Harvinder Singh Bindra v. State Of Punjab And Others









 

 








 


 !"#!$"$#

%  &

$#!"#!$"$# HARVINDER SINGH BINDRA 



STATE OF PUNJAB AND OTHERS





 
 '

 ()
'

!
 *
+ 
*!
 ,
-----

Present:

Mr. Rajiv Atma Ram, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Shreya Kaushik and Mr. Kunal Dawar, Advocates for the petitioner.
Mr. Vipan Pal Yadav, Addl. A.G. Punjab.

****
+ 
*!
 ,.
!





 

 


 
 







 
 
 

 
 







 
  


!

 


 
 




 

"#"$ "%



&  '
& 

(
)'
*
 




 




+


  

! 
,'
+--
.
 
/
!
,'
+--0
 
 

 
 

%"  "%
 





 






12
3
"4

"#"  "4
  


$'
#
. 0


  

! 
,'
+--



 "5)
2!

 



) '
(

-2- #








 

 

! 
 


 
12

  
 




 



! 


& 
6

  


 
 

 '

 7

2 '
8
9'
:5,'
(


) 
'
 7



)  ) '
:5,'
(
2



 


12





& 

.


 0

%"% " '

 



;
!  '
(

 

8
3
 4<=,'
6 
3  '
(







6 




>


-" "
  

+ " 
2

 



12




 




7






;
!  



 





 


 '



 7


2 '




 




 




 9


 
2



 


 




#" "4





%"'"""<5



 7

 


 





 


 


%'"""<5



  

 

 

 


 


 






 



) 
 

 





 

5
) 
'

 
 



  


%'"""<5


 
) 




 


;
!  '
(
?
 

  '


 

  

="$ "4
4

2






*


!  7



 
& 

(



+-#



 



-3-  

2




2
8
9'
:
,'
(



""=
,


 

 

 





;
 '

 

@ 





 




8
9

 7




!

 7


 

 



 
 


 7


2


 
 
2

 


 




 

 





  


! 
2







# '4""<5

  


9



"







"#5&


*
;
,'
+$=

 

,




 '

 

  




 
 




 



-" "4












 





8




>


 4<=,
 

8



 

 4<=,<


 

7

 

 
 







#" "4
8'

 


@ 


 7


 


8
9




 




;'
"4
 

 

 




;
 
2

 


) 
'
 

  





 7




8
9
) 







) 

 
6


!  7

,
6 

%
3

'

 





 


+


  

! 
,'
+--

 



 '
  







-4- 



 
 
  
  



 

 

 



 


  

 


'


 

%"  "%
2




 

 
 



) 



 








$"# "%A
="4 "%

"= "%

& 

@

5

 
 




 



 

"#"$ "%'


 
 


 

%"  "%




 


 


 
 



 


 


 
 

"#"$ "%




8B 
! 

 

4"- "=

=

 




 

C
'
&

 

 '

) 


 

-" "=
 


 

 

 


12

 

 



 



 


 


 

 5 
 












  

7
 





 '




 





 



 




 


  


 

"#"$ "%

$
,
 
 



 

 


&  '
& 

(
)'
*


C
  '
( D  '
*






 




 
  
 

3




 



 





 

 '

-5-


) '
(




  <

 

* 

8B 
 
! 



 


 






2




 


 


 




-

 


 


 


3

#

 
 

 
 


* 


8B 

 
! 









    



 
  < 

  



 

 

 
 



 
 



3

#


 

 5 
 


 



 



 











  

+
,

 

 
 

 


'

 

 '

) 

 


3

#
 










 




 

 
 




 '

@



5 


 
 






 




 

)
/
0!"1!$"#
2 345
)
/
0!"#!$"6
2 3$45 
!


1 5%
 




? 


 



5
 



&< 5

=%
 




2 


*
D 

 

 
! 

"="- "4
E
#
 




 5 
  5#
  
!


1 5%
 



-6-


&< 5

=%
 



"

2




 
 


  

  


! '


)
! 

8 

) 
 



 



 






 



@
 


"#"$ "%

 


 
 


  
 '



 
 


 '
'


 

59



 




* 


8B 
 
! 





 

       
 !!"#$%&&"' 
( 

!
 

 




 




 

 






 





 


 

 

%"  "%




 
 



 





 '
9 
 '





 
  
8

 



 


 
 


 


 

 
9


  


!&
  



 


 
2

 



 

 



  '
 












  


 



 

 
1  '
 

 







 



'
) 
















 
 



8



 

  



) 

'

 




8
9
) 

 

-7- 
 



 
2

 
 



@
 
 


'

@

 


 
 





 



 





 
 


  




 
 
 

&  '
 
(
)'
*




 
 









 
 
7  


 







 




"  "%


 
 









 
 
7
 


 




8














2



9 



2
 






 
8




 


 




 

'
 

 




 
@


 



 
 

"#"$ "%

 





 
?


