High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21054/2013disposed of

General Manager & ORS v. Presiding Officer & ORS

2016-05-24Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik3 pages

!"# #$%&%'(

) !"# #$%&%'(

) *##'#+!,!'!-#+!'.!'"*#+ *##'#+!,!'!-#+!'.!'"*#+ *##'#+!,!'!-#+!'.!'"*#+ *##'#+!,!'!-#+!'.!'"*#+ #"%"%'#+ #"%"%'#+ #"%"%'#+ #"%"%'#+ /#+&0& /#+&0& /#+&0& /#+&0& *#+#&%.%'-

%$#+!'.!'"*#+ *#+#&%.%'-

%$#+!'.!'"*#+ #&1'.#'"& #&1'.#'"& #&1'.#'"& #&1'.#'"& ( ( ( ( 2 3 4

2 3 4

+#&#'"( +##+!5 !.!67

70'5!8 +!.!9:!'";%6#.%7 .6$!"# ++#&1'.#'" <<< !5!'"*+%7 +!, !5!'"*+%7 +!, !5!'"*+%7 +!, !5!'"*+%7 +!, '"*#%'&"!'";+%"1#"%"%'7"*#1#"%"%'#+*!&=0#&"%'#. "*#+.#+.!"#. >

''#?0+#@ 1!&&#.8A+#&1'.#'"

@+#&%.%'-

%$#+7'.0&"+%!,+%80'!,7 !"*%'.!7;*#+#%'$,!%9 "*# +#&1'.#'" *!& 8##' !,,;#. ;*%,# .%+#$"%'- "*# 1#"%"%'#+"+#@%'&"!"#+#&1'.#'"@;+:9!';%"*$'"%'0%"A &#+6%$#!'. B8!$:;!-#& +9"*#.!"# .#9!'.'"%$#.!"#.

+%# !$"& "*#$!&#!+#"*!"+#&1'.#'";!& !11%'"#.!&%$:#"/#+% %#+'.!%,A;!-#8!&%&' D>!'.

*#+&#+6%$#&;#+#"#+9%'!"#.' D D> *#+#&1'.#'"@ ;+:9!'.%.'"+!%&#!'A.%&10"#+#-!+.%'-*#+"#+9%'!"%' + C A#!+&+"*# %+&""%9#7+# #+#'$#;!&9!.#%'"*#A#!+

" "#$*'%$!, #+++7 .!"# "#+9%'!"%' ;!& ;+'-,A &*;'7 "*#+# +#7+# #+#'$#;!&;%"*.+!;'!'. +#&*+# #+#'$#;!&9!.# ' > >

3#!+'#.$0'&#, +"*#1#"%"%'#+&089%""#."*!""*# 3!80+ 0+" &*0,. *!6# +#5#$"#. $,!%9 +#&1'.#'" @ ;+:9!''"*#-+0'. .#,!A CA#!+&'&011+" "*#&!%.

$'"#'"%'7,#!+'#.$0'&#, +"*#1#"%"%'#+$%"#.!.#$%&%' "*%& 0+"%' )

7.#$%.#.' )

'6%#; "*#!86#.#$%&%' "*%&0+"73!80+0+"!;!+.%&,%!8,#"8# +#5#$"#.!'.1+#&#'"1#"%"%'%&"8#!,,;#. #+$'"+!7,#!+'#.$0'&#, +"*#+#&1'.#'"@ ;+:9!' &089%""#."*!".#,!A%'$,!%9%'-*!&8##'.#!,"8A"*# 3!80+0+"%'1!+! "*#!;!+.!'."*#3!80+0+"*!& $9#""*#$'$,0&%'"*!""*#+#&1'.#'"%&#'"%",#." 8!$:;!-#& +9"*#.!"# .#9!'.'"%$#"%,,"*#.!"# *#+ 5%'%'-%'"&#+6%$#0'&#, 0+"*#+&089%""#."*!".#,!A*!&8##'

"!:#''"# 8A"*#3!80+0+"!'."*#+#%&'%'

%+9%"A%'"*# !;!+. 3!80+ 0+" .!"#. >

#'$#7 "*# 1+#&#'"

1#"%"%'%&,%!8,#"8#+#5#$"#. #!+.,#!+'#.$0'&#, +"*#1!+"%#& *#+#&1'.#'"@;+:9!'7;**!&&#+6#.!&! %$:#" /#+% %#+ ' .!%,A ;!-# 8!&%& .0+%'- "*# 1#+%. +9

D>"D D D> "*!"";%"*$#+"!%'8+#!:&*#+#!

"#+ +#&1'.#'"@;+:9!' !%,#."+!%&#.%&10"#!""*##!+,%#&"

1%'" "%9#%'"*#A#!+ D> @ D> +;%"*%'!+#!&'!8,#1#+%.

%#%'"*#A#!+ D>)@ D>C,!%9 "*#;+:9!'%&*%-*,A8#,!"#.

!'."*#+#%&,!$*#&'"*#1!+" "*#;+:9!''"*#&#%&&0#&7

"*#3!80+0+"*!&$99%""#.#+++%''"$'&%.#+%'-"*#.#,!A !'.,!$*#& ' 6%#; "*#&# !$"& !'. $%+$09&"!'$#&7 "*#+# %& !

.#,!A!'.,!$*#&'"*#1!+" +#&1'.#'"@;+:9!'.0+%'- "*#1#+%. +9 D> "

#'$#7"*#3!80+0+"!;!+.%& &#"@!&%.# #"%"%'&"!'.&!,,;#.%'!86#"#+9& !A 7 ) !A 7 ) !A 7 ) !A 7 )

:!'$*!'