High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17089/2016dismissed

Jagsir Singh v. Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal Bathinda And ORS

2023-11-06Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger12 pages

" !

!#$% (%)*+*&, --

#.+*/ 0*,.1 ------ %$*$*&,%/

+ 2%/+3+ /%+*(*,.

''*)%/4 ,(3+$/*#5 /*63,#54 #$1*,(# &$1%/+

------

%+7&,(%,$

+ 8 9

0 0

/%+%,$ +- 1#.:#+1/*4 (;&)#$%

/- <#:

#5 0*,.14 (;&)#$%

7%$*$*&,%/-

/- /;*,( 1#=3/4 (;&)#$%

/%+7&,(%,$+ &-

- - - 0

- %$*$*&,%/

#.+*/ 0*,.1 1#+ '*5%( *,+$#,$ *;*5 /*$ %$*$*&, /$*)5%+

&,+$*$3$*&, ,(*#4 +%%=*,.

>/*$

,#$3/% )%/$*&/#/* ?3#+1*,.

>#/( (#$%( --

,,%@3/% 4 7#++%( 9%#/,%( ,(3+$/*#5 /*63,#54 #$1*,(#

1%/%*,#'$%/ /%'%//%( 8$1% /*63,#58 >1%/%6:

/%'%/%,)% *,(3+$/*#5 (*+73$% /#*+%( /%.#/(*,.

$%/A*,#$*&, 1*+ +%/;*)%+4 1#+ 6%%, #,+>%/%( #.#*,+$ 1*A-

'3/$1%/ 7/#:%/ 1#+ 6%%, A#(% (*/%)$*,.

/%+7&,(%,$+ &-

1%/%*,#'$%/ /%'%//%( 8/%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$8

/%*,+$#$% +%/;*)% &A73$%/ 7%/#$&/++*+$#,$ >*$1 )&,$*,3*$:

+%/;*)% &$1%/ )&,+%?3%,$*#5 6%,%'*$+-

/*%'5:4 /#*+%( #, *,(3+$/*#5 (*+73$% /%.#/(*,.

$%/A*,#$*&, 1*+ +%/;*)%+-

1% +#*( (*+73$% >#+ /%'%//%( #(<3(*)#$*&, 6%5&>- , )5#*A +$#$%A%,$4 75%#(%( 1% >#+ +%/;*,.

&A73$%/ 7%/#$&/++*+$#,$ #$ %1+*5 #,+#4 !*+$/*)$ #,+# +*,)% - - -

*+ +%/;*)%+ >%/% $%/A*,#$%(

- 4 >*$1&3$ #,:

,&$*)%4 )1#/.%+1%%$4 %,?3*/:

)&A7%,+#$*&,4 #$ $*A% 1*+ $%/A*,#$*&,4 1% >#+ 6%*,.

7#*(

+- 4 7%/ A&,$1-

1% '3/$1%/ )5#*A%( ,%> 1#,(+ 1#;% 6%%, /%)/3*$%( %,.#.*,.

)&,$/#)$&/ (%7/*;% >&/=A#, *$+ /*.1$+ 3,%A75&:%(-

1% ,%@$ )5#*A%( 1*+ +%/;*)%+ 1#;% 6%%, $%/A*,#$%( ;*&5#$*&, 7/&;*+*&,+ ,(3+$/*#5 !*+73$%+ )$4

1%/%*,#'$%/ /%'%//%( 8 )$8-

))&/(*,.5:4 7/#:%( /%*,+$#$%A%,$ >*$1 )&,$*,3*$:

+%/;*)% &$1%/ )&,+%?3%,$*#5 6%,%'*$+-

- 1% #'&/%+#*( )5#*A >#+ )&,$%+$%( /%+7&,(%,$ #,#.%A%,$ /#*+*,.

7/%5*A*,#/:

&6<%)$*&, >#+ )&;%/%( (%'*,*$*&, >&/=A#, 0%)$*&,

+ )$ ,%*$1%/ /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ >#+ )&;%/%( (%'*,*$*&, 8*,(3+$/:8-

)#$%.&/*) &6<%)$*&, >#+ $#=%, /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ )&A75%$%(

(#:+ :%#/ 7/%)%(*,.

