Krishna Ganeriwal v. State Of Haryana





 



 !"


   

  
   "!#

,"

"&!& (0 1>2>2 $%&!'(  ("%&) * 222",&,&

("% ;"%!5!

%- ( +, ,"

 222"!< (3

,"

"&!& (0 1>2>2 3"(,

 (. /  &( 222",&,&

("% ;"%!5!

%- ( +, ,"

 222"!< (3 3"(,  

 JUSTICE MAN NJARI NEHRU KAUL
 %"!"(,0 MANJARI %2  % 4 $ ,'5%& 8 34  ,"8 %2% ,"".

3 48 34  ,"

% ,'" <",&,& %2 9 (3""<
''&( 8 8   %- ( 2 NEHRU KAUL  ,' ,'"

%"! &3 <",&,& (!

%" 3&!< !"3

)&,'

%3"% ! ,'

'"- ' 4" %&!"( 5,

,'" ! 6 6" 2  % 7%"4&,-8 ,'"

,! '

4"

7""( , ."( % 6


( ,'"

%"! &3 <",&,& (!8 ,'"

("%! ' 4" !

59', ("!!

!&

%"95* % 7 &* &(  !"    3 ,"3

22

5(3"% +",& (! :8  :8 :  
8 %"9&!,"%"3 ,  *&" +, ,& ( + + % & $' ) / 8 &!,%&,  %&3 7 2 =" %("3 5(!"*

% ,'" <",&,& & ("%! ' 4" , ,'"

5,!", 3% )( ,,"(,&

,'&!
5%, , (,"(,!

, ,'"  )'&' ) ! %"9&!,"%"3 ,

&(!, ("

,'" !

,'" 3"" !"32 , ' ! 7""( !!"%,"3 7- ,'"

5(!"* ,' , <"%5! *

,'" **"9 ,& (! *"4"*"3 &( ,'"  *" %*- %"4" *! ,' , ,'" ("%! ' 4" ( , 7""( ( 6"3 ,'"%"&( ( % &! ,'"%" (- !<"& & **"9 ,& *"4"*"3 9 &(!, ,'"6 !

! , &(4&," ,'" 6&!'&"

"(" 5(3"% +",& : 
? &, ' ! 7""( !!"%,"3 7- ,'" *" %("3 5(!"* ,' , ,'" 3"

&(&,&

@
A ! <% 4&3"3 5(3"% +",& ( 1>

,'" (3& ( "( *
3" &! *!

, ,,% ,"3 &( ,'" &(!, (,  !"2 , ' ! 7""( 5%,'"% !576&,,"3 ,' , 36&,,"3*- ,'"%" )"%" (

&( (& * ,% (! ,& (! 7",)""( ,'" 3"" !"3 (3 ,'" <",&,&  ,'"% *" %("3 5(!"* ' ! !!"%,"3 ,' , <"%5! *

(,"(,!

,'"  %"4" *! ,' , & , **8

"(" 5(3"% +",& ( :

,'" 
7",6"(,

!5&&3"# ) 5*3 7" ,,% ,"3 (*- B5 ,'"

6<* &( (,8 ! &, ) ! , '&!

&(!,&9 ,& (8 '&! "(,&%"

6&*- ' 3 ,,"6<,"3 , "(3 ,'"&% *&4"!2 =" %("3

5(!"* ' ! !576&,,"3 ,' , 5!"38 &6 (!'5  (! *8 )' ' ! 7""( !<"& & **- ( 6"3 &( ,'"  &( B5"!,& ( (3 ' 3 *!

7""( ( 6"3 &( ,'"

!5&&3" ( ," **"9"3*- *"

, 7"'&(3 7- ,'" 3"" !"3 ' 3 !&(" 7""( "C,"(3"3 ("!!&

7 &* 4&3"

%3"% 3 ,"3 12>2

7- ,'" *" %("3 ,%& * 5%,2

=" %("3 +, ,"

5(!"* )'&*"

<< !&(9 ,'" <% -"% ' ! ( , 7""( 7*" ,

(,% 4"%, ,'" !576&!!& (! 6 3" 7- ,'"

<< !&,"

5(!"* B5 ,'"%"

7"&(9 ( **"9 ,& ( 65' *"!! 7- ) -

)'&!<"% *"4"*"3 9 &(!, 7 ,' ,'"

("%!? &, ' ! *!

, 7""( 3&!<5,"3 ,' , ,'"%" )"%" 36&,,"3*- (

(", %- ,% (! ,& (! 7",)""( ,'"

6<* &( (,< %,-D3"" !"3 ! )"** ! ,'"

("%!2  )"4"%8 &, ' ! 7""( !576&,,"3 ,' , 35%&(9 ,'" &(4"!,&9 ,& (8 &,  6" , *&9', ( ,'" 7 !&!

;

, 9" ,' , ,'"

5!"3 ' 3 6" ,

,'" %"!&3"("

6<* &( (, < %,-D3"" !"3 &(  % )'&' ) !

