Baljinder Singh v. Presiding Officer And ANR
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&, -- #./*,(%0 1*,23 ------ %$*$*&,%0 4%0+5+ 0%+*(*,2
''*)%06 #,&$3%0
------
%+8&,(%,$+
0%+%,$ 0- !3#09*,(%0 1*,23
#,(3#:#6 (;&)#$%
8%$*$*&,%0-
&,% - - %$*$*&,%0
#./*,(%0 1*,23 '*.%( *,+$#,$ :0*$ 8%$*$*&, 0$*).%+ &,+$*$5$*&, ,(*# *++5#,)% :0*$ ,#$50% )%0$*&0#0* <5#+3*,2
8#++%(
3%0%*, :3%0%7> 0%'%0%,)% #,+:%0%( '#;&50 20#,$*,2 )&98%,+#$*&, #9&5,$*,2 $&
+- 6 -
50$3%0 80#>%0 7%%, 9#(% (*0%)$*,2 $& 0%*,+$#$% '5..
7#)?
:#2%+ #.&,2:*$3 *,$%0%+$-
- 0*%'.>6 0#*+%( #, *,(5+$0*#.
(*+85$% +%0;*,2 (%9#,( ,&$*)% 58&, '#*.50% )&,)*.*#$*&, 80&)%%(*,2+6 (*+85$%
0%'%00%( $& 1%)$*&, 1%)$*&,
) !*+85$%+ )$6
3%0%*,#'$%0 0%'%00%( $& @ )$@ #(/5(*)#$*&,-
- $ *+ $3#$ 3% #88&*,$%( 1%)50*$> 5#0( + +3&?# 50+*,2
#,#2%9%,$ (0#:*,2 9&,$3.> +#.#0>
+- 6A #$ $*9% 3*+ *..%2#.
$%09*,#$*&, --A-
$ ).#*9%( $3#$ )&,$*,5&5+.> :&0?%( #,#2%9%,$ 8%0*&( '0&9 -- $& --A- $ '50$3%0 ).#*9%( $3#$ '0%+3 #88&*,$9%,$
9#(% %;%, /5,*&0+ $& :%0% 0%$#*,%( #,#2%9%,$ #'$%0 $%09*,#$*&, +%0;*)%+ 8%$*$*&,%0- 3% '50$3%0 ).#*9%( $3#$ $%09*,#$*&, +%0;*)%+ #9&5,$+ $& 5,'#*0 .#7&50 80#)$*)% )$ +#9% ;*&.#$*&, 80&;*+*&,+ 1%)$*&,+ A A A )$-
$ )#$%2&0*)#..>
).#*9%( $3#$ 3#( :&0?%( 9&0% $3#, (#>+ )#.%,(#0 >%#0 80*&0 $& 3*+ $%09*,#$*&,-
))&0(*,2.>6 80#>%0 0%*,+$#$%9%,$ +%0;*)% 7#)?
:#2%+ )&,$*,5*$> +%0;*)%+ '0&9
(#$% 3*+ *..%2#.
$%09*,#$*&, 9#(%-
- 3% ).#*9 )&,$%+$%( #,#2%9%,$ '*.*,2 *$+ :0*$$%, +$#$%9%,$- 3% '*.%( 0%8.*)#$*&, $& :0*$$%, +$#$%9%,$ '*.%( #,#2%9%,$-
, +588&0$ 3*+ ).#*96 3*9+%.'
#88%#0%( $%,(%0%( 3*+ #''*(#;*$
=- +588&0$ 3*+ %=#9*,#$*&, )3*%'
)&00&7&0#$*,2 #;%09%,$+ ).#*9 +$#$%9%,$-
% #.+&
80&;%( !%9#,( &$*)%
=-6 +$#$%9%,$ ).#*9
=- #.+& $%,(%0%( (&)59%,$
=-- &:%;%06 :3%, #$ +$#2% )0&++ %=#9*,#$*&, 8%$*$*&,%0:&0?9#,6 ,&,% #88%#0%( 7%3#.'
