← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13691/2017disposed of

Sukhbir And ORS v. The Commissioner And ORS

2023-04-26Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari11 pages

 

          !"!#$!%&'( )   #&'&*'+!%&'( )  

 

   

 

 



(  ,-  ..

. /

  ,-  ./ - 

      

 "



     

# $% 

   $

 "



& '

( &

"



& )* ++++ .

. /

0  

1+2*131+45#&*'% ) % 



*(*,-**.! & )'/ "





!

0 !  





! #  

   ! 1 "# 

  

 "!

2  3 ##  

4

5 #

6 )(7)5  #! #



 "% 

6 "

"

 ! ## 8 4 8

  #"1 !#  "

  

 "!

#  

 -      

    1      $ 

   !

# 1   "#

/9  & :.7':.:)

:.-(;   1  #    !

 "#!

!!< 

  & :.7' = < 

  & :.-( 

"     = 1     !

  

   

:.:)       

 /   



    

  ! !



   

! !

      

       5 6   

  1  

   !

!

"



1 ## 

    :

  

 

  !# 

=>' 

 5 6    

!

#<       

 !

      #   #          

% 1   

 

    !

   

-.)--*)-    

 

<  

#

   5 6

# 



!

  "!

2 "8 4 8 

1 " =  !

 "

  

!

5

=>'61   

 "" !

 

#

   5 61    #  



 #  #   3!

 

!

!

 

    # 

 #

!

 

  "#

 

!= 

56 !

  "

"

<

# "

  



 



3 !

 



    

    

 !"    

    

   

    

     !

  !  

  

      "

#        $

%& '

  $ %

 %

  !

"

#    $ %  # 

 (        )   



!  !      ) )





         

!

 

     

)     !        $

        

        

           

*   )      *

       $ !+  ,,- $       ( 

         !  



  ( 

 

     

     

  

       ( 



  )  .+   

     

!

  ) (        

       

!

  

))  ! )

 

     

           

         

   ! )

!      

!

  

/  

    )     

    

   

!!

      0+ 

   ( 

     !1   

!     

#

)   $

23, 4/      

)         !1  )   

     

    

 

    ! 



       5   )  )

 

6       

!

  

       !    !1   

!  !

)     

 ) *   )  7 '   

  

   

 

  !

   !



-.)--*)-  !# 

=>' #

  " 

 

!

1  

   #  !

      "      

      1    ""! !

    !

   "!



 !

   5 6 , 

 "  !

 !# 

=> '  =!   #& ):/ "-*):"



  

##  

 !

     #

  #

    !

   

 -7*,-*), 

  =!    # 5 6 !

1 "!

 !# 

=>, 

 =!   #  #



     

/

 

 "

  

     1  #     !

   

-:)--*)7

=! 

& (, !#  

#"

 >



"



 !



 " 

!

 !

5 6

$

  #

  

1 

"

    6*!"27&'&82723!01"#17"!%9:2;!<!2727&'!#"'&2%!+7%!%7'2!#="&8 .!+27&' &8,2;! >-+2,;!#!8&#!02;!7=<*5'!%%!+7"7&'"1#! 831?!%1'%#!@*7#!2;122;!:9!@*1";!%1'%&#%!#&8#!=1'%9! =1%!2&2;! !=1'%!!&*#28&#72"=147'51%!2!#=7'127&'7' #!"<!+2&82;!"17%1""!#27&' 7

  



=>'  " !   

"

 

!

#<     5 6

  

    #  " !  

=  >'    

  

 #     

 1  "

  !  #

""!

   ## " !



=>' 



!

1  #& )'/

1   !

"   

     1     <

  "

  



     

    

! 

!

 ! 

   

#

       1     #     

  

 "

1  # <

  3!

 !

!



 1    "#   

      

 

1 <



!

 "

5 6! ## 1    #   #  

#

 !

   5 6

< 3 !



 



3 !

 

"

3 !

 1 



  #

1 

   !# % 1    



1 

 "   =!1   





1!"

 

5 6!  !





 ""

!

 !

 "

!

           

=

 #    #

  #"   !



 "     0 

!     

