation Limited And ORS




   
 
     !"#$!

%& '(








)#*+ ,-./01$!

%


 

 
 
 














     




  

 











  








 
 

 




   
 
 


 
 
 

 
 


 



! "
#
 


 


 


"











 

+ ,

 
 







!


"



#$
 


"
 
%&


#
' 


"
 
%(

$
)

#


"
 
%


*****
34
 1

  2
 
%&

(


 
+"  
+ 
, 
 ,


 
 
, 
- 
%
&
(




  

 
)
, 
. ),/
  
0 #
  

#


  

-

#
)


 #

(
1

 




&234(3&5
 


"

2


6
 

""

" 
 #







"

"

"

 
 
1

 



7 
 

&834(3&5

#
 
%


7 






 


+ 


 



. /


 

%&




1
 
#
"




"
 

#

&234(3&5


- 
%(90


 
 #
"
 


 
 #
 



"
  
- 
%(
 7 
"


&&3(3&
"

 
"

6
 
 



"
  
1
 

 

3832(3&

%&



"

"

2

'
)


6
 
 

2
- 
%(


,
"

., /
((3:(3&
"

%&





"
 

2

'
) 
6
 
 
 9.

/
"

"

 

;9

 

       

 

    







 

 !"    #   $ 

 

     

    

 

 %&'    

       $

$  %%  %(  % %) * !



 + ,   ,"  ,

-      



   

 

 

       '          



     

  

" 

, 

$  +$"  

$

/  



0   !" 

  

    

 1

    

  + $   2   

           "  

3      "   - 

     





$
 -    5

%&
"








"
-
&<3





"
-
&:43


"
 


 

&438(3&


 


=
3<3&(3&2

 



. /


 

%&
 
%&
> 

 
"

" 

 



 

3

"


"
 
"



#
353((3&5

<
?#



(434(3&2




 
%(

%&
9


;9

4

   /

     

 

3      

  "

 #           

  



   .



     

       

         

5    

      

 5-   

 

3      

    1

  

   4     

   "

 

  

0  3  

6$  $   7- 06   6 *    "

 

5

 "  

  7-  0 6    6  *     

   



" 5 

  0   3 



 

6   

3   

     08 0   8           "

   5

 

    .



 "         3     " 

    

 08

  .

      9

   4 "  

    

 

%

3  5   

   "  

 3 

 

$ 6$  



   

1 

 :
:
?#

"




(<&((3&2




 
%(

%&
"


 


&&&&(3&2

7  
%(

"

 


%(



 #
" 
 
6
.

6/
"
 

 
+
 95
"



%&



%(

 

39#


 
"
(3

"





 

%&

 





 
  


 
"



4
?#



&&((3&2





%&

%(
 

"
@
"
7 
 A

 
"
 




"

 

&53(3&5




 #
" 6


%(
1

 

 
"

 
 

 





 

 

8

 
 

 
 


"
"


 B




&&((3&2
"


 

(<&((3&2

 
"







" 



 



  




C

"


 

$


""






 

 

&3
1
 



" 
1


"


 95
"



(<&((3&2








#




"

 
"
 

 
1 

&



#


#
 


9 
"




 
%(




 
 
"


(<&((3&2

 $

""
1


"








(<&((3&2

 



#




#








"
  
 
"



"
 




#


 


"


"
 

&&
?#



3&3&(3&5

%&



 



$
#

%(

"
7  
%(

" 
%&
"

 





 

  #
 





%(

 


"

  #
 





%(


 


@
 
-
(533333D9
#
#
"
 

#

 


"








 
"

%(

 

#

 

#
1





#






 



"
 

&(






 


"" 








 
"

 
1
 #



A 
"





  
1

"

 



  #
" 

%&

 

 





 









 

%&
  



A 
"
# 
"
 

#

7 #

 
"

%(

 







"

 
1 

#
 


 


"" #





 
#
 

"
"
 
"
 

#




'
"
"



&
+


"





 




@


3&3&(3&5


"





1




 #


 

 
"


"
 

+


 
1








3&3&(3&5


 

"



&2
+








"
 
&234(3&5


"  
1
"" #


@


#


 



 

&5
1





"" #
"


> 

, 


#
"













 

"


3
#


"

 
 


"






#

%(



"
(3



"



#
"


"
A






%(



 
"
3
#
1
 


 


, 
1


 
""
 



"


"
A







 
 

"


"
3
#

&<
+







  
1
  

 




3:&((3&5




.

6 E+F -/





)1+%'
)C+0F
> 1+)0











.10+%0-
+%'C
C+%

/





>'0
<
% 
(3&5
G @