← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24331/2012allowed

Mohan Lal v. State Of Haryana & ORS.

2017-02-23Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan11 pages

   

         

!"# $#%&'&()#*+,!+- .

/ 0!(1!2 #"&"&(#+ 3#+','

4"!"# !+-!(!!($"0#+'

#'5($#("'

 ) 6 1 4714 +#'#(")  

                   

    

!    "

#!$% & '  % (

"

#!  #$% 714  1 )        #     * #   +,+-&+ +.

/  01(2  

+.

/ 0142     !

!  #   &- +&+ +.

/ 01 +2  (1 5!!0  #      #  ! 6 " 6      '    "            0   5 &,+- ,78 #   !   5     &,+, ,,         !        )     +,+4&++(      !  #           ( +3&++8'    !  ) + +&++3

 #(8   7+9 #    + !!       ' !!     &++,    '   8+4 ,88

#   #:) 

 +&+7&++,  (,& (,7)05  &8  !    ,8,    0   ;:

 0 1)   #   #    #<  5  #<5 !

   '     = 0 ;:0 1 )   #   =  7+3&++,         #  <     !   !

 5     :) ,+  &4+8&++,

(&( 8+-  (4)05 # #  ! #  #  ! >

>

 

!    #=      #<  # ! #  )     #            #  <            !

 :) 

7  +&+7&++, )  )?  # 5)   

   #<   :)  47  

4+3&++, (,3 4+ )05  &8 !

  ,8,# 0 ;:0 1)  # 0  #!  &7+3&++, )@"# #  #0;:0 1)  # 50A  # ' 

  #<  1  # #      #        * 

     :) 

 +&+7&++,#    !

  ' "  6=&++,  !6    #  :) '  !     :) 

 +&+7&++, )         +,+-&+ +.

/ 01(2  ! 

(&-.20 "  5

 @1) 0 1) 

, 3.)2.20 " 0

 

       *   #88 

 '  

+.

/ 0142        #88  0 !   ) !  !

     #88 

  7+9 #   #    +           #88  #  

    ! )  

+4&++8.

/ 01 &2 '     !              !

,+-&++,&-

&++,  # BB  B   5    B B)    #  :) 

 +&+7&++,    #      #"

  )  !    6   

 ! 

+ !

 !B

!    #88  )     #

!C  

  

          

  

      

    !  "  ##$%&$#'& 

$  

  

  ( )  ( * )+  +    ) 

        ,  -./ )

!         " # 0%&0 '   

$     

      2  )   

         



    



      )  (  

+ )    

        -.   &  / )  !         "

& #  % $

$ !    

      

)         

         

     ! -', 3     / )     " 04%&45'    #

%    -    6 (      )7

 (     ,  -. &/ )    (      (            05  (  

$0

$

$  (   

   

 87 )

   

  ))      (  9   (            

 +& *  

 , :7   !  

    #;

8 (     

          ! -', 3     / )     " 1#&

'   $

%%    (    )

 )

         ,   

  -.   &  / )     !

)     +  " %%4    

$

   0$   #'#5'#$  -.   & / )          

 



!<=!  >=  '+/ ?? '/   )>  ' .*  +  / ??  , " %0   

  -  =      

     7    

      * 

    9   (   

 +& *  

 , :7   @ )          

  (&-.2    0 "   5 

 @1) 0 1). 

    2 !



   #  !

6 # !  )            #  #  B  B   #      !

,+-&++,&-

&++,  #   !

+7+4&++3    ( +3&++3    + +8&++3    (++,&++3        

!       )   !

#!

!   

 (&-.20 " 5

 @1) 0 1) 

, 3.

2.52 " 0

 

      )        

  !+7+4&++3 ( +3&++3 !+ +8&++3 (++,&++3 

5!!0 

9  /

#  #! 6B@0 =B  ! 6 !+7+4&++3 ( +3&++3 + +8&++3(++,&++3 

  )           # # 

!   # ! 6

  ,+-&++,&-

&++,.  8!2

BB  B  B B 5  B  B'! 6  B  #B ! 6  !

  '! 

!   ! *   !

 *   # 

!   #   !)     '     !  #    !

      ! 6 #         ! &++,      6     ! 6  &++,1&+ + D

 ;      !

#  

+.

/ 0142#         ;    ##       ) !  

+4&++8  4+(&++-.

/ 01&2

/ !

     # 88    ! 7+9 #    #   +            #88  #  

    ! '   +,+-&+ +.

/ 01(2   5!!0  #   

+ .

/ 0142  5!!0  # )     !  

  

 ! ;    

 ) ! 

+4&++8 

4+(&++-.

/ 01&2    !     '!   

 , 3.)2.20 " 0

 

      ' 

    C 

    &A%"   ) ( )        )

  )    B A               !       )  3 ( )  !     (&!  (   



  ( (

  7

 7 C A7 

(  

 

7&  A      ) (&! (  D3 ( ) ! C A   7( 

  ) (    

 ) ##(  7()! ) 

:     :  C A      ) ) ##(  7(  )! )    

       :             

  ) ( !       )!

7   )  (&! (    7 )!

            ) (& ! (     " E&

  ) ( 

 7   )     (  /!     !                  )    ##  (      

)  )   (     ))  !7 

 /!    !          ) ##( 

  9  

&/       (    

 !



!  /!   

(    (      7  ) )     ! ,(    !       (&! (  D3 ( ) !     )! )   (   

         

(   7    (



        &9 )  

(  7 8      

7   

    !    )



   ( 

(

  

   9

       

& A)

     (   7  )

  7 * )   (   7  (       D !   ( 

    (  7  

 )         

          

  ! 

    

;      (  !   7

 (      

  

      

  )

 A 

  

 

  

(  

    ( 7   !

 )

 

   * (7  !     &  9       7  )!

    3 



(* ) ( 

  (   * )

     

  

 7 *  

  7   

(        

 

(          

&/     

       !



!  /!   

   

 

 (

7( /!     

7?    9    ( 7 

!        



   !     7    7(

  6 )    

 

      

 7   

 

' 

  ! 

)    

 !  *       )    !

! 

   

 !* $ '! / !>5  ;0 7&8&+ 45 03 (3&+ &        

         

!"     4+



 >   C F 

 7! " +  $ %  +  !  

 7       

(          (  7 

  

 !

 

!        /!     

   

 

 (

7(   /!      

7?      "   (

!  (

 

 7( /!      )    7(       ) G )   (! 7    !  7!  !                     ) G ) 

 

 @ '          #  >  * #   !

#! 

 )    > 5    

 !*  !

! ! 

, 0 " 0

' !      ! /   )

   !   !  # :) 

 +&+7&++, #  ! 6# #!  

!   #  !' !  * 

 !!   / !     # # !  #88      $





      '!

#  +,+-&+ +.

/ 01(2  !

  !    

+  .

/   0142     *                  &- +&+ +  .

/   01 +2                       ! 6             ' ! 6  #  6#      &++,1&+ +    8+4 ,88      #

     !     #  #    

               *      '   !           # # # D*  D  # !   #

   !!

   "

#!  714 #*+,!+- .

/     

  6#D  %

   C %