← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24240/2012dismissed

Krishan Lal Gosain v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2024-02-01Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri7 pages



      

  

  

!"

"%&'&#( )) *+&', ( - .

#' &( ))))) "!&!&#("+ /"+'0'

1! !"

 +2 ( #!,"+'

))))) "'4#(3"(!'

 5 - ) 1 1 1  +"'"(! +) /&6 2 *07 + &(3 .8 39#% !"

''&'!"3

+) ) * +!&;"2 8 39#% !"8 4"!&!&#("+) +)  0+ 9 &(3 .8 33.) ))8  +2 ( ) +) )1)

6< 8 39#% !"8 #)) +) )*)  .&;8 39#% !"

''&'!"3

+) 1 (3""4

,0..8 39#% !"8 #)=) 1 1 

)

-    > = ..#<"3 4+ 2"3 $#+8 '0:6"%!

..

60'!

"?%"4!&#(')  &(  '"

) ,"

<+&!

$&."3 0(3"+ +!&%."

@A> #('!&!0!&#( (3& &''0 (%"

<+&!

( !0+"

%"+!&#+ +& #+ #!,"+ <+&!8 #+3"+ #+ 3&+"%!&#( '"!!&(B '&3"

'"."%!&#( 4+#%"''

44+#9 .

9&3"

%#770(&% !&#( 3 !"3 )C) (("?0+"

 %#770(&% !&#( 3 !"3 D)) (("?0+"

@

$0+!,"+ &''0"

<+&!

( !0+"

7 (3 70'

3&+"%!&(B



+"'4#(3"(!'

0!,#+&!&"'

&''0"

."!!"+ 44#&(!7"(!

4"!&!&#("+8 <,# #) 1"."%!&#( #77&!!""

4+#%""3&(B'

(("?0+"

@) ) ,"

$&."3 .7#'!

 B# 4"+! &(&(B '"."%!&#( 4+#%"''

<,"+":2 9&3"

(("?0+"

) ,"

+"B +3 %, .."(B"

$#+"' &3 '"."%!&#( 4+#%"''

44#&(!7"(!

$0+!,"+ 44#&(!&(B '"+& .

#) '"."%!&#( 4+#%"'') ) +) /&6 2 *07 + &(3 .8 ''&'!"3 +) ) * +!&;"2 8 39#% !"

44" +&(B :", .$ 44+&'"3 "$$.0?

9 +&#0'

3"9".#47"(!'

4. %") "

<,#'"

44#&(!7"(!

#) #.."B"

%, .."(B"38 +"'&B("3 )D)> 30+&(B 4"(3"(%2 <+&!

4"!&!&#() ,"+" $!"+8 (#!,"+ ( 7".28 , (3"+ 1,";, +

, +3< 6 +&(%&4 .8 <,# 0($#+!0( !".2 3&"3 @))) 1# $ + %#(%"+("38 <#+;&(B ''#%& !"

+#$"''#+ ' 7"

%#.."B"

&)") #) :0!

!! &("3 B"

'04"+ ((0 !&#( +"!&+"3 )) !,+""

B#) "

$0+!,"+ ',#+!

&''0"

&(9#.9"3 <,"!,"+ <,"( , 3 +"'&B("3 9 +&#0'

3&'%&4.&( +2 4+#%""3&(B'

<"+"

4"(3&(B B &('!

,&7 4"+! &(&(B '"."%!&#( !,"( <,"!,"+ #0B,!

1"+& .

#) .&'!

%#0.3 3#("

!,"( "(!&!."3 '#7"

$&( (%& .

:"("$&!

$&?&(B (#!&#( .

4 2 !,"+" $!"+8 +"!&+ .

:"("$&!'

%#740!"3 %%#+3 (%"

' 7"

+"7 &(&(B &''0"'

+"

% 3"7&% ( !0+"

'0:6"%!

7 !!"+ '0+9&9"

(#!&#( .

