High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17211/2016dismissed

Rachna Ram v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitram Nigam Ltd & ORS

2016-08-24Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

!""#$%$&'()

#*& + ,, "!$!$&"- ."-%/%

!! - -0 & $12$.$!- &$3 +4!5 &5 &!*"- ,, "%6&5"&!%

-"%"&!',

-7"2859# !"-!*"6"!$!$&"- :::

"!$!$&"- %% $2%!*"-5"-5 !"5; &&"</-" ,)8 6 %%"5=0!*""&"- 2 & 3"->5+&8 .4!5$&!"-+%?*$#* *$%#2 $+%""@$&3 &!"5 !"56-+!$&!!*"6%!%%$%! &!&3$&""- ?");)A &5 !6 -?$!**$%1/&$-& +"20B* ** =- 8* % =""&5"#2$&"5

2" 5$&3%&-"#-5?/25$&5$# !"!* !!*"6"!$!$&"-="2&3% !!*"# !"3-0 &5* 51$&"5&!*"6%!4$&"B/6"-$&!"&5"&!$&!*" 0" - ;

; ?$!* !*" "-%!?*$2" -0 & B! !" 2"#!-$#$!0 -5 *" &+"&#2 !/-"!*"4$&"B/6"-$&!"&5"&!* %%$&#"=""&#* &3"5!!* ! /&$-&3$&""-B* ** =- ? %3- &!"56-+!$& %,$& ;; "!$!$&"-? %3- &!"5="&"$!-"%"-9 !$&& ##/&!*$% ="2&3$&3!!*"# !"3-0 &59$5"-5"-5 !"5A;;A*"? % 3- &!"5 5""+"55 !"6-+!$&!!*"6%!,?" -#*8;; &6/-%/ &#"!%/#*="&"$!* 9$&3=""& ##-5"5*$%& +"? %-"2"#!"5 $&!*"%"&$-$!02$%!% !B-CC,8?*"-" %!*"& +"B* ** =- ? %-"2"#!"5 !B-CA &5$%6/!"5208B* ** =- ? % 6-+!"5 %%%$%! &!&3$&""-&);)A

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

$&$2"5$&!*"0" -C!$%/-!*"- %/=+$!!"5!* !6%!-"!$-"+"&!!*"6"!$!$&"-* 5$2"5 &(A A &5?*$#*? %5$%6%"59$5"-5"-5 !"5A=05$-"#!$&3!*" -"%6&5"&! /!*-$!$"%!! @" $& 25"#$%$&&*$%2"3 2&!$#"5 !"5 ;A -"#$%" -3/+"&!- $%"5$%!* !5"2 0# &&!5"" !!*" #2 $+!*"6"!$!$&"- %*$%-"6-"%"&! $&* 5=""&$2"5? 0= #@$&!

&5?*$#*-"+ $&"56"&5$&3 &5!*"-" !"-"9"&!*$%/-!* 5 $&!"-9"&"5 & A $& (A A 5$-"#!$&3 !*"

-"%6&5"&!,$3 +!! @" $& 25"#$%$&&*$%2"3 2&!$#" 9$&3*" -52" -&"5#/&%"2-!*"6"!$!$&"- !2"&3!*8!*$% /-!$%!*"#&%$5"-"59$"?!* !!*"#2 $+- $%"5=0!*"6"!$!$&"-$%!$+" = --"5 &5!*"?-$!6"!$!$&%/"-%-+9$#"5"2 0 &52 #*"% &

8!*"&D=2"B/6-"+"/-!* 5#2" -20=%"-9"5!* ! 6"-%& 33-$"9"5 &-5"-6-+!$& 1/&$-?/25="=2$3 !"5!

,C, 66- #*!*"/-!?$!*$& 6"-$5%$<+&!*%- !!*"+%!?$!*$& 6"-$5&"0" - &!*" #!%!*"6-"%"&!# %"8"9"&$8 -"6-"%"&! !$&* 5 =""&$2"5=0!*"6"!$!$&"-$&!*"0" -;;

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

" #2 $+ %-"3 -5% 6-+!$& $& !*" 0" - 6%! *$% -"!$-"+"&! &5 ?$!* -"3 -5 ! 6-+!$& 26%!?"!*"0" -;)A %!*"% +"?/25 +/&!!5$%!/-= %"!!2"56%$!$&$&+ !!"-%6-+!$& &5%"&$-$!0 *$% /-!8 % %/#*8 5"% &! $&5 &0 $&$-+$!0 $& !*" $+6/3&"5-5"-5 !"5; &&"</-" ,)8?*"-"=0#2 $+!

6"!$!$&"-%! &5%-"1"#!"5&!*"3-/&55"2 0 &52 #*"% %?"22

"!$!$&8 ##-5$&3208$%5$%+$%%"5

2/#@0 *"!*"-%6" @$&3>-" %&"5'

"% *"!*"- "6-! =2"'