Alimuddin And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another


  

 
  
 
   

!"#$%$



  

   

           



 &
 '()$ * )* )) ( ****   

   !"#  $     !"#   

 $ %

!  &   $ $ !"#  $ "

 '  !"#   (



 *+"

,!- ./0 $ )*+ ,        #  -.* / /   0   0       '  1       *2.3(.(- 

 0  

  4'!   " 5 #  #   0   #  6

  (  /  0 5   

"0      5    #6##  # 9:32 *2.7(.(*  # *-2;*-8;7(7;-3(;7.(:/)# *(.6%:/   + '  # ' ! #  )(+ <  #        0           # !  

 '5   

5    9:'  #  ' #     0

            ## 

5   '' '5     #      !  #  #    : #   ((

5    9:! 5" ! 

##   0  0   #       # 

- 2 - *=7 / / 0 0 !    5    '  3 

! !  !   ! 1! 00                " 

# " '     

0 #  # ' 

 ((*.(.(() > 7 -! #"+ )7+ 9     '             #  #        0?(#    "

  9:5 # # 5  '"  5' 0    #      #'  " #"05   # >#    #        

     0   5 #     

 " 0 

   / )-+ <   #        5    #     

   ( 0      

 5  " 0      0

 5 #" ""  #  #

 #   ' $ 5 #    #

0      ?( :    0   #  ! #'     0 '"  #  '  

 # !  #  '   #     #    

 #  #     #      /   % #     > /   
 

     

   5       0  #' #    #  7*8 / / #  0 > #     '  #   >     # !     #    5    # '     5     0 '   #   5         0  # 0# " # #   #  #'  ##    

- 3 - )3+   #      '  '   #  )@+   '  

0     #   /5 0  #        *7 ##  

  ,    #  #   #     *2.7(.(*! #  A    ! ! $  5  #       5      

  5  

     B       

 5 >:   " # !  #  > 

 4'     ?* 5  # #          # ?( ! #  !   ## 

5    5   ! ! 

     B    

    B  '"

05 0     '"  05    # B '" 05 0   !  $   #    0  0500    05000   0#     )=+ ,  '   "   '    "

   #  ?*!   #       6       ?(   '  '## ## 

! 5" !  ##  0  0   ##    " #  #   #          ?(  '  '     0   ##  !!$  0 C  

,  5 #   /  '

   #

   *(!5 #   #

0> #!5 #     6

- 4 -
 

   

      



     

  





 

 

          

     

 

     

    



!

 

!

"

 #$ )2+         0 "      ' '"  0   

  4'!      # " # '!   #     #  

 #       / ? 

 '     0  0 "     0              #  5 #  

1    '#  '0      ?*   ?6( 5       0       0 "     

 # ! " #'  05# "#   '    6  ## !!$  0  :      #!     0         #  ?*     #   ?(!  5  0 "       #  5     '    ## !   5#   #"     #  '0     ## '    

5    '   ## 

?   # " # ''  ""  # !  > 0

 '  #

##    00,  '  "    0   " #    5    # 1    " 5 5  #  '    0      5 

 )8+ ?    ' ##   /!   0 0          5     #  7*8     #     

- 5 - >    5  #  0> #    # 5   '  #' " ###

'  

  ' 0     " #  0    /      0 > #     #    #"   0  5 # # # '    #  5   #     # !          

   0#  #  5   '  # 5 

         5  ' '##

 #    0    !# 0 

    5  ""  ' ##

 #!   5     "

     #         "      5 #   0  9:# 5    #      5    "  #" '  ' '   05        '   %  )*.+ ,    /    !   " #    $ %   &!     '     "5     0   /   % #   
 

 

    '

(

"

 

)  

* ! 1"#  6 &' (  

  

    )    

 



  

#  *+,,  



  

- 



   

        

 

   - 

  

 

    

       

 



#  *+ ,,      - 

   )     







   

  -

  

-

 



  -



 

    



 

   

   

 

  ) 

- 6 - 

  

   

-

  

     



 

 

       -    (

     - 

 

   

#  *+,,

   %

& )**+ ,    /         '       #  0 0   " #0  # !  #

        "  #

6>  !  1  #   '  " #     00  ##,     0   5 #             #    > #         '  #  '! 0    #     >      " #!  ' 0!5# "# :  0  # #   # !  #     > #  '5   / )*(+ ,   "#   #  7*8 / / 1   #

  " #"0 0 ##    '  0  ##    # '  /  0 "    # 5'   #

   ' ##  

'    #' #  ## D '     #  7*8 # 

 5        #      5     

  5  '   " 0       ##    

   0     0 0 >#0  " ' '' #  

 #   0

"  0  " #   '  , '     # 0 '   5     #' E #     #         #

 

!   '

 

 #   # 7*8 #  '   )*7+ :    # !     #    5  " '0"  # #    ' #

- 7 -  !0 " #   5   # ''   

    5   #     #   ,  

   0    

     5         ;#  ##

 #   #

0  0    " '        " '      " # 5 

  1 0> 0       '     #  ,     0# # #5        ' #"'      ! #  >''   # # 0  #   # 0  )*-+ ##  '!        5        *2.3(.(- 

 0  

  4'!     0 1     

 (@.8(.(- .. *+"

,!- ./ 

- .

 *?     ';

 F G ; (?    0F G ;