High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17911/2015disposed of

M/S Powergrid Corp Of India Ltd v. Haryana Urban Development Authority & ORS

2015-09-14Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan5 pages

!"##$%&%'()

*& +#,-,%.,/,!"%''.%!0". #"%"%'#, 2#,&3& !,4!'! ,5!'#6#7/8#'"3"9,%"4 "9#,& #&/'.#'"&

,#&#'"(1 ,:&9!49!';<,.6$!"#+%"9 ,8!'!'&!7;.6$!"#,"9#/#"%"%'#, ,##/!:!74!';.6$!"#,,#&/'.#'"& ===

9# /#"%"%'#, &##:& ! ,%" !'.!83& .%,#$"%'- "9# ,#&/'.#'"&"!77+%""$'"%'3#+%"9"9#"#'.#,%'-/,$#&&!"#,-,!'"%'- '#$#&&!,4/#,8%&&%'!'."!77+%"""!:#3/"9#$'&",3$"%'"9#%$# 53%7.%'-!'."9#,#&%.#'"%!7$8/7#> 9#/#"%"%'#,+!&!77""#."+/7"&7!'.%'"9#4#!,? ')"9#/#"%"%'#,+!&-%6#'/&&#&&%'%'<#$",1; !,%.!5!.

!.8#!&3,%'- ;

&@8#"#,&,/3""%'-3/!,#&%.#'"%!7$8/7#>" !$$88.!"#%"&#8/74##& '

/#"%"%'#,5"!%'#./&&#&&%'

"9#/7"%'<#$",?1; !,%.!5!.!.8#!&3,%'-!//,>%8!"#74?

&@ 8#"#,,"9#/3,/&#$'&",3$"%'-"9#%$#$8/7#>+9%$9+!&"5# "9# #-%'!7 #!.@3!,"#,& "9# /#"%"%'#, , ,"9#,' '.%! 9# /#"%"%'#,A&#8/74##&&"!"%'#.!""9%&%$#!,#"5#!$$88.!"#.!"%' "9#,#&%.#'"%!7$7'4"5#$'&",3$"#.'"9#"9#,/7" B 9#/#"%"%'#,+!&"$8/7#"#"9#$'&",3$"%''5"9"9# /7"&+%"9%'4#!,&&%"!%7#.".&;!'"%$#.!"#.CB

+!&

11 %&&3#.$!77%'-3/'%""&9+$!3&#+94"9#/7"&3-9"'""5#,#&38#. +#6#,;6%.#,.#,.!"#.?

"9#,#&/'.#'"&-,!'"#."9#/#"%"%'#, !'#>"#'&%'"+4#!,&547#64%'-!'#>"#'&%'##!53" &)7!$& +9%$9+!&/!%.54"9#/#"%"%'#,9#.!"#,$8/7#"%'$'&",3$"%' &".#>"#'.#.3/" ) &"9#/#"%"%'#,!%7#."$8/7#"#"9#$'&",3$"%'54"9# #>"#'.#..!"#;!',.#,,#&38%'-"9#/7"&+!&/!&&#.') 9# /#"%"%'#,%7#.!'!//#!7!-!%'&""9%&,.#,9#//#77!"#3"9,%"454!' ,.#, .!"#. B +9%7# '"%'- "9!" "9#,# +!& ! .#7!4 ' "9# /#"%"%'#,A&/!,"%'$8/7#"%'-"9#$'&",3$"%';,.#,#.!&3'.#,(1

! "# $ %

$ &

' (

! "# % $ ) *

$ % %,-".&" ,! "

$ / "%&%8/,"!'""'"#"9!""9%&,.#,9!.!""!%'#.%'!7%"4!&"9# ,#&/'.#'"&.%.'"$9!77#'-#"9#&!8#

9# /#"%"%'#,A& $!&# %& "9!" %" "9#,#!"#, !..,#&&#. &#6#,!7 7#""#,&""9#,#&/'.#'"&$!77%'-3/'"9#8"%',8%""9##>"#'&%'## /!4!57#!&/#,"9#,.#,"9#//#77!"#3"9,%"453""9!""9#,#&/'.#'"& '#-7#$"#.".&9#/#"%"%'#,;"9#,#,#;$'"#'.&"9!"%"$!''"5# !37"#.,"9##>"#'&%'##'"9!6%'-5##'/!%.%'/3,&3!'$#""9#,.#, /!&&#.54"9#//#77!"#3"9,%"4 ? '&"#!. %',8%'- "9# /#"%"%'#, "9# #>"#'&%' ##; "9# ,#&/'.#'"&54!',.#,.!"#.B )&"!"#."9!""9#!77"8#'"7!'.,