!



#

1  

  # 1

!

 ! 1     3 !1!  >



  #

   

# "

 

 



   1!

= 1  !      =

 " !" ##1   !#

"

" 

#

  " !

-5 65' 6 5 6 

1 "

=  !

 "

&

# 8

       

 # 1"## 

  !   !

!

# !#  !  !

   #

      !1  !   89 %! " 9

 1    !      

 :*

!  ;

.  ## ;

0   !      

+ $

 $  +         !  





   

     

;

& # !" "

 '"

  (    '!!)

%%

 !") *

!*

! )"*

!* "+) !!*  " "

   (    " "



!

%%%  ,   

 -( .% 

  / * $ 0 !") !" '"

 

%%    '!!) "   1   2 -( 3!")

!" "

'  4)% / * #1

2 -( /  $

 #1*  %)% "

!

  '   , .'% " ,   /    "

/ 56 & # '  !"

  ("

"

 )

"

 "

(



56 5   

  !  ! ( 



     

     ;7 2

    1##" !#

 # !

"  & :.7'1

 =    1##

  

   

" " ##

1        !#

!# 

"

"



 !   "!

-5 65' 6 "8 4 8 !

 " !! 

!

           !

   

  !  1





;  #

  !

 

 # 

" !

   :.:)  

   

1   #"

 !



  "   

 



  =!#

!# 

"

"



 !

!  !

-5 656 "8 4 8  

1 " =  !

 "

1 !

"



#

1! 

 !# 

 

"

 ! 

 > !

!  

   

 "

  -7  ?

    )(,*    !! 

 

 

"! 

#



1   89 %! " 9

 1 *********;

.*********;

0*********;

4********;:

4*******;:

5*********;7 8( "   !" !"



-1 !   !  



    !    



     *  

    

  

    ;

    !  



   (  1    !     

   ;

1 )     !

   !  

   

   !

  <!    

      &     

     !

 ! 2  =

2,5;:

 !    !  

 !

 

 

 ! .> =  253;

!(  ! .> =  253   !

 *   

      1       

          !    !

  ;

   !      



                    !  





   

     

   

 !       )!

    





! 

     ;:

11111:

 %! " *  "

 !"

' "

 (   "'"!

!')  



   ()  0      '   

%! "

  (   

7 * $  *             )         

!   ;7 . @    #

 !!

  1##

!





 





  # 1  #    8  



#

   5 6

1! 

    #  



1



#   "!

2 "8 4 8  !  3!

# !

!

  "##   % 1    

#  !  3!

#

 



 

!

!   

"



      !

# #  >

      

 #

  "  !



   $  !

 8!



  #"   

  

 ( A

1 

!

!



   

 

" !1     

56 #  



 

  !

 "    !!

    #

 3  

   

#

"

 

    !#

   B 

  # """ 

! 

 #!

"

  

 )*



!

  

   

  ""!

 

  #  !

 !





 



""!!

"

#

  "

!

!#

#  #  1 

 

 !

  

       ! !  

    

 3!

1     #

 " !  #   

#      5 61   

# 1 <



3 !



  "!

2 "8 4 81! 1  #



"

!# #   "

 

"1  

0

< ! 1 

 ## 1  ))  !

< !        

  # 

 

  !

 

   ##     3!





   !

"    

"  #        

<     

 

 " ! 

!

 ! !



!

"



"!  !

  



 " 



  # ##    

  !!

!1 # 1 

  !

3 !

 

 

  

  #   

  

 #

     

  0"   

      !

3 !

 

   <

# ## ! 



 #

 

  #  

 !#

 )- % 1 ! 



!

3!

 

#   3!

 !







 ## !

 1 " !

  !!

!1 # 1 

 !  

)'/  5

=  >'6    "

 

"





" 

 ##!

 "

 

  #

 !

#

 

 

""! !

       !

 !



 # 1"##

     !

 ):  !   !  #"  !  ## 

 #!

56"

 # 

56   "  .

. /

  / -   )      

 ;!2;!#"<!147'5A#!1"&'!% ( !"A& ;!2;!##!<&#2193!

( !"A&