#,#2%9%,$ #,#2%9%,$ 80&)%%(%( #2#*,+$ %=8#0$%-
A- 3% #$*#.#6 ;*(% *$+
*,$%0 #.*#6 3%.(
* 3% :&0?%( 0%+8&,(%,$ (#>+ >%#0 *99%(*#$%.> 80%)%(*,2 (#$% 3*+ $%09*,#$*&,
** 3% ,&$ 8#*( #,> )&98%,+#$*&,6 ,&$*)%6 ,&$*)% 8#> .*%5 ,&$*)%
*** 3% +%0;*)%+ 3#;% 7%%, $%09*,#$%( ;*&.#$*&, 80&;*+*&,+ 1%)$*&, A
)$- - &,+*(%0*,2 $&$#.*$> )*0)59+$#,)%+6 .%#0,%( 0%+*(*,2
''*)%06 20#,$%( '&..&:*,2 0%.*%'
! "#$%& ' (() *+ ,
(-( ($- $((- ($
'$ ((() .' ,/ , '
$( ,
'$ ((() .' ,/ % ,
012
3
4 - 2#*,+$ #'&0%+#*(
#880&#)3%( $3*+ &50$ '*.*,2 *,+$#,$ :0*$ 8%$*$*&,-
- 3*.% *++5*,2 ,&$*)% 9&$*&,6 )&&0(*,#$% %,)3 $3*+ &50$ 8#++%(
'&..&:*,2 &0(%0 ,
,
6
7
5 " * 8 5 9 6
9:* ;
$ &&< ($
-(% ($< ;
%(& ($<4 - !%+8*$% +%0;*)%6 ,&,% 85$ #88%#0#,)% 7%3#.'
#,#2%9%,$- - 3#;% 3%#0( .%#0,%( )&5,+%.
3#;% #.+& 8%05+%( 8#8%0 7&&?
:%..
*9852,%(
A
8#++%( .%#0,%( #$*#.#- - &,@7.% 1580%9% &50$ = ;5 > =
1 6 3%.( - 7 ,
,
:
,
)
,) ) , , 3
6
,
,
! "
# 9
,
7 '
%' ,
,
,
, ?
! "
# ,
, , ,
,
.
@ AB" .
((1/% 99$/
,
,
, 9
,
,
,
,
:
,
,
3
, 7
,
7
,
,
, C
D4
- , # E
'7" 9 > F
6
A 1580%9% &50$ #+%+ 6
#7&;%+$#$%( ;*%:
#''*09%(- $ 3%.( $3#$ 0%*,+$#$%9%,$ *+ ,&$ 05.%6 *$ (%8%,(+ 58&, ;#0*&5+ )*0)59+$#,)%+6 .*?% ,#$50% :&0?6 9#,,%0 9%$3&( #88&*,$9%,$6 .%,2$3 +%0;*)% %$)-
-
#?*,2 ,&$% '#)$ $3#$ #88&*,$%( 1%)50*$> 5#0( 3% :&0?%( '0&9 -- $& --A #,#2%9%,$ )&,$*,5&5+.> 3*+ .#+$ (0#:, +#.#0> #$
$*9% $%09*,#$*&,
+- 6A 8%0 9&,$3 +%0;*)%+ 3#( 7%%, $%09*,#$%( ;*&.#$*&, 80&;*+*&,+ 1%)$*&,+ A
)$6 )&58.%( '#)$ $3#$ ,&$ .#*( #,> )3#..%,2% $& #'&0%+#*(
7%%, .*$*2#$*,2 #,#2%9%,$ +*,)% >%#0 AB $3%0%'&0%6 #9 )&,+*(%0%( &8*,*&, $3#$ )&98%,+#$*&, #:#0(%( $& 8%$*$*&,%0 :&0?9#, *+ .&:%0 +*(%-
- ))&0(*,2.>6 9> )&,+*(%0%( ;*%:6 *,$%0%+$ /5+$*)% :&5.( 7% 9%$ *'
)&98%,+#$*&, #:#0(%( $&
*+ %,3#,)%( '0&9
+- 6 $&
+- 66 -
%+8&,(%,$ #,#2%9%,$ *+ (*0%)$%( $& 8#>
%,3#,)%( #9&5,$ )&98%,+#$*&,
#'$%0 #(/5+$*,2
+- 6 *'
8#*( $& :*$3*, 8%0*&( $30%% 9&,$3+ '0&9 (#$% 0%)%*8$ 80%+%,$#$*&, )%0$*'*%( )&8> $3*+ &0(%0-
, ,&,8#>9%,$ #9&5,$
$& :*$3*, +$*85.#$%( 8%0*&(6 +3#..
7% %,$*$.%( $& ).#*9 +*98.% *,$%0%+$ #$ 0#$% C 8%0 #,,59 $*..
+5)3 $*9% 8#>9%,$ *+ ,&$ 9#(%-
A- 3% *,+$#,$ :0*$ 8%$*$*&, *+ (*+8&+%( #'&0%+$#$%( $%09+- - ..
8%,(*,2 #88.*)#$*&, +6 *'
#,>6 +3#..
+$#,( ).&+%(-
--
+/?+ 3%$3%0 +8%#?*,2 0%#+&,%(
"%+
& 3%$3%0 0%8&0$#7.% "%+
&