1B1 "9# #-%'!7 %$#$37.'+'745#$'&%.#,#. !""9#$3,,#'" ,!"#!77"8#'" &;

*1/#,&@8#"#, "3,"9#,&"!"#."9!""9# !77"8#'"7!'.,"9#"+'&9%/"9# #-%'!7 %$#+#,$!''745# $'&%.#,#. !" "9# $3,,#'" %'!'$%!7 4#!,A& !77"8#'" ,!"#& !& !//7%$!57#"-,3/93&%'-&$%#"%#&,"9#4#!, )1 $%,$37!"#.54!

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

&#+#9!6#' 9#&%"!"%'%'-,!'"%'-%'"#,%8,#7%#&+9%$9+37./,"#$""9#%'"#,#&"&"9# /#"%"%'#,!&+#77!&"9#,#&/'.#'"& 9#.#7!4%'$'&",3$"%'+%77 !.6#,&#74##$"'"'74"9#/#"%"%'#,53""9#,#&/'.#'"&!7&#9!6# '9#&%"!"%'%'/!&&%'-"9#%'"#,%8,.#,,8,#"9!''#,#!

"9%&%&!/,F#$"/357%$%8/,"!'$#<#$'.74"9#/,F#$"%&%8/7#8#'"#. 54"9#/#"%"%'#,+9%$9%&+9774+'#.6#,'8#'"'.%!3'.#,"!:%'- 9%,.74!'.8&"%8/,"!'";"9#'74%&&3#%'676#.%&"9#!83'""5#/!%. 54"9#/#"%"%'#,,"9#!77"8#'""9#&!%.7!'.9#,#&/'.#'"&$'"#'. "9!""9#/,%$#3-9""5#!&&"!"#.%'"9#%8/3-'#.$883'%$!"%'.!"#.

1)1 B )9#/#"%"%'#,;'"9#"9#,9!'.;,#74%'-3/'!',.#,"9# //#77!"#3"9,%"4.!"#. B$'"#'.&"9!"%"%&7%!57#"/!4'74 "9##>"#'&%'##!&!//7%$!57#!""9!""%8#9#.%#,#'$#%&!53" &

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

% 9#,#&/'.#'"&&9!77%',8"9#/#"%"%'#,"9#!83'"/!4!57# "+!,.&"9##>"#'&%'##'"9#5!&%&"9#,.#,.!"#. B;/!&&#.

54"9#//#77!"#3"9,%"4"-#"9#,+%"9%'"#,#&""9#,#';%!'4

%% 9#/#"%"%'#,&9!77+%"9%'"++##:&5#%'-&%',8#.;/!4 "9#!83'"",#&/'.#'"'&35F#$"""9#%,,%-9""$9!77#'-#""9#&!8# +#6#,;%'"9#%,&"%'&"!'$#"9#!83'"&9!775#/!%.!'."9#$9!77#'-#% !'4&9!77'745#",#$6#,"9#!83'"9#/!48#'"8!4"9#,#,#5# 8!.#3'.#,/,"#&"

%%% 9#/#"%"%'#,&9!77%7#!'3'.#,"!:%'-"/!4"9#5!7!'$# !83'""9!"8!4%'!7745#3'..3#54"9#//#77!"#3"9,%"4&35F#$"" "9#$9!77#'-#"9#,#";%!'4"%&$7!,%%#."9!""9%&%'"#,%8,.#,%&/!&&#. '74%'6%#+"9#/#"%"%'#,A&3'.#,"!:%'-"9!"%"+%77,#"!%'"9#/7"!'. /!4"9#!83'"!&%'!774!&&#&&#.%,,#&/#$"%6#!'48!,:#"73$"3!"%'

%6 9#,#&/'.#'"&&9!77/,$#&&"9#/#"%"%'#,A&!//7%$!"%', $'&",3$"%' ,"9+%"9 &35F#$" " "9# /#"%"%'#, 8##"%'- !77 "9#, ,#@3%,#8#'"&!'.$'.%"%'&

##.7#&&"!.."9!""9#!//#!7"9#/#"%"%'#,+%775#.#$%.#. +%"93"!'4.#7!4%'6%#+"9#5&#,6!"%'&8!.#%'"9%&/#"%"%' %&/&#. !"#

$%!&'(!)"*+%!$) ),!&#) !&'((!&#+

*#') -./01/-2 73$:4