'

 

 


5 

 



 

 
  

  



 
  

@


 




%"  "%


 


 
  '

 


8



 





 


 



 


* 


8B 
 
! 

2






 

     ' #

2
 
 
 
!
 

 


 
 

 

  


   

 

 

* 




-8- 4

 


 
 

! 





 
 


  
 


 '






 

%"  "%
 



 








 
 

"#"$ "%

%

 


 




 
  


 





 5 
  


<


 '
 


 
 

 


%"  "%'




 

 F5

   

   

           

 

        

  

  

   ! " 

 "  



    

 # $  %  

  

  



     

     & "     

$  



' '   

 

(  

)

 

      

$ &$$

 ' *  

      "       "



         

   

        $

 

$      & 

     '"

      

 



 

$  



  



 $

'   $   '

# $  %       '$



$ &   

   + 

       



    



  ,  

      *   

 

 

 

  '



 $

' 

$ (  

  

 



     

"

+

      $  



           

 # $  %  

 

 



$

' "

      '     

   

 (  

     $

'"

 



$       )

  

 

(  

"

    

-9-

 $

'" 

 

  

 

 (  

#  -% "

 

 "

 

 ' 

# $  %(

   $   

  

       

  ./01+2 

 3/453546 #, 78+%  ( 8 $8

 

 9 9$     

   

5533546  

  "  

     :

$ 

  

    

$   

 "

 

    -&  $ ;
=
2

 
 

 


 
 



 





  


!&

 
 


  
 

!&

 


) 





 

 


  
   



 


 





! 


  


 

!&

 

2

 



  



 

2
.
 0



 
'



  


 




  




 
) 
'









 

$

 

 
@ 





 



&  '
 
(
)'
*

"  "%

 



 
 



 

9 

 F5


3

@ 
2 

 


@ 
 


 
8 

) '
2 '
8
9'
; !  '
('


 




) 


3
4

"%


 







) 




7 

 

 


 

 

-10- 7  '



 


 
'













) 




7


 


7 

  

  
  






  





) 


 
 



 


 
 


 
3



 
 

-


 




 


 






 



 






 






 '
'


 





 
 
2






9 
 


 


  


 


 

 
  



 




 




 



 

12

 






 



  
2 

 
3





 

   



 




) 


 
 



 







 

 



9 


 

 



/ 
) G'


 
 


 

 


 
/!
, G
 
 
;  



 

H B


H  B


'



 


'



-11- 
 



  


5& 

 
 

 





 




 


 
 


 


 





& '








 

 




 



 




   




 

"#"$ "%
 
 

  

'
 
 


3

#


 
 




 '
  '


 

I

3


7





 
  

  
 


 




 





  







7



 
 


C 




*



  

 


 
 



 
  



 


 

  


 
 
&











 


 
 
  
 


 '

  
 






 





  


7

 

< 
  

+



 
@ 



 

  



 




< 
 
 

 


 



  
,
 




 
 

8B 
 
! 

2









   
 
&( (# )%  "&*
 


 



  




-12-  

 







 
 




2  
, 

 
 


  '




 

 





2

 


 




 



 





 

 

 




 
   



 <
 



 

  




2  
, 
@


 
 

 
 


 

  
9 


* 

F5 44 2  '          +,  -' ' . 

 /,    &((!#0% 11 #

% 2$ 3 &((!#)% 1'-'4' $("3 45 &((!# 0%  2(        

     

   <   " 

       '  "

 

 "  $

       

$    4=.  

  







>  . +          $

    



      -

 

'!      $   "



 "

   $     "

  

-



 

 -



   :

 -

   !        <    -

  "

 

 "   $' 

   '    "

   $       

 (   "





'

 '"   



      

   $        

 

'  $

     ' 

  '  

     "

 

 !

  

 " '    $     + 



          $'   ! 

 " '   



  * '  

   "

 



      $          

' 

  $







+  $

    $

 

  $



-13-  

 '    

'$' $    $

    

    



       ?    $ 

    

$  

     -  



 $'







    

 )           

'   7      

  

  

  



 -   

   

$  

    

'

 (    "

  

    



     

      

' 

      

  

       "

   

'    

     $  

  

@        

             ""



  "> @   A 

$   



  4=

   +

 

    4=.    

