Bachu Singh v. Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal & Labour Court Chandigarh & ANR
! "# $ %"
& '& #
&
%
&( ) # & * +& ,# * -,#& #&
"&
. /
& & .0 "
!" ( 12 & " / &
& 10"
* 3 "4/( 12 &
& 3 3& ( 12 & & / 5
&
! "# $ %" "
* "
* & # & 1&
*
" # ) (
0 % 6# "
%
7/#% 18&
1 9#& ( /
,4 " ) # & * +& ,# * -,#& #&( :
+&& &4( " %&"
"& & &&&
;" +& ,# * ,*8; 8"&,4 " && 8
8& %
" / &8&07 !& *4( " / &8&07 &
# & *
/# ,4
&2 % 7
1 9#& $#, 6# *4( "
/# 8
&&& " +& ,# * ,*8 &
<#
/& "
* / ( / & < "
&2
& / 5
+& ) 2
)
-
"& & &&&
;& / %7 ; "
&7 == "
* 7 "2 8&0
## *4
#/
8" "
&2
8& **%*4 &7 2&,**4 ,4 & / %7 )
" /*
/ &8&07 " " " % "
2 /* & 7&& % "
&* #%"& 8"
"
8
9 &
= >
/& / &( " " //* & *2 &7 >
* 7
7 2 7 4 &7 & / %7
+" / &8&07
* 7 " & / %7 2&,**4
" *2 * "
"
7 2 ** * , % 2 +" / &8&07
/
**4
" " 8
** "
7/ 4 7 4 7
& /47 2 ( "82&( 2 7 4 8
% 2 "
,4 & / %7 ** * "
8&0
& %*4( " / &
"2 * " %&"
>
& 7&& % "
#%"&( " / &8&07
* 7 "2 &#& " %&"
<
"
#
( "82&( " & " " %&"
>
"&&( " 8 <
"
# ( "82&( " 8
// &4 %
+" / &8&07
* 7 "
"
& #7 ( " %2 "
<
% &/&
( "82&( & / %7 &#
/ "
7
+" / & 8&07
"
<
% *& "&#%"
&%
& / 1
/& " / &8&07 ( & / %7
**8 % "
<
#4(
&2
"8
#
/
( 8"
"
8
&/* ,4 / & 8&07
( & / %7
24 " / &8&07 " "
&2
& 7& &6# &
& %*4( " / &8&07
* 7 " " 2&,* && /
,4 & / %7 & &7 % "
&2
**%*( &, &&4( # <# %
" /&
/*
#&* <#
*
* " /&2
) # & *
/#
( =
"& & &&&
;= ;
+" / &8&07
* 7 " "&
* $
>?(
>@
> = (
& %*4( /&4& 8
7 & & % & / %7 &
" / &8&07 "
# 4
&2
( #** , 8%
"&
6# * ,
+" &
* " / &8&07 8
,4 & / %7 8"&
8
" " / & 8&07 < & / %7 "
&7
==
==
"
&2
8& 2& &7 &"& " "
* , " <, ,4 , % # #"& A
## *4 &7 >
8&
) 8
*
" " / &8&07 # &7
, # #"& A #& % "
&2
/&
2& & % A & / %7
&#
8&0
/* 7 &
) 8
"
& / %7 " " / & 8&07 2& &/& & / %7 2 7 /"
**
+" / &8&07 8
#
"8
#
2 "
,&& " 8&0& # 8& ,* % 2 " 8"&,#
" / &8&07
&/& % & #4 <# 4 % "
# ( " / &8&07
**4
& " * %
" 2& 8
# "
& / %7 8 %
" ,
,4
#
% " 9
% *,#& *8
& #*& & 7 2
& %*4( /&4& 8
7 & &< % "
* /
> " ,
" /* % " /& ( "
#
8& &7 " /&
* " & & / 2 2
)
#//&
( " / &8&07 "
*
//
,9
1 * 97 "
8&0& //# $ %"
1
$"7,# $ %"
1
" "& " ( & / %7 97 @#&, & * $ %"( @ &* %&
1&
& % "
& / 2 /&
* " 7& *2 2 *,* & &( " +& ,# * ,*8 8& " && %
" / &8&07 ) "
& #7 ( " / &8&07 "
* "
8& / ,& "
#&
= -&
# * & " / &( 8"
* & & % "
7
" 8& / ( &%# " "
7/#% 8&
1 9#&
**%*( # <# &, &&4
& %*4( "
7
* ,* ,
)
#,7 " " *2 " / &8&07 8
&**4 ,4 & / %7 " 8
/&7 7&& %
&7 4 "
>
#%"& "
"
#& ,4 & / %7 " "
*2 8#* ,
+" / &8&07 "
#,7 //*
& *2( "82&(
#, 6# *4 & / %7 " 4 //*
& *2 8
% 2 ,4 " / & 8&07
-&
# * & " / &8&07
"
, 7
&2
,
, 7
&2
" " / &8&07 8#* "2
7 , <
#4
)
#,7 "
" / &8&07 " &/& & #4 " & / %7
#* "2
#
" / &8&07 <
#4
( " / &8&07 " < " #4 " ,
#* "2 , "
# ( & 8"
"
6# &4 8
&6# & ,
#
& %*4(
" "&
, 7
&2
" /& " / &8&07 &* &7
&2
" / & 7#
&& "7
-&
# * & " / &
" " / &8&07 " 8&0 "
& / %7 & " * 4&
"
&2
"2 , &7 "#
7/*4 % "
" /&2
$
>?
