The All India State Bank Officers Federation v. M C Singhal
!
"#$%% & ''"( ) "*
+! + , -!% . ) "/&' , "
+1# "23'
.+%4! %)%5' % + !
"# .+%""( && 33+6) +(- !! ! (37 .+%)& *&+)+ "6(- 6.+%8 3&-)&" 6(- "( .+%''
-+9)"(&46(-
0 +% .!% +-!& &4//6) +)"( "/
'6"
: "% ;;; %)%5' 6%< +'= % +7 + "& 0 "4"( +) "!"(
4+! 6>+ (? &+ '
@
"! 4
"( 6@ !
+ " "/ " / "! & + "
+ " "' "( ? ''
4'
"
+""
:4+ $(
% %
' !! ! ( 37 .+% )& *&+ )+ "6 (- 6 "(!&- ( (@%%6?& '
!!4 "/"
" " 5
" !
'
( ! C'' "( ) "*
+!2 + " "( "+% 8!% ) "*
"( "( & +!D6 & "23'
- !
" " &?!0'
!
0!!&
''
? "/ +#
!
"#$ %& ' ' ( ' )
EF '
( *
+( &
,
!
"#-$ .
!
"#/$
+( &
, 0 1 ' () ( ) 1
' 1 ( 10 '
1
)%) &
+ ')0 11
0 ' () %&
!
"#$0
2 &(0 ' () %&0( )' 1
+( &
, ) !
"#- "#/
1 &
'
( +( &
,
'0() 1 %! 41
1 11 # )
0
$ 1 %! 0 /. !
"# $0 ' )
1
5#
#0 ( 11 #
%& () ( )' 1
+( &
, +
) ) !1 1! $ 1%! 0 /. 2 0 () %&' ! 11
EF # 0 6
70 7 7- !
"#$0
'' 1
(
!
"# $ 0
'' 11 6
1 . 7
110
( 1%! 41 ( 11 #
!
"# $
$ - 1%! 0/.0
1 %D 34 " " "' "( ? ''
4' (
"
+ (
+6 & "
: " !!4 ( "
""
:4+ > 4"( ) "$<="
: A6 1
!!
0+
( "/! "+
! ("
6& +
+ 6& + " !' 3'
3 0+
(/ "!4"(
4+! 6>
+ " "' "(? ''
4'(
"
% % &! "
3
" !!4 ( " & "!" !
% ?
+6 >%%6 .!% +-!& 4//6 ) + )"( "/
'6 "
: "&(3
"!* !! ! "& 1 +% $% (76 '
+ )"( "/
'6 "
: "&! '
(+ 0'737?7
!& +
(-
+%) 11 406 + " 0'
11 !!
+6"
:67*+&?"6 &"( /+&'
"/ ? &""
:4+ ! ? &""
:4+ 3 "/ 114" + 1 & :
+< =65+(<=6 &"( /+&((+ !!
)&+ G++ &"(6+H 4!
%@6 6) +$$6 &"( /+& "
+1 "/ & 1&& ( 1"(+ !
(
!!
!!1 "7 +$&(
E$F
" !7 ( '' & ( !0 !'
- ' 5+ "
4+& +( + "!
& !
4+?& & +?! +'
+%& !1 !* +
+("( 07& +
!400'
'
( '
0 +% @% + )"( "/
'
+ & "
: 4+& "(!&?& '
+ "+ + ( + 1!
+- "413
7 +! / 6 ! +% ) 11 406 ?& ! & + " 0'
11 !!
+6 "
:6 7*+ &?"6 &"( /+&% ! ( !6 "
'!
1 +!
0 +!!
"&- 3
"/ - " "& ?+ "6& +
+ !"
0 !! 3'
: " *"
? 3 4& 1 +!
!!
" "!4+ 10' "
( @%% 34 " !
( '! 37 ?7
"1 !6 ((+ !!
! "( "413 +! %
1 +!
0 +!!
" + 0' ( +
+( " & ?+ 0 " "( 07 & +
4+" !& ( "
: "6
+&? & "?
4'(3 * "37& : " "!4+ 10' "
? &
% A% " & + 41!"
!6 '
' !! ! ( 37 .+% )& *&+)+ "6(- 6! !&& ?
4'( '
"00+ 0+ 00' 5
/ - "/ ( '!
1 +!
0 + !!
" % %"1 !60+ "/ 6((+ !!
!"("413 +! % >% +( "/'76 "& ' /&
0 ! ""
(3 6& "!" " ! ( !0 !
(
! "
'' "/
+ "7 " / "! & + " 4"( + &
4+! 6 > ?& '
/+" "/ ' 3 +7 + '
"00+ 0+ 00' " " +("
? &'?/ - "/
E$F '!!+
++ 3 " + "3'
: " * ! 0! "!4+ 10' "
? & & +!
"23'
- !
" &%
$%% 8 19 : (;
<= ;3 : <= ;3