Dev Raj v. Chief Engineer Pb & ORS





   









 













 
!

  #"$ %
& ' "(
$ !)
 
%"

*       

   "

"

#%+
,''"-+(
,( "
%
* 


. 
/%(
,,0(
$ !)


   12
-2

%
  
*
+
$ "
,"+

3

4
 %
 $

5 (
%
* "
6
$ 


"

% "*  

"'$+"7
%
"
-

88
 


9"


$ +
"
%
* "
  
%
%

 %
"*  
-%"
%
"
%
)
"'$+"7
-



": "2

%
"

++
:+"+2
$
*"  
"'$+"7
-

88

&
%
"

+2-'"( 1%
!
 
%"(
-%
%
": 
) 
":
$2
"
8

2( 
"'$+"7
)2
%
"*  

/:+"+2(
"

0 %
+( -%
": 
) 
":
$2
"
4
2
%
+
)
"'$+"


%
%"
% (
+"


/
$ +
$):
%
% * ";

%

)
 "
"
"'$+"7
-

88

$ 

%
-+$+
) 
":
$2
"

*"

<

  2


""(
%"


""

$) 
%
"'$: 
"
%" "
" 

""


-%2
%
* "(
-%
++'+2
%
-+$++2 ) 
"
<
2(
-
'
6
)6

%
)+%:

5
 :

%
%
"

-"6"
0 %
+
-%
":  ) 
"
4
2
%
)
"'$+"

="

>%
$"


 

            (


 !""##$(
 #$"#

-%+
+ '
-%

:+"
?$

%
%+

$ "

 



      

 



    !   "    # $

#  %     # $

#  

"     !& '(( () )) )) # #   

   * 

    

#    ' +  ,-./012/   

     !&3 4 1 -15 '((#    "!   "         

  %       !&   !      

)  !



 !        /  15  !  !

" "%6 !  !      

  !   %7 8

         "      

!93
#: !&          !

( )

  (

3 !

;  ! ;  !  

&!&< %       "    "   5  =   !&        4   >$> $33+'. 2> )$(    #$

#    !!& > "  !   "    

  "!  +?,> : ?  !&    ,,3          5        !  ##  

  "!      #)" ! # #  

'-

'4,3  !        ?       

         +?  ,>  !          !

         

  "  %         !&            !  

    !    #)     "  ##  

         5  :

 

             !&    ;   !

 &"            

 >/   !  

 ;

% "       !&        @ :  !&   "== !!?  %  !&    ">!& ! "  %7 8   "                  

A  "A 8

  3:

   7     8  B  !  "    @ >%
"*  
%
"

"-

 

%

 %
* "

%


)

%
'"$ 

-+$+
)  ":
$
"
)$
<
2(
-%"(
%
-"6:

%

(


0 %
+(
%
": 
) 

$ 

+'

=-"(
@* %
)+
" (
%"

% '

""

 +$
%
%
* ": 
-+$++2
) 
":
$
"
%
*"

?$

= ;)+
% /$*":
$"(
 

% 
 &' $ $

  $ )"

$ "

%     

,"

 

  !

 5             "   A      "! " !!   !

 @ >%
$:

%
* ";
!  '
%
"


 8


*$

>%
-+$+
) 

%
* "

 *"

>%
* "

)+$+2

%
:
*+

-%
%
 -"6"(
0 %
+(
 
%""(
"

)
"

%
: :

,

 ?$ 

%
)
$ (
%
  
*
 ++-
-%

"

"'$+"7
%
"

%
* "
-

88
 
++
 ?$ +
) 
+- '
%"":
)
'" 
 %:
-%

*"

<
2
":
%
2

"*


"
*2
 %
!$':

 


          



   !