← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/2440/2012allowed

Anju Bala v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2018-08-23Mr. Justice Darshan Singh20 pages

        

 

           

     !

 !

"#$ 

#$%& # '( ) #

 $ *(*(  # +",  ( )  - #./*"( )  0 $%          ,//

(   '  )   0  "    1/   2  34

 3   )   ) /   

$( 5 

 6     " 7 * 7  7 4"   %,// 3  

1/ 2 '

7 %

' "# 

   

%  """  

7  % ( 5 9      0  )   "   )  (  5  7  /'     % &        )  %   '7  ,

: ;,<  "   ""   %,= ) 7 7   -

/&(  5        7        " (     "   > / %  + 7  % =  "   /

%  "      "  ( " /  )  '

 /& % + 2  %?





# ( / :

     ,2+

  

% 4"       &

   &%   

( 4"          7 %)   =  ""   (     4"    

 &  " ( /(.

" (- /+0(+  ( * ! ($ ;

4:

<=7    & "  4"    ,// 3  

1/ 2%// .

"    "   7' 7   -- 5 7'7 )

 

 )  /   8:

4"     ;

4:

<7 " )    4  3 6  9     1/ 29 ($ "" " ;

4  :@<    ) %     .

&  "        "  7

&/  & , )  % ($ ) 

4:@ " ) " "   1/ 29 ($ &/   , )  % ($   5 $ ( ;

4:@< "  

  :

A /  % 

 9/'

:=

&     %  )          5  /"  .

&  "   $

   4"      =     (   4"     &

7  /     

-5    /0  

--5         ) &   .

&

" .

& - % ) 7    ;

 % <9/'



& "  

%/"   % B  C  7)(    7    7     &    7'    "   

     ) "  7  "  ( " (

  &/     

7  "" / / 7  %  @ =  /   ( ""   9   * ( ( '6 %

"" / 

7 /  4"    7 %

&%)    4"    7 % )    %    % (  ,//    , (  .7      $  7

&/  

"   "/&(   * (

(     '  )  

4  :-   %      4"     &/  & 

 &.

&

"       .

&  "    7'

%    "      ) " "   "/&( ;

4:-<"" &   % (,//  , (.7($ 7 7

&/    * ( ( '

"     :

A 4"     &/  &  8

9/'

+ D-(E& 3 $

 &.

"   

.

" 

7'

%"  C -    , )   % (  $  )   #/  +  

   ;

4  :-< 

          *  

( 0( '   4"  

   

 & .

"  %     

4:-7 &%   & &   %,#+@0D @7 7 7  " )      @"

 &

, (

4:- "    " 7  " &                 , )   %      ;

4:-< "     :

A9 &) &   

 8:##:8     5-       &

/  /   % ) &.

& .

" ($   / /"7 7 )  7 &    6     &/ ) & 8 9/'

!89 + D-(E& 3 ($ 7'  .

& " /0   -- 5

,//  3   1/ 2  

  /    )  /"    

=

   

  7'   7'

"  

7 % )  

4"  

%  =

=

    7' & % 

=

   7'

% $ 7 C 0  / "   -  1&( D ;

4  :0<       ,  / (         ,//

(  '

       /& ' % / /7  .

"   

 .

" 



7   7'

%4"   "    7 ") (  ) )    "7 & = 6 

 9 

    

  7' 7  # , (   &7'

% .

" /    4"        7

  &     #   ,      

7)(    4"    

 &   #   ,      7    ""    /       7  

4"  7 6    %7 (   4"    

 & .

" 

6  4"    

 & # , (  & % )    5      /      "     7   

 ( 

""  

,&  %,2+- D     " ( D"

 &

( 7 7 7  7   7   "    7    &    ""       & ""

,  =  /   ( ) %     " ( D;

4:5<   

%  /    ! % = /  ( -7 7

""    5 % ( ) 

4:D  0  '34

3  (0" 7  " 7"

/  )  %2   7 '  %  ( % ) / %  

0 "/&( D;

4:<7  6 ""   & %+ 7  % 

      7

"  & .

