Karma Devi v. Punjab National Bank & ORS
!"
# $% $&''
#"
#
( )*+,-./ 01-++(.(0)1
! "
## #
$%$&%$$& !!!$%$$&'$!!%$$( # ## "
)*
+!'
+!, +!- #. % "# "
/ 0 1/ " 0 %!!!%$$- # #
02 2
). ).)2 ## . # 32 2 2 # ## %'!%%$$- 4 01/" 0" 5 #
6 7 #6 ## 7 !($,%$$& 6 7 2
* ).
) .
).
).
).
).)."
8 !). ) ."
# 8 %"
9 #
" 6 7 5
2 2/ 2 + 6 7
# 2 # * # %,$:%$$&9 #
# 6 7 5
5* # 6
2 #
#
2 4 # :)'. ";). 8 #1/7 <2 # 5)= # #.4 # !(::)
>4 # !(::?.
$%$&%$$&9 #
#
2
# 4 # !: 4 # !(:: $!$(%$$& #" ##
!!!$%$$&
6 # # "
"
4 # !& 4 # !(::
#2 2 #" #
!,!$%$$(
" 7'$!!%$$( "
" # "
' @
#
2 31/ %,$!!(&, # /0
1
"
/
2 *2
7 #0
$;$%%$$% "
/ " # 3 # !!$(%$$;"# 0## 5
'$!%%$$; "
/ " # 31 # #
"
2"##
2#6 %!!!%$$- ; 9 "# "
/ A
01/
# 7
# "
22
%'1
1/ " " 0##
#
- 3 1
2
1
"# $;$,%$$;)*
+;." " <*
=
01/ 8"=# 2
- 2
6 # " "
1 2
# -
"
# # - !$$;%$$- "
- %!$;%$$- /
- 2 # " ## 6
# " 1/
2 #/2 21 2 2
2 # A#
2 #
## #
"
## 2
* # 2"
/ # ### 2
" # " #/>=/1/ ? >=/9 ? $'$%%$$-> ? $;$%%$$-
/ # /
"
0 %!!!%$$-"
#
" # ' # - 4 # !(:: # >
## ?" 2 " # 8
#
6 #
##
2 # # ' # - 4 #
!(:: , "
# 8 "
2 # 2 2" $!!%%$$,$%$%%$$-
2 #
+2 # 01/
"
6
2 #
/
/ "
# !&!!!(&&%-$;%$$$
# # #
2 #
6 "2
2
2 # 2#
2 # 2 2 6 1/
9
## #
2 #
2 22 2#
#
2 " 6 6
# "2 # "
/ 2" " 9 01/
#
# # - "
2 " *2 #9
# # !: # - 4 # !(:: : "
## #
" "
#
# #
#
"
#" # *2#/
"
7 "
1//
"
"
*2 0*2
2 *2 *
#
# " & " # 2 5 ## #
#9
2 # "" "
/" " "
/ "
"
/"
2 "
/7
2 # ## "
# 2
"
2 # #
" "
# ( 9
2 !(&,
%$$-9 7
%$$- # # - ( !$$;%$$-" " %!$;%$$-
/
#
0#
#
#
2 %;$;%$$-
" 2 -31
# 2 " "
" "#
6 # -
/ # !$ # 2 #
#
#
"
5 # 6 7 5
# #
5
#
9
#
5
/
"
# 6 7 5
0
5 # "#2 #
#
29 ##
"
2 #" 6
2 "
# !&!!!(&&%-$;%$$$7 "
2 #"
# # # 2 A
# 2
B # # "
2 # # #< 5
2 !(&,
%$$-
"# 2#
2 *2 <6 # #""# 2
#
2 #
2
## !!
#
#
2#
5 #2 2 " 2 " -
2
7 # # -
0#
# #
#"
# 2 2
# 2 2 # 92 2
# # "
# 9
2
# 2 0 # '
# - 4 # !(:: 0
2 #
# !&!!!(&&%-$;%$$$
2 # 2
2 #
#
#
2 #
2 # 6 #
2 # #7
/ 18@"
2 5
2 #
2 " 01/ 2 0 #
2 # 2 !% 9
# 0
# !: # - 4 # !(::" 0 *2 # #
" 2 2 "
#
6 7 9
#
# !' 9
"
" #
"
"
1/
6 # 5
"
6 *2
#
#"# 2 5
%% 2 # 01/ 2
2 # #"
" *2 2 %$" *2
0*2
2 # #
"
"
2<
!
