High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12003/2018disposed of

Ram Singh v. State Of Punjab Etc

2024-04-09Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary7 pages

! "# $%&'"(()'"(*+,-./ 0123456378984:;(<=(>="("> ?1@A8:BC ===&328284:3D E3D9F9 A212345&F:G1H1:6,2C3D9 ===?39I4:63:29

JK L M

! NNNNN &D393:2; .9=O19:332P1FDQR6S4712354D2C3I328284:3D .D=AT1I1:AC4D3UQ0RV&F:G1H .D=R:W82PF@1DQR6S4712354DD39I4:63:2X4=" .D=?1@RS21DQR6S4712354DD39I4:63:2X49=)1:6> NNNNN

! Y L

K = ZC3 ID1U3D @163 8: 2C3 ID393:2 I328284: 89 54D 93228:B 19863 2C3 4D63D 61236 )=="([ I19936 HU D39I4:63:2 X4="Q R::3\FD3 &'*Q S863 TC87C D38@HFD93@3:2 45 ?9=]=[[ ^179 45 @36871^ 3\I3:939 8:7FDD36 HU 2C3 I328284:3D 54D 2C32D312@3:245C89T853C19H33:63:836= "= _31D:36 74F:93^ 9FH@829 2C12 2C3 T853 45 2C3 I328284:3DQ TC4 C16 D328D36 5D4@ 2C3 I492 45 `\7893 - Z1\1284: a:9I3724DQ C16 24 F:63DB4 _8S3D 2D1:9I^1:2 1:6 2C3 9186 2D312@3:2 T19 :42 1S18^1H^3 8: 2C3 A2123 45 &F:G1H 8:7^F68:B &Va.`?Q $C1:68B1DCQ 2CF9Q 9C3 T19 D353DD36 24 .361:21 b49I821^Q VFDFBD1@ 4: "#=(>="(]Q R::3\FD3 &'#= a2 244W I^173 8: 2C3 @4:2C 45 .

1UQ "(]Q 54D TC87C 2C3 @36871^ 3\I3:939 8:7FDD36 T3D3 ?9=<Q*[Q]()c'Q C4T3S3D 4:^U ?9=)Q(Q<<c' C1S3 H33: D38@HFD936 HU D39I4:63:2 X4=) 8=3= ,D83:21^ a:9FD1:73 $4@I1:U _26= R D353D3:73 89 @163 24 I1D1 ]=R= 45 2C3 &F:G1H V4S3D:@3:2 `@I^4U339 1:6 &3:984:3D9 b31^2C a:9FD1:73 A7C3@3Q R::3\FD3 &'"Q 24 9FH@82 2C12 8: 1: 3S3:2 HF553D 9F@ 8:9FD36 45 ?

"#$ %!& '%%

!(!%!%

) *% )+*

, ! !%

( !

- ! ( .* !%% )

/ !

(

& -! & &!

!** -- !

. 345# "%!

& *%!&-

6-7

*!-

89: ;8<= >?@ AB8BC DE F<G8H 8<=

B;C9? , 1I34JKL54ML5 , -&--

MN#ML#MLN A@

89:OFB;F >?@ PD>C9<OC<B DE Q8O:R S8=F , MLT /11 U V W!- LKNL, X8RGCCB A:<Y; >?@ AB8BC DE F<G8H 8<=

B;C9? , 1I34L5L5N4MLZ, -&--

LZ#M$#M5 !

- A;:>8[8<B\;8>?@]<:D<DE^<=:8 ,_MLZ`LN/11LZK# $# a 89: ;8<= _*!`, !- -& -

/ !

*!)

!%!

& !

-&!%

-7

! *(!

* !% -

!(!%!% (

* !%,%(!

*!!' !- b cK# 1%!

-&!%

! * &- -

3 6! /(& _W-&!%

&` "%, LT5M _ c%d` ' & 7 !(!%!%

3 6! (

*% ) !

- *

# a!

* !%

(

* !% !( & e- )

%# a % &%!)

!f ! *(!

* !% %- 6&

- !f 7 %- 7( )

*% )+*

&%!- ! * !

.- )

h!% !

- i!%) I%!, 3 6! !

- ! *

!-( - )

& &!%

- )

h!%

!%e

!-% !

# . * !&

*!- !%%

(

- & &

4!-!( -!

-j%)L,ML5# .. .. .. T# g# k !7!% !

%!) 7

) %

!) ' & %-

LT5M "%, ' & !

( 7 %!'

-&!%

/ !

3 6!# g , !

), !( -*%%- )

/* / !