" (    7

    4"    7        7      7'  .

&     7'(&4"   

7 % ) 





7 %/" % B  "

4:@& #/  5 $ (  &) D 2 6  7 

 & 

    7 "    ,2+ @D-  7 /

 &    D  +)/&( ;

4:< "

 & 

%$ %

,%% ) &   

%$ %( "  ""  ?+5@   "" 7  ) 7 

%$ %

  )

      (

) :      "   / & ""

 /& /

 %( ""   ?&   5 /&( ;

4:<7            "    "" 4"    "&7 

"  7/

/  "   "



   = "     

""  /"%      #( ;

4: <7 "

 &   *  ( '  /  "" /    " 7  &  * 

7  7 %& ) 

:

A!   /"   >& ,  

  5 (4/    /#      /   &      "     @ D  =             /  , 7  % 7   "" /    )        "

 #)( 4"    #  7   

 

       &  )    &  /(   

% (, ,.7  $ )    +    (  #             "" /   %

     "     1/   2 34

3 C    !

      F 4"     7   F  F )  7  %   "

   F  / ,%7  "" / / 7  %   * (     )   

&  /(  % (, ,(.7)   +  ( : 7      "" / %

 " 1/ 234

3 =

 7    %

7 "     = )    

 "  "   "":&'

-     %    & :

     +7   (.

  7 

&/

   D  1&(      /"

  

"%"

-

7  &/

      7'  3  ,// 3  

1/ 2%// 7

  7 

" "/  7'    " "%"

    

"    

  

7

     " 7

"  &    &   (  7 6 /   "8 "  7   

 &  7 "   7'  " ;.

&< '"

% ) 7 7'" / 

   4"

7 % )  "/  / / 7   &   "    7 A C 4"       

  /

%     7       " ( 

 /  &  '  

 )   7 & /   &  / '=

) 7              

%  &     "   (    8  7 /  "  %7    %  %       7)(  &

   7' 7  .

"  @

  "    &     #   , (  , '

   :

  0   /&( 5    = &

&/  & # ,   /"%      $ ( 5 "

  &        *   (     7   ""     /  7   ""    7  ")   

  @D;<;< = /4(7 ")  '"

%   

/    "    

7 %   /  7'  3  "   9 7'

7  7 %-8:"/  "  

7 % 4"    "= /4(  @  

& 

    )   

'" &   7   & %  &/   &

/ 7 +) 

(=   %  

 ) &  4"    

 &# ,     " & ""   /   " 



7)( 

/  &    

7 % (  (      7' 

  -  ,//

  

"   7  //

% /      "/ ( ,//

 )  *) /      /

;

 %4"     <    &)   & /&7 %      =  4"      )      %  ( "/ 7 '



  / ,//

  

 

""   7  %  ",  (

 

  5D 6  &' & "/ (

   (              6      :

,//

0   : * ( 

     &" %

7  / &   *) / =    / 7 4/   "  

 , ""   &  "" /   &    

   &)7  

 /"%    " )      & /(  % (, ,.7  $

 &  ) &   7  / (& " /  +    & "   &

, 4"

"

/ 

7 %

  "

)  ) 4"   

 % & "  5 +

% 7 &   7  / ( 

     /"%    %( 





/"%      #( ;

4: < &

 &

,  "%"

  /"%    

6  / %     " ( D7 &   '    /"" /  "  4"      &

 &&&   % (,//  , ( .7(  $  )   "    D   ;

4  :-<       , ) 

% ($ ) 

"    ;

4:-<&  /

) +

% & /    /"%   7 "

 79  )&  %    7 ) 

  " 7 )& %  "     7 9   *) /   ' , ) 

%   % ) 4"    %   =

) 7 /( 7 &     4"      %       /   )     .

&  " (       7  

7          ) &  " 7  &/

 .

&.

" .