(#$% 1*+ $%/A*,#$*&,-

$ >#+ )5#/*'*%( >#+ %A75&:%( /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$4 /#$1%/ 1% >#+ )#55%( '/&A $*A% $*A% $%)1,*)#5 #++*+$#,)% >1%,%;%/ 1*+ +%/;*)% >#+ /%?3*/%( 1% >#+ 7#*( /%$#*,%/+1*7

'%%-

$ >#+ +36A*$$%( +%/;*)%+ >%/% 1*/%( )#55 6#+*+ %)1,*)#5 ++*+$#,$ +*,)% /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ /%)%*;%( *,+$/3)$*&,+ '/&A 1*.1%/ #3$1&/*$*%+ 1*/% +%/;*)%+ !#$# ,$/:

7%/#$&/&A73$%/ 7%/#$&/%)1,*)#5 ++*+$#,$ &3$+&3/)% 6#+*+4 #))&/(*,.5:4 +%/;*)%+ >%/% ,& A&/% /%?3*/%(-

1% &$1%/ #;%/A%,$+#55%.#$*&,+ A#(% >%/% (%,*%( /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ 7/#:%/ /%<%)$*&, )5#*A >#+ A#(%- - , 6#+*+ 75%#(*,.+ 7#/$*%+4 6%5&> '/#A%( '&55&>*,.

*++3%+

# $

% & B- , +377&/$ 1*+ )5#*A4 +$%77%( *,$& >*$,%++ 6&@ $%,(%/%( 1*+ #''*(#;*$ @- '*5%( (&)3A%,$+ @- @-

, &$1%/ 1#,(4 /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ %@#A*,%( &,% #/+1#,$ #/.4 !*+$/*)$ 0:+$%A #,#.%/ >1& $1%,(%/%( 1*+ #''*(#;*$ @- #5&,.>*$1 (&)3A%,$+ @- @-B-

7&, )&,+*(%/*,.

A#$%/*#5%;*(%,)% #;#*5#65% /%)&/(4 6%5&>4 ;*(% *A73.,%( >#/( (#$%( --

,,%@3/% 4 /%<%)$%( )5#*A 7%$*$*&,%/- - , #'&/%A%,$*&,%( )*/)3A+$#,)%+4 1#+ '*5%(

*,+$#,$ >/*$ 7%$*$*&, 6%'&/% $1*+ &3/$-

- 1#;% 1%#/( 5%#/,%( )&3,+%5 7#/$*%+ 1#;% #5+& 7%/3+%( 7#7%/6&&= >*$1 $1%*/ #65% #++*+$#,)%- , *,+$#,$ )#+%4 75%#(%( )#+% >#+ 1% >#+ %,.#.%( /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ &A73$%/ 7%/#$&/++*+$#,$ +*,)% - - 1*+ +%/;*)%+ >%/% $%/A*,#$%(

- 4 >1%/%#+ &$1%/ 1#,(4 *$ >#+ )#$%.&/*) )#+% /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ >#+ ,%;%/ %A75&:%( *$4

/#$1%/4 1% >#+ )#55%( '/&A $*A% $*A% $%)1,*)#5 #++*+$#,)% >1%,%;%/ 1*+ +%/;*)%+ >%/% /%?3*/%( 1% >#+ 6%*,.

7#*( /%$#*,%/+1*7 '%%-

%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ $#=%, )#$%.&/*) +$#,( )&A75%$%(

(#:+ :%#/ 7/%)%(*,.

(#$% 1*+ #55%.%( $%/A*,#$*&,-

- $ >%55 +%$$5%( 7/&7&+*$*&, &,3+ 7/&;% *++3% /%.#/(*,.

/%5#$*&,+1*7 %A75&:%%%A75&:%/ #,(&/ *++3% 7/&;*,.

)&,$*,3&3+ +%/;*)% >&/=A#, #,#.%A%,$ $%/A+ 0%)$*&,

B )$ +& #$$/#)$ 7/&;*+*&,+ 0%)$*&,

)$4 /%+$+ 37&, >&/=A#,- - 1*5% )&,+*(%/*,.

#, *++3% %@*+$%,)% /%5#$*&,+1*7 %A75&:%/ %A75&:%% 6%$>%%, 7#/$*%+4

!!"#$%&"4 &,865% 037/%A% &3/$ 1%5( 3,(%/ '( ) *

* * * * + * *,

*, - - *

/0 1 2 , 3*4 2*

5 - 6 7

8(% 9 0 %8. : ;

0 < =3 - * -

- *,) *, *

*, * - , * *,) *, *= '8

2 *

3 ?

