High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13621/2017dismissed

Seema Devi v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-10-09Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan,Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri5 pages

"#$%$&'(')*+ ,$$-"$.'

$#'#')$/ 0$/(1( ,#"#$"/2")"")%#3$/( $(4)%$)#(

* 56 , 56 , 7 6, /$($)#*8 /$//2,"#9%.&"#$9 /4$#'#')$/ /0'.$:,"')'9 "/2")" /7");"< 2"<9%.&"#$9 //$(4)%$)# /-'#73"#:3"/9%.&"#$9 //$(4)%$)# 3$#3$/#3$$4/#$/(<&"<)$;(4"4$/-"2=$"<<;$%# ($$#3$>1%?-$)#@ =$/$$//$%##3$$4/#$//)# 3$#3$/#3$>1%?-$)#(31<%=$/$4/#$%')#3$%'?$(#@ 88 88 6, 9 $#'#')$/'(($/.')?"(" )(#"=<$')"/2")"<'&$&"%$-2 (')&$

##3"##'-$9(3$;"(')#3'/%2$"/3$/<";&1/($ #$/ ?$##')?4$/-'((')/-%$4"/#-$)#9(3$&-4<$#$%3$/66&1/($')#3$ 2$"/

+$(4)%$)#3"%"%.$/#'($% 4(#((('(#")#'(#/'&# ##/)$2

/1455!)+A 9;3$/$')<<;')?$(($)#'"<B1"<''&"#')( ;$/$<"'%%;)*8 5 (($)#'"< C1"<''&"#')( / #3$ 4(# (('(#")# '(#/'&# ##/)$2')/($&1#')9"/2")"

$?/$$ "&3$</ 6";( /$((')"<! "

/$&?)'D$% )'.$/('#2

''!

,31<%3".$$)/<<$%"(")%.&"#$;'#3"/ 1)&'<

'''!

')%',")(:/'#14# "#/'&(#")%"/%/3'?3$/5 )#3$("'%"%.$/#'($-$)#9) $E4$/'$)&$/")%.&"#$'( /$B1'/$%#'(1/#3$/(#"#$%#3"#1<$F+"/ 1)&'<)%'"1<$(="/( #3$ .$/)-$)#($/.")#/-4/"&#'(')?"(")%.&"#$"(<)?"(3$(3$ &)#')1$(')(1&3 .$/)-$)#($/.'&$1$#("'%/1<$94$#'#')$/%'%)# $)/<< 3$/($<;'#3"/ 1)&'< 3$"%.&"#$9;3>') .$/)-$)# ($/.'&$/4/'."#$($/.'&$/($/.'&$)&)#"&#="('(93"(#(1//$)%$/3'(3$/ (")"%<'&$)&$ #'(&<"'-$%=24$#'#')$/#3"#(')&$)$E4$/'$)&$;"( /$B1'/$%9 #3$/$/$9 #''&"#') , )(#/# +

9 "( "44<'&"=<$#"/2")",#"#$/($&1#')6$?"<

/1455!,$/.'&$1<$(9

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

$/#'($-$)##;"((#"#$%#3"#"#$/"44')#-$)#9 #3$&")%'%"#$(=$&-$)#''$%"( .$/)-$)#<$"%$/1=<'&/($&1#// "44$"/")&$)=$3"< .$/)-$)#=$/$."

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

1/#="('&"<<2"(")"%.&"#$#31?39)=$3"< .$/)-$)# 3$ %.&"#$(&#9+9"<<;()<2"%.&"#$(#4/"&#'($')#3$ 1/#( ,$&#')+%.&"#$(&#9+9<"2(%;)"(1)%$/*8 5

8 ,1=>$&# # #3$ 4/.'(')(#3'(&# ")%")2/1<$(-"%$#3$/$1)%$/9 #3$/$(3"<<9"(/-#3$"44')#$%%"29=$)<2)$&<"(( 4$/()($)#'#<$%#4/"&#'($ #3$4/$((')<";9 )"-$<29"%.&"#$(5 ,$&#') %.&"#$(&#9+91/#3$/<"2(%;)"(1)%$/*8 5 ! 8 ,1=>$&# # 4/.'(')(#3'(&#9$.$/2"%.&"#$;3($)"-$'( $)#$/$%')#3$,#"#$/<<(3"<<=$$)#'#<$%"(/'?3## 4/"&#'($ #3/1?31# #3$ #$//'#/'$( # ;3'&3 #3'( &# $E#$)%(8

')"<<&1/#(')&<1%')?#3$,14/$-$ 1/#G

8F8

''!

=$/$")2#/'=1)"</4$/()<$?"<<2"1#3/'($%# #":$$.'%$)&$G")%

'''!

=$/$")2#3$/"1#3/'#2/4$/()=$/$;3- (1&3"%.&"#$'(=2/1)%$/")2<";/#3$#'-$ =$')?')/&$$)#'#<$%#4/"&#'($5 3$("'%4/.'(')(&<$"/<2(3;#3"#)<2")"%.&"#$9;3'( $)/<<$%;'#3#3$"/ 1)&'<9(3"<<=$$)#'#<$%#4/"&#'($') 1/#,')&$ #3$ .$/)-$)#<$"%$/((('(#")#'(#/'&###/)$2("/$"%.&"#$(9;3 4/"&#'($')#3$ 1/#9-"2=$)=$3"< .$/)-$)#9(#'<<<'&$)&$# 4/"&#'($"(")"%.&"#$'(4/$&)%'#')#"44$"/')#3$ 1/#(3"#=$')?

(9/$(4)%$)#(&1<%<$?"<<2'-4($#3$&)%'#')#3"#)<2#3($9;3"/$ 3".')?<'&$)&$#4/"&#'($"(")"%.&"#$9"/$$<'?'=<$#"44<23$/$'() .'<"#')/#'&<$+ ! ?! )(#'#1#'))%'"4$#'#')$/'(')

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

8A8 ##/)$29'()?/1)%#3<%#3"#$.$)$)/<<-$)#"(")"%.&"#$'()# /$B1'/$%/#3$"44')#-$)#"((('(#")#'(#/'&###/)$2')/($&1#') $4"/#-$)#,#"#$3"#=$')?(9#3$;/'#4$#'#')'(%$.'%")2-$/'# ")%'("&&/%')?<2%'(-'(($%

6, !

+ (>:( 3$#3$/(4$":')?/$"()$% * $( 3$#3$/$4/#"=<$ * $(