 



4"     4"   7'

"      +7(  /  "

 &

,/ / / )&    / )& 7  "  

 

, 

       / 4"     

 &.

"     0 5 ,

         .

&  "  

  7     (     "   

   "    & 6    

 /   0 5"

 &

, "  &7 :

 A#    "" /  " 1/ 234

3       / 

/ 7     + G   &

    7  %

/           "   G 4"     ' 

 %    4"       :

 %          "  4"    

 & /.

&(.

" $  "  /    - 5=     /.

 

 7  

"     "    & 6    ?



/ D 5C D   ' //"7   0

# 59 D " ( 5(

"

  7 %  :

A "   %    4"           ""    "" /  "  1/ 2=

"  3 

%  4"       

  &    /".

&(.

" ($ ;

4 :

< / " &    

4:@ 4 6  7  

  .

 %%    (   %  9  (

4:- :-7

)     ) 4"     

   "  ( /

  &  4/   &     +    '    7 

"  7'

/ 

"    4   % ?



/ - 5C



 =    " 

( /7

 &4/  &  *    /7    - 59 - 5(

,& )      D@ 5 /"    4  ( )  7 &"

  /7    D5 52 //"  % D5 5( "'

%   0 5 7 &%   &  7  ,#+D @ 5

/7   &"    

4!8 7 % 7 "

  D5 5 :

A,#+D @ 5 

""   ( "'

% "

 &  *  ( 0 5( "    

,  D@ 5(

% &"     ""   7  "'

%  '

  

4!:8(&

4 7  7  /    55  (    ,2+ @@  "    "'

% 

7     .

& .

" ($ ?

   #   , (  , '

   (  7    

   4"       ( 

4  :@    :0  ;"<(  " )(  7  &    "          6      &        *  

(    ")        "   (    (  7

7'

%7  /  "    

 4"     = ( " "'

% '   (    6   )             

  & "   (

   "   

7 %  )7'

  " ) "    "       ( 4"    

 &        .

&  " (  $ ( 

7      "     7  

%    /       !

 8:(  4"    

  &  # , (, '

  (   (    

  7  7 %  !

-8: "  /    "

 "   

7 7'

%  "  ?     & 

    .

&       .

&

" ($ ( ?

 # , ( , '

  ( 7 

  &"  %

 """ " ((" / (

 % 4"      

 7 & & 0 5

 

7 7"  )  7 "  ) &  /"       &/

)& 

&)   "  

= %  (

,7  7 7   )    0 5"

 &    "

 "    / 

,  D@ 5    0 5

"    

4!8"%50 "":&'

    4       6   "          % ( ,//  , (.7($ )   "  D  ;

4:-< , )  % ($ )   "     ;

4  :-<       "  &     "/        )  / )     /    '

  /   "'

%       0 5  ;

4  !:<  "

"     



,  * 

  "%"

  ;"%55  "":&'< A= " /     

4

 

4  :-   &  

4  &     "     7      "     

4:-7 &%   & &   %,#+@0D @7 ""   7 7  " )       @"

 &

, (

4:- "    7  " &    

@ =  /"%   ;

4!8<(  '

'7     /) &   

 &.

"  

 &# ,  = %    

 &# , 7 " & "   (    7 )& ""  )  )   5 0= &    .

 74"      / =   4"    "  

&

7 /    - 57   4"      "   &

7 /0   -- 5

/ .

& "     7 %/".

" /0   -- 5     7  % )           &)  "      (  7 / &   % 3)

/     ?     #   , (  , '

     &

"  7       &

 & /   /"        

     //&

%&     

) &7  /   '"   -

&

(         &

// "  "%"

  ;

4!:8<"

 &   *     %/ / & " )  /   A   

    7 

 7  % 

  C;

A

  C<2 

 % (  * 

 // "  & ) 4"     ) /  &

 &&  (&   "   ( % (  %  ""     "   /             

  &  #   , (  , '

   ( 0   -- 5  5 - 57  

 &.