9 - 0 @

8(A 0 "B" - <

C1%/% 7%/+&, #++%/$+ 1% >#+ >&/=A%, &A7#,:4 *$ (%,*%( )&A7#,:4 *$ 1*A 7/&;% '#)$- $ &A7#,:

7/&;% 1% >#+ #, %A75&:%% &A7#,:

63$ +&A% &$1%/ 7%/+&,-C AB 3 C * -

* *,

*, * C

, ;

0 +

, - , *DE

3/$1%/4 >1*5% )&,+*(%/*,.

#, *++3% >1%$1%/ >&/=A#, )&A75%$%(

(#:+ >&/= A#,#.%A%,$ $%/A+ 0%)$*&,

B 4 +& #$$/#)$ 7/&;*+*&,+ +%)$*&,

,(3+$/*#5 !*+73$%+ )$4 4 7%$*$*&,%/>&/=A#, >#+ /%?3*/%( 7/&;% 1% >&/=%(

(#:+

A&,$1+ 7/%)%(*,.

(#$% >1%, 1% >#+ #55%.%(5:

*55%.#55:

$%/A*,#$%( /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$- , &/(%/ (*+)1#/.% &,3+ 7/&;*,.

#'&/%+$#$%( '#)$ 1#;*,.

>&/=%(

(#:+

A&,$1+ 7/%)%(*,.

(#$% 1*+ #55%.%(5:

$%/A*,#$*&,4 (*( 5%#( %;*(%,)% %*$1%/ '&/A +$#$%A%,$ #,:

)&>&/=%/ #,:

&$1%/ %;*(%,)%

'&/A 7/&&'

/%)%*7$ +#5#/:

>#.%+

(#:+ #,:

&/(%//%)&/( #77&*,$A%,$ %,.#.%A%,$ /%5%;#,$ 7%/*&(- 1% >&/=A#, (*( 5%#( #,:

%;*(%,)% 7/&;% 1% >&/=%(

(#:+

A&,$1+ 7/%)%(*,.

(#$% >1%, 1% >#+ #55%.%(5:

$%/A*,#$%( /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$- $ >%55 +%$$5%( 5#> A%/% #''*(#;*$+ +%5'+%/;*,.

+$#$%A%,$+ A#(% )5#*A#,$>&/=A#, >*55 +3''*)% A#$$%/ (*+)1#/.% 63/(%, 75#)%( 5#> >&/=A#, 7/&;% 1% >&/=%(

(#:+ .*;%, :%#/- , $1*+ /%.#/(4 /%'%/%,)% )#, 6% A#(% )#+%

!!""# && (

)*(*+* ,

* !!%-# .%! - &A*,.

)#+% 1#,(4 6%5&>4 1#+ /%$3/,%( '&55&>*,.

'*,(*,.+ F @

* * "'B ,

, **

* * "'B ,

*, *

* *

/ **

*, -, *

- * *

- 5 5+ ) 5+ )F *

5+ )" 5+ )F ** C * , -

5+)

C -, 2-)

* , 3

* , -

, ,

*, -, * * ( 3 4 *

, - * 3 -

- *

- - ***

, * 3 -

, + * *,

*, - *

+ * - * * 3 -

, @

*, * * * "'B , . 2 *

3 -

*, *

* * "'B ,

, ;

& 8

* -,

@ * - ?

- & & E

7%/3+#5 #6&;% %@$/#)$%( '*,(*,.+ /%$3/,%( 6%5&> >&35( A#,*'%+$ '#*5%( (*+)1#/.% &,3+ 75#)%( 37&, 1*A 5#> +1&> 1% >&/=%(

(#:+ 7/%)%(*,.

)#5%,(#/ A&,$1+ '/&A (#$% 1*+ $%/A*,#$*&,-

- $ 1#+ )&A% /%)&/( >#:

)/&++ %@#A*,#$*&, 1% >#+ ,%*$1%/ *++3%( #,:

#77&*,$A%,$ 5%$$%/ ,&/ #,:

$%/A*,#$*&, &/(%/ >#+ .*;%, 1*A-

1% '3/$1%/ #(A*$$%( $1%/% >#+ ,& #$$%,(#,)% /%)&/( #,:

&$1%/ /%)&/( +1&>*,.

'#)$ 1% +%/;%( /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$

(#:+ A&/% 1% /%A#*,%( %A75&:%( >*$1 /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$-

$ 1#+ '3/$1%/ 6%%, &6+%/;%( 6%5&> $1%/% ,& %,$/:

)#+1 6&&= +1&>*,.

