Haryana Karnataka Roadways v. Ishwar Garg

 
           

  






 



!
"
# $"%

!
"&
'( $$&")

!
*+  % $ %   !  "  #"  #% % ,
-% !
.(/0
 )%
"!
,
1%%
"+!0
 )%0 
!%
$$&") #" $

 #% %
$$&")"


!
/%%
2"&%
' %
%)"


4
56
# 0 
+
2
&%1%

$$%&
+" 
-'

2
)7'"&

89 $ %
/
!%
:'

")"&
,+" %

& 0
! "+!0
!%%/ % $ %
!
/%%
)7'"% 2
!%
)!+%
' %
%)"


4
2
!% %+ "/&%
 '(%
)0
44
52 
!

0
;44
);6 

)
&% "+

!%
$% %
) %
%
!

)) '
2
" !

'

2
)!%7'%
/%"+
 88

<0
( '"+


<00=0


>+!
?/

$%"1%
>
. 0
>  !0
" ")
"( '
5"()!&
# % !60
% $ %

%

 ))' %
"

) ($&"
/%"+
 89

@0
"&%

  

    



2"&%
' %
%)"


4
2
44
) 


%
 1%
!"
) %0
) ($&"
%%%
"
!%
"%

  / A

B

% %%
!"
22"

1"
A B
& +
"!

)'(% A 

A 
!%%2%0
%(%
2
% $ %))' %

%)

' %
%)"



# 0
!%%"0
!%
%"%
!%
&&%+"


/%"+ ") %)0
$&%
" )%)%

2& %
"($&")"


% $ %

)&&%

'$ 

&%
!"
%1"

%)%

"
!"
%2%)%0
!%
%A("% !"1(
*+0 )) '
>)!0
+ !(
#& 
#1
. 
&
(/0
" ")
"( ' 5#6

B

)&
!"
%1"

%)%
< 
$$%)""


2
%1"

%)%

2%
!%"+
+'(% 1)%
/
&%%
) ' %&
2 
/ !
!%
$"% 0
!%
"&

'
)7'"%

!%
% $ %
1"

%
"
-'

89
!%
$% %
$$&")"


+
2
&%1%

$$%&
+" 
2 % "

-'

+(%
!
/%%
2"&%
/ " "+
1"

'
+ ' 8 .%%
) ' %&
2 
!%
$$&")
'/("
!
!%
"&

'
! 2"&%

)  "

%
!%
%1"

%)%
$ $%&0

"
!"
) %A(""

0
!% ) ($&"
 ("%
!
!"
/ !%
&


2%
!%
)) '
C
!%
!""+

2
$% 

!%
"
%A$%
"
)) '"+0
!' 0

 1% %
"2%%)%
!

'&

!1%
/%%
%
"
!"
%+ 
%
2'!%
'/("
!
!%
$$&")
"
 ' ")
$% 

+ 
"
!%
$
2
!%
% $ %0
!




& 
2 ( !"(

+1%
!%
)!%7'%
2
!"
2"(

!' 0
!%
"&

'
!
 +& )7'"%
!%
% $ % @ 1"+
!%
!%
+'(%
 1)%
/
&%%
) ' %&
2 
!% $$&")
/% "

%
!1"+
+ %
! '+!
!%
-'

+(%
$ %
/
!%
"&

'
 !%

)'(%
1"&/&%

!%
2"&%0

(
'/&%

2"
 '/ )%
"
!%
'/(" "


( %

/%!&2
2
!%
$$&")  
$%
!%
1% "


2
$$&")) ($&"0
!%
% $ % ) )%
!"(
2 
$ 1"

"+
1%!")&%
2 
!"
$

')
"
!"
2) 

" %

 !%
"1 ")%

)% "
/ "
 
!"
%7'% 0
!%
$$&")
%&"1%%
!%  $ 
1%!")&%

)% "
/ " 0
/'
"
!"
) %A(""

0
!%
%$

!
!%
%1%
$ 1"


2)"&""%
2

"

))' %
 
"
!"

$% &
)$)"

!"
%"%
%&"+
2
$ 1"

"+
 $ 

"!
!% ) ($
'
/
))' %
 
%
&
 ("%
!
!%

%
 
!1%
 $% &
 &% +%
/ '
!%

)'(% = %(%
A 0
!"
/ !%
)

&
%&&
!

'+!0
) ($&"D
/ !%#%(
.&
&
%$$%
"
"% / A

B0
/'
!%
"

 

!"+
/ '
!%
$% %
) ($&"


%1%
2"&%
 1%
!"
1% "


, % 1%0
!%%


%1"

%)%

%)


!

0
!

$ % %
!%
 &% +%
/ '
!%
)!%7'%
"
7'% "




!

)'&&

!%
"%) 
2
!%
"

) ($ 4


1"%
2
!%
2 %(%"

% / %1"

 0

 
2"
 "&&%+&"

$%1% "
"
!%
-'

2
)7'"&
$ %
/
!%
"&

'

%&'()*('

+ ,-./0*& ) "/,/* &*1&* *-/*2 /0* '3(56 &.

*6'/.& + ,-./0*&70
%$ %

95<6

5 "("&6
@40
!%  D/&%
'$%(%

'
!
&"


!%
2 && "+
+'"

%&"%
2 
!% $$%&&%
) '
!"&%
%&"+
"!
) %
!%%
"&
) '
)7'"%
!% ))' % 









 
 

 !






"

"
# 




$
%  
 





 


"
#
"
 

"
 



 



 
 


&


"


$
 
"



#  
"'









" 
  



#


 





 
 "!
(

 







 
  
#
"

 
# 
" 









  
 !
#

"  )





!


!
 

"


) 

$
%
#


!
  
 

 
#

 *
&#
"
 






"
 


  


% '



 


+  ,





 

#
#

 -


#
%
 


  !
 #
" 
#


 




 
 



# 
"

 .




/  







 


$
"


 






 " 


/#






/   






 
# 



   




/  
#




 

"

!
  


 "

9


!%
&"+!
2
2 % "

+'"

%&"% 0

!1%
%A("%
!%
-'

+(%

2
!%
"&

'

!%
% "+
+"1%
/
"
2 
!%
)7'"&
2
!% % $ %

!%
2)

)")'( )%
2
!%
$% %
) %
/ % 
!% %1"

%)%
1"&/&%

%) 0
!%
"&

'0
2%
$ $%&
$$%)""+
!% %1"

%)%0
!
"+!&
) (%

!%
) )&' "


!
!%
) ($&"
!
2"&%

 1%
!%
) %
+" 
!%
% $ %
/%
&&
% /&%

'/ 
!% 1"%
%
/
!%
"&

'
"
 
"


'% /&%0
$%1% %
"($ "/&%0
!%0
"
!%
2)

)")'( )%
2
!%
) %

!% %1"

%)%
&%
/
/ !
!%
$"% 0

%)
1"%
"
$ "/&%

$&' "/&% !%
"&

'
!
"+!&
!%&
!
)!%7'%
"
7'% "



 
" '%
/ !%
))' % % $ %
"
" )!+%
2

&%+&&
%2 )%/&%
%/ 


1"%
2
!%
" )' "


( %
!%%"
/ 1%0
!%%
/%"+


"&&%+&"

$%1% "
"
!%
% "+
%)
/
!%
"&

'0

  2"

+ '

+
&%1%

$$%&
+" 
"
-'

+(%

89
%)%0
!%
$% %
$$&")"


"
" (" %  8#" 9

"

 !%!%
$%"+=% %  E% =

!%!%
%$ /&% E% =