=
)
#&"&
" " +& ,# * ,*8 "
*
& //&
" 2 &%& % 7&& % #%"& / &8&07 8& %*4 /& #7
,
, 7
&2
" && "
, 8& %*4 8& %
" / &8&07 *4 " ,
" " / &8&07
#* /&# " & *
0
"
<#& 4 &7 " % &"
"
2 /*
& %*4(
#,7
" & ,
# & / %7 &
" / &8&07 (
# 4
&2
( #** , 8%
"&
6# * ,
" "& " ( *&
# * & & / %7 "
// " /&4& " / &8&07 ,4
#,7 % " "&
**%* 4 & /&2&
4
"
7/#% 8& "
7 "
, & & ,4 " +& ,# * ,*8 &
& % "
& / 2 /&
* " ,
7& *2 2 *,* & &
-&
# * & & / %7
#,7
" 2 ,& " +& ,# * ,*8( & / %7 " & " / &8&07 <
, #4 "# " , 8% ( "82&( " / &8&07 "
*&*4 &# <
, " #4 "# , 8%
)
" " / &8&07 " 2& 4
8&0 "
& / %7
)
#,7 " " /&
&& "7 &7
&2
)
#&"&
#,7 "
"
& #7 (
"
, "* " 8" " 8&07
7 % &8&
/ " <,
7/
%
" "
* &
7 "
, 8%
7#
, 7
) "
&%&( *&
# * & & / %7 "
&&& <#%7 & & ,4 !7,4 %"
#&
)
#&"&
#,7 ,4 *&
# * & & / %7 " " / &8&07 " * /&2 & & " & *84
0
*"#%"
/
8
0 ,4 "
" " " ,0 "
0
& "
*2 8
&**4
( "82&( " 7
*
&
&4
7
"
2 8" "
" " ,0
0( &"& " /#& " "
0 "
# &
)
9
#,7 " " / &8&07 "
* * /&2 " "& 8
4 /& #&/&
"
& / %7 &**4
" *2
)
#,7 " " +& ,# * ,*8 "
&#& /#& %
8"
"
& * ,* ,
&& "
,4 "
#&
9&
& &&
<#&
& %*4( /&4& &
* " 8& / "
, 7
) "2 "& *&
# * & & / 2 /&
"2 /&# " //&,0 "
" & ,*
+" +& ,# * ,*8 "
&#& " **8 % %
!
"# $%&'"'
"# ( % &'"'
"# $% &'"' "# ( %&'"'
"# $%&'"' "# ( &'"')
%
* +
,
"# $%&'"' "# ( %&'"'
-
!
-.& -.#
+
-.&
* +
"/
,
=
0
-.#
*
+
,
0
1+ 23"2%23#2 2342
+
"'
6
-
4
6
"7 ( %&'"'
6 "7 ( %&'"'
6
"8 ( % &'"'
1+ 2-."9-2
1+ 2.&2
#1+
2.&2
*
6
!
6
/
"# $% &'"'
"# ( %&'"'
! 1
! :0;
"# $%&'"'
+
<
/ 7 1+ -.*"9-
=
!
* +
*
! ""
+ 6
"&
1+ 2-."9-2
6!
+
< 6
=- $."
1+ 2$."9-2
6
-
5 !
% !
> 3 "/%''' )
!
6
!
! 6
+
?
>
6$
@%!
$."
3 "/%'''9*
! >5
+
$."
"&
A
!@
6
+
-.&>
* + <
0 2
!@
!@
($
!@
0
(%&'"/=-
-.&>
!@
0
+
!@
+
* + 1
A
6
?
%
-
>
"#
%
-
?
= /&# * " %
&#& ,4 " +& ,# * ,*8 8#* 7 " "
%
& , 7& *2 2 *,* & &
1//& *4( " / &8&07 "
* /&2 " " " //* & *2 & " "
*2 8
&**4
& " "& 8
4 /& #&/&
& / %7
" *2 &**4
+" / &8&07 "
#&"& * /&2 4 & *84
0 2
% "
<#& 4 &7 " %&"
"
2 /*
) "
*
7 & & " " / &8&07 8
% 2 & ,4 & / %7 <
, #4 "# , 8% ( 8"
"
8
&# ,4 " / &8&07
+" /& /"&
& &&
<#&
%"
#&
#"& 2*4 *
B C 3 % -3"7D
! D44( 8"&
B,* " $#/&7 #& "*
# &
4 A
6
, !
- &&7
A
!
-
6
E
6
% +
%
+
6
-
+
6
%
!
%
%
A
%
%
6
%
%
6
6
!
+
-
!
!
A
-
% %
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
A
A
+ 6
%
!
6
, !
- &&7
+
8 %
%
A
.
F
.
!
*
%
% %
% +
%
%
+
, !
%
!
F
% %
! %
%
A
.
%
=
>
& % " * 4
& #7
" * %" *%* /
,2( ) 4 7&
"
8& /
7
& %*4
1//*
/ %(
4(
"**
*
<0
""&
/0 %&
C
5
""& &/&,* C
5