'#)$ >#+ %;%/ %A75&:%( /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ 1% %;%/ >&/=%( >*$1 *$-

))&/(*,.5:4 6%5&> 1#+ )&,)53(%( ,%;%/ /%A#*,%( %A75&:%% /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ ,%*$1%/ 1% >&/=%( >*$1 *$ 7%/*&(

(#:+ A&/% 5#+$ )#5%,(#/ :%#/-

1% ,%*$1%/ 6%'&/% 6%5&> ,&/ 6%'&/% $1*+ &3/$ 1#+ 6%%, #65% +1&> 1% /%,(%/%( )&,$*,3&3+ +%/;*)% /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$ $%/A+ 0%)$*&,

B )$4 +& )5#*A 6%,%'*$ 0%)$*&,

)$-

, #6+%,)% #,:

+3)1 A#$%/*#5%;*(%,)% 7%$*$*&,%/4 ,& /%5*%'

)#, 6% ./#,$%( 7%$*$*&,%/-

B- + /%.#/(+ 75%# #(;%/+% *,'%/%,)% 6% (/#>, #.#*,+$ /%+7&,(%,$(%7#/$A%,$ 7/&(3)*,.

/%5%;#,$ /%)&/(4 *$ &6+%/;%( (/#>*,.

#(;%/+% *,'%/%,)% &7$*&,#5 &65*.#$&/:

+#A% >*$1*, (&A#*, ,(3+$/*#5 /*63,#5-

3/$1%/4 (/#>*,.

#(;%/+% *,'%/%,)% (%7%,(+ '#)$+ )*/)3A+$#,)%+ %#)1 )#+% #(;%/+% *,'%/%,)% )#,,&$ 6% (/#>, &,5:

6%)#3+% *$ 5#>'35 (& +&- , *,+$#,$ )#+%4 6%5&> 1#+ (/#>, #,:

#(;%/+% *,'%/%,)%-

3/$1%/A&/%4 #7#/$ '/&A 6#/% 75%# ,&,7/&(3)$*&, /%5%;#,$ /%)&/( /%+7&,(%,$#,#.%A%,$D $1%/% ,& 75%# /%+7&,(%,$ #,#.%A%,$ 1#+ +377/%++%( /%5%;#,$ /%)&/(- , #6+%,)% +3)1 75%# +377/%++*&,4 ,& #(;%/+% *,'%/%,)% )#, 6% (/#>, #.#*,+$ /%+7&,(%,$ (%7#/$A%,$-

, $1*+ /%.#/(4 /%'%/%,)% )#, 6% A#(% <3(.A%,$ &,E65% 7%@ &3/$ /0

12 1

!!%"# 34%4 >1%/%*, *$ 1#+ 6%%, 1%5( 3,(%/ A D 3 -

)

- * -,

* "'B ,

, 3 - , ) * *

, *

** -,

- -

9 , - , - *

, ;

0 $ ""F 0

-, - , * 3 + * * DE

3/$1%/A&/%4 7#/#A%$%/+ %@%/)*+% <3/*+(*)$*&, *.1 &3/$ /$*)5%

&,+$*$3$*&, ,(*# )#+%+ *,;&5;*,.

)1#55%,.% #>#/( 7#++%( 9#6&3/ &3/$,(3+$/*#5 &/(%/+ 7#++%( &$1%/ <3(*)*#5 ?3#+*<3(*)*#5 6&(*%+ #/% >%55 (%'*,%(-

>/*$ )%/$*&/#/* )#, 6% *++3%( )&//%)$*,.

%//&/+ <3/*+(*)$*&, )&AA*$$%( *,'%/*&/ &3/$+ /*63,#5+-

>/*$ )#, #5+& 6% *++3%( >1%/% %@%/)*+% <3/*+(*)$*&, )&,'%//%( *$4 &3/$ #)$+ *55%.#55:

*A7/&7%/5:

*-%- *$ (%)*(%+ ?3%+$*&, >*$1&3$ .*;*,.

#, &77&/$3,*$:

6% 1%#/( 7#/$:

#''%)$%( &/(%/ >1%/% 7/&)%(3/% #(&7$%( *$ &77&+%( 7/*,)*75%+ ,#$3/#5 <3+$*)%- &>%;%/4 *$ A3+$ 6% /%A%A6%/%( <3/*+(*)$*&, *.1 &3/$ *++3% >/*$ )%/$*&/#/* +37%/;*+&/:

<3/*+(*)$*&, #77%55#$% &,%- 1*+ ,%)%++#/*5:

A%#,+ '*,(*,.