" "
#
#
!;
#
# 6 7 5
#
#
5
" 2
## "
1
#2 #9
#
# 6 7 5
*
!,
2 " " 2 # 92
6 7
6
2 "
# 2 2
2" " #6 6
"
2 2
"2
!- #
#
!: 9
, (2 # 2 2## 2# 2 * 6 "
= 2 ! ;/ # # , (
2 # 2 "
! ;# 2 #
, (# A #).+ 2 #
2 /
/5
# 2
+2 ) , (. A ## ## +2
22 - ( "
2 2# 2
! ;31/
# , (9
" 5 2 , (
6 8 -) 1
.
8 :)94B 2.
8 &)C .8 ( ) . " 0
# # 2 !& 9 5
6 - ( * %%2 # " 2
2 #
7 # #
- !$$;%$$-" "
%!$;%$!-
6 # -
"
2 #
2/
2
2##
#/
- ( "
-
" 6
222" # 6 2 2"2
# /
2
2 ##/#
2 /
# -
" "#
6 # " " " - (
/ 9
2 #
- #
2 # 1/
2 "
"/ "1/
#/
2 #= # #
- (" " ""
#
8 #
2
2
22
2
2 "
# ##
0 1 /
2 "
- ( 7
# # "
#
2 6 "
6 #
6 ###
#/#
!( 9
2 # 8
" 0 # ' # - 4 # !(::
"
##
22
#
# 2
2 / " #"
" 2
# 2 9
01/5
# " 2
2 ## "
9
# #
"# 2 # 8 # 0
# ' # - 4 # !(:: 2 #
##
2
"#$%%##& '#( )#*+' ,#-
!! .
./ '01-)#.& &#&23
*4+! .
5 4''&#)#6-'
! . # 2 "
# ##
22 #
2 # " ##
2
-78%3)#63#/9%$- )&7%&''&#
D
. ( %,E# 0
! "
! #
$
%
#&% &
$$ # '
& !
##& &$( $
%
(
$$ $ ! & !# )
! $ &
! & && $
$ $# & # #& $ $
$ &# ! # $ # && $# & !
*
& (
$ $ $% #
%
#$ &
'
( & + # &
,$ - <
6
6 #
## %$ 7 6
# " /
2 2#2 2
" 2
2 # $!!%%$$, $%$%%$$- # 9
2 #
01/
# "
# !&!!!(&& %-$;%$$$92
6 #
## # "
2 # # 6
9 " #
2 " 2 "
/" "
"6
#<
# 22A%3C A'3
2 #### 0
6 6 " "
2
2 #
2 2F
*2 # 26
" 0 2.
& * / ! $ ! &
% + ! ) 0
$ !
!$ &1 1 1 !2 2% !
&$%
4 % 335 $ #
$ #!
$# !!
!
2/ 2 $ $ $$ && $
%+ ! $ # $$ & ! ! $ !
'$ (
$ $ &
$
!
& && $
$ !
.
6 & *
!
$& )
& 1
%+7 !
!$ & 1 1 1 !2 2$
& $!
2/ %#
$ $ ##
# ! $! # $! && $
.
89 & *
! !!
& )
& ! && $ $: $ $
& ;7&& $%$ $: $ $ & $ & $< 2
!
#
& $
# $ $ *
#
#
! ! $ &+7$ #$
$& $ # $ &
$
.
&
*=
>) 0")
> < 2 + & $ $ % # 1 1 !# % $11 !
+ & !
?
$ $
1 1 1 !@(
"5#
$ $
$ &
.
"= & *= ! $ ) " 3"
"
3
"
#
$
3
"
) 9
2/ 1 %
3"
"
# #
1
A! 1 ! $ ! $ 3"
"
1
1 1 !# $ &1 A! 1 ! #$ !
2? ) 9 $$ $ $
# "
.
= & *=
) 5 ?B+$ $ 5:8C "C ""
"88C !
