High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18713/2014dismissed

Sukhjinder Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2017-12-07Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh16 pages

!" "#

(( "#

) *+

, -*+ ""

& !*+ "" $

. *

+" "# ""

( / "

"# "" $

(( + "# ""

( , )#! "#

,, !" "#

,. /2" "#

2" "# ""

( )!" "#

. * + /!" "# ""

, 1"

"# ""

. */2 "# ""

( !" "#

. % !

"# ""

(

,( /!" "# ""

,. "+ / "# ""

, & + "#

, / " "# "" $

.(, , *

+" "# "" $

.( ,

2" "# ""

, ( . "# ""

. . 5- "# "" $

!" "# ""

! "# ""

6)078679 9:

5 # 2 /"

<)- "#<)-

'"" '""" , ) <)/)5<!

"<)-

5 +"1 ==== 0"

!#+ +" //"

' /

% "#

< (( <

((< ,< ,,< ,.< < (< .< <

< (< .<

,(<

,.< , , <.(,

.( ,< ( .<

++> " / 2

"-/-" //

32-<

-"<

%"#? + 0'"" - "/' '"")"/

"" 9"

2""

+ + ""# #/ "A" -" + """"

/ ''"+ /#2" // >"

/% " " + !#+ 3B%/)'?""-"/)'' /,(

,"/

!"# $%&'&# #$"( )* + ! "# $% " ) ' C

%+ "

2" " " " >

"# "+'# . '

%C ' <2%C</ "+ '""

%! C

"!#+ 3D%/)'?"

,&- &$.&)/% 0 1" /C<

+ "' '""

'"" < 2 ?;

-"+< 2 #"

2" +'/C+? #

1 5 " /" )< ."

E)B)>"

""2

%C ';1 /"6'

+-")?;

'"" 2'2

# 2""

%5 +"1 " "6"

'0'""

%2 "#2" ';1 /

;

C 0C

- '' "" #/ "

" -" %C ""#"

C/# -""-"2 !#+

3D%/)'?"

,&- &$.&)/% 0 / "+ '"" 2

!-" . )?;<2" "

%!+ //#"' '"" 1C 2 C "/"# ' '""< '"" / "+"# C "/ #/ "A "

2//

C /

//2

# "+"/ /C " # 2 "# 2" ';1 + " ''"+ F / '"" %+" "# "

% " !

%"C ( 2

+"/" "-"" < 2

" ' "" /'- "/"#/

" "2" - "/ %/'/"' / "2

" " "" /'/"

" %C?"

"#'2 "

) '"" 2 ''" "#/CF /

%+" "

"#/-/"+"# / ( <2"<"2

"'-">"

"# %C "

"# "" / 0% "" % " "

/% % ''"

'/"

C 2/%"

"'/" / " '"

/" "

"9-"2 "

"< >"

""2

%C ';1 /"6'

+ ''"+ < 5 '" "C 1 F /

%+"

''-"

" " )<

''"2#"-

+'2 <'"-"/# '"<2"

#"-

" )9"

#+ /

( / '"" 2 ''"%C

/C 2 # 6 2%"#'

"%C% "" <2"2 /

%C'/"'

+" / )</ / '"" %+" "+'# . )?;

//C"//# /</ / C!#+ 3B%/ )'?"

,&- &$.&)/% 0 F / ';

%+"

" + %C/ / '"" %+" '"" ?''"" 2- ''"

" ) ''"+/ 2"

%C'/" '

+ ''"+ 2+ "#"

%/C% % >/C2" + <"+

+'//C '' 0 '"" 2 ''" %C ';1 " 2/-/

"+%C /CF / %+" '"" 2 - // C +% "

% /%C '"" 2"/ "/"#' '"" F /

%+" /C-"

" " '"" 2

+ %C'/" '

+ '"" -

" "/' '"" +'

+ /- 2"'"" <22'

,&- &$.&)/% 09"

#+ / / 22 ''""#"

+2!"

3+5 %'"" 2" " '

%/ C2

%3+5

C 2- ''"

0'"" /" '' "

%C2 C "/"#,( <2"2

"+'/"

"< "/ ' "#2

%C ';

<2"<"2

" //C+" '"" 2-"/"+' C

" #

< <C % "%+'/C /" 6'

+ +'

+ /- 2"'"" "

,&- &$.&)/% 0"%C ""#"+ ''"+ "-"2 + "" ''"+)</

/ %+" ' '"""

%/%"

/C # '"" % "

+'/C /"6'

+ -

" "/' '"" F / , %+" ' '"" "

+ " " %/

/ " "' +'/C +'/C%2+ '"" 0'""

2 "#

""+ %"#'

" "+%"# "/C # F / %+" '"" 2 %C '/"'

+%"#?;

-"+" +)+C -"

C2'

"#/" 2 ' )</ / , %+" 2

- C2" ';

''"+

1 5 3 #+ - %C / / '

" - ##+ - "/ %/ "/"#"+'# !" / "#/+ '"" 2"+'/C+ ? # ''"+2" ';1 "

'9"

'%C '"" %"#'

C C;; C%

0'"" / "+"#/" #/ "A "

" -" "-"2 !#+ 3D%/)'?"