   $ 







          

      





 "    

        $  $

 " 

' 

  

 "

  

 

  



$  @ )  $  

                33 3  2 



>  33 ( " 



     "

 

 $

 "

 





       

' 9    



 " $

         

'   

   7      

  

   

 

7     

  

  (    



'      , 

  

 

  

  





 $    

$



 



 

    

 (  





     

$       

 



        ""

 



 @  3    ! $  '    

    





   

 $

 "

-14- 



 

         "    "'

 

 

$    '  " 

$    





 " 



   7 "  +   $        "   '



 

 



 "

  



     $







     

'

 

" @  43(   A 

$   $

   



      -

 

' "

  "

  $   "

   -



 

 -



  

  <         -

 "





 "   $  "



  "

 

 "  "



 

 





 

(

$          "   

' "



   4=    4=// +

    4=.    

 



-



 ' A 

$ 

  $  

'   $'

 

$  

    

'  

 "



 

 $

  $ $

  (   

  

 

  "

 

 " $' 

   '  -

       A 

$ 

     

 



  -

  "

      $

  

     $'





 '  

'

 

 

7 "    



 $'



      $ $

$'

       

 $' 

  '

    

' -

 (            

     $  $

  

  

  



 " 



 

    





           "



  "



$

 

  



'     '  <    



  





    

'     $



 

 '    

'  

   

 $

       

$

       

    

 $'

  



$' 

  '$

$  

   ;

-15- "


* 







)
8 
! 

!   
 
3
+$

" #

!  , 
3
4=

"+
 

  6  1' 7 


"+" " 4



 

 



* 





8  1+  9''  

&(&&# % ':'1'- , &&2

$  " 



 






* 

 

 . 0

 
 




 <


 
 




 



* 



 


9



  

C
 
@ 










 




 

 

9

5 



 
  '








 

 
 



 



! 

 
 


 








 

 
  


#
/1 
  G







 


 

 






  



2
'


 




 
  '

9

 


   
 

 
 


 





7 
8  '


9
 
 


'
  
'
 


 






5 

 
 



4
2






5 


 


 

  






!&
  

 

   











 


 



-16- 7



 

1  '
 
 '


 

 


  



  
 


 





 '
  '

 


 

%"  " 4
  



  


 
   
  

<!&


 
 

 



 

'





 
 

 I
 



 

'

 
 





 


7




 
=


 
 

"#"$ "%




 




9 

 F5
/C   

    

 9  4//50 

 4C56354D

 ' *  

  !    

 

 



 "



 





   " 

 "   '             

  " 

7  

"

 

  

  (  

 

"" 

'

           

 "

7        $  

  

   (  

 

" "  

' 

      $    



 $    

 

       $   '  $   ' 

   *  

    E$ 



 '  *  

  

$

 

   $    '    $    

     *  

    $  



   

 

"

 $     

  

   (  

 $

 

 

 $    $ 

     E$       '            

" 



+  

"   , $   4=0D035430+0.D=3 

 35.354  A 

$    ! *  

"

>8 @(   

      '  



    

-17- ! $     

$            

 

    ( *0 &

7   ' #4==C#4%(F4.4% 

        '    $       "

   

    

       







   $  

'"   $ '      " 

  

        

  @  



<    



$ 

 $ 

     

    

$      

  ' *  

  !   $ "    

  "+

 

   

$    "  "      



  



  



    '   *   &  $      ! $  

 '   

$   ( ' 7 (+ &





   

   !  

'         

   

    

    

   

 (  

 9  9$     :(29 6 

5533546

  . 4#3%   

    

  + 4=//

 "   4358(  *  

2        " 

<   ' *  

; %
 

 
 





 

 


 5 
 




 

! 



) 





 

  




8 
'
2


 

 <9 
I55 I

 
 


 
=


 
 

"#"$ "%

  
 







 
3#


 
 

%"  "%


 
 


 5 
  

 
 


  

 

!&

 




! 


  



-18-  

!&
2

 
 



!
?


 
(
)'
*

 

 

 
  



 

 


  


!

&
 



  

8 

) 



 


 


  
2


 

 

7


 



  
2




 


 
 




2 
,'
""%
 

 

)'











 


   





 


7


 

%"  "%






  
 
 


 
8'


 
 

 




5 

 





  
 


 
 

%"  "%



 



 '



  



 
  '



 



 '
2



 

@


 

 
 



* 


8B 
 
!



    #% 

  


 






 


I

 



 



 


 
  '

 
 

"#"$ "%


 




=



 
 











@
 


* 




 

 


 
  '
2
 
 


 


 


 



 *

 


 

7
 


  


 



-19- $

 


 







 

"#"$ "%
.,9 
50

 











2+ 
*!
 ,5



)
$#.
$"$#
















  * $ >
7 < 

J<3







>
  







F








J<3