← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18797/2014allowed

Chandigarh Administration And ANR v. Babloo Kumar And ORS

2025-03-26Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mrs. Justice Meenakshi I. Mehta11 pages



          ! 

"#"$%"&'(

)  *+" ",-#-'( ./

)    

              

       ) ! 

              

/    .) )

          

   

      /.     

             

! "  

 

  

  

 

  #####

- -

$%&' ( )"  *   ' '+ '

"  *     ,-./01023.4  ,-2356323./  '  7 "  * "  '  7  *   '  "  *     ,-.4023.8    

-46,-./01023.4   

-0/,-.683023.8  ' 9  :  *    '   :  *      ,-.683023.8 -8,-./01023.4 -0,-.4023.8  '

 "  *    '   7$"  *      -.,-./01023.4  ,-.4023.8;  -6, -.683023.8 -   -5& < ,-./01023.4 -   -2& < ,-.4023.8  ' '  ((" (      

-2 4,-.683023.8  '

'=$"  *   '  *  "  *    

-5 8& !,-.4023.8  ' ) (>"(       -.& < ,-.683023.8 

 .  $ $  *

 * 

  &*  &  ,    /0 0      

$  

 

 ! "   * ?   @  ! AB 

-1- 2/3.23.4  $  1--  $ * &   ?  $   -. ,     0 &&      @ AB"    1/     



    $ ! 213423.8     /2 12   ? $ 

 -5 1    & 

& B"

 $ ?! B

 &    2/3.23.4 *   

$ 2.3123.0    /2 $         

   213423.8  " * C

 *

    &  2   *

 $  *

"*      

 & "     &   & *    1-- + C     .63823.23.3023.2" 

C  *    $  C

*     

( >   $!** D $  $

 $ "   *"    $  

  *  

 -5  4          )  >   $!** ?  @ AB C    (  $>

" * *  

  .531233."

 ?

B  *     ( >   $!**      " 

 "   D $  $ 9

- -    & <   )>! ?

B 

  2836.118 -5&7   '*;9  (*  &52" ?  @ 7'9AB * *   (  $>

)>!

E)>!

?

B 24.3.116"     ( -./F  &  >



  2632.110!   "*   *   ?38B$ )>!?

B"  C

&7'9 *   *    D  

( >   $!**9  "  

   .531233."  -5

    (  $>

 )>!

)>!

?

B"    *  $  )>!

 ?

B    *    )>!

    *  *  

) >   $!**?

B ) !**?

B"  

$*    *       ?  B    $    !      -4&= *    *" 7'9 +   

     & *    *   * 

     )>!

   

"

   (     ? $   

 -4  6         , /0 0B

( >   $!**   *    *   $     $& *  $   *  $& *

)>!

?

B   

-0- 5 

 -.  4   1--     

&

*

*  "    *C* 



!** G* )>!

?

BH      *    

   .531233.  C $"  

 *     =

"          "    *    *       

( >   $!**      * 

  *   

)>!  * '*>   $!**7 & '   "

 

 !**    *      =

 

 $    

  )>!

  *         =

7'9*" * +   $          $& *     * "        * &  < "  *  

" & $ 

-. 4  

&

   *      !     1--        2/3.23.4 4           $   

 

 7'9   0  $ 

(    /0 0   $    ? $  

-8"06

-/- * $ 1-- B

 &     2/3.23.4     1/  $  &   

7'9? $  

-25 /2 12  B 

   

$ ! 213423.8"   /2 12      $ *

 ("   "

  "!

+"     "  >       ? $   

-5 1  1/ #"   + ?

B7'9"   $ ?! B      2/3.23.4  1--

 $*   

2.3123.0  

  *34*56674+$'4% /  $   &    

 !    

 

, 

      

0   *

* &       &

   

*

  1-- 8 ,     * *      *     -.&*  ,- ./01023.4.4023.8   (     

-2"54,-.683023.8"  *   

-5 8& !,-.4023.8  (    & < ,-.683023.8       * $

-- 6 >   * *     * 

)>!

)>!

?

B  E *

* * C* 

E * 



      $  " )>!?

B     $ <  ! $     C   +  $        "  *  

)>!?

B" **$ $ * 

   $ *  $"  * $**

 )>!

?

B  $ *

E

*   $       $& *   

)>!

?

B   * (  $>

*

F* *  

  2632.110?  @  (  $>

AB"  C $"  * 

         * *

*  &     *   *    $  )>!

"  

   *"        

D $ 0  &* "   *        & *     (  $>

)>!

?

B  *   $& *  

  $   &   *      &=

 $   *  $ )>!

?

B   &  (  $>



--  * *    (  $ >

    G)>!

 ?

BH

*           $& *    

( >   $!**?   ( '*>   $!**B    

* *   *

* *  * " !    $  1--

    /2 12  *34*56674+$'4% / ** $"     /



$"        

)>!?

B 

  2836.118" *  

3436.118?D 2 .  * $      *   D ?36B

)>!

?

B   

*  

   

   ** 

*  *

)>!

?

B

 

  *;'*I* ( *?

 !**B ".113?  @  .113AD  .4. .83   B   * !"      D& "

*

 ?  "  

!**

 ( -46

>   $!**E>

7 & E ) !**  ( -83    *  *$  4    

C*  

)>!

)>!

?

B    %&

- - 0 *1" #+ &2,*+-'*342*3- -,*+-' . ) >   $ !** ?

B ?$ (* .233&2.33B ?B' * (** * *  

 !    $  D * $ *F $ ?B  *  

   C*  2 ) >   $ !** ?$ (* .233& 2.33

 C $  ./33&5233B ?B ' *  (**" =   '* > !** $ *F 

  ?B  *  

   C*  1

D @=A?  -.8/.81 

 B*

* *&   

  **$      9 (   $ II 

 )>! 

 ( -2 , &>

 C  D ** )>!

=

$ C*   

   

   =

 , &>

* *   

)>!?

B *    C*    ! & *

 *

 -4    *& C *$

+  *  .113" * !"      "  *   *

*    )>!

?

B  "  *

--  $" (  $>

 $   &  *   * * 

  2632.110 $& *

 & 

  "*"$

*  " *

 $*  

* E    

 &  

 *  .3 !  D &6?D  -.58 .51  #   

$ 

$

= *   *7'9"        

( !**?

B *  $ 7     

  26..23.3 

       

( !**?

B  * "<  ! ( " 26..23.3"  *   

! *

+ * $

*     26..23.3"    

( !** D

=

 *" *  * *       

( >   $!**

 $& *  *   "        * ..

  C     *

"     *       $ !  2/3.23.4"  1--       $ ?! B213423.8"   /2 12

    $     & 

--      2/3.23.4          

 $    2.3123.0    / "  $ 

    "    & ,  ** $   $"   ,   

  .2

   ' * *  

    05

600 !!60!       !*$,7 .+78

)   :=

E