Sohan Lal Arora v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

 

 !"#"$"

%""" "$"





&'()*+,)-./.*0 1  &213*4'05'672*2' 111)(.(.*0)2 8)2/9/ 3('()*+90:';'0,'0*(4)2 111<)/=*0,)0(/ 

">? @#A> B!

C">""

$"

% 2)/)0( 2190))(D.0,'6E3217,F*-'()G.(4 2172/40**23.0H4E7,F*-'()+*2(4)=)(.(.*0)21 217I'2=2))(3.0H4J'.0/E77KE90:';1 LLL ">""

$"

%M!BN OPQR 1 S4) =2)/)0( =)(.(.*0 4'/ ;))0 +.6), +*2 T9'/4.0H (4) /4*G -'9/) 0*(.-) ,'(), 11 E 700)U92)  '0, *2,)2/ ,'(), 1 VE 1 VE 1 '0, W1 1 E700)U92)/EEV'0,WE2)/=)-(.F)6X1 1 5)'20), 3)0.*2 -*90/)6 /9;I.(/ (4'( (4) =)(.(.*0)2 G4* G'/ G*2Y.0H '/ 3)0.*2 ),.-'6

++.-)2 G'/ .//9), ' -4'2H)/4))( *0 11

G.(4 (4) +*66*G.0H-4'2H)/ Z1[U-)//-6'.I*+'22)'2/ \*9

&21 3*4'0 5'6 72*2' 3)2F.-) ]*1  G4.6) =*/(), '/ ),.-'6

++.-)2 '( 
3'2,**6H'24 ,92.0H X)'2 *+ WWW X*9 G)2) 4*6,.0H && =*G)2 *+ 
3'2,**6H'24 '0, '/ && X*9 -6'.I), X*92 '22)'2/ +2*I 
3'2,**6H'24 (42*9H4 +*66*G.0H I)0(.*0),;.66/ 321 ]*1 J.66 09I;)2 '0,,'() )2.*, *+ -6'.I 7I*90( <)I'2Y/  V^7 11WW

1 1WW (* 1 V1WWV E EVW^ &2'G0 *+ +966 ='X *+ /9/=)0/.*0 =)2.*, ^7

1 1WW

11WW (*

1WW EVWE^
6'.I*++966='X  ^7

1 1WW 1 V1W (* 11WW E ^ 722)'2/ *+ '009'6 .0-2)I)0(/  ^7

1 1WW

1WW (* 11WW E ^ 722)'2/ *+ '009'6 .0-2)I)0(/ S S75 EE ^

 




 !"
#! !$% & &$! $'& ! &(

#'' )&* (

# &!!&$+ (!+ !+

$ $) !+ ,''% -+ . !+   /#! $&! !+ $'&  & !+  0$ $'& &&% -+# *# & $+& (!+ # *#)(!$'& #!!'&&% %1#$! 2$ -&0 3#+&!)&$ !&0!+&&$'& &#

&

%%44! % %44 .54." 60$ $'& &&"#,!$

,

% %44!% 5%44 . .54" 60$ $'& &&"#,!$

$ % 5%4! %%44 .

" 60$ $'& &&"#,!$



% %44! %%44 . " 60$ $'& &&"#,!$ %7&$! &!&'$ !

&$$#! +# /, & 8 9#&' $&! *#

1% 7+&

&' :& &))' ! !+

$
' 7# . &!&'&  % %44



&! &!&' $ !  '# +# /,"8 9#&' $&! &

! &$! !+

# &!&' $ ! (%% % 5%44%

$
' 7#  &!&'& &; *# ! #, ! *# # /,"8
! $&!  '!! %6"44" &!

% %444. %644"  &! 4% %444. %6"44 &! % %444. %6"444 &! % %444%

&! 

$
' 7#  && &' &;

 #,  !+ $! $&!  '!! %6 "

 &!

% 5%

6 !+ *#

&' ! #, ! !+ $# !% 2!  $'& !+&! *# +&

! &$! !+ $ ! ,* '& & $ !+ )&! ! (!+#! +& &* +# /,"8
! $&!% : # <%4 .  " +& !+# , $'&   0$ !!' ! (+$+  $&,'

 *#% 3# +& )#! #9# ,#  !+

 !0$+9#,* # )(% 2 !+ ' +! &, $+&  *# +& & *#'

'&,' ! )#+ ! # #' #/&,
' 7$

#+ ! & &))&'<#'.45 %= % -+ & & $+& +! $#' &!  &   &' (+$+. #) , $+&''  ,  !+
#! (& ! &  /# ! &! % 5%

. :0#  .> ?@ABCD>  & !$+$&'

# !+&! !+ $)* &))&' '!! 7
+& ! , #))' ! + & (!+ ',!* ! )& &

+ % E !+&! & ! &*.   +& , )&. $! )! )$ ( !&! (+ !+ 7$!&* (& # . (+& !  

% %

5. :0# . !+ )#+ !  &' (& &!&% -+ & & $& 

   

   !! "
 # 

$% &  '!

"!" ( (

$%  !) *

 "

" *

 '  && +! +& & &!

 '!

 ,*

)



( ( % +!  !)! !"  "&"  "'!&! & - .* (

 -  * ,
!'! /"'! .*&% 0( 11%
 " 11% +!

!"!

 "&   &! " -!& +! "& 2 #3 "

*)( 4!&   !&&*  - &+ *&

!

 (( % +"!

+  ! - )55) +& ' !

&  !! " +! +&

 " -  "!