" ($ 9 "/ (  *                

  &  

    )    

-       

%   /"%

&  % ( %   " ) & 4"  &    7  &/

&

, &        6   =    & /     7 )

  

0   7 "    "  7'

7    .

" ("/ / "" &    %)  "  &      (7 " /

    6   

(7 7 4"    %,// 3   1/ 21/ 

4"   &%  (7  /" ) "  /%) /  "  7 F  "     /   ) /      "( (  " (

 / %  

 6     % &   1/ 234

3   =    "   / =

      &%  # 

  

 /    ( & "" /  ,//  1/ 2

 " /*) / 7 /&   "  &

"&  " )   

  )7 4"  

7' %,// 3   1/ 2( )&  ,// 3   1/ 2

 / &   /      )      =       7    

/ .

&") %    4"  & )         "     )    "     " ( 

  &

   /"/ 7 4"   "       &%  / (" (  /  /&)   ')    "      %"

 / (//  

 4"     /  (7   /      

   "/  

 "    /%      :@  7   .

"   %  & "    (  "  &    "    / 

,   4"       7   

  &  %  

    1  %    & 

  (  

&  &'&% 7   

/ .

& && ) =     ) 

% &  %  /"%      #( ;

4: <     $ ( 5 / > 

   )&   * 



'

  *     7 4"

  //   /

/ "  :

"'

%   "" % 

   

 

%

 7)&" ) &  %  7  7) 



5  

 7/ &

  / "   1  ( 4"     7 

 F  ( )  7  %   "

   (  /,% 7  % 7  "" /   %7    

(=/ ) 7 7  /  & 

  ' &% ( / &&  &(7   4"  ) &  :"/ =  /   (=

  6   )  4"    .

&

"      )&        :"/ 7  %  4"    & %' &% &  &  /

    .

&

" 

%

 4"      1 /(      % (,//  , ( .7($ )   "  D ;

4:-<(&  , ) 

% ($ )   "    ;

4:-<4"

    "

)  4"     %  =  /   (=   4"   7 "   7  6 /  % &  



   

    ( 7   :

     (    & %    7   %    "   %    "%"

 7 "      

 "" /      (

/(# (#   ' # '

7 7"" 

/&( 

% )/ / &

  &     &    :   * (  (



 "  7     " (        7  ""    /&(    =      

 /      5)    ) ,,%   ) 7 ) &  %"

/ 7  % =    " &  :"/ 

 7  % 7 / &" 2  % 7

""  &     ,//

   7        "/    "   7 +"   2  %   )  // 

     2  %   " /     (&/  7  

 ) &  "/  

/     "" /   " 7 

 /7  



%  

7 7     "     7)(      "     /     

/&( 9 / %'

7      

" (  %%% ) '"   )  %  ;

4:5<  @ D ( & "

& /" 7  % 7 &//&(  & 6  "" / 7 

@8-/

 "" /  7 

  7   =

% (      "/ ,(  %  (  ! # ) E = (;DD-< ,

@(     )  

, !  8

+

)      ;< ,   



% 

, / ! )   

  ;,2+0D @   

D 0<



D =  ) 7       &)(                :

"/  )  7  %  "

    /,% 7  % 7  "" /    ) 7   )&       

"

7     %  & :

   7

 )    4"      (  

"  / 

  %  &"

"  

 7 /

-     %  (& 

& ) &)(     /")'  "  7/    

%% )  4"    

% 8 / %   7"

7 ' 

  7 "

 %  /"%    %  "

 "     



,  ( "    /  ?"

 & ""     )  5 /&(

;

4:<   "    =  /   (=    "" %     /  /) & 





&   7  = ) 7 &)( 7 "   7   : *     

 "" /   " 1/ 234

3 7 

"  07'

/   "   "    

      /" %     /  6 /   

"" / 

&'     7    7 ""   %,   >  

& 4 &7    & &)  7 / )&



""   " /  7)(&  6   ( / &   7 &    7 &/   "" /   $ &'

'   (