3 6! (# "! V !)! k!77!, _LTTZ` 5 /11 LLK# a /*

-&!%

!%% 7 2 &% L l 5K

!"# $%&#'# & ( #&# "# )*+ %,(-

# .#+&&- /0 /112 &#(34# "# &3" "# $# ("3# %,(-

&' '# '# #& ("33 (&('(# !"# & "#, " "# %,(- 5 %# (",,#3#6 "#

(, %#( &#,#7 ( #&0 #7#&-

'#, &3" +# (&# 5" %#&'+,# &#+,# &#&(6 (#& #8%## &# #8(, "# %,(-0 "# (,' 5, ,#

& &#'+&#'# #8%## (&&# %&7# "%, !"# $%&#'# & &#(34# "# &3" 933

,, '# (, &#'+&#'# (&&# #&33 "#& &3#&- :(& ;%,0 <#5 =#," "# &# %&#(&+# +- >

?$ + "#

,, #8%# &# (&&# :(& @ %

(0 "# &#'# #&3# +- 933 5 7,+,# >

?$0 <#5 =#," + "# %# (, +# A# >

?$ "#&# 5 &A# "%,

(,# 5#&# 7,+,# !" "5 933 A "# #'#&3#(- &#'# :(& 7# " , # !"# &#,#7 %3# 5"(" ''# "# %&## (# %& "#* 3'# )& &# ,,5BC D $

& "# %%#, &3 $E)FG < //1HIJ1K ((#&# 0 5#

" "# &#% # "

"# "#& (A 1" .#+&&-0 /112 5

7# 3 =#," /I" .#+&&-0 /112 + (( ,3 &A# "# >,,

# ?# (, $(#(# F>

?$G "# 5

'# "# :(& @ "#

( 5# &# (,# #& #&# !"# &#% # " +## % "#

'+,# &# "# >

?$ + (,' "#

#&#(# +#5## 5" % 5"

'+,# &# :(& EA3 "#

( (&('(# " (#0 5# ", " "# &#% # $E) FG < //1HIJ1K #,# +# % "#

#&#(# ' 5" % 5" "# &#

'+,# :(& "# !"# '# ", +# % 5" # '"

&' - L# 'A# (,#& &#'+&#'# "# &#% # %%&7# +- +# &## %&#(# # + " +## 37# "#

( (&('(# "## (# M 88 88 88 // !"# N# %&##,- &3 " E7# E7#& !&%,

(,- 5 7,+,# >

?$0 <#5 =#," 5"# "# &#'# 5 A#

7,+,# >

?$0 <#5 =#," "# "# %,(-

# .#+&&- /0 /112 " +# &# (,#&,-

7& "# %##& +&3 " #&#

# $%& !

$ '##&

(#&

& %! ) *#$ #+

,&#!# -!

! + /( 0 (

& #12 &

%! !"1

# (

!# 3

$ $ & & ,

# ( #& +

' # 1 (

3 * (

( !

2 1& & & $ # # 1) *# # &

456 7'

#' '& $#

+ '&1

'&# &# + ( '& # ' & (1

1 #) +

#$ #+

!29! & &

#:' $

# 1 $

%! '##&

( (

3 ;'<

!# #

& -,,=8+ /(0)* ( .

> ) 4?) , ( '&+

#$ #+ (

! & !# 2 &

#&# & & -!# ?@+ ?64A & &#

! # (

$ #!

$ # $& !2

#&#) * #:' $ #

&2& !2 && 3(

( ;#" C#1 3)

$ ;'<+ D455@E 44 8FF A55

$ ( & 2

8'!# '#

& # '#

# %!& #!# !#%# $<'# & )G ) .

8'!# '# ! I& JK

LMNOPQRP D '!#E

& !

# ' ##1 (

3# &

!2+

!# 3&

! 2 & ! # # !#

' S3 $

!2 & 2 &

# +

3& # !

2+ # # & '

# ' <'& !#& * #3 !#

<'&1 #& ' T U4) ,

& +

'# 3

" 3(

# # (

3# &

, '#

!2+ # #

$ 2

#& !# 2 & #

&'&+

#!# # + (#

! 2

! #

!# 2) * 3# ( &'1

!' #2

+ 3#2 ! 2

! # <

2 !21

' #!

) , 2

!" #$%&

!" #'$%&

(

) ** *(

!" +$%& *

)" - *.*

)* , /,, 0 , 0* ,*( 0

01 !" 2 0 3)

)* ) 0* 0 3 * (

4 1* 5 */* 4* *4*( * )** !"6"0 3)" 27" 84

)* * , 1

0 0*

*,*

)* 0 , , (* 1

)* *,0 1**

* 1 :

)* *

) 5 *

)* :**(

* **

)* ;

.* ,*

(

)* * , 15

)** 0 ,

* *

* *(

* *( *,*,*

)* * , 15 *.*

)* 5

)* 0 0 1

)* ;

.* ,*

* )*( 1

) ) ** ** *(01 )*0( 1

4 (*

4 . <.

=* )*

) *00

)* -

> 0* ?*,*

)* (*

?). @

A) ."

4 ( * *( C7$#'DEFA+#6C?9D" // // // 22" G)**4 *5

)* ;

.* ,*

(

) 5 4

* ,*

3 ) 05

)*1 *

0*(

0 , *,*,*

)* -* 0 * ?)*,*

)*1 0 , (* E*( 0

* ( * !0*" H0

(

)* ?

* ;

.* ,*

) 5 4

* ,*

3 ) 05 )**

)**

*,*:* 15

)* *

*,0 1**

0*( *,*,*

* )* (*

)* -* 0 * ?)*,*

)* E*( 0

* ( *!0*" " G)**

(* 1 :

)* 4

)

* ,*

(*:

* 1 4*

)* *

*,*:*

(

. 0 0* ?

