(O&M) Om Parkash Malik And ORS. v. Virinder Kumar Malik
!!"#$#%&'()*
+& ,-
!! "
#
$
" %%% &'( )"
! !
$! *+*,,**- . )
/! ! . $! *0'*,**,.
/!1/
)
2 ! "
&,(
""3 "
" "
. " 4' " " 4, 0 "
$
!" 4' ""
!
"
"" 4, 0 ! " " 4, 0 "
""
"""" 4,
"
! "
" " 4,
$
! !
"
" &0(
""
! " 4' . . )
56
" "
5 "
"" " 4'
! .
. #
" 7 8)
) 8 4
8. 8 4
)
)
9 : .
" : "
;
.
!
'<=> " 78)
) 8 4
)" 4'
"
""
" )" 4' "
"
.
&?(
"" "
! "
7 @
'<+>
"
7 8 )
) 8 4
!
" " " "
"")" 4'
.
"
"" : " " 4'
. "" "
"" " 4' " .
" " 4,
" .
" " 40 # "
" "
" "
.
" " 5 "
"" "
"
" 4' .
!
""
"
"
"" &=(
""
"
'<+<
""
" 4, 0 @
" "
. " 4' .
! . "
""A '<-? "
7 8 )
) 8 4
.
. !
! 8. !
!
7 7" 40 @
7" 4, !
""$
.
'<-? &+( '<-+
""
"
40*,, 3,>3) !
! :
9 "
" "
5 "
""
'<>+ )" 4'
!" ; "
"" .
'=***73 "
" "
; "
""
""
! " 4, 0
. . " " " . .
$
.
! &-( " " " 7 7 @
7 $. : B
7
B
)
! A
. " 4'
"
.
"
"" " 4'
"
.
" ! 7"
; .
"" " 4'
" "
.
&>( ! ,=*='<>0 ; .
"" " 4' ! =*C A ! .
" 7
.
! "
"" " 4'
! =*C " 4' 9 ! " @
! ! " . ; " : ; " " " " 4' "
"
:
" @
"" " 4' "
"=*C
&<(
7 @
7" 4, .
"" " =*C
"" " 4':
" @
"" " 4' !"
"=*C
&'*(
7 $. : B
.
=*C
"" " 4'
! .
.
A " ! .
"" " 4'
"
"
"*'*+'<>0
"=*C
. 9 . 0'*0'<>?
;
. =*C". : "
. . " 4'
""
! "
"
.
)" 4' .$
! "
""
!
""
7 @
" " ; " !
)" 4' "
" !
""
"
)" 4'.
! . .
"""
"
! ! !
!! &''( '<>=" 4'; " "
.
! !
! : " ! ; '+*?'<>= )" 4' .
.
. . "=*C
A !
! .
" " 4,
.
"=*C !
=*C
. " 4' &',( . ! " 4' ! "@
"" ; "
,=*-'<>+
""
; "
!
.
:
" .
.
! " 4' ;
" " 4,
"" .
!
; "
.
B
D
""!"
"" 4, ""
""
0****73 " " 4' "
" .
; &'0( )" 4'
"
" !
"
" 4? =
"
7" 4, 0
" )" 4' . . "
" " 4? =
" .
!
""
""
" 4? = " " 4, 0 : " " 4'
" D " 4'
! " "
!
" " " " 4'
" 4? = "
"
"" " 4? = . " " 4' !
"" .
" 4'
!
!.!
"")" 4' ; !
.
:
"" "
"
"
"
9 ! )" 4' "
"
7!
;
"
""
" " 4' ; "
"
!
&'?(
" . " 4'
"" . . "
" " 4'
! . "
! .
"
. )" 4'
! ; "" " $
"
)" 4'
" " 4, 0 "
@
"
" .
5 $
.
" " 4'
""
" @
E
! B "
. "9 )" 4'
! "
9 "
. "
" " 4, 0
"" .
" . "
.
! . " 4'
&'=( . ! ."
.
""9
! " 4' "
" " 4, 0
!
! "
.
.
". "
"
"
..
"
"
.
"
; .
"" 4' "
. " " 4' "
" " 4, 0
""" "" 4, 0.
3 "" 4, 0
; " " 4, 0
; " "
. " " 4'
" . " 4' "
.
"
.
. " 4'
" "
"" 4' " 4, 0 ! ;
"
!".
"" 4, 0 &'+(
. "
)" !
7
"
.
'<*''<>> )"
"
7 " ! " 4'
7 $.: B
: " "
. " .
""
"
""
7
8 )" 4'
7
B
)
7 7 @
" " 4' )" 4'
! 7 7 @
" " 4' 0'*0'<<0 " .
"" 4'
""
!
)" 4'"
! 8.
"
78 )
) 8 4
! : "
"
#
'<-? 8.
.
.
.
" 78)
) 8 4
.
" 8
)" 4'
"
" " @
. . "
.
""
)" 4'"
7 $.: B
D " "
" .
""
"" ! )" 4'
7
B
)
7 7@
"" 4'
""
&'-( . "
! " "
"3
!