4"('&#( !,"+" $!"+ +"9&'"

4"('&#( +2 :"("$&!'

4"!&!&#("+) ) ( #!,"+ , (38 +) )*)  .&;8 44" +&(B :", .$ #)=8 +) )1)

6< 8 %#0('".

44" +&(B :", .$ #) +)  0+ 9 &(3 .8 33&!&#( .

39#% !"

"("+ .8  +2 ( 44" +&(B :", .$ #)A1! !"

6#&(!.2 '0:7&!!"38 $&+'!.28 .&'

4"+! &('

%, .."(B&(B '"."%!&#( ,&7 $ ..

<&!,&( 60+&'3&%!&#( 30% !&#( +&:0( .

!,"+"$#+"8 &!'".$ 7 &(! &( :.") 1"%#(3.28 $!"+ 8 +"'&B("3 $+#7 > $!"+

$&9"

!,"+" $!"+8 (#!,"+ ( 7".28 , (3"+ 1,";, +

, +3< 6 '"+9"3

:#0!

$#0+ 3&"3 @)) 7" (!&7"8 +"!&+"3 $+#7 '"+9&%"

!,"+"$#+"8 % 0'"

%!&#( '0+9&9"'

!#< +3'

3&'40!"

40+".2 % 3"7&% ( !0+") ,"2 $0+!,"+ $&( (%& .

:"("$&!'

% ( $&?&(B 4"('&#( (#!&#( ..2 (#+



<#+;"3 (#+ 3&3 3+ < ' . +2 $!"+  ( "$$.0?

!&7"8 "(!&+"

'0:6"%!

7 !!"+ :"%#7"

% 3"7&% ( !0+"

+&B,!

+ !,"+ "?!&(B0&',"3) ,"2 !,"+"

&(!"+&7 #+3"+ 4 ''"3 30+&(B 4"(3"(%2 4"!&!&#() =)  ," +3 %#0('".

4 +!&"') @) 1# $ + 60+&'3&%!&#( .

&''0"

%#(%"+("38

$&."3 .7#'!

 B# '&(%"

!,"( 9 +&#0'

3"9".#47"(!'

4#&(!"3 #0!

%#0('".

4 +!&"'

4. %")

0+&(B %#0+'"

+B07"(!'8 +"$"++"3 (("?0+"

 

."!!"+ 3 !"3 D))>8 <+&!!"( "("+ .

1"%+"! +2 #9"+(&(B

#32

2 .

1&(B, #.."B"8 * +( .

#) #9"+(7"(!8 +"%#77"(3&(B 44+#9 .

: '&'

+"4+"'"(! !&#( 44#&(!&(B ,&7 %#.."B") #<"9"+8 +"4.2 $&."3 1! !"8 &!

'# '! !"3 '0%, 44+#9 .

% ( 7"+"

$ %!

"9"( !&7"8 ;"4!

< &!&(B .&'!

7" ( 0!#7 !&% ..2 !! &('

+&B,!

:"&(B $!"+ 4 ''&(B . +B"

(07:"+ "9"( #!,"+<&'"

< &!&(B .&'!8 &$ (28 ;"4!

'&?

7#(!,'

$!"+ +"'&B( !&#( <,# &)") #)=8 9 % (%2 B"!'

%#('07"3 &77"3& !".2 $!"+ 44#&(!7"(!

$+"', 39"+!&'"7"(!

&''0"3 &!

=

$$"%!'

+&B,!

7 (2 #!,"+ 4"+'#(') ,"+"$#+"8 1! !"

44+#9 .

#.."B"

44#&(!&(B $ %!0 ..2 <"..8 +&(%&4 .) ,"+"$#+"8 &!

44" +'

3#"'

3&'40!"

%#.."B"

%#.."B"

&!'".$ +"%#77"(3"3 1! !"

<,"+" '

1! !"

44+#9 .

!,"+"$#+"8 9&"< +&:0( .

