High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21094/2013allowed

Praneet v. State Of Punjab And Others

2017-03-24Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi14 pages

" # $ # %& '(

"$ ) $ *+, $+ $ ) *+

( -$# * .*+/ . # %&

0 , ( & (

1 2.. 2 2 4 , # 3#)(#2 &4,(# ) ((2 ) ,#)#.+

& )(&4 ( 5 & ( ,(( $ 67#+8 *( . 5 4

( , (( 6. .'2

,. . 2

) (( 7 :

( $ $ 6. )) *

+#.&. .##( . . 2 ) (( * ((. , +

6. .'2

+..2$#& 1 & + 9+, .# . . .. ( ) ,

# 2 +..2 )+& 2

# 4 *#((.) 4. .+ $ #& 1 , ( ( '#

. . 2 ) *)(. , )&4 -, $ 2 ,, ,

), + .

+, .

) & ..

9 . , & #2 .4 )

2 :

0 . !

,, &4$6. ))

(#4)) /# (# 2$

.. 2,#&% !

, ( 2 . + 0 , (#4))

/# (# &4( :!

,4 # & ..2

2#. + . ( 2+..2$#& 1 .4 2

$6. )) ) 2 2 (

, + , ) 9

0 ( #&) . (.4 & #2 #.( ) # 0 2!

<,# ( $6. )) # %& $ $'= 5*$ )) -. ,(( 5

, #&) $ 4 # %&

95,..2# 2# 4 + ,

.&4( # ( + 22 ( 08 ,,'#

) #., ((

( +..2 20) ,

# %&#&. $ +)) 1 2(( +., )% ( .4# '#.< +7) # %&+.$ +# ) *((.'#. '#. *))

2 ,)( (# ) )

,2 )) >,+ ,1 &4& )( (# ) ((2 ) , #)#.+

+ )(#2 *22 +2 ( . , (

"$ ) .

$ # . (( 2 &.

( )(#2 (# ) )(#( ( ((2 ) ,#)#.+

,..4# ,

+&5 2# (# ) & )( .4 +4

)(. 4 ,.#&) 2 , ?)(. '#. # %&+.$ +# ) *((.'#.

,. .4,, + )) #.

2 2 4(# ) &)( & (4 +&4)) , #+ & (.& ) ?( ..

) )(.45 2# ) ,(##(& # %&#&.$ +))

2 2 )( ( .4 ((2 ) , #)#.+

,+ )) 2 ,( (.

, ( ( ((# ) 7+ +#.#.&# + 4&) ##

## 5 2# 4 .

# # &.

# , + + # +. '#.9 # %&+.$ +# ) *((.'#. 5 )(. 42 + 2 ;. ) + . # 4 )4 ((.,, +. 0 ,1 &4(

, # 4. .# # %& $6. )) *

$ 9 * ( +( 4 2 < -$# .

* .*+/ .

# . ( ?$#&)( # &

#&4$6. )) <

,#.&

2 . . .. ;. ..&)

4 2..&) .4,( (( +. )) 5 #&)$6. ))

+ . !

& #2 /+

) ( ,. & 2 ( $ ))

2#. &4. 2;

2 #)& +

). . ..

,#( (( +.5 )) )) ) , , ( ) .

2# '#.9 # %&+.$ +# )

< *((.'#. 0( , +, 2 !

<>,+ (.4,2+ 2 *

4, # 5 4

#&) 0 4 , ( & )) ,

(.4,

&4)* (( # 4 ( . 2,2+

( &4)( # 40)( # 4) .# , ) ..2.4&#, 2.2 ,1 )(( .4 ((2 ) ,#)#.+

0) ,(. & # %&#&.$ +)) #

;+ , 2 ) ,

)) ? 0)) + ,(.) & # . , 2 , )) )( ( .4 ((2 ) ,#)#.+

: 5+ .

# . ( +. ( # ! 03# 3# & , ( , .4 )( ( .4

.# 4

@ , +. '#. 9 # %& +. $ + # ) *((.'#. 9 '#.9 # %&+.$ +# ) *((.'#. #

!" #

" $

%# "& "

$"()

$" #

' "

' ' '

* ''

* $"

'' %

! +

!"#$%&'&(

% ))%% ,- A

# $

(

)

$ *++,- .

% &

*/0

. #%

!*# +!, -. ##!/"

!0 '112 $2( 3* ))&% #

((0

"' ' $"1

" " /

" " " "

% 2

!"# !

$ % &% ' !"# .4 & .# ( ) . 4& # ,# ( + 4

( + ( ) &# 3#?%#.

,#47) + +

& . 3#

7) +

2, 2 ( + 0 . , %#2) 4 & # )

&4 .., 2 #. # .%#

) >2#

# * .: # 5 ) * '

'2 "

'2 (' & 3

# %'

' "

()

'#.

/ / - %#

!!4(!!)%"

5 6 7

8 !0(!!)+ #

) )(

0(!!)

5# /

# ' '2 '

' '2 ('

# '

(9! (!!)

# (0! (!!) *

$" * %

$" " #$"

$" +

+$"3

"# '"' '

$" % # 9

' "

" '

5 9 (

5 "

" '

' % '

" "

# : %

"(!!)

" 5 9 )

" '

( !!4(!!)# #"

5 &

( "

5 " '

" ' '" '

* '

!!4(!!) '

# #

+$"3

# #

# 4 :;< %

% '

'#.

# "

# '

: =

''#

" " ?#((.4 2 2, + # %&#&.)) ,#. & . #-

#&.$ +)) & 2 .4 )) 5 ., ., (

( ) *+% ,-*.-/*!! $ 0112#3454 & . , 4

. 3# )(.4 (. 4( 2 # ; &# . #.#(4 &

22 +)(.4 2+)(.4 (( # 4,, , ( %#&# ?#((.4 0 4( 2

#. .4&? # ; &# .

,#.+)

(# ) #.&?5 2 )

& )+.&.(

,#.+&

)(# ) ,&)(5,& , ( )( ( .4 ((2 ) 0 &4(. 2 . #( %#2) (

() *+% ,-*.-#( # ( ( %# & # ( &4 ?)(. '#. '#. : * , .4 )( 2( .4#( ( B*).4 (

, +,)) 2 2

2#. . . ..

0 ,( (. 2#. 4&4

< 4

#&) !

+ #..4&4)(#2

)% ( .4, )( ((2 ) , #)#.+

( 4+ 2& )(. !

9(# ) )& )( ( <4 0( ) )+.( ,1 #( .4 *( . , ) ,

# %& #&. $ + )) + 0 7(.

) 2,4) , .# &.)

) *). ) )#( & # * -* -

(

**/*!!%%*6& .0113 0# 277, $ 2.8 # .,,

,.4#&4(# 2# 4 # 2,#

+ 4 5,.C

! "

$ %"

%0.

$ 2. & . + . %#2) # ,+,7( 3# , # # 2 # .45 & .4

)( 2(# ) *& .) )2 $ 7( )

,,#. .4)

,., ,( )(#5 .4 # 2 # 1 , +((

# . 3#

5.,...( ,#.& . (( # )&4((.4 2 ., .) +1 2( (. .4 .0 &4((.4 2)( (. .4 )( 2(# )

.4 < 4 &41( 2 ).D , 2 2 .4 ,

, #(., 4+0)(#2 (# ) +&?

! 0 +, ,& # &+ # ( 4 #

)+ & +. '#.9 # %&+.$ +# ) *((. '#. # + ( # &4( 2 4 + 0 4 .

+ (# ) ,#.&# # &. 9 0, ( &4.., )(#2 +535804

(1 2;

E &.