" "
#
$ % &'
$ (
)* $ +
$ ,
- . )* $
!,!+( #, +(! " $ /
0 &'>(
: "
""
$! *0'*,**, .
!
"" . ""
"" 4, 0
.9 !
! ! "" 4, 0 : " 4' " @
!
"" 4, 0.
"" )" 4'
"
! " " 4, 0
"
""
!
"" " " 4, 0 !
"
" " 4, 0
"
"" "
"" 4, 0 . " "
! ,=*='<>0 '+*?'<>= )" 4'
! " " " 4, 0 @
&'<( :
"
." 8
*+*,,**-@
."
&,*( 5
! . 9 " . "
! " 3 1
'
1
'
.
2
1
3 4141 3 413 /
5 1
* * "
" 6 1 " 6
1 6
1
#, +(!
"
!,!+( 1
-
+(!
++
"
*
"
-
1
7.$8
*
2
"
2
'1
/
9
"
' :
;
2
61
* "
"
0 &,'( A ! " " . .
&,,(
!
"". . ! "
!.
! )
:
" " ! 7"
"
!"" 3
<25=3
*:
* >
* =
5
* 3 &%* >
3
<
6 :
3 "
> * 3 &%* < <
* >
:
>
*
3
<
6 <2 3 "
7 * + *
* $
3 ?
=
<
6 !,@
3 A
A 3 96 / '=
<2 '
B 7
*<
*
3 ?
=
<
6 %!@ 3
<
6 !@B
6
.
>&(*
%!@
3 ?
=
<
6 !@ 3
<
60 &,0( # . ! 7
.
.
"" " 4'
!=*C
" @
9 " ""
!
!
" "
" 9 . .
. " 4' " =*C "
"" =*C " " 4' .; 7
.
" @
.
! " 4'
""
=*C
&,?(
7@
.
.
! =*C " @
9 " ""
! !
" "
"" 4' " =*C
" ". . .; ! 7 @
. ! .
"" " 4'
.
!=*C
&,=(
""
" 7
B
"" " 4'
. 9 " ,=C
" =*C
7
B
A "
! $. : B
" .;
"" " 4' 9 " =*C
.
!"3''>
. . " =*C 5 *'*+'<>0
"" " 4' "
.
.
. " "
=*C # . 9
" .
&,+(
"
'+*?'<>= "
! 3 5:
3 "
> *3 &%*< <
* >
9 :
> 9
*
3
<
6 A<23 '
B 7
*<
*
3 ?
=
<
6 %!@ 3
<
6 ! @ B
6
.
>&(
%!@
3 ?
=
<
6 !@ 3
<
60 " ! !
7@
.
.
"" " 4'
! =*C
" @
9 " ""
! !
" "
" " 4' " .
" ; " =*C "
"" " 4' . ; ! 7 @
. @
.
!
"" " 4'
.
!=*C
&,-( "
! $. : B
" . ; .
"" " 4'
9 " =*C
.
! " 3''>
. . "=*C &,>( 5 *'*+'<>0 . . "
.
""
. " =*C
.
:
! '+*?'<>= !
! " !
"" "*'*?'<>=
" . . "*'*?'<>= &,<( #"
! . 9 " $ . "
.
.
!."
A
"
"
! ,=*='<>0 '+*?'<>= ! ; . " 4' " "
.
. : !
.
".
! " .
!
.
B
!
. "
'<*''<>> B;); .
"" " .
9 "
.
&0*( #" 8
; " ! B;D07'+*?'<>= B;D07# ,=*='<>0 ; : "
"
! !
; .
F
!"
B;); !
F: . ! "
; "! " 4' " "
#
! ; " " ! " 4' " "
! B;D07 ; .
. .
" 4, 0"
! )" 4' " !
4'- 3+
" 3
"" $
" .
) B;D>7D>7" ! " !
! . B;)D?7'
,=*-'<>+ .
"
!
! @
8
"
! $
""
" 4," "
!" .! B;)D?7,
.
@
8 !
!
" "
! " '<>0 '<>= . .
!
.
&0'( ! " "
!
! ; " ! .
"
!B;)G " ".
: !
".
" .
" &0,( 8 "
.
"
.
"
!
"
: ! .
!
.
.
"
. "
$
.! &00( #".
! "
"
. . "
"
! : ; " ! ." . )" 4' ; " ! ! ""
.
"
.4 " "
"
"
. "
"
. ; ". ! ." . B
.
! "
B;)G '<*''<>>!; &0?( "
" . A
"
B;)G
.
!4?+<" :
!
$ .
3 ; " ! : !
. .
"" " .
" ." : .".
:
!
! .
""
"
.
.
! :
! "
. A " " " ."
.
! H. I J " "
K :
" ."
:
" "
H ! I H'<>>I "
. "
! D07 D07#. : "
! !
"
"
4;
.
! ." A
"" ! :
! .
9
!B;)G"
" ." .
""" "
.
.$ : H ! I H/ I H'<>>I H" "
I "
!