$ $ $
$ ! 593 $ #!
$ & & ! $% #
& & ! $ 0"% 0 % 0"C 0"C2 # $ #! & # $ ! < 2/ ' $$ !
! $
! % &
$ # $$ & D 7&& $% !
7&& $ && $ $
! $ ! $ #
$ $
# !
# && $ $ # @ ! * (
& 0"% 0 % 0"C 0"C2% $ !#!
! !
.
9= & *=
) "5$ &
>7 ! 1 E
#
2/ F% ! 1 E ' !
!
- 9
A0%)C .A0') . 2 *
2 # 2 2 %! 9
" *2
# 0 # !: # - 4 # !(::
31/
# " 2 2
2 #
0 # !& # - 4 # !(:: "
01/2 # 0 # !: # - 4 # !(::
#
6
* 0 # !:
# - 4 # !(:: %% 9
#
*2
0*2#/"
#
# " - / # *2)A, A-A&.9
"
# # *2
2
.6)#5&'%%&930 50'&#
!! ./$$ . #
2 *2
#
29
5
*2 A, A-A& ##
# #
9
A, A- A& " " 2 " #
# 2" 9
## *
%' 9
2 # #
*
01/ GHI #
2
" " 2 # #
2 " 2#
01/
#" "
"
"
2 2
6 # #
2 # 2#"
# # 2 1/
" ##
2 2##"
" %; 9 5
2 !(&, %$$-
2
22 2
2#*2
@
%$$%9
01/
"
#"
#
%, 9 5
#
#
# 6 7 5
2
#
# 01/5
# 2 #
0" 22 " 2 "
#
/
## "
#
22 #
###*
#/ ##
"
9
5
#
#
# A
!
# 2 " 2 9 #2
"
#
2
'&.2633)#& :3&9 %%##&
! .
".&0/% 4.)#5 4''&#
.
2
&,# 0 ;C
'##
& #
# )$ &
# $ ! % !
' $
! &&
# *
%
# # !
!
! ! &
&&&
- 9 #
2
0 #
J# # " / ""
#2
K#
22 # 6 2
# #" 2 #
# 6 0 #
2
2
+) <#= )# >#9 33&9 +2'
.
#
# #
# 4
"
# 2
2 #9
*2 #"
2/
2
1/33)#.& ?-
!! .
# "
# > #
#
"
? > #
# / " * #
# " "
#2
# 9 0
# # 2
#
#
# 9
01/ ## "
22 #
#
# #
#
#
## KF#
# " ##
2
# #
#
#
#
# ## 1 #
#
# " ##
2*
#
*
# "
9
# " "##
2 ##C < 44H
#7&-)#35 @&93&/3'&#
!
*33:+ # 0
?& $$ $
&$ & $ $$ $ & $ & ! & ! && ) ! ?& #$
!
!
& ! & % #
!
& # & <> &
! % ! & !
& &&$ $
) - 9 #
.&/'')#.&
##
*4+!
3 !
#
#
" ##
#
#
#
2 #"
#
#
2 "
>
2
2
## ?9
# "
#
2 2 # ## # " 9
##
" " ##
#
2 #
2
#
"
2
-8A#&&#)&7%&')#5 4' '&#
.
;!
;' ;,# 0
9"
? $ $ ;
#%$ & !
$
$ $ &
9=
& % + ( #0$
$ "8 =
33C
? # & % !
$$ ! (
*$
&
$ &
#
$ ; ! +
*$
% & % & ; !+ $$ ! ( ' $$
& !
$ & $ & #$ !
&
&
*% #% $ & $ % $ $& ! & #0 $
$& $ $$ $# # & # ! & $ $ !
- %- "
2
" ## "6 "## 0
5
#
6 7 5
$%$&%$$& !!!$%$$& '$!!%$$( # ## "
)*
+!'
+!,+!- #. %: # "
## "
#
2 # "
/
2 # # "
##
2 "
2#
##
#
2
#
#"
$%$&%$$&##
2"
2%$$&## 2## *
## 4 # #/
#
" #"
### #
#
"
# +
#
#
2" 9 *
##
2 #"
2
2
#"
# 3++%4% 5'6 / .78 A + / H A
# H