7 2 60+&'3&%!&#( "(!"+! &( '&(%"

3&'40!"

3#"'

44" + %#.."B"

:0!

&!

1! !") #+"#9"+8 4"(3&(B  !,"+"$#+"8 &!

<&..

44+#4+& !"

+"."B !"

30% !&#( +&:0( .

%#('&3"+&(B $#+"' &3 3"9".#47"(!'

4. %"

30+&(B 4"(3"(%2 4"!&!&#() >) -" +("3 44" +&(B :", .$ %#($&("3 "?!"(!

B+ (!&(B $&( (%& .

:"("$&!'

(#!&#( .

4"('&#( !,"+" $!"+ B+ (!

%#('"E0"(!& .

4"('&#( +2 :"("$&!'

B+#0(3 #0B,!

'"."%!"3 <+#(B.2 &B(#+"3 44#&(!"38 B &('!

<,#7 !,"+"

<"+"

9 +&#0'

%#74. &(!'

!,"+" $!"+8 &(E0&+2 %#(30%!"3 !,"+" $!"+8 +"'&B("3 $+#7 '"+9&%"

$!"+

$&9"

<,&."

'"+9&(B %#.."B"

, 3 !&7"8 ..

$&( (%& .

:"("$&!') -" +("3 '&(%"

'"%#(3 (07:"+ 7"+&!

.&'!8 3"'"+9"'

." '!

$!"+ +"'&B( !&#( :0!

(#!,&(B 3#("

@

1! !"

#9"+(7"(!

3&3 B&9"

44+#9 .) 4 +!

$+#7 :#9"8 !,"+"

&(!"+&7 #+3"+ 4 ''"3 4"+ %#0('".

4 +!&"') D) ,&'

9&"< 7 3"

% ((#!

%%"4!"3 0('0'! &( :.") !

!&7"8 "9"+ B&9"( 44#&(!7"(!

(#+ 3&3 <#+;

+"!&+"7"(!) "

+"!&+"3 ( ''#%& !"

+#$"''#+ ..

:"("$&!'

: '&'

. '!

4 2 3+ <( ''#%& !"

+#$"''#+)

&!, "$$.0?

!&7"8 +&B,!

"?!&(B0&',"3) ,"

44#&(!7"(!

'"+9"3

$&9"

+"'&B("3) ,"+" $!"+8 #("

(#!,"+ ( 7".28 , (3"+ 1,";, +

, +3< 6 44#&(!"38 <,# '"+9"3 :#0!

$#0+ 3&"3) ,"

'! (3 1! !"

%#0('".

<,&."

+"$"++&(B +"4.2 #(%"

+&(%&4 .8 9 % (%2 B#!

%#('07"3 "9"( #!,"+<&'"

.'#8 < &!&(B .&'!

% ((#!

".#(B !"3 '&?

7#(!,'

% ++&"'

<"&B,!) ,&'

9&"< !,"+"$#+"

% ((#!

(#!&#( .

:"("$&!

4 2 , 3 <#+;"3) !

'!&..

'"+9&%"

(#+ '# '! !"3 '!&..

+&B,!

'&74."

+" '#( !! &("3 B"

'04"+ ((0 !&#( B#!

+"!&+"3 ''#%& !"

+#$"''#+) ,"+"$#+"8 %#('&3"+"3 9&"< (#!&#( .

>

4 2 %#('"E0"(!

4"('&#( % ((#!

B&9"( 4"!&!&#("+) C)

#('"E0"(!.28 $&(3&(B 7"+&!

4"!&!&#(8 ' 7"

,"+":2 3&'7&''"3) ) ..

44.&% !&#('

4"+! &(&(B 3&+"%!&#('

&74." 37"(!

', ..

3""7"3 3&'4#'"3 7 &( 3&'7&''"3) ))

1 1 

,07&;

  )

,"!,"+ '4" ;&(BA+" '#("3

"'A# )

,"!,"+ +"4#+! :."

"'A#