* ;

.* ,*

- 05 .*

4 ))5 *4** * * , (*

IJKLM NMOP QJM C D5 )** -

R0*

)* ?*,* )*0(

)* :)

4 :

.* ,*

*,0 1**

,*( 0 * *4 5 (* :

)* *

0 1

4 9;-?

(

)* )* 0 ) *

**(

)* *,0 1**5 )0* *,) S :

)* , 1

* ,*

1 T 04*( (

" (* *(

)* 9;-?

)* 0 *

)* *

*5 * :

S :

** 1

4 *,*:* 1

* ,*

(* *

&*, *00*( ) 0 *

( S*(

)* (* 0

4 *,*,*

0*01 *(

) 0 0

5 * :

)* ,

4 0

* ,*

" G)* *0*.

)** 4* ( )U

"# #$ % % !#& '$( $

("#)

*'$! % + ( #'

+ ' % '

( $

$ # !

% $ + #+ % ( - + -

$ $# + - $ "

- #$ % '!%

-- " # -#((#$

. % *(

- #$

# %#/

%#* '

#$) /% % #-#'. /%# /

' ,#% #$

(- 1* +- #$

' $- !

$ ')

-#"

+ # % "

$ #' %

& #

# % ( $$ ' $ /%-% %

( $

%#* '

- ) %# "

, % +#' '

( $ #+

( $

'&-

#+ #-#'

-"$

,) "

$ #$) #

$ *'

"'#"

'. 1*'

+ '

( $ $

% 5$! '

( $ $

- ) %# " ,)

+ /#*

"'&

#$ # - ( (,*'

( $

#$ % !'#*$ % %

%# " $# $-* $ % !#& '$( $ #'

' 6% '!% # ( - - ( - $$#

$ ( - *

% $ ( #+ % %# " $# $-* $ % !#& '$( $ #'

' 6%

(* % + -*( #+ '

( $ +#'

$) ( - - ( %#$#*'

. %

*%#'

,#*$ #

$ *'

# /% % ' % - ( $ %

-* $ '

( $

$ % + -*( #+ '

( $

*""#' ,) -#'

*) - '+ ,) #-#'

8%# "

-#$- '$ 9$- .

, % . % - ( - $$#

$ #$ -%$- !'#*$

'). $ % "'

$ -

. ,) 5$!

') $%*( $

""'# -%. % #++-

#+ 4:;3 %

$ % !'

$ #+ ( - (,*'

( $ $ +* #% "

#$ '+#'

$!%(# ""'# -%% 4#*' < 6% % ' )

+ -#')

++ '

*%#'

1*'

# (#'

"#$ &

$ - $$# $

( -% $- ( $$ '

"'&

("#)

#+ %

!( (,*'

( $ 6% $'

:#& '$( $ ;

% 3-% ( =4:;3> /

"'#"#*$ /%

"*'"#

#+ "'#& $! %

% + -)

-% ( # % $'

:#& '$( $

("#)

% %

+ /%#* ( - -

+ ' '

( $ /

$ +*'% $- #+ % #,?

- #+

/ + 3 . /%-% (* "'#& +#'

*-% ( - - % %

-% ( /

,'#*!% $ +#'- $ % + - #+ % "'

$ -

. - $$#

$ % % /' "

#$ ' /

( $ %

,#&

%# "

( '!

$-) -#$ #$ @#'

#& '. %

$# 1*'

% "'#' "

#$ %

# $ $

*-%

* #$ /% %

*'&& #+ % "

#$ % "'( -#$ #$ 6% #-#'

% #"

$ % ("

$ 4A6BC

$ % #$

$ ( ) 6%#*!% % - ( #+ %

"#$ $ 3 % %

0#', $ /%

-% '!

+#'

*-% + -)

% #$)

4:;3

$ % ##

+ ' +##/$!

"'#"

' "'#- *'

!& $ $ % -'-*

* #$ ( # ( ,) % @$ ') -#$- '$ .

- $$#

$ % % "

#$ ' /

$ # %# " *$ '

( '!

$-) -#$ #$ +#'

*'&& #+ % + /%-%

$ !

& ''%#!&

'( )*( +

# & " !,

# $!%% !&!

./01 &! ' ,!

23 $ !, # #$ %

''4 3 !,

# . ' /!" &'!5

% &!( +

# $

% $$

$ !,

# $ -

# !&!

# & ! !4 & ''% #!&

3 $

! !& ! ',

# '"

( 6-

#,!- %$

# &!%

! 5

! !, 7 8-**-999

& !( 6

'! 2 $'

% %$! $!,% ! #$ !'5(: ;( < % $!' ,!

# &!% %&

# ,,!

! $! !"

# $ ' &! !

% %

5 % $ "

,! !%=%3 ! $ 5$! 5'

( ( + " !,

,! %-

# & & ! %&!% !,

#=%3 & % >?@A>BCD EF >?@GHIAH

% EA@J>K>BILA> M& N(

O OPOQROST LQRUV FF W(X 6# #& 23Y !% Z [Y\! 6# #&!

' Z [Y\!