%"9&!,"%"3 &( ,'" ( 6"

!&!,"%&(* )

,'" <",&,& ("%8  (. /  &(2 '"%"

,"% ,'" <",&,& ("%8  (. /  &( ) ! %%"!,"3 (3 '" !5

"%"3 3&!* !5%" !, ,"6"(, ( 6&( ,&(9 <",&,& ("%$%&!'(  ("%&) * ! ( 5!"3 &( ,'" <%"!"(,  !" )'"%"&( '" !, ,"3 ,' , ,'" <",&,& ("% ,

) ! <%"!"(, )'"( ,'" !"5%&,- 95 %3

,'" 3"" !"3 ) ! , ."( ) - % 6 ,'" <* "

5%%"("2 =" %("3 +, ,"

5(!"* ( &(!,%5,& (! ' !

5%,'"% !576&,,"3 ,' , + ' ! ( ) 7""( (!,&,5,"3 &( ,'" <%"!"(,  !" (3 '"("8 &, ) 5*3 , ."

!

6" ,&6" , <%"!"(, ,'"

&( * %"< %,2 2  ' 4" '" %3 *" %("3 5(!"*

% ,'" < %,&"! (3 <"%5!"3 ,'"

6 ,"%& * <* "3 ( %"

%32 :2 "

%" <% ""3&(9 &, ) 5*3 7" << !&," , 6"(,& ( ,' , ,'"

**"9 ,& (! *"4"*"3 &( ,'" 8 )'&' &! %"<% 35"3 ! 5(3"%0 E   

  
  

 
   
 
  
   

  !"



 
#  

  


$%&  '# (     
  )   


   * 

  

)+

),  

 
 

*   - 
 .


 )
  /     

 ) )  #   0 
   /
    1  )     -
&
 '


 2 
 0  



 0 )
  3 .


 )  # *  
 
     
 4    

  )  
     
#   # 5 

   

 6

  3
  0 

 
  

 

)    # 
 

5 
 

 
   

 ) 
 *     


)  

7 * 

 6 
3 

   * #  8 9  ,9  4    

 
 
 
 
 )     

  )   0

:

0 #
*) 
)
 9'. 
 13 .
     - 
 ;
  .



 3
 8   
    
  
  
   5



    
 # *  )  3  
  
 
    6 
 ) 




 
*


 4453  *<    
  *
 # **
 
3  0  
)         
    3*
 # 
3 
)
0  ) * 

 
 *
  

 
 


 

 )     

    0


:
 0 #
*
  

 = 
 *  
#  #     
  )  3 # 
 )     
*   5  * 
 
)
   
   
 "


    
 )    
  
  
 
 
 
  
  
#         
- 
 .


 )
  13.
3
8  

 )  

  *

 
3
*
  2F  <"%5! *

,'"  &( B5"!,& ( %"4" *! ,' , ,'" <",&,& ("%! )"%"

("&,'"% ( 6"3 ,'"%"&(8 ( % (- **"9 ,& (!

7",6"(, )"%" *"4"*"3 9 &(!, ,'"62 5%,'"%6 %"8 ! ( , 3&!<5,"3 7- ,'" *" %("3 +, ,"

5(!"*8 ,'"%" )"%"

(", %- ,% (! ,& (! 7",)""( ,'"

6<* &( (, < %,-D3"" !"3 (3 ,'"

("%!2 '"

 5!"3 )'

) ! !<"& & **- ( 6"3 &( ,'"  &( B5"!,& ( ! )"** ! &( ,'" **"9"3 !5&&3" ( ," ' ! *%" 3- 7""( "C,"(3"3 ,'"

("!!&

%"95* % 7 &*2 >2 '" <",&,& ("%!8 $%&!' (  ("%&) * (3  (. /  &(8 ' 4" ( ) 7""( &( 5!, 3-

% 6 %" ,' ( 6 (,'

,"% ' 4&(9 7""( %%"!,"3 2:2

(3 :2:2

%"!<",&4"*-2 '" &(4"!,&9 ,& ( ' ! *%" 3- 7""( ,% (!

"%%"3 , + (3 ) 5*3 ,'5! , ." ,&6" ,

(*53"2 :2 ( ,'"

,! (3 &%56!, ("! ! "(56"% ,"3 '"%"&( 7 4"8 ,'&!

5%, 3""6! &, &, , "C,"(3 ,'"

("!!&

%"95* % 7 &* , ,'" <",&,&  %3&(9*-8 ,'" &(!, (, <",&,& ( &! ** )"32 '" <",&,& ("%! 7" 36&,,"3 ,

7 &* !57/", , 5%(&!'&(9

7 &*D!5%",- 7 (3! , ,'" ! ,&!

,& ( , ,%& *
5%,D 5,-  9&!,% ,"

("%("32

>2  )"4"%8 &, &! 6 3" *" % ,' , (-,'&(9 7!"%4"3 '"%"&( 7 4"

!' ** ( , 7"

(!,%5"3 , 7" ( "C<%"!!&

<&(& ( ,'" 6"%&,!

 !"2 1>2>2

MANJARI NEHRU KAUL

  G'",'"% !<" .&(9D%" !

("30 "!D G'",'"% %"< %, 7*"0 "!D