: "
! " " B;)G.
"
" B;)G
"
; . &0=( # . " ! .
$ ! ! B;D07 D07#
:
6 B;D?7' B;D?7, B;D>7 D>7
!! !
. "B;)G " "" . "
&0+( A
"
!
" . !"
!
" .
"
"
.
" " &0-( )
.
;
"
!
:
"
61 2
"
1.
! 2 1
2
"
1
2
; " D
. "
" 7 " ! " "
!
"
"
: J
.
K
12 . 1'2" '?"
"
" '<+0
. )
"
!
!
! .
.
.
"
.
"
"
"
! .! " "
"
9
"
.
"
" &0>( 8 "
.
!
!"##$ %
&' !()* +' , -,('
&.#"#, /0 0 1$ !''$ %0 '&2(' -(2('#,&&)#(, 3'(&&# (( /001 4#$ 0%&',&, )&&)#(, /0 / %$5 10! !
9 "
.
"
.
&0<( "" "
! "" : !
"
"
.
" "
""
! . " 4'7
!
9 A "
" ; " ! " 4' " ""
!"
: " !
.
"
! .
:
" !
! "
""
.
.
.
"
!
.
" 4 .
!
.
; " ! . " 4'7
" $
" ! . " 3;
!
!. . "
! . .
" .
&?*( 8 "
. "
! !
! " .
"
" . 3$
!
A" "
! !
! ""
.
:
" "
! "" 7 @
! 7 !
.
" ! ! .
! !
.
! 8
! " ."
.
! " " !
;
.!
"
! A
! . "
.
!A
""
". A
"
.!
+<" " " "
! :
"
"" "
!D3 > 3)" 4'
B
A "
# # )" 4'
!!
; ",=C" $.: B
&?'( 8 " . . !
"
! "
,>3) !
"
! . """ 4'
'<-0
! 9 ! B;)G'<*''<>> "
"" .
"""
"! &?,( 8 " . "
.
'?1021 2"
"
" '<+0
"
"
"
"
"
$
#
! *#,&## 5# # &6(,,
7 %$ !''$ 8 , '(&, (&' (&#',' ' 4'2(' '2(' #, /00
$ ,&#$ %7
#,( && ',&, )(& '&( & )#(, /00 %$ !''$ %7 "(& '&( -,$ #()( 5 '&( & )#(, /00 /$ !''$8 ! '?1021 2"
" " "
" " .
! ; "
.
!
"
.
; " .
"" .
! .
"
"
"
" " 3"
"
9
"L "
" .
" "
.
. .; &?0(
!
"
"! " 9 "! .
!
.
.
. " !
.
"
" "
: !
"
"".
$
.
" " !
.
!! .
B; " ! ." . . !
"
!
"
"
&??( : !
9 . "
! "
"" .!
"
!
" ""
! .
!
"
$
. "
!
5
!
#,( && ',&,)(& '&(&)#(, *$"
" " ! !
"" )" 4' ! .
3 @
8 " "
" "
! "
!
" .
!
. "
&?=( 8 " " . ; "! " . : "" $
" ! "
: ,=*-'<>+ B;)D?7' . " "
!
! @
8 ! ! &?+( 8
! !
,=*-'<>+ ; . " 4'
""
! . " 7 7 @
!
"" " 4'
! @ 40*,, ,>3) !
" " ! "
. " " " 4' !
B;D07
" . 7
""" 4'*- 3+
:
" ,,=***73"
$"
"
! . " " " 8
! . !
! "
'>'''<<,
" $
" "
8
!
B;)D?7
; . *''''<>>
! )"
,=C
"" ,=C
" "
!
:
! !
!
A
@
7
B
A
9 " ):
"" 4'
"" "
9 &?-( )
"! "
! 7 . . "" 4' ! E A . !
""
!
!
!"
5
"
; . " 4'
'<<0 " "
"" " '<<0 "
.
. " :
.
"
. 9 . " "
"" .
"
" "
.
"
.
&?>( 8 "
'<*=,**< "
! . 9 " " 3 1
"
3 3 4141 3 /
5 1
0 # . .
!" $! " 9
.
M "
! " " "
" 9 " " &?<( : !
9
. "
" ! .
"
"
!
."
" ! !
.
.
5
!
. . : " "
"!
!B;)G .
!"
! .
! "
:
!
!
&=*(
" "
!(& ' ,$ 2 5 &&#( ,$ 25
% !$7 894' ##,).3, &&)#(, /00 1$ !!%
* #&) ),&,&#). &) /001 /$! !''$%8 6&# ' : ; 2(( ' !)*& ' #()( (' (&#( ('
/008 /$ ! ,&#$ %7 " 9
. ! "
! : ! .
! "
!
.
:
.
! "'<>=
'<<0 " " " .
. . "
"
; " "
"" ! . &='( : "
!" " " . " "
"
""
. " "
"" "
" . +<"
!A
! "'<*=,**<
! " .
. 9 " .
&=,(
" " . A"
;
. ! !. "
9 " .
.""
*<*=,*'+