,&- &$.&)/% 02"< 2#/ "A0/ "+

'"" 2"# #/ "A " '

C+ #/ '

%"%C ';

2//

%C ';

# '"" / "+ '

"C 2" '"" "

,&- &$.&)/% 0

''""#"

+ % 2

C%" '

" ""

//C"

1 ';

2//

1 "" C"#"/"

%"/"C%C

C"# '""

"/ #/ "A " #/ '

C /

"C " ?;

-"+ C "/ /" # " ' '""0/ "+ '"" 2

!%C'

' "#<2"<"2

" //C+" !#+

3D%/)'?"

,&- &$.&)/% 0"

''/" %/

'"" "

2 ''"

%C/"6'

+ " )<2

<"'

<'""

2'"1 1 5 " 0/- '" !" . "

G0!#+ '

%C3D%/ '+ ""-"/)'' /,( ,"/

" / "# 5 $ !

% "

''/" %/"

'"" %

" " / "#D

< '"" 2 ''"

%C/"6'

+ " /")< . C2 '1 1 5 C 9"

''""# "C2

'"" 2 ''"

1 5 %C 1 "" " 2 /-/ 0C 2

''"

%C/"6'

' "

/")< . '"" -/ "+ #/ "A " " -""/"6'

+ 9-"2

"' ""<' "

'"" "

!0C+ C '' "" #/ "A " " -" %

% "

" ''""# "CH I"

'/C'"" 2'#'/"

"" 2

5 +"1 C2'

" # %C1 /C0"

+ ""

''"+ 2 '"" 2 ''"%C'/" '

+ 9 ''

'/" 2

" "'' /C 0

%/ " "' +'/C +'/C"# -"<""

2 C+'/C2 '-"

" "" "

+'/C/-+'/C"

"+'

"+""# +'/C;+'/C/ " "'"+

" +" " / " "'%2+

- "

"# +

'-"

/-2 %C - /C"+ ""#

2 2 -

% + "2"2"//"

2 9+""#/ " "'

+'/C +'/C<%/"

"+' %"

/ +""# / " "')// /-

"+ >"% ""+

"" J

2 "

/ +'/C

/ '

C+ "+- + -" 2 C + "" %2 '""'

+'/C +'/C "

%+" "/ ""#"

<""

% +'// '-"

"%C+'/C%"'

< + -%'/ %C'"" " C + "" 2 "? 2"/ ''""# '""

"%C ';

"%C1 "

"'/" C "/ -% %C /C

"+"/ "

% 3B%/)'?"

# #$"(

* &#

!"# $%&'&

!"# $%&

F&..9

"C2

#%C'

"+ 2 " +'/C+' C%

"5-+/ 0C2

''"@+'/C '" 2C "" "

++C + "' %

""+ 0C /"+% " #/ "A " '

"C"'

C '

2"#/ +'/C 92

2"/

C/" '' / "/%C ''// ;

//2 3"#2

"0/- '"

"!#+"

G + C //2"# 2// / '""'/ / "##/ "A " '

"C"'

C</-

"? '' :

"3"# <"?"

"#'2)"/

. "" 2"// "

"" #/ "A "<

% '" '+ " < /

+'/C

/ "+"##/ "A " % ''""'

#/ "+" 2"/- / " ' +'""- '

< # "

" - ' 0 > /"C /

" " )"/ . / %

'/ /C //2 /"

#/ "A " -" +'/C2"2/% -"/ "- "" / + "/ +"# "

"#/ 2 +'/"

2" /+ " '

/" 2" # '

< %#/ "A<% " < ''"+

C "" / + @ ''"+

"/"#"%/ " %#/ "A """ " -"%C +' C "/C;2 #+'/C<- +""+

<2/ '"+ C"#% % % " -"<

-"2/%K/""#" +'/C+D 7- +' C< "/C;2 # -" /# +% C </ / -" 2C <2"// "/ +'/C / "+ #/ "A "< "

2 "# # "

" ' C+'

"+ % # '

"# C

#/ "A "" % /# /"#

, """7-2 +"

+/ #/ "A "2"

+'-""# ' 2 '" '"

"+% C -" ""#" +'/C+

<""

"%/

22 ''" % >

</ "+ + / % ''/" + %C ?"#

"" +"#

+ '-""#

"- ;"++'/C "/ #/ "A "

C 2 "# # " C

"' 0 % "" % '"< #/ "A " '+ " '

"++' C+'/C - "+ +' C +'/C " #-+ " "" / "+ '

"C "

C 2" #/ +'/C #-+'""'/ > /'

C > /2 +'/C "'"- +'/C+<-"

-"# // "+< '

"C "

C 2" #-+ +'/C 0"#/ "+ '

C # "

+ "

% 3B%/)'?"

# #$"( !"# $%&'& $2

#/ ''"+ /C%+

/" %C%/" -"++"

" ';+'/C % " -"%C/ "+"#'

"C9

%/"

,& - &$.&)/% 0

2//!#+"

$-%$# %1# #$"(3 % #2

!"# $%&'& $5 !"# $%& . 0.

3"#

. "?"

'2)"/

. "" 9"

#/ "A +'/C/C# + - %#/ "A9 #"- C"#/ "+'

"C 9'

" C+ ""

C +""

"-/ ';

+" %-< " "

/ / " "' +'/C +'/C

% %/"

%2 '

" '"" / "+'

"C2"'"" "

,& - &$ .&)/% 0 )"#/C< %C ""#

2//

/ 2' ""?'/ " %-<"

+"" " "

%C / / '"" '"" %"#-" C+" %C"

. 0 '!

' "#@

' %/ L