 "

&

 ((

( 6 "  " &*)! +'"%  !) *

 "

"

 ( ( $%

7*"  )   !  && % "'  "+"-" &*& '!+ -  '

!&*&&! &%   !

!'  /+
*& 9! *

" "* (

 -  .*& " "' !

& :"( / ; 6""( 4!&

"& &  -"* * )

"  !)!

"+ - -!

! -!& - .&(# %  <  + - -*"

!!  ") & -" =

 " +! - 

 !'(  !) &* -!

"&& )!&*& - !&

"+!

!&*"&!

+"&( /

  

"+

)55 '"!*& >*&  )* !

 .&(#( ?

*"!

 "

( 1 "

"  !) & * - 3 "'!&! <" *"  &! -  &!

"( @*"" * !" && - .&(#( ?

.&(# %  < )  "'" -")  "!"

*& - &!

" "

 +!-!

!"*&(A ( ;"

 / !" * &

"+&  ! - 
*"   "

 #( (

%

7*" % "

"!

"'" -  )* -

!!  ") !(( .&(# %  <       +! "+   !! " +!% !

&"*! &%&*)!&&

&" "'" ( ( @*""  &*)!&&! '  !&  ! !& & +  +!* " !

"

%  )  

   !& ( B' "+!&% & " .* (  !!

  ! ' &   &*,  !)!! -  "& "!"  

 - !

 % +! )! % !& & !&

% &   ! - )55) & "&   "

 ( "&%  !) *

 "

" +"

 "!  ,*

) -

(
!- C* !!  !&"



   



!"#!

$



!

"# %

$

"

$

&"' " (    )

!

"

!%'$$ 



" '  "

! * $ "

!

+' & "$

* + $

  $



&"' " ( ,,)

$ (  --)

 & $ +  "



*"# "

!



!.'

$ #$ /'$& " # $

 %# + 

" $

'  0 1 2"

4"

& $ 5!

   

" 

  $$ "

 

 "%%" .' 



*""6

!

 !#$ $'

+"$ 7#

 !"+ " *%%  $



*"#

$ .'

# "

* +"$'!$ "

 $

% " + 8&

"

 &+%"8

$ $$'!

" & $ *8

'8 "

*

!

$ 7#

  " "! "$)"$ + $ *8


"'

* +"$'!$ "&

!

 *

!

$

"



*"#

$ + 8&

# * & $ 9'

  !"!%'$$

  " $ "

*"#

$ + 8&

$

  " /'

!

" " $  "



*"#

$ + 8& :



*"#

$ + 8&  $ "&



'8 

   "

" & ++"+

   2" 1 2"

4"



$

 "#&

*

$

 "! !"+ "

 *%%  %8 

1 2"

 %4" :

$

% "!

.' # '$ 2;"
.';"

 4&"' ('+   ,- , , 

,-)   

, )  ,  

-  )  -- , -



)  -  

-)  -  ,

 -- ) , -    

 

)  -  , 



) - - ,

, 

  )  - -,



  ,) :"

% &"'  ,,) << << <<    '



$

" '

 .'

8

!"$'!

$  $

 + 8&   

"



   " +" !'

"  ='!

 2 "

"  +"

   +" !'

"   * $

& %

$



& %  "%8 $"'* '%  $



*"#

$ + 8& " (  -) ;" .'8

!"$'!

$ 

 *8

& "

 !"!$ $+  &

" #8







*"#

$ &"'

*# %$%8$ *' $""

 << << <<  !  # " $ !' " & $

 *"#


"'

!"&

"

 !"!%' "

 +" !'

"

&  *%8 %$

" +"#  

 



!!' $ *8"$



$" " " *% $"'* :

'  *8 #

 * " $"'* 



!!' $ > / 2  >

$ 2"

4"

 "$$

" *

 

  !

"  #!  " # $ #!  %&'&&'&''(& ) *
+ , -  .!

!  

"  ./.!

  /. / #! # !- / #! + 0. / #! #    

"1  "2. #+3 + 4# $ #!.1 !2

! /!

!1 ! #/.  /  

!!/"!! #!#

#-5! /.!!#  2 #+ '+ * ! # ."#- .

#. 5!   "2.

-6 !  #

2#!

# # "2.

-1

! 8. !   /

 /- 2/. 

- # !2

  1 #  .8..  #!

"1 !.! # /

 ! 2#2.!1 !

"! 9# 7  /!!

 # #

#-   #

"!.

+ *# /!#

 1  !



! #



##  #..-+ ,  

"/::."#1 #  2!# !1 /!

#   2#!

"#



! /# 2!!1 /# #  2



 #.   1  !1 

7 ! #  #  #!# 2#!

"# .#   ##  / !!#+ ,   ;#1 "2 #  + + '!!!+ + < 7 !  !1   # ## # 



2#!

"#1 (##;    8 =!+% 1  & ! ##1  !" !  / .

9 2..- # 87

 !/"!! #

.# $# #!. !""#



 .  %+ +

1 (##;  #

8#    

    "2 #



! /# 2!! /- 

8#"#1 ! ! 1   . / # 8! #

22.1  !1 7

 ;2!!# #-

2# #

# "!1  " ! "   "2# 

-   !

#  #"

2#!

"#1  ## 2!

#. #   2 #+ %+ *#87

 / 81 2!#2 #!#!!2 !

+ > ?>@A@B>CD@EFD@GH>I> > JKLKMLNKNO> > PEFQR> !

9   !29# &!

# S!&<   2 /. S!&<