'#)$ /%#)1%( *,'%/*&/ &3/$ /*63,#54 /%+35$ #77/%)*#$*&, %;*(%,)%4 )#,,&$ 6% /%&7%,%( ?3%+$*&,%( >/*$ 7/&)%%(*,.+ %@)%7$ >1%, <3(.A%,$4 &/(%/ #>#/( +3''%/+ '/&A #, %//&/ 5#> #77#/%,$ '#)% /%)&/(- 1*+ #6+$/#)$ +$#$%A%,$ 5#>4 63$ ;%@%( ?3%+$*&, >1#$ #, %//&/ 5#> #77#/%,$ '#)% /%)&/( >1#$ )*/)3A+$#,)%+ '*,(*,.

'#)$ /%)&/(%( #,

*,'%/*&/ &3/$ ?3#+*<3(*)*#5 #3$1&/*$:

)#, 6% )&//%)$%(- /&#(5:

+7%#=*,.4 #, %//&/ 5#> &,% >1*)1 )#, 6% (*+)&;%/%( 6#/% /%#(*,.

<3(.A%,$4 &/(%/ #>#/( )1#55%,.% #5&,.

>*$1 (&)3A%,$+ >1*)1 1#;% 6%%, /%5*%( 37&, *,'%/*&/ &3/$4 ?3#+*<3(*)*#5 #3$1&/*$:- , %//&/4 (*+)&;%/:

>1*)1 7&++*65% &,5:

#'$%/ (%$#*5%( +)/3$*,:

%;*(%,)% 7/&(3)%( 7#/$*%+ 5%,.$1:

(%6#$% #$ 6#/ )#,,&$ 6% /%.#/(%( #, %//&/ 5#> 73/7&+% >/*$ )%/$*&/#/*-

'*,(*,.

'#)$ /%)&/(%( #, *,'%/*&/ &3/$ )#, 6% )&//%)$%( &,5:

*$ +1&>, /%)&/(*,.

+#*( '*,(*,.

&3/$ %//&,%&3+5:

/%'3+%( #(A*$ #(A*++*65% A#$%/*#5 %;*(%,)% %//&,%&3+5:

#(A*$$%( *,#(A*++*65% %;*(%,)% +#A% 1#+ *,'53%,)%( *A73.,%( '*,(*,.- 0*A*5#/5:4 '*,(*,.

'#)$ 6#+%( ,& %;*(%,)% >&35( 6% /%.#/(%( #, %//&/ 5#> >1*)1 )#, 6% )&//%)$%( >/*$ )%/$*&/#/*- &>%;%/4 +3''*)*%,):

#(%?3#):

%;*(%,)% /%5*%( 37&, *,'%/*&/ &3/$ ?3#+*<3(*)*#5 #3$1&/*$:

)#,,&$ 6% .&,% *,$& *.1 &3/$ >1*5% )&,+*(%/*,.

7/#:%/ *++3% >/*$ )%/$*&/#/*- 9*=%>*+%4 A%/%4 7&++*6*5*$:

'&/A*,.

(*''%/%,$ &7*,*&, /%#77/%)*#$*&, %;*(%,)% 7#/$*%+ +3''*)*%,$ *++3% >/*$ )%/$*&/#/* 0+5/*

,6/ &43" "..7 * * * 8 *+ 5 9 *5 +*

,6/&4.!3&7 :

* /* * ; * , ;*' * ,6/&4-"4.37/ )<+ *

&444"#//

# %$#=:&4443#%!.*

**'> ,* * 6 ,(: ?

: !! -#34 - 1%, '#)$+ )*/)3A+$#,)%+ $1*+ )#+% #5+& '*,(*,.+ /%$3/,%( 9#6&3/ &3/$ #/% )&,+*(%/%( 5*.1$ 5%.#5 7&+*$*&, *,(*)#$%( #6&;%4 (& '*,( #,:

*55%.#5*$:

*,'*/A*$:

>*$1 *A73.,%( #>#/( (#$%( --

,,%@3/% 4 >1*)1 A#:

)#55 #,:

*,$%/'%/%,)% $1*+ &3/$4 >1*5% %@%/)*+*,.

*$+ >/*$ <3/*+(*)$*&,- 1%/%'&/%4 *,+$#,$ >/*$ 7%$*$*&, 6%/%'$ #,:

A%/*$ +#A% #))&/(*,.5:

(*+A*++%(- - 7%,(*,.

#775*)#$*&, +4 *'

#,:4 +1#55 +$#,( )5&+%(-

-- +<=+ 1%$1%/ +7%#=*,./%#+&,%(

"%+

& 1%$1%/ /%7&/$#65% "%+